第11关
Premise: (All x)P(x)\/(All x)Q(x)
Conclusion: (All x)(P(x)\/Q(x))
Premise: (All x)P(x)\/(All x)Q(x)
Conclusion: (All x)(P(x)\/Q(x))
1. P(x) |- P(x) prem
2. P(x) |- P(x)\/Q(x) ori 1
3. (All x)P(x) |- (All x)(P(x)\/Q(x)) aai 2
4. Q(x) |- Q(x) prem
5. Q(x) |- P(x)\/Q(x) ori 4
6. (All x)Q(x) |- (All x)(P(x)\/Q(x)) aai 5
7. (All x)P(x)\/(All x)Q(x) |- (All x)(P(x)\/Q(x)) ore 3,6
第12关
Premise: (All x)(A->P(x))
Conclusion: A->(All x)P(x)
1. A->P(x) |- A->P(x) prem
2. (All x)(A->P(x)) |- A->P(x) lai 1
3. (All x)(A->P(x)),A |- A prem
4. (All x)(A->P(x)),A |- A->P(x) premi 2
5. (All x)(A->P(x)),A |- P(x) imple 4,3
6. (All x)(A->P(x)),A |- (All x)P(x) ai 5
7. (All x)(A->P(x)) |- A->(All x)P(x) impli 6
第13关
Premise: A->(All x)P(x)
Conclusion: (All x)(A->P(x))
1. A->(All x)P(x),A |- A prem
2. A->(All x)P(x),A |- A->(All x)P(x) prem
3. A->(All x)P(x),A |- (All x)P(x) imple 1,2
4. A->(All x)P(x),A |- P(x) ae 3 (x/x)
5. A->(All x)P(x) |- A->P(x) impli 4
6. A->(All x)P(x) |- (All x)(A->P(x)) ai 5
第14关
Premise: (Exist x)(P(x)\/Q(x))
Conclusion: (Exist x)P(x)\/(Exist x)Q(x)
Premise: (Exist x)(P(x)\/Q(x))
Conclusion: (Exist x)P(x)\/(Exist x)Q(x)
1. P(x) |- P(x) prem
2. P(x) |- (Exist x)P(x) ei 1 (x/x)
3. P(x) |- (Exist x)P(x)\/(Exist x)Q(x) ori 2
4. Q(x) |- Q(x) prem
5. Q(x) |- (Exist x)Q(x) ei 4 (x/x)
6. Q(x) |- (Exist x)P(x)\/(Exist x)Q(x) ori 5
7. P(x)\/Q(x) |- (Exist x)P(x)\/(Exist x)Q(x) ore 6,3
8. (Exist x)(P(x)\/Q(x)) |- (Exist x)P(x)\/(Exist x)Q(x) lei 7
第15关
Premise: (Exist x)P(x)\/(Exist x)Q(x)
Conclusion: (Exist x)(P(x)\/Q(x))
1. P(x) |- P(x) prem
2. P(x) |- P(x)\/Q(x) ori 1
3. (Exist x)P(x) |- (Exist x)(P(x)\/Q(x)) eei 2
4. Q(x) |- Q(x) prem
5. Q(x) |- P(x)\/Q(x) ori 4
6. (Exist x)Q(x) |- (Exist x)(P(x)\/Q(x)) eei 5
7. (Exist x)P(x)\/(Exist x)Q(x) |- (Exist x)(P(x)\/Q(x)) ore 3,6
第16关
Premise: (All x)(P(x)/\Q(x))
Conclusion: (All x)P(x)/\(All x)Q(x)
1. P(x)/\Q(x) |- P(x)/\Q(x) prem
2. P(x)/\Q(x) |- P(x) ande 1
3. P(x)/\Q(x) |- Q(x) ande 1
4. (All x)(P(x)/\Q(x)) |- (All x)P(x) aai 2
5. (All x)(P(x)/\Q(x)) |- (All x)Q(x) aai 3
6. (All x)(P(x)/\Q(x)) |- (All x)P(x)/\(All x)Q(x) andi 4,5
第17关
Premise: (All x)P(x)/\(All x)Q(x)
Conclusion: (All x)(P(x)/\Q(x))
1. (All x)P(x)/\(All x)Q(x) |- (All x)P(x)/\(All x)Q(x) prem
2. (All x)P(x)/\(All x)Q(x) |- (All x)P(x) ande 1
3. (All x)P(x)/\(All x)Q(x) |- P(x) ae 2 (x/x)
4. (All x)P(x)/\(All x)Q(x) |- (All x)Q(x) ande 1
5. (All x)P(x)/\(All x)Q(x) |- Q(x) ae 4 (x/x)
6. (All x)P(x)/\(All x)Q(x) |- P(x)/\Q(x) andi 3,5
7. (All x)P(x)/\(All x)Q(x) |- (All x)(P(x)/\Q(x)) ai 6
第18关
Premise: (Exist x)P(x)->(All x)Q(x)
Conclusion: (All x)(P(x)->Q(x))
1. (Exist x)P(x)->(All x)Q(x),P(x),(Exist x)P(x) |- (Exist x)P(x)->(All x)Q(x) prem
2. (Exist x)P(x)->(All x)Q(x),P(x),(Exist x)P(x) |- (Exist x)P(x) prem
3. (Exist x)P(x)->(All x)Q(x),P(x),(Exist x)P(x) |- (All x)Q(x) imple 1,2
4. (Exist x)P(x)->(All x)Q(x),P(x),(Exist x)P(x) |- Q(x) ae 3 (x/x)
5. (Exist x)P(x)->(All x)Q(x),P(x) |- (Exist x)P(x)->Q(x) impli 4
6. (Exist x)P(x)->(All x)Q(x),P(x) |- P(x) prem
7. (Exist x)P(x)->(All x)Q(x),P(x) |- (Exist x)P(x) ei 6 (x/x)
第19关
Premise: (All x)(P(x)->Q(x))
Conclusion: (All x)P(x)->(All x)Q(x)
1. (All x)(P(x)->Q(x)),(All x)P(x) |- (All x)(P(x)->Q(x)) prem
2. (All x)(P(x)->Q(x)),(All x)P(x) |- P(x)->Q(x) ae 1 (x/x)
3. (All x)(P(x)->Q(x)),(All x)P(x) |- (All x)P(x) prem
4. (All x)(P(x)->Q(x)),(All x)P(x) |- P(x) ae 3 (x/x)
5. (All x)(P(x)->Q(x)),(All x)P(x) |- Q(x) imple 4,2
6. (All x)(P(x)->Q(x)),(All x)P(x) |- (All x)Q(x) ai 5
7. (All x)(P(x)->Q(x)) |- (All x)P(x)->(All x)Q(x) impli 6
第20关
Premise: (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y)
Conclusion: (All x)R(x,x)
1. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y) |- (All x)(Exist y)R(x,y) prem
2. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y) |- (Exist y)R(x,y) ae 1 (x/x)
3. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t) |- R(x,t) prem
4. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t) |- (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)) prem
5. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t) |- (All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)) ae 4 (x/x)
6. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t) |- R(x,t)->R(t,x) ae 5 (t/y)
7. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t) |- R(t,x) imple 3,6
8. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t) |- R(x,t)/\R(t,x) andi 3,7
9. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t) |- (Exist y)(R(x,y)/\R(y,x)) ei 8 (t/y)
10. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y) |- (Exist y)(R(x,y)/\R(y,x)) ee 2,9
11. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t)/\R(t,x) |- R(x,t)/\R(t,x) prem
12. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t)/\R(t,x) |- (All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)) prem
13. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t)/\R(t,x) |- (All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)) ae 12 (x/x)
14. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t)/\R(t,x) |- (All z)(R(x,t)/\R(t,z)->R(x,z)) ae 13 (t/y)
15. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t)/\R(t,x) |- R(x,t)/\R(t,x)->R(x,x) ae 14 (x/z)
16. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t)/\R(t,x) |- R(x,t)/\R(t,x) prem
17. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y),R(x,t)/\R(t,x) |- R(x,x) imple 15,16
18. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y) |- R(x,x) ee 10,17
19. (All x)(All y)(R(x,y)->R(y,x)),(All x)(All y)(All z)(R(x,y)/\R(y,z)->R(x,z)),(All x)(Exist y)R(x,y) |- (All x)R(x,x) ai 18