软件测试新标准ISO29119的是是非非

您听说过ISO 29119（ http://softwaretestingstandard.org/  ）吗？您公司在采用这个标准吗？也许您都没有听说过，也算它失败之处吧，哈哈。软件测试新标准ISO／IEC 29119 其前四部分于2013、2014年相继发布，还莫名其妙增加了第5部分。个人感觉第5部分——关键字驱动测试（Keyword Driven Testing）只是自动化脚本的一种技术，没有必要单独成章，还不如搞一个“自动化测试及其框架”：

• ISO/IEC 29119-1: Concepts & Definitions (published September 2013)
• ISO/IEC 29119-2: Test Processes (published September 2013)
• ISO/IEC 29119-3: Test Documentation (published September 2013)
• ISO/IEC 29119-4: Test Techniques (at DIS stage, anticipating publiation in late 2014)
• ISO/IEC 29119-5: Keyword Driven Testing (at CD stage, anticipating publication in 2015)

除此之外，还在定义一个类似于TMMi的过程评估模型
ISO/IEC 33063: Process Assessment Model (at DIS stage)

这个标准是为了取代一些老的国际标准，如：

• IEEE 829 Test Documentation
• IEEE 1008 Unit Testing
• BS 7925-1 Vocabulary of Terms in Software Testing
• BS 7925-2 Software Component Testing Standard

之前，review过这个标准，定义过于具体，高度和深度都不够，对企业的帮助和指导作用有限，特别是在敏捷开发模式、DevOps技术与流程等开始流行的今天，这个标准在企业应用起来更困难。实践上，在其推出前后争论一直不断，反对声音不小，现在就让我们看看有哪些反对声音？通过这些文章的阅读，让我们对软件测试有更深刻的思考，更理解我们需要一个什么样的国际标准。当然，我们也要去看支持、赞成ISO 29119的文章，不失公正。

Iain McCowatt
The ISO 29119 Debate

The ISO 29119 Debate

 

Kieran Cornwall
Are Standards Stifling Innovation
http://www.softwaretestingconference.com/conference-programme/speakers/kieran-cornwall/

Iain McCowatt
Stop 29119
http://exploringuncertainty.com/blog/archives/1124

House Of Test
Petition to stop ISO 29119
http://www.houseoftest.se/archive/2014-08-19-petition-to-stop-iso-29119/

Cem Kaner
Please sign the Petition to Stop ISO 29119

Please sign the Petition to Stop ISO 29119

 

Ben Klaasen
ISO 29119 is dead in the water
http://www.fluidlogic.org/post/2014/08/29/ISO-29119-is-dead-in-the-water

James Bach
HOW NOT TO STANDARDIZE TESTING (ISO 29119)

How Not to Standardize Testing (ISO 29119)

 

James Christie
ISO – the dog that hasn’t barked
ISO – the dog that hasn’t barked

Neil Studd
Forming a resistance against ISO 29119
http://blog.neiltest.com/2014/08/21/forming-a-resistance-against-iso-29119/

Joep Schuurkes
Joining the fray on ISO 29119
Joining the fray on ISO 29119

Johan Jonasson
A solution to a non-existent problem
http://blog.johanjonasson.com/?p=774

Keith Klain
The Petition to Stop ISO 29119

The Petition to Stop ISO 29119

 

Justin Rohrman
ISO 29119: What you should know about software testing standards

ISO 29119: What you should know about software testing standards

 

Simon Morley
ISO 29119 Questions: Part 1
http://testers-headache.blogspot.ch/2014/08/iso-29119-questions-part-1.html

Majd Uddin
Why Standards don’t help software world
Why Standards don’t help Software world

Rikard Edgren
On ISO 29119 Content
http://thetesteye.com/blog/2014/08/on-iso-29119-content/

Markus Gärtner
ON AUDITING, STANDARDS, AND ISO 29119

On auditing, standards, and ISO 29119

 

Maria Kedemo
I am a professional tester – are you?
I am a professional tester – are you?

Fiona Charles
Why I oppose adoption of ISO 29119
http://quality-intelligence.blogspot.ca/2014/08/why-i-oppose-adoption-of-iso-29119.html

Tim Hall
Stop ISO 29119
http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/computing/testing/stop-iso-29119/

Rob Lambert
Standard. Or Not.
http://thesocialtester.co.uk/standard-or-not/

Michael Bolton
Rising Against the Rent Seekers

Rising Against the Rent-Seekers