AOP Benchmark

AOP Benchmark

1、性能测试的AOP或代理框架

（1）字节码框架

l         AspectWerkz 1.0

l         AspectWerkz 2.x

l         AspectJ 1.2

l         JBoss AOP 1.0

（2）代理框架

l         Spring AOP 1.1.1

l         cglib proxy 2.0.2

l         dynaop 1.0beta

（3）AspectWerkz可扩展Aspect容器

l         AspectJ

l         AOP Alliance

l         Spring AOP

 

2、性能测试结果

AWBench (ns/invocation)	Aspect Werkz2.x	awproxy	Aspect Werkz1.0	aspectj	jboss	spring	dynaop	cglib	ext: aopalliance	ext: spring	ext: aspectj
before, args() target()	10	25	606	10	220	355	390	145	-	220	-
around x 2, args() target()	80	85	651	50	290	436	455	155	465	476	-
before	15	20	520	15	145	275	320	70	-	40	10
before, static info access	30	30	501	25	175	275	330	70		35
before, rtti info access	50	55	535	50	175	275	335	75		35
after returning	10	20	541	10	135	285	315	85	-	45	15
after throwing	3540	3870	6103	3009	5032		6709	8127		-	3460
before + after	20	30	511	20	160	445	345	80	-	35	20
before, args() primitives	10	20	555	10	195	350	375	145		210
before, args() objects	5	25	546	10	185	325	345	115		200
around	60	95	470	10		225	315	75		-	90
around, rtti info access	70	70	520	50	140	250	340	80	70	70	-
around, static info access	80	90	486	25	135	245	330	75	80	80	-

 

下面的表格以AspectWerkz 2.0.RC2-snapshot 作为参考标准：

AWBench (relative %)	Aspect Werkz2.x	awproxy	Aspect werkz1.0	aspectj	jboss	spring	dynaop	cglib	ext: aopalliance	ext: spring	ext: aspectj
before, args() target()	1 x	2.5 x	60.6 x	1 x	22 x	35.5 x	39 x	14.5 x	-	22 x	-
around x 2, args() target()	1 x	1 x	8.1 x	0.6 x	3.6 x	5.4 x	5.6 x	1.9 x	5.8 x	5.9 x	-
before	1 x	1.3 x	34.6 x	1 x	9.6 x	18.3 x	21.3 x	4.6 x	-	2.6 x	0.6 x
before, static info access	1 x	1 x	16.7 x	0.8 x	5.8 x	9.1 x	11 x	2.3 x		1.1 x
before, rtti info access	1 x	1.1 x	10.7 x	1 x	3.5 x	5.5 x	6.7 x	1.5 x		0.7 x
after returning	1 x	2 x	54.1 x	1 x	13.5 x	28.5 x	31.5 x	8.5 x	-	4.5 x	1.5 x
after throwing	1 x	1 x	1.7 x	0.8 x	1.4 x		1.8 x	2.2 x		-	0.9 x
before + after	1 x	1.5 x	25.5 x	1 x	8 x	22.2 x	17.2 x	4 x	-	1.7 x	1 x
before, args() primitives	1 x	2 x	55.5 x	1 x	19.5 x	35 x	37.5 x	14.5 x		21 x
before, args() objects	1 x	5 x	109.2 x	2 x	37 x	65 x	69 x	23 x		40 x
around	1 x	1.5 x	7.8 x	0.1 x		3.7 x	5.2 x	1.2 x		-	1.5 x
around, rtti info access	1 x	1 x	7.4 x	0.7 x	2 x	3.5 x	4.8 x	1.1 x	1 x	1 x	-
around, static info access	1 x	1.1 x	6 x	0.3 x	1.6 x	3 x	4.1 x	0.9 x	1 x	1 x	-

 

测试环境：Java HotSpot 1.4.2，Windows 2000 SP4，Pentium M 1.6 GHz，1 G RAM