RocketMQ事务消息 超时重发还是原来的消息吗？

以下面的一个demo例子来分析一下，探索RocketMQ事务消息原理。

    public static final String PRODUCER_GROUP = "tran-test";
    public static final String DEFAULT_NAMESRVADDR = "127.0.0.1:9876";
    public static final String TOPIC = "Test";

    public static void main(String[] args) throws Exception {
        TransactionListener transactionListener = new TransactionListener() {
            @Override
            public LocalTransactionState executeLocalTransaction(Message msg, Object arg) {
                System.out.println(String.format("executeLocalTransaction: %s", msg.getTransactionId()));
                return LocalTransactionState.UNKNOW;
            }

            @Override
            public LocalTransactionState checkLocalTransaction(MessageExt msg) {
                System.out.println(String.format("checkLocalTransaction: tranId=%s, commitLogOffset=%s, queueOffset=%s, msgId=%s",
                        msg.getTransactionId(), msg.getCommitLogOffset(),
                        msg.getQueueOffset(), msg.getMsgId()));
                return LocalTransactionState.UNKNOW;
            }
        };
        TransactionMQProducer producer = new TransactionMQProducer(PRODUCER_GROUP);
        producer.setTransactionListener(transactionListener);
        producer.setNamesrvAddr(DEFAULT_NAMESRVADDR);
        producer.start();
        Message msg = new Message(TOPIC, "test".getBytes());
        SendResult sendResult = producer.sendMessageInTransaction(msg, null);
        System.out.println(String.format("sendResult: tranId=%s, offsetMsgId=%s, queueOffset=%s msgId=%s",
                sendResult.getTransactionId(), sendResult.getOffsetMsgId(),
                sendResult.getQueueOffset(), sendResult.getMsgId()));
        CountDownLatch countDownLatch = new CountDownLatch(1);
        countDownLatch.await();
    }

executeLocalTransaction: C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000
sendResult: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, offsetMsgId=null, queueOffset=82 msgId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1315411, queueOffset=83, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F0000000000141253
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1315805, queueOffset=84, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F00000000001413DD
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1316199, queueOffset=85, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F0000000000141567
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1316593, queueOffset=86, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F00000000001416F1
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1316987, queueOffset=87, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F000000000014187B
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1317381, queueOffset=88, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F0000000000141A05
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1317775, queueOffset=89, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F0000000000141B8F
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1318169, queueOffset=90, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F0000000000141D19
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1318563, queueOffset=91, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F0000000000141EA3
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1318957, queueOffset=92, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F000000000014202D
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1319352, queueOffset=93, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F00000000001421B8
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1319747, queueOffset=94, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F0000000000142343
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1320142, queueOffset=95, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F00000000001424CE
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1320537, queueOffset=96, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F0000000000142659
checkLocalTransaction: tranId=C0DE00428BEC18B4AAC27F377B6E0000, commitLogOffset=1320932, queueOffset=97, msgId=C0DE004200002A9F00000000001427E4

通过上述例子的输出结果可以发现，checkLocalTransaction中queueOffset、msgId都发生的变化。那么在broker中到底发生了什么呢。

事务消息原理

当客户端发送一个事务消息时，MessageConst.PROPERTY_TRANSACTION_PREPARED=“true” 标记这个消息是一个事务消息。

        SendResult sendResult = null;
        MessageAccessor.putProperty(msg, MessageConst.PROPERTY_TRANSACTION_PREPARED, "true");
        MessageAccessor.putProperty(msg, MessageConst.PROPERTY_PRODUCER_GROUP, this.defaultMQProducer.getProducerGroup());
        try {
            sendResult = this.send(msg);
        } catch (Exception e) {
            throw new MQClientException("send message Exception", e);
        }

broker在收到消息时会取出traFlag，如果traFlag=true消息将交给TransactionalMessageService处理

        String traFlag = oriProps.get(MessageConst.PROPERTY_TRANSACTION_PREPARED);
        boolean sendTransactionPrepareMessage = false;
        if (Boolean.parseBoolean(traFlag)
            && !(msgInner.getReconsumeTimes() > 0 && msgInner.getDelayTimeLevel() > 0)) { //For client under version 4.6.1
            if (this.brokerController.getBrokerConfig().isRejectTransactionMessage()) {
                response.setCode(ResponseCode.NO_PERMISSION);
                response.setRemark(
                    "the broker[" + this.brokerController.getBrokerConfig().getBrokerIP1()
                        + "] sending transaction message is forbidden");
                return response;
            }
            sendTransactionPrepareMessage = true;
        }

        long beginTimeMillis = this.brokerController.getMessageStore().now();

        if (brokerController.getBrokerConfig().isAsyncSendEnable()) {
            CompletableFuture<PutMessageResult> asyncPutMessageFuture;
            if (sendTransactionPrepareMessage) {
                //处理事务消息
                asyncPutMessageFuture = this.brokerController.getTransactionalMessageService().asyncPrepareMessage(msgInner);
            } else {
                asyncPutMessageFuture = this.brokerController.getMessageStore().asyncPutMessage(msgInner);
            }

TransactionalMessageService在保存消息时会将原来的topic使用RMQ_SYS_TRANS_HALF_TOPIC来替换，原topic信息存放在properties中。这样在是先把消息保存下来，而不让Consumer立刻就能收到。
当收到TransactionMQProducer发来的COMMIT_MESSAGE时，再将消息从RMQ_SYS_TRANS_HALF_TOPIC取出替换成原来的topic写入。同时再向RMQ_SYS_TRANS_OP_HALF_TOPIC的topic中也写一份。
broker通过对比RMQ_SYS_TRANS_OP_HALF_TOPIC和RMQ_SYS_TRANS_HALF_TOPIC中是否同时存在来判断事务消息是否结束了。
当收到的不是COMMIT_MESSAGE而是UNKNOW时，TransactionalMessageCheckService会定时回调TransactionMQProducer#checkLocalTransaction查询本地事务状态，默认最多检查15次。

TransactionalMessageCheckService

TransactionalMessageCheckService是一个运行在broker中的一个线程，线程默认每1分钟执行一次来检测系统中超时的half事务消息并发起重试。

    @Override
    public void check(long transactionTimeout, int transactionCheckMax,
        AbstractTransactionalMessageCheckListener listener) {
        try {
            String topic = TopicValidator.RMQ_SYS_TRANS_HALF_TOPIC;
            Set<MessageQueue> msgQueues = transactionalMessageBridge.fetchMessageQueues(topic);
            if (msgQueues == null || msgQueues.size() == 0) {
                log.warn("The queue of topic is empty :" + topic);
                return;
            }
            log.debug("Check topic={}, queues={}", topic, msgQueues);
            for (MessageQueue messageQueue : msgQueues) {
                long startTime = System.currentTimeMillis();
                //每个half queue都有一个对应的op queue
                MessageQueue opQueue = getOpQueue(messageQueue);
                //获取当前未完成的half queue的offset
                long halfOffset = transactionalMessageBridge.fetchConsumeOffset(messageQueue);
                //获取当前已完成的op queue的offset
                long opOffset = transactionalMessageBridge.fetchConsumeOffset(opQueue);
                log.info("Before check, the queue={} msgOffset={} opOffset={}", messageQueue, halfOffset, opOffset);
                if (halfOffset < 0 || opOffset < 0) {
                    log.error("MessageQueue: {} illegal offset read: {}, op offset: {},skip this queue", messageQueue,
                        halfOffset, opOffset);
                    continue;
                }
                ......
                // single thread
                int getMessageNullCount = 1;
                long newOffset = halfOffset;
                long i = halfOffset;
                long nextOpOffset = pullResult.getNextBeginOffset();
                int putInQueueCount = 0;
                int escapeFailCnt = 0;

                while (true) {
                    if (System.currentTimeMillis() - startTime > MAX_PROCESS_TIME_LIMIT) {
                        log.info("Queue={} process time reach max={}", messageQueue, MAX_PROCESS_TIME_LIMIT);
                        break;
                    }
                    if (removeMap.containsKey(i)) {
                        ......
                    } else {
                        //从RMQ_SYS_TRANS_HALF_TOPIC取出half消息
                        GetResult getResult = getHalfMsg(messageQueue, i);
                        MessageExt msgExt = getResult.getMsg();
                        if (msgExt == null) {
                            if (getMessageNullCount++ > MAX_RETRY_COUNT_WHEN_HALF_NULL) {
                                break;
                            }
                    	......
                        ......
                        //是否需要丢弃消息
                        if (needDiscard(msgExt, transactionCheckMax) || needSkip(msgExt)) {
                            listener.resolveDiscardMsg(msgExt);
                            newOffset = i + 1;
                            i++;
                            continue;
                        }
                        ......
                        //判断上次check是否超时
                        boolean isNeedCheck = opMsg == null && valueOfCurrentMinusBorn > checkImmunityTime
                            || opMsg != null && opMsg.get(opMsg.size() - 1).getBornTimestamp() - startTime > transactionTimeout
                            || valueOfCurrentMinusBorn <= -1;

                        if (isNeedCheck) {
                            //超时
                            if (!putBackHalfMsgQueue(msgExt, i)) {
                                continue;
                            }
                            putInQueueCount++;
                            log.info("Check transaction. real_topic={},uniqKey={},offset={},commitLogOffset={}",
                                    msgExt.getUserProperty(MessageConst.PROPERTY_REAL_TOPIC),
                                    msgExt.getUserProperty(MessageConst.PROPERTY_UNIQ_CLIENT_MESSAGE_ID_KEYIDX),
                                    msgExt.getQueueOffset(), msgExt.getCommitLogOffset());
                            //重新给TransactionListener发起check请求
                            listener.resolveHalfMsg(msgExt);
                ......
                ......
                ......
                if (newOffset != halfOffset) {
                    transactionalMessageBridge.updateConsumeOffset(messageQueue, newOffset);
                }
                long newOpOffset = calculateOpOffset(doneOpOffset, opOffset);
                if (newOpOffset != opOffset) {
                    transactionalMessageBridge.updateConsumeOffset(opQueue, newOpOffset);
                }                            

上述代码中有三个比较重要的细节，needDiscard、putBackHalfMsgQueue和listener.resolveHalfMsg。
needDiscard：从half queue取出来后判断消息的TRANSACTION_CHECK_TIMES属性是否大于15次。
小于15次，则TRANSACTION_CHECK_TIMES属性值+1。
大于15次，则从RMQ_SYS_TRANS_HALF_TOPIC中丢弃，通过listener.resolveDiscardMsg保存在TRANS_CHECK_MAX_TIME_TOPIC中交由人工处理。
putBackHalfMsgQueue：将消息重新插入一份到RMQ_SYS_TRANS_HALF_TOPIC，因为CommitLog的applyOnly特性不能修改原消息。所以需要重新apply消息导致queueOffset、commitLogOffset、msgId都发生了变化。

    private boolean putBackHalfMsgQueue(MessageExt msgExt, long offset) {
        PutMessageResult putMessageResult = putBackToHalfQueueReturnResult(msgExt);
        if (putMessageResult != null
            && putMessageResult.getPutMessageStatus() == PutMessageStatus.PUT_OK) {
            msgExt.setQueueOffset(
                putMessageResult.getAppendMessageResult().getLogicsOffset());
            msgExt.setCommitLogOffset(
                putMessageResult.getAppendMessageResult().getWroteOffset());
            msgExt.setMsgId(putMessageResult.getAppendMessageResult().getMsgId());
            log.debug(
                "Send check message, the offset={} restored in queueOffset={} "
                    + "commitLogOffset={} "
                    + "newMsgId={} realMsgId={} topic={}",
                offset, msgExt.getQueueOffset(), msgExt.getCommitLogOffset(), msgExt.getMsgId(),
                msgExt.getUserProperty(MessageConst.PROPERTY_UNIQ_CLIENT_MESSAGE_ID_KEYIDX),
                msgExt.getTopic());
            return true;

listener.resolveHalfMsg：通过回调resolveHalfMsg方法向TransactionMQProducer重发check。

    public void resolveHalfMsg(final MessageExt msgExt) {
        if (executorService != null) {
            executorService.execute(new Runnable() {
                @Override
                public void run() {
                    try {
                        sendCheckMessage(msgExt);
                    } catch (Exception e) {
                        LOGGER.error("Send check message error!", e);
                    }
                }
            });
        } else {
            LOGGER.error("TransactionalMessageCheckListener not init");
        }
    }

    public void sendCheckMessage(MessageExt msgExt) throws Exception {
        CheckTransactionStateRequestHeader checkTransactionStateRequestHeader = new CheckTransactionStateRequestHeader();
        checkTransactionStateRequestHeader.setCommitLogOffset(msgExt.getCommitLogOffset());
        checkTransactionStateRequestHeader.setOffsetMsgId(msgExt.getMsgId());
        checkTransactionStateRequestHeader.setMsgId(msgExt.getUserProperty(MessageConst.PROPERTY_UNIQ_CLIENT_MESSAGE_ID_KEYIDX));
        checkTransactionStateRequestHeader.setTransactionId(checkTransactionStateRequestHeader.getMsgId());
        checkTransactionStateRequestHeader.setTranStateTableOffset(msgExt.getQueueOffset());
        checkTransactionStateRequestHeader.setBname(brokerController.getBrokerConfig().getBrokerName());
        msgExt.setTopic(msgExt.getUserProperty(MessageConst.PROPERTY_REAL_TOPIC));
        msgExt.setQueueId(Integer.parseInt(msgExt.getUserProperty(MessageConst.PROPERTY_REAL_QUEUE_ID)));
        msgExt.setStoreSize(0);
        String groupId = msgExt.getProperty(MessageConst.PROPERTY_PRODUCER_GROUP);
        Channel channel = brokerController.getProducerManager().getAvailableChannel(groupId);
        if (channel != null) {
            //取出与broker相连的netty channel发送check消息
            brokerController.getBroker2Client().checkProducerTransactionState(groupId, channel, checkTransactionStateRequestHeader, msgExt);
        } else {
            LOGGER.warn("Check transaction failed, channel is null. groupId={}", groupId);
        }
    }

half消息示意图