需求如下:需要从数据库的Cargo表中取出商品名称为“钉子”的货物。
可以这样做:
public class CargoRepository
{
public List SelectByPartName(string partName){}
}
当需求发生变化了,它要从数据库的Cargo表中取出商品编码为“0001”的货物。
可以这样做:
public class CargoRepository
{
public List SelectByPartCode(string partCode){}
}
当需求又一次变化了,它要从数据库的Cargo表中取出商品名称为“钉子”并且商品编码为“0001”的货物。
这时候问题严重了,看下上面的方法都是一些特定的查询,可能还有很多这样的查询。
他们单个的查询通过组合又形成了新的查询。这就是组合爆炸。
有两种模式可以解决这样的问题:Specification-[Evans的DDD]和Query Object[Fowler,PEAA]
这里只讨论Specification
在对DDD一书中提到:
(原文如下:业务规则不适于放在任何已个实体或值对象中,而且规则的变化和组合会掩盖那些领域对象的基本含义。)
有时经常造成组合爆炸。规格是模型的一部分,将它们从实体或值对象中独立出来有助于使模型更加清晰,它表达的是业务的规则。规格是值对象,它用来判断对象是否满足标准的谓词。谓词是指计算结果未true或false的函数,可以用and、or、not操作符连接。
对规格的接口定义:
public
interface
ISpecification
{
bool isSatisfiedBy(object candidate);
ISpecification and(ISpecification other);
ISpecification or(ISpecification other);
ISpecification not();
}
我们希望具体的规格只实现isSatisfiedBy方法,所以定义抽象类:
{
bool isSatisfiedBy(object candidate);
ISpecification and(ISpecification other);
ISpecification or(ISpecification other);
ISpecification not();
}
public
abstract
class
AbstractSpecification : ISpecification
{
ISpecification 成员#region ISpecification 成员
public abstract bool isSatisfiedBy(object candidate);
public ISpecification and(ISpecification other)
{
AndSpecification andSpec = Singleton<AndSpecification>.Instance();
andSpec.SetAndSpecification(this, other);
return andSpec;
}
public ISpecification or(ISpecification other)
{
OrSpecification orSpec = Singleton<OrSpecification>.Instance();
orSpec.SetOrSpecification(this, other);
return orSpec;
}
public ISpecification not()
{
NotSpecification notSpec = Singleton<NotSpecification>.Instance();
notSpec.SetNotSpecification(this);
return notSpec;
}
#endregion
定义操作符谓词:
{
ISpecification 成员#region ISpecification 成员
public abstract bool isSatisfiedBy(object candidate);
public ISpecification and(ISpecification other)
{
AndSpecification andSpec = Singleton<AndSpecification>.Instance();
andSpec.SetAndSpecification(this, other);
return andSpec;
}
public ISpecification or(ISpecification other)
{
OrSpecification orSpec = Singleton<OrSpecification>.Instance();
orSpec.SetOrSpecification(this, other);
return orSpec;
}
public ISpecification not()
{
NotSpecification notSpec = Singleton<NotSpecification>.Instance();
notSpec.SetNotSpecification(this);
return notSpec;
}
#endregion
internal
class
AndSpecification : AbstractSpecification
{
ISpecification one;
ISpecification other;
public void SetAndSpecification(ISpecification x, ISpecification y)
{
one = x;
other = y;
}
public override bool isSatisfiedBy(object candidate)
{
return one.isSatisfiedBy(candidate) && other.isSatisfiedBy(candidate);
}
}
{
ISpecification one;
ISpecification other;
public void SetAndSpecification(ISpecification x, ISpecification y)
{
one = x;
other = y;
}
public override bool isSatisfiedBy(object candidate)
{
return one.isSatisfiedBy(candidate) && other.isSatisfiedBy(candidate);
}
}
internal
class
OrSpecification : AbstractSpecification
{
ISpecification one;
ISpecification other;
public void SetOrSpecification(ISpecification x, ISpecification y)
{
one = x;
other = y;
}
public override bool isSatisfiedBy(object candidate)
{
return one.isSatisfiedBy(candidate) || other.isSatisfiedBy(candidate);
}
}
{
ISpecification one;
ISpecification other;
public void SetOrSpecification(ISpecification x, ISpecification y)
{
one = x;
other = y;
}
public override bool isSatisfiedBy(object candidate)
{
return one.isSatisfiedBy(candidate) || other.isSatisfiedBy(candidate);
}
}
internal
class
NotSpecification : AbstractSpecification
{
ISpecification wrapped;
public void SetNotSpecification(ISpecification notSpec)
{
wrapped = notSpec;
}
public override bool isSatisfiedBy(object candidate)
{
return !wrapped.isSatisfiedBy(candidate);
}
}
如果使用规格模式,系统中会存在许多小颗粒的规格类。性能会有影响。这里使用享元模式获取规格。
{
ISpecification wrapped;
public void SetNotSpecification(ISpecification notSpec)
{
wrapped = notSpec;
}
public override bool isSatisfiedBy(object candidate)
{
return !wrapped.isSatisfiedBy(candidate);
}
}
public
class
SpecificationFactory
{
private static readonly SpecificationFactory instance = new SpecificationFactory();
private Dictionary<string, ISpecification> m_SpecList;
private SpecificationFactory() { }
public static SpecificationFactory Instance()
{
return instance;
}
public ISpecification GetSepcification(string assembly,string type)
{
ISpecification spec;
if (m_SpecList==null) { m_SpecList = new Dictionary<string, ISpecification>(); }
string key = assembly + type;
if (!m_SpecList.ContainsKey(key))
{
spec = Assembly.Load(assembly).CreateInstance(type) as ISpecification;
if (spec!=null) { m_SpecList.Add(key, spec); return spec; }
throw new Exception(type + "规格不存在,请确保存" + assembly + "中存在" + type + "类");
}
return m_SpecList[key];
}
}
这里简单的测试:
{
private static readonly SpecificationFactory instance = new SpecificationFactory();
private Dictionary<string, ISpecification> m_SpecList;
private SpecificationFactory() { }
public static SpecificationFactory Instance()
{
return instance;
}
public ISpecification GetSepcification(string assembly,string type)
{
ISpecification spec;
if (m_SpecList==null) { m_SpecList = new Dictionary<string, ISpecification>(); }
string key = assembly + type;
if (!m_SpecList.ContainsKey(key))
{
spec = Assembly.Load(assembly).CreateInstance(type) as ISpecification;
if (spec!=null) { m_SpecList.Add(key, spec); return spec; }
throw new Exception(type + "规格不存在,请确保存" + assembly + "中存在" + type + "类");
}
return m_SpecList[key];
}
}
[TestMethod]
public void TestSpec()
{
SpecificationFactory sf = SpecificationFactory.Instance();
Cargo cargo=null;
ISpecification spec = sf.GetSepcification("Bmrxntfj", "Bmrxntfj.Specification.NullSpecification");
Assert.AreEqual(true, spec.isSatisfiedBy(cargo));
spec=spec.or(new EqualSpecification());
Assert.AreEqual(true, spec.isSatisfiedBy(cargo));
cargo = new Cargo();
cargo.PartCode = 2;
cargo.PartName = "2";
Assert.AreEqual(false, spec.isSatisfiedBy(cargo));
}
public void TestSpec()
{
SpecificationFactory sf = SpecificationFactory.Instance();
Cargo cargo=null;
ISpecification spec = sf.GetSepcification("Bmrxntfj", "Bmrxntfj.Specification.NullSpecification");
Assert.AreEqual(true, spec.isSatisfiedBy(cargo));
spec=spec.or(new EqualSpecification());
Assert.AreEqual(true, spec.isSatisfiedBy(cargo));
cargo = new Cargo();
cargo.PartCode = 2;
cargo.PartName = "2";
Assert.AreEqual(false, spec.isSatisfiedBy(cargo));
}
然而我们却不常这样做。因为有些ORM框架采用对象的属性来查询。在基础结构层中生成SQL,这样我们就不需要这样麻烦了。