java 拆分类_拆分或不拆分类(用Java)

我有一个句子,在不同的阶段进行分析.首先,我得到一些属性(比如X,Y,Z)：

public class AnalyzedSentence {

private String X;

private String Y;

private String Z;

public AnalyzedSentence(String sentence) {

extractX();

extractY();

extractZ();

}

// getters, setters

}

然后,我使用这些属性来进一步分析句子以获得另一个属性,比如“XYZ”,之后我创建了以下类：

public class FinalSentence {

private AnalyzedSentence data;

private String XYZ;

public FinalSentence(String XYZ, AnalyzedSentence data) {

this.data = data;

this.XYZ = XYZ;

}

// getters, setters

}

工作流程如下：

public class SentenceAnalyzer {

/// ...

public FinalSentence analyze(String sentence) {

AnalyzedSentence as = new AnalyzedSentence(sentence); // every attribute of "as" can be calculated beforehand

String XYZ = SpecialClass.extractXYZ(sentence, as); // extract XYZ (needs a special class), based on as

return new FinalSentence(XYZ, as);

}

}

或者,我可以只有一个类保存所有信息,在提取时填充属性,这可能会导致一些空结果.它是这样的：

public class Sentence {

private String X;

private String Y;

private String Z;

private String XYZ;

public Sentence(String sentence) {

extractX();

extractY();

extractZ();

}

public String getXYZ() {

// with this design, this method can be called, even if XYZ was not extracted yet.

// remember that XYZ cannot be extracted as X,Y,Z

}

public void setXYZ(...) {...}

// getters, setters

}

我的问题是：哪种设计更受欢迎,为什么？如果还有更好的方法来完成我在这里尝试做的事情,我也想听听它.