Configuring Quartz with JDBCJobStore in Spring

I am starting a little series about Quartz scheduler internals, tips and tricks, this is a chapter 0 - how to configure persistent job store. In Quartz you essentially have a choice between storing jobs and triggers in memory and in a relation database ( Terracotta is a recent addition to the mix). I would say in 90% of the cases when you use RAMJobStore with Quartz you don't really need Quartz at all. Obviously this storage backend is transient and all your pending jobs and triggers are lost between restarts. If you are fine with that, much simpler and more lightweight solutions are available, including ScheduledExecutorService built into JDK and[color=darkred] @Scheduled(cron="*/5 * * * * MON-FRI")[/color] in Spring. Can you justify using extra 0,5MiB JAR in this scenario?

This changes dramatically when you need clustering, fail-over, load-balancing and few other buzz-words. There are several use-cases for that:

[list]
[*]single server cannot handle required number of concurrent, long running jobs and the executions need to be split into several machines - but each task must be executed exactly ones
[*]we cannot afford to run jobs too late - if one server is down, another should run the job on time
[*]...or less strictly - the job needs to run eventually - even if the one and only server was down for maintenance, delayed jobs need to be run as soon as possible after restart
[/list]

In all cases above we need some sort of non-transient global storage to keep track which jobs were executed, so that they are run exactly ones by one machine. Relational database as a shared memory works good in this scenario.

So if you think you need to schedule jobs and have some of the requirements above, keep reading. I will show you how to configure Quartz with Spring and fully integrate them. First of all we need a DataSource:

import org.apache.commons.dbcp.BasicDataSource
import com.googlecode.flyway.core.Flyway
import org.jdbcdslog.DataSourceProxy
import org.springframework.jdbc.datasource.{DataSourceTransactionManager, LazyConnectionDataSourceProxy}
import org.h2.Driver

@Configuration
@EnableTransactionManagement
class Persistence {

    @Bean
    def transactionManager() = new DataSourceTransactionManager(dataSource())

    @Bean
    @Primary
    def dataSource() = {
        val proxy = new DataSourceProxy()
        proxy.setTargetDSDirect(dbcpDataSource())
        new LazyConnectionDataSourceProxy(proxy)
    }

    @Bean(destroyMethod = "close")
    def dbcpDataSource() = {
        val dataSource = new BasicDataSource
        dataSource.setDriverClassName(classOf[Driver].getName)
        dataSource.setUrl("jdbc:h2:mem:quartz-demo;DB_CLOSE_DELAY=-1;DB_CLOSE_ON_EXIT=FALSE;MVCC=TRUE")
        dataSource.setUsername("sa")
        dataSource.setPassword("")
        dataSource.setMaxActive(20)
        dataSource.setMaxIdle(20)
        dataSource.setMaxWait(10000)
        dataSource.setInitialSize(5)
        dataSource.setValidationQuery("SELECT 1")
        dataSource
    }

}

As you might have guessed, Quartz needs some database tables to work with. It does not create them automatically, but SQL scripts for several databases are provided, including H2 which as you can see I am using. I think Flyway is the easiest way to run database scripts on startup:

@Bean(initMethod = "migrate")
def flyway() = {
 val fly = new Flyway()
 fly.setDataSource(dataSource())
 fly
}

BTW in case you haven't noticed: no, there is no XML in our sample application and yes, we are using Spring.

Let's move on to Quartz:

@Configuration
class Scheduling {

    @Resource
    val persistence: Persistence = null

    @Bean
    @DependsOn(Array("flyway"))
    def schedulerFactory() = {
        val schedulerFactoryBean = new SchedulerFactoryBean()
        schedulerFactoryBean.setDataSource(persistence.dataSource())
        schedulerFactoryBean.setTransactionManager(persistence.transactionManager())
        schedulerFactoryBean.setConfigLocation(new ClassPathResource("quartz.properties"))
        schedulerFactoryBean.setJobFactory(jobFactory())
        schedulerFactoryBean.setApplicationContextSchedulerContextKey("applicationContext")
        schedulerFactoryBean.setSchedulerContextAsMap(Map().asJava)
        schedulerFactoryBean.setWaitForJobsToCompleteOnShutdown(true)
        schedulerFactoryBean
    }

    @Bean
    def jobFactory() = new SpringBeanJobFactory

}

It is nice to know you can inject instance of @Configuration annotated classes into another such class for convenience. Except that - nothing fancy. Note that we need @DependsOn(Array("flyway")) on Quartz scheduler factory - otherwise the scheduler might start before Flyway fired the migration script with Quartz database tables causing unpleasant errors on startup. The essential bits are SpringBeanJobFactory and schedulerContextAsMap. The special factory makes Spring responsible for creating Job instances. Unfortunately this factory is quite limited which we will see shortly in the following example. First we need a Spring bean and a Quartz job:

@Service
class Printer extends Logging {

    def print(msg: String) {
        logger.info(msg)
    }

}

class PrintMessageJob extends Job with Logging {

    @BeanProperty
    var printer: Printer = _

    @BeanProperty
    var msg = ""

    def execute(context: JobExecutionContext) {
        printer print msg
    }
}

First unexpected input is @BeanProperty instead of @Autowired or @Resource. Turns out that Job is not really a Spring bean, even though Spring creates an instance of it. Instead Spring discovers required dependencies using available setters. So where does the msg string come from? Keep going:

val trigger = newTrigger().
        withIdentity("Every-few-seconds", "Demo").
        withSchedule(
            simpleSchedule().
                    withIntervalInSeconds(4).
                    repeatForever()
        ).
        build()

val job = newJob(classOf[PrintMessageJob]).
        withIdentity("Print-message", "Demo").
        usingJobData("msg", "Hello, world!").
        build()

scheduler.scheduleJob(job, trigger)

Quartz 2.0 ships with a nice internal DSL for creating jobs and triggers in a readable manner. As you can see I am passing an extra "Hello, world!" parameter to the job. This parameter is stored in so called JobData in the database per job or per trigger. It will be provided to the job when it is executed. This way you can parametrize your jobs. However when executed our job throws NullPointerException... Apparently printer reference was not set and silently ignored. Turns out Spring won't simply look through all the beans available in the ApplicationContext. The SpringBeanJobFactory only looks into Jobs' and Triggers' JobData and into so called scheduler context (already mentioned). If you want to inject any Spring bean into Job you must explicitly place a reference to that bean in schedulerContext:

@Configuration
class Scheduling {

    @Resource
    val printer: Printer = null

    @Bean
    def schedulerFactory() = {
        val schedulerFactoryBean = new SchedulerFactoryBean()
        //...
        schedulerFactoryBean.setSchedulerContextAsMap(schedulerContextMap().asJava)
        //...
        schedulerFactoryBean
    }

    def schedulerContextMap() =
        Map(
            "printer" -> printer
        )

}

Unfortunately each and every Spring bean you want to inject to job has to be explicitly referenced in schedulerContextMap. Even worse, if you forget about it, Quartz will silently log NPE at runtime. In the future we will write more robust job factory. But for starters we have a working Spring + Quartz application ready for further experiments, sources as always available under my GitHub account.

You might ask yourself way can't we simply use MethodInvokingJobDetailFactoryBean? Well, first of all because it does not work with persistent job stores. Secondly - because it is unable to pass JobData to Job - so we can no longer distinguish between different job runs. For instance our job printing message would have to always print the same message hard-coded in the class.