内存管理算法,支持malloc,realloc,align_alloc,配有内存碎片合并算法

1 篇文章 1 订阅

起因

在嵌入式开发中,由于每个平台的内存管理实现算法不同,有时就需要我们自己实现一套内存管理算法。今天查看RTX5系统的内存分配源码,发现其内部实现中并没有内存碎片合并的算法,这样在随机大小分配内存时就会产生内存碎片的问题,不是很完美。而FreeRTOS的Heap4及Heap5的内存算法带有内存碎片的合并算法,但是其可移植性不好,没有对realloc、align_alloc的支持,不是很完美。基于这个原因,仿照了FreeRTOS中合并内存碎片的算法,自己编写了一套内存控制算法,使用单链表按地址按排序管理内存块,编写完成后使用vs2015编写了相应的测试代码,测试结果较为理想。
下面是算法源码及测试工程,源码分为两个文件,mem_manage.h与mem_manage.h

源码

mem_manage.h

/********************************************************************************
* @File name: mem_manage.h
* @Author: wzh
* @Version: 1.1
* @Date: 2021-8-14
* @Description: 内存管理算法,带有内存碎片合并算法,支持malloc、align_alloc、
*				realloc、free等常见的内存管理函数,支持多块内存合并管理,支持多线程
* @Todo	具体使用方法如下
*		 1、使用Mem_Manage_Heap_Init(Mem_Root* pRoot, const Mem_Region* pRigon)初始化
*			内存区,pRoot为句柄,pRigon描述了内存区个数以及内个内存区起始地址和大小
*			pRigon的格式如下
*			const Mem_Region pRigon[]=
*			{
*				(void*)(0x20000000),512*1024,
*				(void*)(0x80000000),256*1024,
*				....
*				NULL,0
*			}
*			注意地址必需由低到高排列,同时使用NULL,0标识结尾,内存区容量不要太小,至少大于64个字节
*			推荐内存区地址与内存区大小8字节对齐,这样会减少对齐操作对内存的损耗
*		 2、使用Mem_Manage_Malloc、Mem_Manage_Realloc、Mem_Manage_Align_Alloc进行内存
*			分配,其中Mem_Manage_Malloc、Mem_Manage_Realloc默认均为8字节对齐,可修改
*			.c文件中的宏定义修改,Mem_Manage_Align_Alloc可以指定地址对齐,但对齐的参数
*			有限制,align_size需要为2的整数次幂,否则会直接返回NULL。
*		 3、内存使用完毕后使用Mem_Manage_Free进行内存释放
*		 4、可通过Mem_Manage_Get_State查看内存使用情况,通过句柄Mem_Root成员total_size获取总内存量,
*			通过Mem_State成员remain_size获取内存剩余量
*		 5、使用默认的8字节对齐有助于减少小内存块,进而提高内存利用率
*		 6、目前最小内存块控制为16字节,可通过.c文件进行修改
*		 7、算法中使用了块大小标识的最高位作为分配标记,可在一定程度上检验非法释放,
*			但这也使得内存管理的最大内存限制为2GB(32位机)
********************************************************************************/
#ifndef MEM_MANAGE_H_
#define MEM_MANAGE_H_

#include <stddef.h>

//#define MEM_MANAGE_LOCK()
//#define MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK()
#define MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(A)					if(!(A))printf("MEM_MANAGE Malloc Error:%s,%d\r\n",__FILE__,__LINE__)
#define MEM_MANAGE_MALLOC_FAIL()				printf("MEM_MANAGE Malloc Fail:%s,%d\r\n",__FILE__,__LINE__)

#ifndef MEM_MANAGE_LOCK
#define MEM_MANAGE_LOCK()
#endif

#ifndef MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK
#define MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK()
#endif

#ifndef MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT
#define MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(A)			((void)(A))
#endif

#ifndef MEM_MANAGE_MALLOC_FAIL
#define MEM_MANAGE_MALLOC_FAIL()		
#endif

#if defined(__clang__)
#define MALLOC_API		__attribute__((malloc))
#else
#define MALLOC_API
#endif

#ifdef __cplusplus
extern "C" {
#endif

typedef struct Mem_Region {
	void*	addr;//内存区起始地址
	size_t	mem_size;//内存大小
}Mem_Region;

typedef struct Mem_Node {
	struct Mem_Node* next_node;
	size_t mem_size;
}Mem_Node;

typedef struct Mem_Root {
	Mem_Node* pStart;
	Mem_Node* pEnd;
	size_t total_size;		//总内存
}Mem_Root;

typedef struct Mem_State {
	size_t remain_size;		//内存剩余量
	size_t free_node_num;	//空闲节点个数
	size_t max_node_size;	//最大节点内存
	size_t min_node_size;	//最小节点内存
}Mem_State;

MALLOC_API void* Mem_Manage_Align_Alloc(Mem_Root* pRoot, size_t align_size, size_t want_size);
MALLOC_API void* Mem_Manage_Malloc(Mem_Root* pRoot, size_t want_size);
MALLOC_API void* Mem_Manage_Realloc(Mem_Root* pRoot, void* src_addr, size_t want_size);
void Mem_Manage_Free(Mem_Root* pRoot, void* addr);
void Mem_Manage_Heap_Init(Mem_Root* pRoot, const Mem_Region* pRigon);
void Mem_Manage_Get_State(Mem_Root* pRoot, Mem_State* pState);

#undef MALLOC_API
#ifdef __cplusplus
}
#endif

#endif

mem_manage.c

/********************************************************************************
* @File name: mem_manage.c
* @Author: wzh
* @Version: 1.1
* @Date: 2021-8-14
* @Description: 内存管理算法,带有内存碎片合并算法,支持malloc、align_alloc、
*				realloc、free等常见的内存管理函数,支持多块内存合并管理,支持多线程
********************************************************************************/
#include <stdint.h>
#include <stdio.h>
#include <string.h>
#include "mem_manage.h"

#define MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT		8
#define MEM_MANAGE_BITS_PER_BYTE				8
#define MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE				Mem_Manage_Align_Up(sizeof(Mem_Node),MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT)
#define MEM_MANAGE_MINUM_MEM_SIZE				(MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE<<1)
#define MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL					((size_t)(1<<(sizeof(size_t)*MEM_MANAGE_BITS_PER_BYTE-1)))


static inline size_t Mem_Manage_Align_Down(size_t data, size_t align_byte) {
	return data&~(align_byte - 1);
}

static inline size_t Mem_Manage_Align_Up(size_t data, size_t align_byte) {
	return (data + align_byte - 1)&~(align_byte - 1);
}

static inline Mem_Node* Mem_Manage_Addr_To_Mem(const void* addr) {
	return (Mem_Node*)((const uint8_t*)addr - MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE);
}

static inline void* Mem_Manage_Mem_To_Addr(const Mem_Node* mem_node) {
	return (void*)((const uint8_t*)mem_node + MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE);
}

//将内存节点插入空闲列表中
static inline void Mem_Insert_Node_To_FreeList(Mem_Root* pRoot, Mem_Node* pNode) {
	Mem_Node* pPriv_Node;
	Mem_Node* pNext_Node;
	//寻找地址与pNode相近的节点
	for (pPriv_Node = pRoot->pStart; pPriv_Node->next_node < pNode; pPriv_Node = pPriv_Node->next_node);
	pNext_Node = pPriv_Node->next_node;
	//尝试pNode与前一个块进行合并
	if ((uint8_t*)Mem_Manage_Mem_To_Addr(pPriv_Node) + pPriv_Node->mem_size == (uint8_t*)pNode) {
		if (pPriv_Node != pRoot->pStart) {//不是Start块的话可以合并
			pPriv_Node->mem_size += MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE + pNode->mem_size;
			pNode = pPriv_Node;
		}
		else {//后面如果是Start块不进行合并,以免浪费内存
			pRoot->pStart->next_node = pNode;
		}
	}
	else {//不能合并时直接插入到空闲单链表中
		pPriv_Node->next_node = pNode;
	}
	//尝试后面一个块与pNode进行合并
	if ((uint8_t*)Mem_Manage_Mem_To_Addr(pNode) + pNode->mem_size == (uint8_t*)pNext_Node) {
		if (pNext_Node != pRoot->pEnd) {//不是end块的话可以进行块合并
			pNode->mem_size += MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE + pNext_Node->mem_size;
			pNode->next_node = pNext_Node->next_node;
		}
		else {//后面如果是end块不进行合并,以免浪费内存
			pNode->next_node = pRoot->pEnd;
		}
	}
	else {//不能合并时直接插入到空闲单链表中
		pNode->next_node = pNext_Node;
	}
}

//获取管理内存的状态
void Mem_Manage_Get_State(Mem_Root* pRoot,Mem_State* pState) {
	MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(pRoot->pStart != NULL);
	MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(pRoot->pEnd != NULL);
	pState->max_node_size = pRoot->pStart->next_node->mem_size;
	pState->min_node_size = pRoot->pStart->next_node->mem_size;
	pState->remain_size = 0;
	pState->free_node_num = 0;
	MEM_MANAGE_LOCK();
	for (Mem_Node* pNode = pRoot->pStart->next_node; pNode->next_node != NULL; pNode = pNode->next_node) {
		pState->remain_size += pNode->mem_size;
		pState->free_node_num ++;
		if (pNode->mem_size > pState->max_node_size)
			pState->max_node_size = pNode->mem_size;
		if (pNode->mem_size < pState->min_node_size)
			pState->min_node_size = pNode->mem_size;
	}
	MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
}

//对齐分配内存
void* Mem_Manage_Align_Alloc(Mem_Root* pRoot,size_t align_size, size_t want_size) {
	void* pReturn = NULL;
	Mem_Node* pPriv_Node,*pNow_Node;

	MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(pRoot->pStart != NULL);
	MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(pRoot->pEnd != NULL);
	
	
	if (want_size == 0) {
		return NULL;
	}

	if ((want_size&MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL) != 0) {//内存过大
		MEM_MANAGE_MALLOC_FAIL();
		return NULL;
	}

	if (align_size&(align_size - 1)) {//内存对齐输入非法值
		MEM_MANAGE_MALLOC_FAIL();
		return NULL;
	}
	
	MEM_MANAGE_LOCK();
	if (want_size < MEM_MANAGE_MINUM_MEM_SIZE)
		want_size = MEM_MANAGE_MINUM_MEM_SIZE;
	if (align_size < MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT)
		align_size = MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT;
	//确保分配的单元都是MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT的整数倍
	want_size = Mem_Manage_Align_Up(want_size, MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT);

	pPriv_Node = pRoot->pStart;
	pNow_Node = pRoot->pStart->next_node;
	
	while (pNow_Node->next_node != NULL) {
		if (pNow_Node->mem_size >= want_size+ MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE) {
			size_t use_align_size;
			size_t new_size;
			pReturn = (void*)Mem_Manage_Align_Up((size_t)Mem_Manage_Mem_To_Addr(pNow_Node), align_size);//计算出对齐的地址
			use_align_size = (uint8_t*)pReturn-(uint8_t*)Mem_Manage_Mem_To_Addr(pNow_Node);//计算对齐所消耗的内存
			if (use_align_size != 0) {//内存不对齐
				if (use_align_size < MEM_MANAGE_MINUM_MEM_SIZE+ MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE) {//不对齐的值过小
					pReturn = (void*)Mem_Manage_Align_Up(\
						(size_t)Mem_Manage_Mem_To_Addr(pNow_Node)+ MEM_MANAGE_MINUM_MEM_SIZE+ MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE, align_size);
					use_align_size = (uint8_t*)pReturn - (uint8_t*)Mem_Manage_Mem_To_Addr(pNow_Node);
				}
				if (use_align_size <= pNow_Node->mem_size) {
					new_size = pNow_Node->mem_size - use_align_size;//计算去除对齐消耗的内存剩下的内存大小
					if (new_size >= want_size) {//满足条件,可以进行分配
						Mem_Node* pNew_Node = Mem_Manage_Addr_To_Mem(pReturn);
						pNow_Node->mem_size -= new_size + MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE;//分裂节点
						pNew_Node->mem_size = new_size;//新节点本来也不在空闲链表中,不用从空闲链表中排出
						pNew_Node->next_node = NULL;
						pNow_Node = pNew_Node;
						break;
					}
				}
			}
			else {//内存直接就是对齐的
				pPriv_Node->next_node = pNow_Node->next_node;//排出空闲链表
				pNow_Node->next_node = NULL;
				break;
			}
		}
		pPriv_Node = pNow_Node;
		pNow_Node = pNow_Node->next_node;
	}

	if (pNow_Node == pRoot->pEnd){//分配失败
		MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
		MEM_MANAGE_MALLOC_FAIL();
		return NULL;
	}

	if (pNow_Node->mem_size >= MEM_MANAGE_MINUM_MEM_SIZE+ MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE + want_size) {//节点内存还有富余
		Mem_Node* pNew_Node =(Mem_Node*)((uint8_t*)Mem_Manage_Mem_To_Addr(pNow_Node) + want_size);//计算将要移入空闲链表的节点地址
		pNew_Node->mem_size = pNow_Node->mem_size - want_size - MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE;
		pNew_Node->next_node = NULL;
		pNow_Node->mem_size = want_size;
		Mem_Insert_Node_To_FreeList(pRoot, pNew_Node);
	}
	pNow_Node->mem_size |= MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL;//标记内存已分配
	MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
	return pReturn;
}

void* Mem_Manage_Malloc(Mem_Root* pRoot, size_t want_size) {
	return Mem_Manage_Align_Alloc(pRoot, MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT, want_size);
}

void* Mem_Manage_Realloc(Mem_Root* pRoot, void* src_addr, size_t want_size) {
	void* pReturn = NULL;
	Mem_Node* pNext_Node,*pPriv_Node;
	Mem_Node* pSrc_Node;
	MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(pRoot->pStart != NULL);
	MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(pRoot->pEnd != NULL);
	if (src_addr == NULL) {
		return Mem_Manage_Align_Alloc(pRoot, MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT, want_size);
	}
	if (want_size == 0) {
		Mem_Manage_Free(pRoot, src_addr);
		return NULL;
	}

	MEM_MANAGE_LOCK();
	if ((want_size&MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL) != 0){
		MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
		MEM_MANAGE_MALLOC_FAIL();
		return NULL;
	}

	pSrc_Node = Mem_Manage_Addr_To_Mem(src_addr);

	if ((pSrc_Node->mem_size&MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL) == 0) {//源地址未被分配,调用错误
		MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
		MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT((pSrc_Node->mem_size&MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL) != 0);
		MEM_MANAGE_MALLOC_FAIL();
		return NULL;
	}

	pSrc_Node->mem_size &= ~MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL;//清除分配标记
	if (pSrc_Node->mem_size >= want_size) {//块预留地址足够大
		pSrc_Node->mem_size |= MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL;//恢复分配标记
		pReturn = src_addr;
		MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
		return pReturn;
	}
	//开始在空闲列表中寻找与本块相近的块
	for (pPriv_Node = pRoot->pStart; pPriv_Node->next_node <pSrc_Node; pPriv_Node = pPriv_Node->next_node);
	pNext_Node = pPriv_Node->next_node;

	if (pNext_Node != pRoot->pEnd && \
		((uint8_t*)src_addr + pSrc_Node->mem_size == (uint8_t*)pNext_Node) && \
		(pSrc_Node->mem_size + pNext_Node->mem_size + MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE >= want_size)) {
		//满足下一节点非end,内存连续,内存剩余足够
		pReturn = src_addr;
		pPriv_Node->next_node = pNext_Node->next_node;//排出空闲列表
		pSrc_Node->mem_size += MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE + pNext_Node->mem_size;
		want_size = Mem_Manage_Align_Up(want_size, MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT);
		if (pSrc_Node->mem_size >= MEM_MANAGE_MINUM_MEM_SIZE+ MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE+ want_size) {//去除分配的剩余空间足够开辟新块
			Mem_Node* pNew_Node = (Mem_Node*)((uint8_t*)Mem_Manage_Mem_To_Addr(pSrc_Node) + want_size);
			pNew_Node->next_node = NULL;
			pNew_Node->mem_size = pSrc_Node->mem_size - want_size - MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE;
			pSrc_Node->mem_size = want_size;
			Mem_Insert_Node_To_FreeList(pRoot, pNew_Node);
		}
		pSrc_Node->mem_size |= MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL;//恢复分配标记
		MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
	}
	else {
		MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
		pReturn = Mem_Manage_Align_Alloc(pRoot, MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT, want_size);
		if (pReturn == NULL){
			pSrc_Node->mem_size |= MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL;//恢复分配标记
			MEM_MANAGE_MALLOC_FAIL();
			return NULL;
		}
		MEM_MANAGE_LOCK();
		memcpy(pReturn, src_addr, pSrc_Node->mem_size);
		pSrc_Node->mem_size |= MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL;//恢复分配标记
		MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
		Mem_Manage_Free(pRoot, src_addr);
	}
	return pReturn;
}

//释放内存
void Mem_Manage_Free(Mem_Root* pRoot,void* addr) {
	Mem_Node* pFree_Node;
	MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(pRoot->pStart != NULL);
	MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(pRoot->pEnd != NULL);
	MEM_MANAGE_LOCK();
	if (addr == NULL) {
		MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
		return;
	}
	pFree_Node = Mem_Manage_Addr_To_Mem(addr);

	if ((pFree_Node->mem_size&MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL) == 0) {//释放错误,没有标记
		MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
		MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT((pFree_Node->mem_size&MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL) != 0);
		return;
	}

	if (pFree_Node->next_node != NULL) {//释放错误
		MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
		MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(pFree_Node->next_node == NULL);
		return;
	}
	pFree_Node->mem_size &= ~MEM_MANAGE_ALLOCA_LABAL;//清除分配标记
	Mem_Insert_Node_To_FreeList(pRoot, pFree_Node);//插入到空闲链表中
	MEM_MANAGE_UNLOCK();
}

void Mem_Manage_Heap_Init(Mem_Root* pRoot,const Mem_Region* pRegion) {
	Mem_Node* align_addr;
	size_t align_size;
	Mem_Node* pPriv_node=NULL;

	pRoot->total_size = 0;
	pRoot->pEnd = NULL;
	pRoot->pStart = NULL;

	for (; pRegion->addr != NULL; pRegion++) {
		align_addr = (Mem_Node*)Mem_Manage_Align_Up((size_t)pRegion->addr, MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT);//计算内存块对齐后的地址
		if ((uint8_t*)align_addr > pRegion->mem_size+ (uint8_t*)pRegion->addr)//对齐消耗的内存超过内存区
			continue;
		align_size = pRegion->mem_size - ((uint8_t*)align_addr - (uint8_t*)pRegion->addr);//计算对齐后剩下的内存大小
		if (align_size < MEM_MANAGE_MINUM_MEM_SIZE+ MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE)//对齐剩下的内存太小
			continue;
		align_size -= MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE;//求除去掉表头后内存块的大小
		align_addr->mem_size = align_size;
		align_addr->next_node = NULL;
		if (pRoot->pStart == NULL) {//如果是初始化
			pRoot->pStart = align_addr;//将当前内存块地址记为start
			if (align_size >= MEM_MANAGE_MINUM_MEM_SIZE+ MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE) {//若剩下的块足够大
				align_size -= MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE;//去掉下一个块的表头剩下的内存大小
				align_addr = (Mem_Node*)((uint8_t*)pRoot->pStart + MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE);//下一个块的表头地址
				align_addr->mem_size = align_size;
				align_addr->next_node = NULL;
				pRoot->pStart->mem_size = 0;
				pRoot->pStart->next_node = align_addr;
				pRoot->total_size = align_addr->mem_size;
			}
			else {//内存太小了,将当前内存块地址记为start
				pRoot->total_size = 0;
				pRoot->pStart->mem_size = 0;
			}
		}
		else {
			pPriv_node->next_node = align_addr;//更新上一节点的next_node
			pRoot->total_size += align_size;
		}
		pPriv_node = align_addr;
	}
	//此时,pPriv_node为最后一个块,接下来在块尾放置表尾end
	//求出放置end块的地址,end块仅是方便遍历使用,因此尽量小,分配为MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE
	align_addr = (Mem_Node*)Mem_Manage_Align_Down(\
		(size_t)Mem_Manage_Mem_To_Addr(pPriv_node) + pPriv_node->mem_size - MEM_MANAGE_MEM_STRUCT_SIZE, MEM_MANAGE_ALIGNMENT_BYTE_DEFAULT);
	align_size = (uint8_t*)align_addr-(uint8_t*)Mem_Manage_Mem_To_Addr(pPriv_node);//求出分配出end块后,前一个块剩余大小
	if (align_size >= MEM_MANAGE_MINUM_MEM_SIZE) {//若剩下的块足够大
		pRoot->total_size -= pPriv_node->mem_size - align_size;//去掉分配end块消耗的内存
		pRoot->pEnd = align_addr;			//更新表尾的地址
		pPriv_node->next_node = align_addr;
		pPriv_node->mem_size = align_size;
		align_addr->next_node = NULL;
		align_addr->mem_size = 0;//end块不参与内存分配,因此直接为0就可以
	}
	else {//最后一个块太小了,直接作为end块
		pRoot->pEnd = pPriv_node;
		pRoot->total_size -= pPriv_node->mem_size;
	}
	MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(pRoot->pStart != NULL);
	MEM_MANAGE_ASSERT(pRoot->pEnd != NULL);
}





测试工程

Mem_manage_test.zip
提取码:02xf

  • 1
    点赞
  • 3
    收藏
    觉得还不错? 一键收藏
  • 0
    评论

“相关推荐”对你有帮助么?

  • 非常没帮助
  • 没帮助
  • 一般
  • 有帮助
  • 非常有帮助
提交
评论
添加红包

请填写红包祝福语或标题

红包个数最小为10个

红包金额最低5元

当前余额3.43前往充值 >
需支付:10.00
成就一亿技术人!
领取后你会自动成为博主和红包主的粉丝 规则
hope_wisdom
发出的红包
实付
使用余额支付
点击重新获取
扫码支付
钱包余额 0

抵扣说明:

1.余额是钱包充值的虚拟货币,按照1:1的比例进行支付金额的抵扣。
2.余额无法直接购买下载,可以购买VIP、付费专栏及课程。

余额充值