jedis是一个著名的key-value存储系统,而作为其官方推荐的java版客户端jedis也非常强大和稳定,支持事务、管道及有jedis自身实现的分布式。
在这里对jedis关于事务、管道和分布式的调用方式做一个简单的介绍和对比:
一、普通同步方式
最简单和基础的调用方式:
1 @Test2 public voidtest1Normal() {3 Jedis jedis = new Jedis("localhost");4 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();5 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {6 String result = jedis.set("n" + i, "n" +i);7 }8 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();9 System.out.println("Simple SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");10 jedis.disconnect();11 }
很简单吧,每次set之后都可以返回结果,标记是否成功。
二、事务方式(Transactions)
redis的事务很简单,他主要目的是保障,一个client发起的事务中的命令可以连续的执行,而中间不会插入其他client的命令。
看下面例子:
1 @Test2 public voidtest2Trans() {3 Jedis jedis = new Jedis("localhost");4 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();5 Transaction tx =jedis.multi();6 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {7 tx.set("t" + i, "t" +i);8 }9 List results =tx.exec();10 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();11 System.out.println("Transaction SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");12 jedis.disconnect();13 }
我们调用jedis.watch(…)方法来监控key,如果调用后key值发生变化,则整个事务会执行失败。另外,事务中某个操作失败,并不会回滚其他操作。这一点需要注意。还有,我们可以使用discard()方法来取消事务。
三、管道(Pipelining)
有时,我们需要采用异步方式,一次发送多个指令,不同步等待其返回结果。这样可以取得非常好的执行效率。这就是管道,调用方法如下:
1 @Test2 public voidtest3Pipelined() {3 Jedis jedis = new Jedis("localhost");4 Pipeline pipeline =jedis.pipelined();5 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();6 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {7 pipeline.set("p" + i, "p" +i);8 }9 List results =pipeline.syncAndReturnAll();10 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();11 System.out.println("Pipelined SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");12 jedis.disconnect();13 }
四、管道中调用事务
就Jedis提供的方法而言,是可以做到在管道中使用事务,其代码如下:
1 @Test2 public voidtest4combPipelineTrans() {3 jedis = new Jedis("localhost");4 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();5 Pipeline pipeline =jedis.pipelined();6 pipeline.multi();7 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {8 pipeline.set("" + i, "" +i);9 }10 pipeline.exec();11 List results =pipeline.syncAndReturnAll();12 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();13 System.out.println("Pipelined transaction:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");14 jedis.disconnect();15 }
但是经测试(见本文后续部分),发现其效率和单独使用事务差不多,甚至还略微差点。
五、分布式直连同步调用
1 Test2 public voidtest5shardNormal() {3 List shards =Arrays.asList(4 new JedisShardInfo("localhost",6379),5 new JedisShardInfo("localhost",6380));6
7 ShardedJedis sharding = newShardedJedis(shards);8
9 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();10 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {11 String result = sharding.set("sn" + i, "n" +i);12 }13 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();14 System.out.println("Simple@Sharing SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");15
16 sharding.disconnect();17 }
这个是分布式直接连接,并且是同步调用,每步执行都返回执行结果。类似地,还有异步管道调用。
六、分布式直连异步调用
1 @Test2 public voidtest6shardpipelined() {3 List shards =Arrays.asList(4 new JedisShardInfo("localhost",6379),5 new JedisShardInfo("localhost",6380));6
7 ShardedJedis sharding = newShardedJedis(shards);8
9 ShardedJedisPipeline pipeline =sharding.pipelined();10 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();11 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {12 pipeline.set("sp" + i, "p" +i);13 }14 List results =pipeline.syncAndReturnAll();15 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();16 System.out.println("Pipelined@Sharing SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");17
18 sharding.disconnect();19 }
七、分布式连接池同步调用
如果,你的分布式调用代码是运行在线程中,那么上面两个直连调用方式就不合适了,因为直连方式是非线程安全的,这个时候,你就必须选择连接池调用。
1 @Test2 public voidtest7shardSimplePool() {3 List shards =Arrays.asList(4 new JedisShardInfo("localhost",6379),5 new JedisShardInfo("localhost",6380));6
7 ShardedJedisPool pool = new ShardedJedisPool(newJedisPoolConfig(), shards);8
9 ShardedJedis one =pool.getResource();10
11 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();12 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {13 String result = one.set("spn" + i, "n" +i);14 }15 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();16 pool.returnResource(one);17 System.out.println("Simple@Pool SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");18
19 pool.destroy();20 }
上面是同步方式,当然还有异步方式。
八、分布式连接池异步调用
1 @Test2 public voidtest8shardPipelinedPool() {3 List shards =Arrays.asList(4 new JedisShardInfo("localhost",6379),5 new JedisShardInfo("localhost",6380));6
7 ShardedJedisPool pool = new ShardedJedisPool(newJedisPoolConfig(), shards);8
9 ShardedJedis one =pool.getResource();10
11 ShardedJedisPipeline pipeline =one.pipelined();12
13 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();14 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {15 pipeline.set("sppn" + i, "n" +i);16 }17 List results =pipeline.syncAndReturnAll();18 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();19 pool.returnResource(one);20 System.out.println("Pipelined@Pool SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");21 pool.destroy();22 }
九、需要注意的地方
事务和管道都是异步模式。在事务和管道中不能同步查询结果。比如下面两个调用,都是不允许的:
1 Transaction tx =jedis.multi();2 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {3 tx.set("t" + i, "t" +i);4 }5 System.out.println(tx.get("t1000").get()); //不允许
6
7 List results =tx.exec();8
9 …10 …11
12 Pipeline pipeline =jedis.pipelined();13 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();14 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {15 pipeline.set("p" + i, "p" +i);16 }17 System.out.println(pipeline.get("p1000").get()); //不允许
18
19 List results = pipeline.syncAndReturnAll();
事务和管道都是异步的,个人感觉,在管道中再进行事务调用,没有必要,不如直接进行事务模式。
分布式中,连接池的性能比直连的性能略好(见后续测试部分)。
分布式调用中不支持事务。
因为事务是在服务器端实现,而在分布式中,每批次的调用对象都可能访问不同的机器,所以,没法进行事务。
十、测试
运行上面的代码,进行测试,其结果如下:
Simple SET: 5.227seconds
Transaction SET:0.5seconds
Pipelined SET:0.353seconds
Pipelined transaction:0.509seconds
Simple@Sharing SET:5.289seconds
Pipelined@Sharing SET:0.348seconds
Simple@Pool SET:5.039seconds
Pipelined@Pool SET:0.401 seconds
另外,经测试分布式中用到的机器越多,调用会越慢。上面是2片,下面是5片:
Simple@Sharing SET: 5.494seconds
Pipelined@Sharing SET:0.51seconds
Simple@Pool SET:5.223seconds
Pipelined@Pool SET:0.518 seconds
下面是10片:
Simple@Sharing SET: 5.9seconds
Pipelined@Sharing SET:0.794seconds
Simple@Pool SET:5.624seconds
Pipelined@Pool SET:0.762 seconds
下面是100片:
Simple@Sharing SET: 14.055seconds
Pipelined@Sharing SET:8.185seconds
Simple@Pool SET:13.29seconds
Pipelined@Pool SET:7.767 seconds
分布式中,连接池方式调用不但线程安全外,根据上面的测试数据,也可以看出连接池比直连的效率更好。
十一、完整的测试代码
1 package com.example.nosqlclient;2
3 import java.util.Arrays;4 import java.util.List;5
6 import org.junit.AfterClass;7 import org.junit.BeforeClass;8 import org.junit.Test;9
10 import redis.clients.jedis.Jedis;11 import redis.clients.jedis.JedisPoolConfig;12 import redis.clients.jedis.JedisShardInfo;13 import redis.clients.jedis.Pipeline;14 import redis.clients.jedis.ShardedJedis;15 import redis.clients.jedis.ShardedJedisPipeline;16 import redis.clients.jedis.ShardedJedisPool;17 import redis.clients.jedis.Transaction;18
19 import org.junit.FixMethodOrder;20 import org.junit.runners.MethodSorters;21
22 @FixMethodOrder(MethodSorters.NAME_ASCENDING)23 public classTestJedis {24
25 private staticJedis jedis;26 private staticShardedJedis sharding;27 private staticShardedJedisPool pool;28
29 @BeforeClass30 public static voidsetUpBeforeClass() throws Exception {31 List shards =Arrays.asList(32 new JedisShardInfo("localhost",6379),33 new JedisShardInfo("localhost",6379)); //使用相同的ip:port,仅作测试
34
35
36 jedis = new Jedis("localhost");37 sharding = newShardedJedis(shards);38
39 pool = new ShardedJedisPool(newJedisPoolConfig(), shards);40 }41
42 @AfterClass43 public static voidtearDownAfterClass() throws Exception {44 jedis.disconnect();45 sharding.disconnect();46 pool.destroy();47 }48
49 @Test50 public voidtest1Normal() {51 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();52 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {53 String result = jedis.set("n" + i, "n" +i);54 }55 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();56 System.out.println("Simple SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");57 }58
59 @Test60 public voidtest2Trans() {61 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();62 Transaction tx =jedis.multi();63 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {64 tx.set("t" + i, "t" +i);65 }66 //System.out.println(tx.get("t1000").get());
67
68 List results =tx.exec();69 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();70 System.out.println("Transaction SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");71 }72
73 @Test74 public voidtest3Pipelined() {75 Pipeline pipeline =jedis.pipelined();76 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();77 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {78 pipeline.set("p" + i, "p" +i);79 }80 //System.out.println(pipeline.get("p1000").get());
81 List results =pipeline.syncAndReturnAll();82 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();83 System.out.println("Pipelined SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");84 }85
86 @Test87 public voidtest4combPipelineTrans() {88 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();89 Pipeline pipeline =jedis.pipelined();90 pipeline.multi();91 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {92 pipeline.set("" + i, "" +i);93 }94 pipeline.exec();95 List results =pipeline.syncAndReturnAll();96 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();97 System.out.println("Pipelined transaction:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");98 }99
100 @Test101 public voidtest5shardNormal() {102 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();103 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {104 String result = sharding.set("sn" + i, "n" +i);105 }106 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();107 System.out.println("Simple@Sharing SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");108 }109
110 @Test111 public voidtest6shardpipelined() {112 ShardedJedisPipeline pipeline =sharding.pipelined();113 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();114 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {115 pipeline.set("sp" + i, "p" +i);116 }117 List results =pipeline.syncAndReturnAll();118 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();119 System.out.println("Pipelined@Sharing SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");120 }121
122 @Test123 public voidtest7shardSimplePool() {124 ShardedJedis one =pool.getResource();125
126 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();127 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {128 String result = one.set("spn" + i, "n" +i);129 }130 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();131 pool.returnResource(one);132 System.out.println("Simple@Pool SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");133 }134
135 @Test136 public voidtest8shardPipelinedPool() {137 ShardedJedis one =pool.getResource();138
139 ShardedJedisPipeline pipeline =one.pipelined();140
141 long start =System.currentTimeMillis();142 for (int i = 0; i < 100000; i++) {143 pipeline.set("sppn" + i, "n" +i);144 }145 List results =pipeline.syncAndReturnAll();146 long end =System.currentTimeMillis();147 pool.returnResource(one);148 System.out.println("Pipelined@Pool SET:" + ((end - start)/1000.0) + "seconds");149 }150 }