OpenCompass 评测 InternLM-1.8B 实践

OpenCompass介绍

上海人工智能实验室科学家团队正式发布了大模型开源开放评测体系 “司南” (OpenCompass2.0),用于为大语言模型、多模态模型等提供一站式评测服务。其主要特点如下:

  • 开源可复现:提供公平、公开、可复现的大模型评测方案
  • 全面的能力维度:五大维度设计,提供 70+ 个数据集约 40 万题的的模型评测方案,全面评估模型能力
  • 丰富的模型支持:已支持 20+ HuggingFace 及 API 模型
  • 分布式高效评测:一行命令实现任务分割和分布式评测,数小时即可完成千亿模型全量评测
  • 多样化评测范式:支持零样本、小样本及思维链评测,结合标准型或对话型提示词模板,轻松激发各种模型最大性能
  • 灵活化拓展:想增加新模型或数据集?想要自定义更高级的任务分割策略,甚至接入新的集群管理系统?OpenCompass 的一切均可轻松扩展!

评测对象

本算法库的主要评测对象为语言大模型与多模态大模型。我们以语言大模型为例介绍评测的具体模型类型。

  • 基座模型:一般是经过海量的文本数据以自监督学习的方式进行训练获得的模型(如OpenAI的GPT-3,Meta的LLaMA),往往具有强大的文字续写能力。
  • 对话模型:一般是在的基座模型的基础上,经过指令微调或人类偏好对齐获得的模型(如OpenAI的ChatGPT、上海人工智能实验室的书生·浦语),能理解人类指令,具有较强的对话能力。

工具架构

  • 模型层:大模型评测所涉及的主要模型种类,OpenCompass 以基座模型和对话模型作为重点评测对象。
  • 能力层:OpenCompass 从本方案从通用能力和特色能力两个方面来进行评测维度设计。在模型通用能力方面,从语言、知识、理解、推理、安全等多个能力维度进行评测。在特色能力方面,从长文本、代码、工具、知识增强等维度进行评测。
  • 方法层:OpenCompass 采用客观评测与主观评测两种评测方式。客观评测能便捷地评估模型在具有确定答案(如选择,填空,封闭式问答等)的任务上的能力,主观评测能评估用户对模型回复的真实满意度,OpenCompass 采用基于模型辅助的主观评测和基于人类反馈的主观评测两种方式。
  • 工具层:OpenCompass 提供丰富的功能支持自动化地开展大语言模型的高效评测。包括分布式评测技术,提示词工程,对接评测数据库,评测榜单发布,评测报告生成等诸多功能。

设计思路

为准确、全面、系统化地评估大语言模型的能力,OpenCompass 从通用人工智能的角度出发,结合学术界的前沿进展和工业界的最佳实践,提出一套面向实际应用的模型能力评价体系。OpenCompass 能力维度体系涵盖通用能力和特色能力两大部分。

评测方法

OpenCompass 采取客观评测与主观评测相结合的方法。针对具有确定性答案的能力维度和场景,通过构造丰富完善的评测集,对模型能力进行综合评价。针对体现模型能力的开放式或半开放式的问题、模型安全问题等,采用主客观相结合的评测方式。

客观评测

针对具有标准答案的客观问题,我们可以通过使用定量指标比较模型的输出与标准答案的差异,并根据结果衡量模型的性能。同时,由于大语言模型输出自由度较高,在评测阶段,我们需要对其输入和输出作一定的规范和设计,尽可能减少噪声输出在评测阶段的影响,才能对模型的能力有更加完整和客观的评价。 为了更好地激发出模型在题目测试领域的能力,并引导模型按照一定的模板输出答案,OpenCompass 采用提示词工程 (prompt engineering)和语境学习(in-context learning)进行客观评测。 在客观评测的具体实践中,我们通常采用下列两种方式进行模型输出结果的评测:

  • 判别式评测:该评测方式基于将问题与候选答案组合在一起,计算模型在所有组合上的困惑度(perplexity),并选择困惑度最小的答案作为模型的最终输出。例如,若模型在 问题? 答案1 上的困惑度为 0.1,在 问题? 答案2 上的困惑度为 0.2,最终我们会选择 答案1 作为模型的输出。
  • 生成式评测:该评测方式主要用于生成类任务,如语言翻译、程序生成、逻辑分析题等。具体实践时,使用问题作为模型的原始输入,并留白答案区域待模型进行后续补全。我们通常还需要对其输出进行后处理,以保证输出满足数据集的要求。

主观评测

语言表达生动精彩,变化丰富,大量的场景和能力无法凭借客观指标进行评测。针对如模型安全和模型语言能力的评测,以人的主观感受为主的评测更能体现模型的真实能力,并更符合大模型的实际使用场景。 OpenCompass 采取的主观评测方案是指借助受试者的主观判断对具有对话能力的大语言模型进行能力评测。在具体实践中,我们提前基于模型的能力维度构建主观测试问题集合,并将不同模型对于同一问题的不同回复展现给受试者,收集受试者基于主观感受的评分。由于主观测试成本高昂,本方案同时也采用使用性能优异的大语言模拟人类进行主观打分。在实际评测中,本文将采用真实人类专家的主观评测与基于模型打分的主观评测相结合的方式开展模型能力评估。 在具体开展主观评测时,OpenComapss 采用单模型回复满意度统计和多模型满意度比较两种方式开展具体的评测工作。

快速开始

概览

在 OpenCompass 中评估一个模型通常包括以下几个阶段:配置 -> 推理 -> 评估 -> 可视化。

  • 配置:这是整个工作流的起点。您需要配置整个评估过程,选择要评估的模型和数据集。此外,还可以选择评估策略、计算后端等,并定义显示结果的方式。
  • 推理与评估:在这个阶段,OpenCompass 将会开始对模型和数据集进行并行推理和评估。推理阶段主要是让模型从数据集产生输出,而评估阶段则是衡量这些输出与标准答案的匹配程度。这两个过程会被拆分为多个同时运行的“任务”以提高效率,但请注意,如果计算资源有限,这种策略可能会使评测变得更慢。如果需要了解该问题及解决方案,可以参考 FAQ: 效率。
  • 可视化:评估完成后,OpenCompass 将结果整理成易读的表格,并将其保存为 CSV 和 TXT 文件。你也可以激活飞书状态上报功能,此后可以在飞书客户端中及时获得评测状态报告。 接下来,我们将展示 OpenCompass 的基础用法,展示书生浦语在 C-Eval 基准任务上的评估。它们的配置文件可以在 configs/eval_demo.py 中找到。

环境配置

创建开发机和 conda 环境

在创建开发机界面选择镜像为 Cuda11.7-conda,并选择 GPU 为10% A100。

安装

面向GPU的环境安装
conda create -n opencompass python=3.10
conda install pytorch==2.1.2 torchvision==0.16.2 torchaudio==2.1.2 pytorch-cuda=12.1 -c pytorch -c nvidia -y
cd ~
conda activate opencompass
git clone -b 0.2.4 https://github.com/open-compass/opencompass
cd opencompass
pip install -e .
apt-get update
apt-get install cmake
pip install -r requirements.txt
pip install protobuf

在运行时我遇到了如下错误,改了好久最后发现是缺少了__init__.py文件

解决方案:

看看自己的opencompass文件夹有没有一个opencompass文件夹,在这个文件夹里有__init__.py文件,utils文件夹等内容。如果没有,需要在下面这个链接里下载相关文件,否则会报错

https://github.com/open-compass/opencompass

补充:

如果在运行后面的代码时发现报错

ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'opencompass'

也是上面的解决方案,亲测有效!!!

有部分第三方功能,如代码能力基准测试 HumanEval 以及 Llama 格式的模型评测,可能需要额外步骤才能正常运行,如需评测,详细步骤请参考安装指南。

数据准备

解压评测数据集到 data/ 处

cp /share/temp/datasets/OpenCompassData-core-20231110.zip /root/opencompass/
unzip OpenCompassData-core-20231110.zip

将会在 OpenCompass 下看到data文件夹

查看支持的数据集和模型

列出所有跟 InternLM 及 C-Eval 相关的配置

python tools/list_configs.py internlm ceval

将会看到

+----------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Model                                  | Config Path                                                          |
|----------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------------|
| hf_internlm2_1_8b                      | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_1_8b.py                      |
| hf_internlm2_20b                       | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_20b.py                       |
| hf_internlm2_7b                        | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_7b.py                        |
| hf_internlm2_base_20b                  | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_base_20b.py                  |
| hf_internlm2_base_7b                   | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_base_7b.py                   |
| hf_internlm2_chat_1_8b                 | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_1_8b.py                 |
| hf_internlm2_chat_1_8b_sft             | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_1_8b_sft.py             |
| hf_internlm2_chat_20b                  | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_20b.py                  |
| hf_internlm2_chat_20b_sft              | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_20b_sft.py              |
| hf_internlm2_chat_20b_with_system      | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_20b_with_system.py      |
| hf_internlm2_chat_7b                   | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_7b.py                   |
| hf_internlm2_chat_7b_sft               | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_7b_sft.py               |
| hf_internlm2_chat_7b_with_system       | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_7b_with_system.py       |
| hf_internlm2_chat_math_20b             | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_math_20b.py             |
| hf_internlm2_chat_math_20b_with_system | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_math_20b_with_system.py |
| hf_internlm2_chat_math_7b              | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_math_7b.py              |
| hf_internlm2_chat_math_7b_with_system  | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm2_chat_math_7b_with_system.py  |
| hf_internlm_20b                        | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm_20b.py                        |
| hf_internlm_7b                         | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm_7b.py                         |
| hf_internlm_chat_20b                   | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm_chat_20b.py                   |
| hf_internlm_chat_7b                    | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm_chat_7b.py                    |
| hf_internlm_chat_7b_8k                 | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm_chat_7b_8k.py                 |
| hf_internlm_chat_7b_v1_1               | configs/models/hf_internlm/hf_internlm_chat_7b_v1_1.py               |
| internlm_7b                            | configs/models/internlm/internlm_7b.py                               |
| ms_internlm_chat_7b_8k                 | configs/models/ms_internlm/ms_internlm_chat_7b_8k.py                 |
+----------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------------+
+--------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Dataset                        | Config Path                                                       |
|--------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------|
| ceval_clean_ppl                | configs/datasets/ceval/ceval_clean_ppl.py                         |
| ceval_contamination_ppl_810ec6 | configs/datasets/contamination/ceval_contamination_ppl_810ec6.py  |
| ceval_gen                      | configs/datasets/ceval/ceval_gen.py                               |
| ceval_gen_2daf24               | configs/datasets/ceval/ceval_gen_2daf24.py                        |
| ceval_gen_5f30c7               | configs/datasets/ceval/ceval_gen_5f30c7.py                        |
| ceval_ppl                      | configs/datasets/ceval/ceval_ppl.py                               |
| ceval_ppl_1cd8bf               | configs/datasets/ceval/ceval_ppl_1cd8bf.py                        |
| ceval_ppl_578f8d               | configs/datasets/ceval/ceval_ppl_578f8d.py                        |
| ceval_ppl_93e5ce               | configs/datasets/ceval/ceval_ppl_93e5ce.py                        |
| ceval_zero_shot_gen_bd40ef     | configs/datasets/ceval/ceval_zero_shot_gen_bd40ef.py              |
| configuration_internlm         | configs/datasets/cdme/internlm2-chat-7b/configuration_internlm.py |
| modeling_internlm2             | configs/datasets/cdme/internlm2-chat-7b/modeling_internlm2.py     |
| tokenization_internlm          | configs/datasets/cdme/internlm2-chat-7b/tokenization_internlm.py  |
+--------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------+
启动评测 (10% A100 8GB 资源)

使用命令行配置参数法进行评测

打开 opencompass文件夹下configs/models/hf_internlm/的hf_internlm2_chat_1_8b.py ,贴入以下代码

from opencompass.models import HuggingFaceCausalLM


models = [
    dict(
        type=HuggingFaceCausalLM,
        abbr='internlm2-1.8b-hf',
        path="/share/new_models/Shanghai_AI_Laboratory/internlm2-chat-1_8b",
        tokenizer_path='/share/new_models/Shanghai_AI_Laboratory/internlm2-chat-1_8b',
        model_kwargs=dict(
            trust_remote_code=True,
            device_map='auto',
        ),
        tokenizer_kwargs=dict(
            padding_side='left',
            truncation_side='left',
            use_fast=False,
            trust_remote_code=True,
        ),
        max_out_len=100,
        min_out_len=1,
        max_seq_len=2048,
        batch_size=8,
        run_cfg=dict(num_gpus=1, num_procs=1),
    )
]

确保按照上述步骤正确安装 OpenCompass 并准备好数据集后,可以通过以下命令评测 InternLM2-Chat-1.8B 模型在 C-Eval 数据集上的性能。由于 OpenCompass 默认并行启动评估过程,我们可以在第一次运行时以 --debug 模式启动评估,并检查是否存在问题。在 --debug 模式下,任务将按顺序执行,并实时打印输出。

python run.py --datasets ceval_gen --models hf_internlm2_chat_1_8b --debug

命令解析

python run.py
--datasets ceval_gen \ # 数据集准备
--models hf_internlm2_chat_1_8b \  # 模型准备
--debug

遇到错误mkl-service + Intel(R) MKL MKL_THREADING_LAYER=INTEL is incompatible with libgomp.so.1 ... 解决方案:

export MKL_SERVICE_FORCE_INTEL=1
#或
export MKL_THREADING_LAYER=GNU

遇到问题

KeyError: './data/ceval/formal_ceval'

解决方案:

将datasets.py文件中的内容用下面的代码替换

import os
from .fileio import download_and_extract_archive
from .datasets_info import DATASETS_MAPPING, DATASETS_URL
from .logging import get_logger

USER_HOME = os.path.expanduser("~")
DEFAULT_DATA_FOLDER = os.path.join(USER_HOME, '.cache/opencompass/')



def get_data_path(dataset_id: str, local_mode: bool = False):
    """return dataset id when getting data from ModelScope repo, otherwise just
    return local path as is.

    Args:
        dataset_id (str): dataset id or data path
        local_mode (bool): whether to use local path or
            ModelScope/HuggignFace repo
    """
    print(f"Received dataset_id: {dataset_id}")
    print(f"Local mode is set to: {local_mode}")
    # update the path with CACHE_DIR
    cache_dir = os.environ.get('COMPASS_DATA_CACHE', '')

    # For absolute path customized by the users
    if dataset_id.startswith('/root/opencampus/data/ceval/formal_ceval') or os.path.exists(dataset_id):
        return dataset_id


    # For relative path, with CACHE_DIR
    if local_mode:
        local_path = dataset_id if os.path.isabs(dataset_id) else os.path.join(cache_dir, dataset_id)
        if not os.path.exists(local_path):
            return download_dataset(local_path, cache_dir)
        return local_path


    dataset_source = os.environ.get('DATASET_SOURCE', None)
    if dataset_source == 'ModelScope':
        ms_id = DATASETS_MAPPING[dataset_id]['ms_id']
        assert ms_id is not None, \
            f'{dataset_id} is not supported in ModelScope'
        return ms_id
    elif dataset_source == 'HF':
        # TODO: HuggingFace mode is currently not supported!
        hf_id = DATASETS_MAPPING[dataset_id]['hf_id']
        assert hf_id is not None, \
            f'{dataset_id} is not supported in HuggingFace'
        return hf_id
    else:
        # for the local path
        local_path = DATASETS_MAPPING[dataset_id]['local']
        local_path = os.path.join(cache_dir, local_path)
        
        if not os.path.exists(local_path):
            return download_dataset(local_path, cache_dir)
        else:
            return local_path


def download_dataset(data_path, cache_dir, remove_finished=True):
    get_logger().info(f'{data_path} does not exist!'
                    'Start Download data automatically!'
                    'If you have downloaded the data before,'
                    'You can specific `COMPASS_DATA_CACHE` '
                    'to avoid downloading~')
    # Try to load from default cache folder
    try_default_path = os.path.join(DEFAULT_DATA_FOLDER, data_path)
    if os.path.exists(try_default_path):
        get_logger().info(f"Try to load the data from {try_default_path}")
        return try_default_path

    # Cannot find data from default cache folder, download data.
    # Update DATASET_URL for internal dataset
    try:
        import json
        internal_datasets = '.OPENCOMPASS_INTERNAL_DATA_URL.json'
        file_path = os.path.join(USER_HOME, internal_datasets)
        assert os.path.exists(file_path), f"{file_path} not exits"
        with open(file_path, 'r') as f:
            internal_datasets_info = json.load(f)
        DATASETS_URL.update(internal_datasets_info)
        get_logger().info("Load internal dataset from: {file_path}")
    except Exception as e:  # noqa
        pass

    valid_data_names = list(DATASETS_URL.keys())
    dataset_name = ''
    for name in valid_data_names:
        if name in data_path:
            dataset_name = name
    assert dataset_name, f'No valid url for {data_path}!\n' + \
    f'Please make sure  `{data_path}` is correct'
    dataset_info = DATASETS_URL[dataset_name]
    dataset_url = dataset_info['url']
    dataset_md5 = dataset_info['md5']
    cache_dir = cache_dir if cache_dir else DEFAULT_DATA_FOLDER

    # download and extract files
    download_and_extract_archive(
        url=dataset_url, 
        download_root=os.path.join(cache_dir, 'data'),
        md5=dataset_md5,
        remove_finished=remove_finished
    )
    
    return os.path.join(cache_dir, data_path)

如果一切正常,您应该看到屏幕上显示 “Starting inference process”:

评测完成后,将会看到:

dataset                                         version    metric         mode      opencompass.models.huggingface.HuggingFace_Shanghai_AI_Laboratory_internlm2-chat-1_8b
----------------------------------------------  ---------  -------------  ------  ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ceval-computer_network                          db9ce2     accuracy       gen                                                                                       47.37
ceval-operating_system                          1c2571     accuracy       gen                                                                                       47.37
ceval-computer_architecture                     a74dad     accuracy       gen                                                                                       23.81
ceval-college_programming                       4ca32a     accuracy       gen                                                                                       13.51
ceval-college_physics                           963fa8     accuracy       gen                                                                                       42.11
ceval-college_chemistry                         e78857     accuracy       gen                                                                                       33.33
ceval-advanced_mathematics                      ce03e2     accuracy       gen                                                                                       10.53
ceval-probability_and_statistics                65e812     accuracy       gen                                                                                       38.89
ceval-discrete_mathematics                      e894ae     accuracy       gen                                                                                       25
ceval-electrical_engineer                       ae42b9     accuracy       gen                                                                                       27.03
ceval-metrology_engineer                        ee34ea     accuracy       gen                                                                                       54.17
ceval-high_school_mathematics                   1dc5bf     accuracy       gen                                                                                       16.67
ceval-high_school_physics                       adf25f     accuracy       gen                                                                                       42.11
ceval-high_school_chemistry                     2ed27f     accuracy       gen                                                                                       47.37
ceval-high_school_biology                       8e2b9a     accuracy       gen                                                                                       26.32
ceval-middle_school_mathematics                 bee8d5     accuracy       gen                                                                                       36.84
ceval-middle_school_biology                     86817c     accuracy       gen                                                                                       80.95
ceval-middle_school_physics                     8accf6     accuracy       gen                                                                                       47.37
ceval-middle_school_chemistry                   167a15     accuracy       gen                                                                                       80
ceval-veterinary_medicine                       b4e08d     accuracy       gen                                                                                       43.48
ceval-college_economics                         f3f4e6     accuracy       gen                                                                                       32.73
ceval-business_administration                   c1614e     accuracy       gen                                                                                       36.36
ceval-marxism                                   cf874c     accuracy       gen                                                                                       68.42
ceval-mao_zedong_thought                        51c7a4     accuracy       gen                                                                                       70.83
ceval-education_science                         591fee     accuracy       gen                                                                                       55.17
ceval-teacher_qualification                     4e4ced     accuracy       gen                                                                                       59.09
ceval-high_school_politics                      5c0de2     accuracy       gen                                                                                       57.89
ceval-high_school_geography                     865461     accuracy       gen                                                                                       47.37
ceval-middle_school_politics                    5be3e7     accuracy       gen                                                                                       71.43
ceval-middle_school_geography                   8a63be     accuracy       gen                                                                                       75
ceval-modern_chinese_history                    fc01af     accuracy       gen                                                                                       52.17
ceval-ideological_and_moral_cultivation         a2aa4a     accuracy       gen                                                                                       73.68
ceval-logic                                     f5b022     accuracy       gen                                                                                       27.27
ceval-law                                       a110a1     accuracy       gen                                                                                       29.17
ceval-chinese_language_and_literature           0f8b68     accuracy       gen                                                                                       47.83
ceval-art_studies                               2a1300     accuracy       gen                                                                                       42.42
ceval-professional_tour_guide                   4e673e     accuracy       gen                                                                                       51.72
ceval-legal_professional                        ce8787     accuracy       gen                                                                                       34.78
ceval-high_school_chinese                       315705     accuracy       gen                                                                                       42.11
ceval-high_school_history                       7eb30a     accuracy       gen                                                                                       65
ceval-middle_school_history                     48ab4a     accuracy       gen                                                                                       86.36
ceval-civil_servant                             87d061     accuracy       gen                                                                                       42.55
ceval-sports_science                            70f27b     accuracy       gen                                                                                       52.63
ceval-plant_protection                          8941f9     accuracy       gen                                                                                       40.91
ceval-basic_medicine                            c409d6     accuracy       gen                                                                                       68.42
ceval-clinical_medicine                         49e82d     accuracy       gen                                                                                       31.82
ceval-urban_and_rural_planner                   95b885     accuracy       gen                                                                                       47.83
ceval-accountant                                002837     accuracy       gen                                                                                       36.73
ceval-fire_engineer                             bc23f5     accuracy       gen                                                                                       38.71
ceval-environmental_impact_assessment_engineer  c64e2d     accuracy       gen                                                                                       51.61
ceval-tax_accountant                            3a5e3c     accuracy       gen                                                                                       36.73
ceval-physician                                 6e277d     accuracy       gen                                                                                       42.86
ceval-stem                                      -          naive_average  gen                                                                                       39.21
ceval-social-science                            -          naive_average  gen                                                                                       57.43
ceval-humanities                                -          naive_average  gen                                                                                       50.23
ceval-other                                     -          naive_average  gen                                                                                       44.62
ceval-hard                                      -          naive_average  gen                                                                                       32
ceval                                           -          naive_average  gen                                                                                       46.19

ps:需要经过漫长的等待!!!

使用配置文件修改参数法进行评测

除了通过命令行配置实验外,OpenCompass 还允许用户在配置文件中编写实验的完整配置,并通过 run.py 直接运行它。配置文件是以 Python 格式组织的,并且必须包括 datasets 和 models 字段。本次测试配置在 configs文件夹 中。此配置通过 继承机制 引入所需的数据集和模型配置,并以所需格式组合 datasets 和 models 字段。 运行以下代码,在configs文件夹下创建eval_tutorial_demo.py

cd /root/opencompass/configs
touch eval_tutorial_demo.py

打开eval_tutorial_demo.py 贴入以下代码

from mmengine.config import read_base

with read_base():
    from .datasets.ceval.ceval_gen import ceval_datasets
    from .models.hf_internlm.hf_internlm2_chat_1_8b import models as hf_internlm2_chat_1_8b_models

datasets = ceval_datasets
models = hf_internlm2_chat_1_8b_models

因此,运行任务时,我们只需将配置文件的路径传递给 run.py:

cd /root/opencompass
python run.py configs/eval_tutorial_demo.py --debug

如果一切正常,您应该看到屏幕上显示:

评测完成后,将会看到:

  • 17
    点赞
  • 7
    收藏
    觉得还不错? 一键收藏
  • 0
    评论
评论
添加红包

请填写红包祝福语或标题

红包个数最小为10个

红包金额最低5元

当前余额3.43前往充值 >
需支付:10.00
成就一亿技术人!
领取后你会自动成为博主和红包主的粉丝 规则
hope_wisdom
发出的红包
实付
使用余额支付
点击重新获取
扫码支付
钱包余额 0

抵扣说明:

1.余额是钱包充值的虚拟货币,按照1:1的比例进行支付金额的抵扣。
2.余额无法直接购买下载,可以购买VIP、付费专栏及课程。

余额充值