混合高斯聚类的一种实现方法

近来看了一篇文章《Hierarchical Clustering of a Mixture Model》【1】，它是一篇比较早的文章了，2005年，Jacob Goldberger Sam Roweis，Department of Computer Science, University of Toronto。文中讲到一种简单的高斯聚类方法，近来有文章将它用于目标检测（Object Detection）最后阶段，以代替NMS（non maximum suppression，非极大值抑制），获得更好的bbox预测。我试了一下，这种方法有其独到之处，经它处理后的bbox相互重叠的情况有很大改善，而且较NMS要“软”一些，没那么“硬”，生成的box样子要比NMS能更好地覆盖目标。接下来，我将结合自己的代码和实验进行小结。

一、高斯聚类

混合高斯模型（MoG，Gaussian Mixture Model）是一种常见的参数化概率模型，其表达形式如下：
$$f(y)=\sum _{i=1}^k{\alpha }_{i}N(y;{\mu }_i,{\Sigma }_i)=\sum _{i=1}^k{\alpha }_i{f}_i(y)(1)$$
$f(y)$是由 $k$ 个d维高斯分布构成的混合分布，各高斯分布 $f_i(y)$ 的期望和方差分别为 ${\mu }_i,{\Sigma }_i$。可将每个独立的高斯分布称为一个高斯核，所谓高斯聚类就是将多个高斯核进行聚类，用较少的高斯核来近似表达它，此过程描述如下：
$$f(y)=\sum _{i=1}^k{\alpha }_i{f}_i(y)\approx \sum _{j=1}^m{\beta }_j{g}_j(y)\text{, and }k>m(2)$$
(2)式中 $g_j(y)$ 也是与$f_i(y)$ 同维度的高斯分布，且约等于式左边的高斯核数量要大于右边的高斯核数量。所谓高斯聚类，指的就是用较少的高斯核混合分布来拟合较多核的高斯混合分布。
要完成 $G(y)={\sum }_{j=1}^m{\beta }_j{g}_j(y)$ 对 $F(y)={\sum }_{i=1}^k{\alpha }_i{f}_i(y)$ 的拟合即求使分布 $G(y)$ 与分布 $F(y)$ 距离最小的参数，设 $\theta$ 是 $G(y)$ 的可调参数集，于是 $G(y)$ 可写为 $G_{\theta }(y)$，于是拟合问题就是：
$$\theta =\arg \underset{\theta }{\min }Distance(G_{\theta },F)(3)$$
$G(y)$ 与 $F(y)$ 是两个分布，衡量概率分布的距离可以用KL散度：
$$KL(G,F)={\mathbb{E}}_F(\log \frac{p_g}{p_f})(4)$$
有了衡量拟合效果的距离定义（KL），有了可控参数模型（$G(y)$），似乎拟合问题就可以直接转化为最优化问题了：将 $G_{\theta }(y)$ 和 $F(y)$ 是代入（3）、（4），距离KL对参数集（ θ = { β , μ , Σ } \theta=\{\beta,\mu,\Sigma\} θ={β,μ,Σ}）求偏导，偏导置零求解最优参数集。但不幸的是$G_{\theta }(y)$ 和 $F(y)$ 都是混合高斯模型，这个过程没有闭式解，直接求最优解的方法行不通。怎么办？
突破点1：
两个混合高斯的KL没有闭式，但两个高斯的KL却是有闭式形式的：
设两个高斯分布分别为 $N_1({\mu }_1,{\Sigma }_1)$ 和 ${\mathbb{N}}_2({\mu }_2,{\Sigma }_2)$，则它们的KL距离为：
$$KL(N_1||N_2)=\frac{1}{2}\left(\log \frac{|{\Sigma }_2|}{|{\Sigma }_1|}+Tr({\Sigma }_2^{-1}{\Sigma }_1)+({\mu }_1-{\mu }_2{)}^T({\Sigma }_2{)}^{-1}({\mu }_1-{\mu }_2)+d\right)$$
证明：
d维高斯分布：
N ( x ∣ u , Σ ) = 1 ( 2 π ) n / 2 ∣ Σ ∣ 1 / 2 exp ⁡ { − 1 2 ( x − u ) T Σ − 1 ( x − u ) } N(x|u,\Sigma ) = {1 \over {{{(2\pi )}^{n/2}}{{\left| \Sigma \right|}^{1/2}}}}\exp \{ - {1 \over 2}{(x - u)^T}{\Sigma ^{ - 1}}(x - u)\} N(x∣u,Σ)=(2π)n/2∣Σ∣1/21​exp{−21​(x−u)TΣ−1(x−u)}
则两个高斯分布的KL散度为：
$$\begin{gathered} D_{KL}(P_1||P_2)=E_{P_1}\left[\log P_1-\log P_2\right] \\ =\frac{1}{2}{E}_{P_1}\left[-\log \left|{\Sigma }_1\right|-{(x-u_1)}^T{\Sigma }_1^{-1}(x-u_1)+\log \left|{\Sigma }_2\right|+{(x-u_2)}^T{\Sigma }_2^{-1}(x-u_2)\right] \\ =\frac{1}{2}\log \frac{\left|{\Sigma }_2\right|}{\left|{\Sigma }_1\right|}+\frac{1}{2}{E}_{P_1}\left[-{(x-u_1)}^T{\Sigma }_1^{-1}(x-u_1)+{(x-u_2)}^T{\Sigma }_2^{-1}(x-u_2)\right] \\ =\frac{1}{2}\log \frac{\left|{\Sigma }_2\right|}{\left|{\Sigma }_1\right|}+\frac{1}{2}{E}_{P_1}\left\{-tr\left[{\Sigma }_1^{-1}(x-u_1){(x-u_1)}^T\right]+tr\left[{\Sigma }_2^{-1}(x-u_2){(x-u_2)}^T\right]\right\} \end{gathered}$$
这是因为 $(x-u_1{)}^T{\Sigma }_1^{-1}(x-u_1)$ 是一个标量，因此有：
$$\begin{gathered} (x-u_1{)}^T{\Sigma }_1^{-1}(x-u_1)=tr\left((x-u_1{)}^T{\Sigma }_1^{-1}(x-u_1)\right) \\ =tr\left({\Sigma }_1^{-1}(x-u_1)(x-u_1{)}^T\right) \end{gathered}$$
$$\begin{gathered} =\frac{1}{2}\log \frac{\left|{\Sigma }_2\right|}{\left|{\Sigma }_1\right|}+\frac{1}{2}{E}_{P_1}\left\{-tr\left[{\Sigma }_1^{-1}(x-u_1){(x-u_1)}^T\right]\right\}+\frac{1}{2}{E}_{P_1}\left\{tr\left[{\Sigma }_2^{-1}(x-u_2){(x-u_2)}^T\right]\right\} \\ =\frac{1}{2}\log \frac{\left|{\Sigma }_2\right|}{\left|{\Sigma }_1\right|}-\frac{1}{2}tr\left\{E_{P_1}\left[{\Sigma }_1^{-1}(x-u_1){(x-u_1)}^T\right]\right\}+\frac{1}{2}tr\left\{E_{P_1}\left[{\Sigma }_2^{-1}(x-u_2){(x-u_2)}^T\right]\right\} \\ =\frac{1}{2}\log \frac{\left|{\Sigma }_2\right|}{\left|{\Sigma }_1\right|}-\frac{1}{2}tr\left\{{\Sigma }_1^{-1}{E}_{P_1}\left[(x-u_1){(x-u_1)}^T\right]\right\}+\frac{1}{2}tr\left\{E_{P_1}\left[{\Sigma }_2^{-1}(x{x}^T-u_2{x}^T-x{u}_2^T+u_2{u}_2^T)\right]\right\} \\ =\frac{1}{2}\log \frac{\left|{\Sigma }_2\right|}{\left|{\Sigma }_1\right|}-\frac{1}{2}tr\left\{{\Sigma }_1^{-1}{\Sigma }_1\right\}+\frac{1}{2}tr\left\{{\Sigma }_2^{-1}{E}_{P_1}(x{x}^T-u_2{x}^T-x{u}_2^T+u_2{u}_2^T)\right\} \\ =\frac{1}{2}\log \frac{\left|{\Sigma }_2\right|}{\left|{\Sigma }_1\right|}-\frac{1}{2}d+\frac{1}{2}tr\left\{{\Sigma }_2^{-1}({\Sigma }_1+u_1{u}_1^T-u_2{u}_1^T-u_1{u}_2^T+u_2{u}_2^T)\right\} \end{gathered}$$
这是因为$x\sim N_1(u_1,{\Sigma }_1)$：
$$E_{P_1}\left[x{x}^T\right]={\Sigma }_1+u_1{u}_1^T$$
$$\begin{gathered} =\frac{1}{2}\left\{\log \frac{\left|{\Sigma }_2\right|}{\left|{\Sigma }_1\right|}-d+tr({\Sigma }_2^{-1}{\Sigma }_1)+tr\left\{{\Sigma }_2^{-1}(u_1{u}_1^T-u_2{u}_1^T-u_1{u}_2^T+u_2{u}_2^T)\right\}\right\} \\ =\frac{1}{2}\left\{\log \frac{\left|{\Sigma }_2\right|}{\left|{\Sigma }_1\right|}-d+tr({\Sigma }_2^{-1}{\Sigma }_1)+tr\left\{{\Sigma }_2^{-1}{u}_1{u}_1^T-{\Sigma }_2^{-1}{u}_2{u}_1^T-{\Sigma }_2^{-1}{u}_1{u}_2^T+{\Sigma }_2^{-1}{u}_2{u}_2^T\right\}\right\} \\ =\frac{1}{2}\left\{\log \frac{\left|{\Sigma }_2\right|}{\left|{\Sigma }_1\right|}-d+tr({\Sigma }_2^{-1}{\Sigma }_1)+tr\left\{u_1^T{\Sigma }_2^{-1}{u}_1-2u_1^T{\Sigma }_2^{-1}{u}_2+u_2^T{\Sigma }_2^{-1}{u}_2\right\}\right\} \\ =\frac{1}{2}\left\{\log \frac{\left|{\Sigma }_2\right|}{\left|{\Sigma }_1\right|}-d+tr({\Sigma }_2^{-1}{\Sigma }_1)+{(u_2-u_1)}^T{\Sigma }_2^{-1}(u_2-u_1)\right\} \end{gathered}$$
这是因为 $x\sim N(u,\Sigma )$ 有：
$$E\left(x^{T}Ax\right)=tr(A\Sigma )+u^{T}Au$$
证毕。

突破点2：
经聚类后，$f_i$ 必对应于一个 $g_j$，一个 $g_j$ 可以对应多个 $f_i$，这是一个多对一的映射，该映射可定义为：
π : i → j ,   i ∈ { 1 , 2 , ⋯   , k } ,   j ∈ { 1 , 2 , ⋯   , m } ,  and  k > m \pi:i\to j,\ i\in \{1,2,\cdots,k\}, \ j\in \{1,2,\cdots, m\},\ \text{and} \ k\gt m π:i→j, i∈{1,2,⋯,k}, j∈{1,2,⋯,m}, and k>m
由上，定义一个具有闭式形式的混合高斯分布F和G的距离：
$$d(F,G,\pi )=\sum _{i=1}^k{\alpha }_{i}KL(f_i\Vert g_{\pi (i)})(5)$$
高斯聚类的结果就是使（5）最小。

二、聚类迭代

设F有k个高斯核，是需要拟合的混合高斯分布；G有m个高斯核，是参数化混合高斯分布模型。
1、初始化G的m个高斯核；
2、计算 $f_i$ 与 $g_j$ 之间距离，根据最近邻原则，构造映射关系 $j=\pi (i)$，$i={\pi }^{-1}(j)$ 是它的反函数。
3、计算 group_j 对应的高斯核
$$\begin{gathered} u_j^{\prime }=\frac{1}{{\beta }_j}\sum _{i\in {\pi }^{-1}(j)}{\alpha }_i{u}_i(6a) \\ {\Sigma }_j^{\prime }=\frac{1}{{\beta }_j}\sum _{i\in {\pi }^{-1}(j)}{\alpha }_i\left({\Sigma }_i+(u_i-u_j^{\prime })(u_i-u_j^{\prime }{)}^T\right)(6b) \\ {\beta }_j=\sum _{i\in {\pi }^{-1}(j)}{\alpha }_i(6c) \end{gathered}$$
4、重复2、3步骤，至收敛。

三、实验

问题：设F是3个高斯核的混合分布，G有两个高斯核，用G来拟合F。
1、定义高斯核

class guassian_component:
    def __init__(self, miu1, miu2, var1, var2, co12=0, co21=0):
        self.miu = np.asarray([[miu1], [miu2]])
        self.sigma = np.zeros((2,2))
        self.sigma[0][0] = var1
        self.sigma[1][1] = var2
        self.sigma[0][1] = co12
        self.sigma[1][0] = co21
        
    def getMiu(self):
        return self.miu
    
    def getSigma(self):
        return self.sigma
    
    def sigmaDet(self):
        #return self.sigma[0][0]*self.sigma[1][1]
        return np.linalg.det(self.sigma)
    
    def sigmaInv(self):
        '''
        inv = np.zeros((2,2))
        inv[0][0] = 1/self.sigma[0][0]
        inv[1][1] = 1/self.sigma[1][1]
        '''
        inv = np.linalg.inv(self.sigma)
        return inv

def Gaussian2D(x, gaussian_ker):
    y = x-gaussian_ker.getMiu()
    y = np.exp(-0.5*np.matmul(np.matmul(y.transpose(),gaussian_ker.sigmaInv()),y))
    y = 1/(2*np.pi)/np.sqrt(np.abs(gaussian_ker.sigmaDet()))*y
    return y

def f_contour(x,y, guassian_ker):#定义函数生成对于（x,y)的高值
    z = []
    for _y in y:
        for _x in x:
            _xy = np.asarray([[_x],[_y]])
            z.append(Gaussian2D(_xy,guassian_ker))
    z = np.asarray(z)
    return z.reshape((x.shape[0],y.shape[0]))

dx=0.01;dy=0.01
x=np.arange(-2.0,2.0,dx)
y=np.arange(-2.0,2.0,dx)
X,Y=np.meshgrid(x,y)#生成网格矩阵
    
c1 = guassian_component(0,0,0.1,0.2)
z = f_contour(x,y, c1)

fig = plt.figure(figsize=(8,8))
ax = fig.add_subplot(1,1,1)
C=ax.contour(X,Y,z,8,colors='black')#绘制等高线，为等高线设置为黑色
ax.contourf(X,Y,z,8)#添加颜色（颜色区分等高线）
ax.clabel(C,inline=1,fontsize=10)#0闭合添加数字，1表示开口添加等高线。等高线字体大小
plt.show()

2、混合高斯分布

c_a = guassian_component(1,0,0.1,0.3) # miu_x, miu_y, var_x, var_y
c_b = guassian_component(0,0,0.2,0.2)
c_c = guassian_component(0,0.5,0.2,0.1)

dx=0.01;dy=0.01
x=np.arange(-2.0,2.0,dx)
y=np.arange(-2.0,2.0,dx)

z_a = f_contour(x,y, c_a)
z_b = f_contour(x,y, c_b)
z_c = f_contour(x,y, c_c)

z = 0.4*z_a + 0.1*z_b + 0.5*z_c

fig = plt.figure(figsize=(8,8))
ax = fig.add_subplot(1,1,1)
C=ax.contour(X,Y,z,8,colors='black')#绘制等高线，为等高线设置为黑色
ax.contourf(X,Y,z,8)#添加颜色（颜色区分等高线）
ax.clabel(C,inline=1,fontsize=10)#0闭合添加数字，1表示开口添加等高线。等高线字体大小
plt.show()

3、高斯聚类

def gaussian_KL(f_ker, g_ker):
    y = np.log(np.abs(g_ker.sigmaDet())/np.abs(f_ker.sigmaDet()))+ \
        np.matmul(np.matmul((f_ker.getMiu()-g_ker.getMiu()).transpose(),g_ker.sigmaInv()), \
                  (f_ker.getMiu()-g_ker.getMiu())) + \
        np.trace(np.matmul(g_ker.sigmaInv(),f_ker.getSigma()))
    return 0.5*y

def new_GaussianComp(kernels, weights):
    '''
    args:
        kernels: (list) [#num_kernels, ]
        weights: (list) [#num_kernels, ]
        
    returns:
        guassian_component
    '''
    if weights == None:
        raise Exception("group is empty!")
        
    if len(weights)==1:
        #print('group is 1.')
        return kernels[0]
    
    
    miu = np.zeros((2,1))
    sigma = np.zeros((2,2))
    beta = 0
    for w,ker in zip(weights, kernels):
        miu += w*ker.getMiu()
        beta += w
    miu /= beta
    
    for w, ker in zip(weights, kernels):
        y = ker.getSigma()+np.matmul((ker.getMiu()-miu),(ker.getMiu()-miu).transpose())
        #print(ker.getSigma())
        #print(ker.getMiu()-miu)
        #print(y)
        #print()
        y *= w
        sigma += y
        
    sigma /= beta
    return guassian_component(miu[0][0],miu[1][0], sigma[0][0], sigma[1][1], sigma[0][1], sigma[1][0])


class GaussianCluster:
    def __init__(self, group_num, original_gaussians, weights):
        '''
        args:
            orginal_gaussians: (list) each of orginal_gaussian is guassian_component
            weights: (list) the sum of all weights is 1.
        '''
        self.original = original_gaussians
        self.weights = weights
        self.group_num = group_num
        
        self.match_grid = np.zeros((group_num, len(weights)))   # one-hot, one result to serveral original
        self.distance_grid = np.zeros((group_num, len(weights)))   # distance between original-kernels and result-kernels
        
        # initialize group_kers by some selected original-kernels
        idx = np.arange(len(weights))
        np.random.shuffle(idx)
        idx = idx[:group_num]
        
        self.group_kers = []     # new groups
        self.group_betas = []    # new mixture weights
        for i in idx:
            var1 = original_gaussians[i].getSigma()[0][0]
            var2 = original_gaussians[i].getSigma()[1][1]
            miu1 = original_gaussians[i].getMiu()[0][0]+np.random.randn()*np.sqrt(var1)
            miu2 = original_gaussians[i].getMiu()[1][0]+np.random.randn()*np.sqrt(var2)
            ker = guassian_component(miu1, miu2, var1*2,var2*2)
            
            self.group_kers.append(ker)
            
    def cal_distance(self):
        for i,g in enumerate(self.group_kers):
            for j,f in enumerate(self.original):
                self.distance_grid[i][j] = gaussian_KL(f,g)
                
    def cal_pie(self):
        self.match_grid = np.zeros((self.group_num, len(self.weights))) 
        self.cal_distance()
        pie = np.argmin(self.distance_grid, axis=0)
        for i,grp_idx in enumerate(pie):
            self.match_grid[grp_idx][i]=1
    
    def cal_kernels(self):
        self.group_kers = []
        self.group_betas = []
        for i in range(self.group_num):
            group_j = self.match_grid[i]
            #print(group_j)
            index = np.asarray([idx for idx in range(len(self.weights))])
            j_i = index[group_j>0]
            
            if (len(j_i)==0):
                print('j_i is Empty!') 
                # reinitialize the kernel:
                # initialize group_kers by some selected original-kernels
                idx = np.arange(len(self.weights))
                np.random.shuffle(idx)
                idx = idx[0]
                var1 = self.original[i].getSigma()[0][0]
                var2 = self.original[i].getSigma()[1][1]
                miu1 = self.original[i].getMiu()[0][0]+np.random.randn()*np.sqrt(var1)
                miu2 = self.original[i].getMiu()[1][0]+np.random.randn()*np.sqrt(var2)
                ker = guassian_component(miu1, miu2, var1*2,var2*2)
                
                self.group_kers.append(ker)
                self.group_betas.append(0)
                #break
                
            else:
                #print(j_i)
                gau = []
                wgt = []
                for idx in j_i:
                    gau.append(self.original[idx])
                    wgt.append(self.weights[idx])
                c_new = new_GaussianComp(gau,wgt)
                self.group_kers.append(c_new)
                self.group_betas.append(sum(wgt))
            
    def iteration(self, times):
        for _ in range(times):
            self.cal_pie()
            self.cal_kernels()
        return self.group_kers
    
    def getGroupKers(self):
        return self.group_kers
    
    def getGroupBetas(self):
        return self.group_betas

def mixture_for_contour(kernels, weights):
    dx=0.01;dy=0.01
    x=np.arange(-2.0,2.0,dx)
    y=np.arange(-2.0,2.0,dx)

	def f(x,y, guassian_kers, weights):#定义函数生成对于（x,y)的高值
        z = []
        for _y in y:
            for _x in x:
                mix = 0
                for ker,wgt in zip(guassian_kers, weights):
                    _xy = np.asarray([[_x],[_y]])
                    mix += wgt*Gaussian2D(_xy,ker)
                z.append(mix)
        z = np.asarray(z)
        return z.reshape((x.shape[0],y.shape[0]))

    z = f(x,y, kernels, weights)
    return x,y,z

kernels = [c_a, c_b, c_c]
weights = [0.4, 0.1, 0.5]
gCluster = GaussianCluster(2, kernels, weights)

kernels = gCluster.iteration(5)
weights = gCluster.getGroupBetas()
print(weights)

X,Y,Z = mixture_for_contour(kernels, weights)
fig = plt.figure(figsize=(8,8))
ax = fig.add_subplot(1,1,1)
C=ax.contour(X,Y,Z,8,colors='black')#绘制融合后等高线
C=ax.contour(X0,Y0,Z0,8,colors='black') #绘制原图等高线
ax.contourf(X,Y,Z,8)#添加颜色（颜色区分等高线）
ax.clabel(C,inline=1,fontsize=10)#0闭合添加数字，1表示开口添加等高线。等高线字体大小
plt.show()

四、小结

该方法能够很好地实现高斯聚类，一般的迭代次数仅为5~6次，但它也有一些局限：
1、初始化对结果有很大的影响；
2、需要设定唯一的超级参数，即聚类的数量。
3、以上实现方法在聚类数量较大的时候，运行速度还是慢一些，可以再做一些优化，比如在期望相差较远的高斯核之间就不用计算其距离了，另外在设定被抛出的高斯核的初始值时，可以更科学一些。
最后，这种方法可以用来合并Object Detection产生的bbox，它的效果与NMS各有千秋，将其复合起来用，效果会更好。

---

【1】《Hierarchical Clustering of a Mixture Model》