会议论文审稿意见
审稿意见,请参考论坛帖 reviewer的博弈和paper的境界
最终的会议论文评审结果:
Recommendation,评分递减
- definitely accept
- probably or likely accept
- borderline
- probably or likely reject
- definitely reject
期刊论文审稿意见
审稿意见,请参考百度文库 论文审稿意见模板
最终的期刊论文评审结果:
A. Evaluation,评分递减
- Award Quality
- Excellent
- Good
- Fair
- Poor
B. Recommendation,评分递减
- Accept with no changes
- Author should prepare a minor revision
- Author should prepare a major revision for a second review
- Reject