本文通过构造一个满足n+m=7的图片,改变对角线的数值用来模拟0或者1,观察网络的分类能力的变化。
假设一组图片对神经网络有三个属性分别是频率和质量和对称关系。频率与点的分布有关,质量与点的数值大小有关,这两个属性可以通过迭代次数曲线携带。而和对称关系有关的信息只能有网络本身来携带。本文通过改变x的值也就是改变图片的质量信息来观察这一组斜线的频率和质量有哪些数值上的变化。
实验过程
制作一个带一个3*3卷积核的神经网络,测试集是mnist的0和1图片集,将28*28的图片缩小成9*9,隐藏层30个节点所以网络的结构是
这个网络分成两个部分左边的是让mnist 0向1,0收敛,右边的是让mnist 1向 0,1收敛。让左右两边的权重实现同步更新,实现权重共享。前面大量实验表明这种效果相当于将两个弹性系数是k1和k2的弹簧并联得到弹性系数为k的弹簧,并且使得k1=k2=k/2的过程。
将上图简写成
d2(mnist0,1)81-con(3*3)49-30-2-(2*k) ,k∈{0,1}
这个网络的收敛标准是
if (Math.abs(f2[0]-y[0])< δ && Math.abs(f2[1]-y[1])< δ )
每个神经网络对应每个收敛标准δ都有一个特征的迭代次数n,因此可以用迭代次数曲线n(δ)来评价网络性能。
本文尝试了δ从0.1到1e-6在内的22个值,训练集是mnist0和1的前4999张图片,
具体进样顺序 | |||
进样顺序 | 迭代次数 | ||
mnist 0-1 | 1 | 判断是否达到收敛 | |
mnist 1-1 | 2 | 判断是否达到收敛 | |
梯度下降 | |||
mnist 0-2 | 3 | 判断是否达到收敛 | |
mnist 1-2 | 4 | 判断是否达到收敛 | |
梯度下降 | |||
…… | |||
mnist 0-4999 | 9997 | 判断是否达到收敛 | |
mnist 1-4999 | 9998 | 判断是否达到收敛 | |
梯度下降 | |||
…… | |||
如果4999图片内没有达到收敛标准再次从头循环 | |||
mnist 0-1 | 9999 | 判断是否达到收敛 | |
mnist 1-1 | 10000 | 判断是否达到收敛 | |
…… | |||
达到收敛标准测量准确率 |
测试集中有980个0和1135个1.将整个过程重复299次,取平均值,用这种方式得到的迭代次数n,用n12表示。
再用同样的办法做两个网络
d2(mnist x,0)81-con(3*3)49-30-2-(2*k) ,k∈{0,1}
意思是用同样的网络分类mnist的0和一张x图片,让0向1,0收敛,让x向0,1收敛,得到的迭代次数用nx0表示
d2(mnist x,1)81-con(3*3)49-30-2-(2*k) ,k∈{0,1}
用同样的网络分类mnist的1和一张x图片,让x向1,0收敛,让1向0,1收敛,得到的迭代次数用nx1表示
这张图片x就是一个9*9的二维数组
double [][]conx=new double[9][9];
for(int n=0 ;n<9;n++){
for(int m=0 ;m<9 ;m++){
if(n+m==7){
conx[n][m]=d;
} } }
本文分别让d=0.1,0.2,0.3,0.4,0.5,0.6,0.7,0.8,0.9,1也就是计算了10组.
现在有了3个网络
A:d2(mnist0,1)81-con(3*3)49-30-2-(2*k) ,k∈{0,1}
B:d2(mnistx,0)81-con(3*3)49-30-2-(2*k) ,k∈{0,1}
C:d2(mnistx,1)81-con(3*3)49-30-2-(2*k) ,k∈{0,1}
根据前面的大量实验n01,nx0,nx1可以用两个方程组去计算
让n01=ω01,nx0=ωx0,nx1=ωx1
频率方程组
质量方程组
因为测量了10组d因此可以得到10组ωx,ω0, ω1,mx,m0,m1,mx0,mx1,m01,k的数据
首先观察网络
B:d2(mnistx,0)81-con(3*3)49-30-2-(2*k) ,k∈{0,1}
的平均准确率
xx0 | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 |
δ | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave |
0.5 | 0.498706 | 0.499213 | 0.504503 | 0.500836 | 0.505807 | 0.506046 | 0.504988 | 0.501772 | 0.506249 | 0.50471 |
0.4 | 0.4666 | 0.468664 | 0.477484 | 0.477423 | 0.48315 | 0.493614 | 0.508802 | 0.526803 | 0.539458 | 0.532645 |
0.3 | 0.49431 | 0.492826 | 0.518069 | 0.544055 | 0.583293 | 0.60028 | 0.644016 | 0.655474 | 0.705722 | 0.726319 |
0.2 | 0.511094 | 0.534946 | 0.561874 | 0.601448 | 0.63066 | 0.680133 | 0.722354 | 0.787563 | 0.775308 | 0.811971 |
0.1 | 0.525424 | 0.570268 | 0.602876 | 0.655267 | 0.671529 | 0.722025 | 0.765648 | 0.801602 | 0.825894 | 0.832611 |
0.01 | 0.543204 | 0.568431 | 0.587539 | 0.665459 | 0.674029 | 0.695129 | 0.753161 | 0.759597 | 0.782408 | 0.784562 |
0.001 | 0.517389 | 0.524611 | 0.546694 | 0.57323 | 0.587055 | 0.610766 | 0.626408 | 0.666346 | 0.66324 | 0.676947 |
1E-04 | 0.490685 | 0.5001 | 0.528967 | 0.532328 | 0.559164 | 0.570866 | 0.571498 | 0.619642 | 0.63906 | 0.649003 |
9E-05 | 0.491966 | 0.498147 | 0.515346 | 0.53507 | 0.532003 | 0.591032 | 0.57301 | 0.60679 | 0.622635 | 0.64129 |
8E-05 | 0.476931 | 0.489224 | 0.506832 | 0.523792 | 0.536561 | 0.581704 | 0.602418 | 0.627479 | 0.660269 | 0.642104 |
7E-05 | 0.478427 | 0.492192 | 0.514549 | 0.522212 | 0.542663 | 0.566335 | 0.584377 | 0.621798 | 0.651276 | 0.62258 |
6E-05 | 0.490364 | 0.491013 | 0.503995 | 0.529299 | 0.558198 | 0.578502 | 0.602592 | 0.63419 | 0.649405 | 0.630092 |
5E-05 | 0.477676 | 0.498612 | 0.508412 | 0.521889 | 0.541656 | 0.560372 | 0.571514 | 0.631925 | 0.651099 | 0.645733 |
0.00004 | 0.490685 | 0.492599 | 0.515136 | 0.52604 | 0.538095 | 0.569476 | 0.588583 | 0.607208 | 0.648507 | 0.64628 |
3E-05 | 0.479962 | 0.490092 | 0.503435 | 0.509492 | 0.550125 | 0.577229 | 0.589544 | 0.639081 | 0.623565 | 0.642012 |
0.00002 | 0.47927 | 0.486188 | 0.500995 | 0.498968 | 0.535541 | 0.558155 | 0.578527 | 0.605054 | 0.630935 | 0.609407 |
0.00001 | 0.474972 | 0.48936 | 0.498857 | 0.515575 | 0.530656 | 0.553634 | 0.57719 | 0.604407 | 0.593691 | 0.642088 |
9E-06 | 0.478291 | 0.488456 | 0.492077 | 0.50455 | 0.535202 | 0.537927 | 0.575072 | 0.591447 | 0.616387 | 0.626062 |
8E-06 | 0.485962 | 0.486028 | 0.493834 | 0.50995 | 0.534209 | 0.546713 | 0.562279 | 0.595313 | 0.598566 | 0.632986 |
0.000007 | 0.488913 | 0.489188 | 0.494839 | 0.502933 | 0.534461 | 0.532751 | 0.572289 | 0.581178 | 0.604355 | 0.606963 |
0.000006 | 0.479872 | 0.488414 | 0.497374 | 0.511315 | 0.511304 | 0.522647 | 0.566475 | 0.587639 | 0.608022 | 0.622347 |
5E-06 | 0.479719 | 0.481849 | 0.5016 | 0.512341 | 0.525885 | 0.541808 | 0.575278 | 0.580814 | 0.604377 | 0.619477 |
4E-06 | 0.475334 | 0.488003 | 0.49773 | 0.514388 | 0.521825 | 0.54689 | 0.556318 | 0.588086 | 0.590934 | 0.608762 |
0.000003 | 0.478849 | 0.483772 | 0.484613 | 0.498956 | 0.52953 | 0.538084 | 0.555222 | 0.565181 | 0.596711 | 0.602965 |
2E-06 | 0.470291 | 0.478972 | 0.491085 | 0.50987 | 0.520256 | 0.538264 | 0.559382 | 0.561792 | 0.595593 | 0.620489 |
1E-06 | 0.46933 | 0.478326 | 0.486939 | 0.497866 | 0.505244 | 0.508899 | 0.533264 | 0.565651 | 0.588494 | 0.6285 |
很明显x越大分类能力越差,表明x=0.1更接近图片1的特征。
B:d2(mnistx,1)81-con(3*3)49-30-2-(2*k) ,k∈{0,1}
的分类能力
xx1 | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 |
δ | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave | 平均准确率p-ave |
0.5 | 0.517047 | 0.519064 | 0.514826 | 0.507428 | 0.5224 | 0.518248 | 0.515276 | 0.50745 | 0.5131 | 0.516005 |
0.4 | 0.668509 | 0.693649 | 0.719944 | 0.742948 | 0.76452 | 0.778184 | 0.798044 | 0.819023 | 0.791304 | 0.804304 |
0.3 | 0.67957 | 0.71175 | 0.73271 | 0.770251 | 0.783379 | 0.804319 | 0.815193 | 0.818663 | 0.828359 | 0.813089 |
0.2 | 0.684324 | 0.71947 | 0.746194 | 0.748514 | 0.787142 | 0.824234 | 0.833567 | 0.833541 | 0.829786 | 0.822206 |
0.1 | 0.684505 | 0.703919 | 0.737228 | 0.760908 | 0.791776 | 0.802843 | 0.81751 | 0.836372 | 0.833132 | 0.834519 |
0.01 | 0.647651 | 0.669799 | 0.692034 | 0.724171 | 0.740879 | 0.764107 | 0.802521 | 0.80231 | 0.829748 | 0.837161 |
0.001 | 0.634259 | 0.662228 | 0.680298 | 0.705844 | 0.727225 | 0.748514 | 0.793036 | 0.815682 | 0.81506 | 0.815011 |
1E-04 | 0.597403 | 0.615793 | 0.633858 | 0.670506 | 0.696233 | 0.720561 | 0.765833 | 0.802677 | 0.815529 | 0.818697 |
9E-05 | 0.587901 | 0.608507 | 0.630638 | 0.669458 | 0.692429 | 0.732263 | 0.751582 | 0.792286 | 0.821006 | 0.799902 |
8E-05 | 0.595534 | 0.601268 | 0.636581 | 0.665806 | 0.695508 | 0.730416 | 0.762156 | 0.790776 | 0.807712 | 0.813848 |
7E-05 | 0.58849 | 0.613125 | 0.638755 | 0.672056 | 0.697925 | 0.722778 | 0.756919 | 0.794725 | 0.811578 | 0.810456 |
6E-05 | 0.596671 | 0.61685 | 0.637632 | 0.675618 | 0.673512 | 0.718722 | 0.757113 | 0.804073 | 0.818886 | 0.82365 |
5E-05 | 0.598395 | 0.605992 | 0.641168 | 0.653279 | 0.675769 | 0.739436 | 0.764623 | 0.80102 | 0.815957 | 0.823478 |
0.00004 | 0.592419 | 0.614899 | 0.639935 | 0.669907 | 0.681473 | 0.716502 | 0.766815 | 0.786981 | 0.821824 | 0.801678 |
3E-05 | 0.595968 | 0.602298 | 0.64703 | 0.667592 | 0.703652 | 0.729323 | 0.756032 | 0.794597 | 0.810963 | 0.808389 |
0.00002 | 0.58512 | 0.604568 | 0.63816 | 0.656103 | 0.685296 | 0.72576 | 0.760655 | 0.783856 | 0.814134 | 0.810007 |
0.00001 | 0.580442 | 0.595283 | 0.629201 | 0.664325 | 0.688533 | 0.712703 | 0.737418 | 0.781374 | 0.804689 | 0.815176 |
9E-06 | 0.565855 | 0.590786 | 0.614131 | 0.653045 | 0.672557 | 0.730292 | 0.736955 | 0.783779 | 0.809206 | 0.811156 |
8E-06 | 0.572515 | 0.591957 | 0.616109 | 0.6494 | 0.681654 | 0.724759 | 0.747184 | 0.7909 | 0.799677 | 0.803969 |
0.000007 | 0.591456 | 0.604545 | 0.621906 | 0.641639 | 0.672255 | 0.71157 | 0.748348 | 0.785161 | 0.794707 | 0.803852 |
0.000006 | 0.580959 | 0.599331 | 0.614915 | 0.648006 | 0.674266 | 0.715393 | 0.745713 | 0.776143 | 0.801923 | 0.805176 |
5E-06 | 0.572189 | 0.599146 | 0.62153 | 0.664839 | 0.672016 | 0.722236 | 0.735598 | 0.790275 | 0.799145 | 0.81228 |
4E-06 | 0.57409 | 0.605011 | 0.622529 | 0.644267 | 0.674273 | 0.718192 | 0.736991 | 0.770338 | 0.799719 | 0.804167 |
0.000003 | 0.578369 | 0.597081 | 0.600419 | 0.645082 | 0.682097 | 0.725201 | 0.74936 | 0.786051 | 0.800217 | 0.802536 |
2E-06 | 0.576525 | 0.594209 | 0.622428 | 0.651095 | 0.679894 | 0.706997 | 0.763952 | 0.78947 | 0.796164 | 0.808305 |
1E-06 | 0.57134 | 0.592852 | 0.603998 | 0.655058 | 0.662615 | 0.712373 | 0.748209 | 0.781075 | 0.787916 | 0.797799 |
这个规律是同样的x越大分类能力越差,但是这个网络的平均性能要好于第一个网络,表明x=0.1是的特征更加接近0.
迭代次数综合
x0 | ||||||||||
迭代次数n |
| |||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 |
0.5 | 15.35452 | 18.94983 | 18.31104 | 17.69565 | 16.79599 | 16.83278 | 19.46154 | 16.26756 | 19.30769 | 16.67893 |
0.4 | 1117.99 | 1187.555 | 1197.535 | 1278.94 | 1357.803 | 1370.231 | 1421.395 | 1500.177 | 1462.839 | 1432.171 |
0.3 | 1378.371 | 1435.201 | 1520.753 | 1530.819 | 1637.542 | 1706.666 | 1754.612 | 1781.488 | 1685.408 | 1757.468 |
0.2 | 1522.672 | 1589.321 | 1682.732 | 1753.656 | 1803.742 | 1890.746 | 1950.117 | 1994.09 | 2100.505 | 1923.823 |
0.1 | 1773.977 | 1819.542 | 1963.361 | 2086.659 | 2082.431 | 2200.351 | 2250.518 | 2190.358 | 2302.98 | 2324.097 |
0.01 | 2553.468 | 2670.438 | 2806.231 | 2881.12 | 2973.214 | 2979.896 | 3068.03 | 3113.401 | 3191.147 | 3094.839 |
0.001 | 4228.445 | 4295.957 | 4218.144 | 4175.709 | 4204.88 | 4061.575 | 4170.385 | 4133.863 | 4244.017 | 4026.786 |
1.00E-04 | 8060.124 | 7499.415 | 7139.114 | 6891.462 | 6639.722 | 6176.211 | 6086.151 | 5947.14 | 5797.836 | 5812.579 |
9.00E-05 | 8283.04 | 7837.589 | 7530.839 | 6954.445 | 6802.833 | 6401.729 | 6208.906 | 6157.91 | 5787.227 | 5819.689 |
8.00E-05 | 8670.351 | 8223.756 | 7772.773 | 7223.201 | 6885.809 | 6568.358 | 6340.298 | 6148.251 | 5990.465 | 5969.468 |
7.00E-05 | 8966.037 | 8528.579 | 7851.02 | 7535.916 | 7169.147 | 6699.716 | 6450.946 | 6379.957 | 6187.936 | 6186.786 |
6.00E-05 | 9573.194 | 8989.475 | 8404.204 | 7887.582 | 7343.849 | 6958.98 | 6697.662 | 6525.368 | 6287.589 | 6416.866 |
5.00E-05 | 10486.42 | 9576.572 | 8879.983 | 8294.592 | 7708.411 | 7193.508 | 6791.047 | 6685.261 | 6478.786 | 6516.559 |
4.00E-05 | 10796.31 | 10328.2 | 9505.227 | 9020.278 | 8034.452 | 7545.167 | 7139.227 | 6966.732 | 6862.813 | 6701.776 |
3.00E-05 | 12615.76 | 11390.36 | 10206.77 | 9632.967 | 8653.843 | 8229.803 | 7763.602 | 7323.803 | 7081.261 | 7026.01 |
2.00E-05 | 14290.22 | 12712.02 | 11895.89 | 11004.82 | 9575.776 | 8871.783 | 8368.98 | 7958.324 | 7636.064 | 7654.806 |
1.00E-05 | 19590.14 | 16685.96 | 14971.21 | 13450.55 | 12115.49 | 10916.28 | 10131.43 | 9302.425 | 8972.926 | 8709.896 |
9.00E-06 | 19369.42 | 17926.62 | 15458.92 | 13700.68 | 12032.81 | 11171.62 | 10173.31 | 9456.13 | 9218.592 | 9183.783 |
8.00E-06 | 20898.02 | 17822.38 | 16138.6 | 14483.19 | 12438.18 | 11684.68 | 10413.79 | 9790.057 | 9631.656 | 9276.505 |
7.00E-06 | 21530.06 | 19599.07 | 17075.43 | 15177.07 | 13051.3 | 11766 | 10722.55 | 10215.11 | 9639.957 | 9697.167 |
6.00E-06 | 22983.2 | 20647.8 | 18229.57 | 15343.79 | 14013.39 | 12130.34 | 11103.27 | 10168.81 | 9737.134 | 10145.89 |
5.00E-06 | 25112.67 | 21185.3 | 19040.36 | 16908.94 | 15078.32 | 13247.34 | 11265.88 | 10872.95 | 10656.88 | 10276.24 |
4.00E-06 | 27894.48 | 25069.92 | 20645.43 | 17625.26 | 15866.23 | 14007.23 | 12300.8 | 11611.66 | 10945.6 | 10944.16 |
3.00E-06 | 32092.47 | 27664.89 | 23149.66 | 19667.91 | 17548.92 | 14726 | 12992.57 | 12128.02 | 11840.05 | 11454.33 |
2.00E-06 | 37375.13 | 30547.89 | 27850.06 | 23064.1 | 19158.65 | 15905.17 | 14769.62 | 13519.72 | 12690.2 | 12701.23 |
1.00E-06 | 51550.46 | 40985.27 | 34607.76 | 29823.74 | 24326.77 | 20274.39 | 17986.22 | 16094.89 | 15180.33 | 15012.21 |
x1 | ||||||||||
迭代次数n | ||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 |
0.5 | 17.15719 | 17.53846 | 18.57191 | 18.82943 | 18.17726 | 18.6388 | 18.77592 | 17.81271 | 20.61873 | 20.99331 |
0.4 | 1106.234 | 1143.639 | 1306.381 | 1322.341 | 1432.415 | 1523.01 | 1712.977 | 1767.264 | 1800.903 | 1978.649 |
0.3 | 1244.074 | 1399.692 | 1523.532 | 1601.137 | 1695.09 | 1832.408 | 1917.592 | 2039.98 | 2157.458 | 2331.157 |
0.2 | 1474.789 | 1596.094 | 1716.763 | 1766.361 | 1874.669 | 2003.344 | 2219.967 | 2308.054 | 2431.759 | 2497.405 |
0.1 | 1726.943 | 1826.207 | 1923.344 | 2057.913 | 2168.134 | 2340.181 | 2429.652 | 2632.562 | 2707.338 | 2801.452 |
0.01 | 2614.963 | 2825.211 | 2916.094 | 2968.02 | 2993.217 | 3136.615 | 3308.421 | 3500.783 | 3683.732 | 3690.662 |
0.001 | 4851.833 | 4871.699 | 4906.936 | 4831.833 | 4740.241 | 4720.482 | 4809.813 | 4778.435 | 4954.254 | 4990.328 |
1.00E-04 | 11627.7 | 10530.17 | 9840.08 | 8766.488 | 8058.054 | 7058.475 | 6852.783 | 6559.605 | 6530.134 | 6551.258 |
9.00E-05 | 11914.98 | 11208.97 | 9821.278 | 9220.274 | 8317.672 | 7569.873 | 7132.395 | 6686.635 | 6651.371 | 6651.137 |
8.00E-05 | 12895.67 | 12067 | 10495.94 | 9792.02 | 8357.03 | 7787.197 | 7132.522 | 6724.14 | 6635.853 | 6880.421 |
7.00E-05 | 13385.04 | 12058.49 | 10861.02 | 9882.615 | 9309.746 | 7879.13 | 7391.833 | 7031.418 | 6890.562 | 6950.662 |
6.00E-05 | 13818.58 | 12810.59 | 11776.17 | 10383.82 | 9067.545 | 8343.525 | 7327.632 | 7196.074 | 6921.94 | 7051.572 |
5.00E-05 | 16082.01 | 14173.44 | 12579.15 | 10779.86 | 9680.401 | 8610.95 | 7760.622 | 7312.341 | 7145.565 | 7242.776 |
4.00E-05 | 16973.04 | 16033.73 | 13479.8 | 11665.71 | 10494.13 | 9140.468 | 7962.482 | 7536.368 | 7409.117 | 7460.368 |
3.00E-05 | 20943.67 | 17167.83 | 15182.3 | 14249.18 | 11338.78 | 9946.602 | 8562.107 | 8129.679 | 7769.826 | 7918.736 |
2.00E-05 | 23995.46 | 21386.47 | 17906.29 | 15266.68 | 12616.27 | 10834.17 | 9379.639 | 8669.953 | 8285.05 | 8570.689 |
1.00E-05 | 33037.41 | 28373.46 | 24371.43 | 19940.94 | 16168.89 | 13458.85 | 11004.92 | 9840.1 | 9346.769 | 9550.836 |
9.00E-06 | 34781.26 | 29889.26 | 25603.51 | 19236.82 | 16701.53 | 13978.84 | 11406.21 | 9997.264 | 9488.207 | 9305.98 |
8.00E-06 | 38124.84 | 31047.18 | 25547.65 | 21355.55 | 17459.02 | 14283.77 | 12130.39 | 10238.3 | 9644.729 | 10029.36 |
7.00E-06 | 40778.25 | 33907.32 | 26963.9 | 22943.16 | 18022.86 | 15247.41 | 11984.52 | 10638.9 | 10025.21 | 9980.87 |
6.00E-06 | 44399.53 | 35151.1 | 30160.43 | 24085.9 | 19863.44 | 15602.85 | 12506.18 | 10952.92 | 10431.91 | 10619.42 |
5.00E-06 | 47481.75 | 39056.92 | 31852.49 | 25780.82 | 21343.05 | 16205.67 | 13408.98 | 11666.93 | 10749.43 | 10500.95 |
4.00E-06 | 51666.84 | 44700.93 | 35495.18 | 29009.14 | 21984.74 | 18251.19 | 14559.57 | 11822.75 | 11068.94 | 11001.82 |
3.00E-06 | 64737.61 | 52535.19 | 40708.62 | 32223.9 | 25491.04 | 20613.97 | 15032.35 | 13101.28 | 11883.68 | 11853.48 |
2.00E-06 | 78519.32 | 56693.77 | 49340.35 | 37336.09 | 29391.59 | 22241.87 | 17472.01 | 13730.76 | 12803.19 | 12470.37 |
1.00E-06 | 115929.9 | 92079.88 | 68424.07 | 51575.29 | 38724.45 | 28858.88 | 20547.67 | 16472.6 | 14605.4 | 14873.51 |
第一组数据计算ωx
计算ωx | |||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 | |
0.1 | 1539.038 | 1641.757 | 1829.238 | 2063.258 | 2169.605 | 2513.723 | 2712.117 | 2864.885 | 3260.068 | 3499.26 | 减 |
0.01 | 2380.17 | 2649.823 | 2869.018 | 3002.942 | 3136.616 | 3311.985 | 3663.611 | 4026.954 | 4526.925 | 4274.625 | 减 |
0.001 | 5019.207 | 5156.789 | 5062.45 | 4910.674 | 4859.483 | 4623.414 | 4879.032 | 4789.238 | 5160.779 | 4816.197 | 增 |
1.00E-04 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 30140.3 | 13839.9 | 10405.27 | 7572.426 | 7171.466 | 6642.097 | 6408.155 | 6448.223 | 增 |
9.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 72350.87 | 14695.48 | 11007.06 | 8438.51 | 7497.669 | 6912.429 | 6368.939 | 6412.073 | 减增 |
8.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 17350.29 | 10462.58 | 8640.17 | 7400.499 | 6696.865 | 6414.751 | 6606.378 | 减增 |
7.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 24228.82 | 14358.97 | 9037.877 | 7859.744 | 7322.583 | 6895.166 | 6953.754 | 减增 |
6.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 26195.25 | 12114.66 | 9481.479 | 7663.888 | 7272.871 | 6700.216 | 6983.283 | 减增 |
5.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 35939.95 | 13955.59 | 9784.514 | 7925.274 | 7310.599 | 6893.611 | 7028.09 | 减增 |
4.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 86402.07 | 14047.89 | 9984.888 | 7933.484 | 7311.605 | 7080.917 | 6945.85 | 增 |
3.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 15223.37 | 11141.32 | 8633.63 | 7679.173 | 7126.365 | 7181.696 | 减增 |
2.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 15600.06 | 11080.14 | 8921.115 | 7902.372 | 7324.669 | 7537.716 | 减增 |
1.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 49685.45 | 16485.38 | 11347.07 | 9264.434 | 8564.156 | 8478.29 | 增 |
9.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 50700.31 | 18174.58 | 11747.74 | 9497.459 | 8848.366 | 8670.744 | 增 |
8.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 34488.15 | 17350.15 | 11856.66 | 9504.557 | 8899.501 | 8888.09 | 增 |
7.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 53708.59 | 18499.11 | 11903.55 | 10093.49 | 9087.892 | 9102.185 | 减增 |
6.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 17616.44 | 12105.66 | 9841.334 | 9107.885 | 9578.021 | 减增 |
5.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 20865.25 | 12667.73 | 10785.6 | 9877.095 | 9395.07 | 增 |
4.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 23977.86 | 14189.23 | 11035.46 | 9926.249 | 9876.698 | 增 |
3.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 24334.14 | 14039.53 | 11665.25 | 10577.13 | 10279.76 | 增 |
2.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 27607.32 | 17684.26 | 12790.35 | 11434.94 | 11203.53 | 增 |
1.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 41715.35 | 20408.98 | 14929.03 | 12944 | 13020.3 | 减增 |
当δ<0.001随着d的增大ωx有多个拐点
第二组数据计算ω0
计算ω0 | |||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 | |
0.1 | 2165.011 | 2071.282 | 2132.1 | 2110.875 | 2004.986 | 1980.942 | 1965.215 | 1841.054 | 1879.768 | 1861.435 | 增 |
0.01 | 2771.125 | 2691.542 | 2747.394 | 2773.016 | 2832.949 | 2731.111 | 2692.181 | 2629.189 | 2602.89 | 2547.542 | 增 |
0.001 | 3722.544 | 3759.142 | 3691.414 | 3695.269 | 3759.054 | 3664.772 | 3701.505 | 3690.125 | 3688.742 | 3530.436 | 增 |
1.00E-04 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5120.446 | 5206.4 | 5260.99 | 5345.883 | 5379.925 | 5432.797 | 5334.152 | 5334.132 | 增减 |
9.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5339.59 | 5218.375 | 5348.074 | 5363.764 | 5416.007 | 5606.461 | 5340.423 | 5366.022 | 增减 |
8.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5344.392 | 5500.985 | 5508.014 | 5634.99 | 5715.58 | 5640.575 | 5487.158 | 增减 |
7.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5462.445 | 5418.252 | 5562.882 | 5601.358 | 5727.324 | 5661.499 | 5628.013 | 增减 |
6.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5708.249 | 5747.693 | 5756.711 | 6023.781 | 5969.279 | 5942.869 | 5969.134 | 增减 |
5.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5944.858 | 5920.959 | 5954.428 | 6036.192 | 6197.073 | 6130.835 | 6102.593 | 增减 |
4.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 6395.75 | 6211.868 | 6311.837 | 6543.953 | 6666.467 | 6663.696 | 6481.747 | 增减 |
3.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 6682.842 | 6824.225 | 7112.733 | 7013.603 | 7037.003 | 6880.029 | 增减 |
2.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7515.989 | 7610.593 | 7908.115 | 8015.482 | 7990.88 | 7777.528 | 增减 |
1.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 8697.208 | 8735.773 | 9237.971 | 9340.887 | 9446.436 | 8961.583 | 增减 |
9.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 8630.884 | 8771.393 | 9099.005 | 9415.337 | 9639.551 | 9800.19 | 减 |
8.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 9095.869 | 9396.133 | 9395.234 | 10102.93 | 10580.45 | 9720.741 | 增减 |
7.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 9367.995 | 9315.054 | 9835.187 | 10341.23 | 10306.64 | 10426.5 | 减 |
6.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 9820.101 | 10314.69 | 10531.31 | 10517.88 | 10828.44 | 减 |
5.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 10483.1 | 10245.61 | 10962.46 | 11656.3 | 11463.26 | 增减 |
4.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 10875.84 | 11008.93 | 12288.7 | 12361.25 | 12454.55 | 减 |
3.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 11520.93 | 12149.58 | 12650.63 | 13699.67 | 13152.67 | 增减 |
2.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 12314.86 | 12941.54 | 14390.02 | 14476.87 | 15023.24 | 减 |
1.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 15265.98 | 16261.79 | 17584.89 | 19207.74 | 18331.79 | 增减 |
当δ<0.001随着x的增大ω0有多个拐点
第三组数据计算ω1
计算ω1 | |||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 | |
0.1 | 2006.3 | 2091.121 | 2033.65 | 2052.61 | 2166.666 | 2198.24 | 2220.318 | 2448.91 | 2365.1 | 2403.051 | 减 |
0.01 | 2936.534 | 3040.777 | 2965.566 | 2934.289 | 2867.844 | 2986.445 | 3039.855 | 3138.419 | 3184.84 | 3295.024 | 减 |
0.001 | 4700.158 | 4629.202 | 4764.927 | 4756.671 | 4629.366 | 4823.932 | 4743.458 | 4767.704 | 4770.691 | 5184.823 | 减 |
1.00E-04 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7151.15 | 6933.167 | 6809.636 | 6636.719 | 6573.127 | 6480.113 | 6659.354 | 6659.394 | 减增 |
9.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 6976.907 | 7274.866 | 6958.101 | 6923.952 | 6815.783 | 6481.615 | 6975.05 | 6919.103 | 减增 |
8.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7551.373 | 7160.853 | 7145.428 | 6891.695 | 6751.752 | 6881.516 | 7191.667 | 减增 |
7.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7298.208 | 7407.298 | 7075.719 | 6998.633 | 6772.434 | 6885.967 | 6947.574 | 减增 |
6.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7649.098 | 7556.86 | 7536.495 | 7032.077 | 7121.659 | 7167.24 | 7121.904 | 减增 |
5.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7799.96 | 7854.842 | 7778.486 | 7605.823 | 7314.084 | 7427.332 | 7478.419 | 减增 |
4.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 8286.757 | 8739.181 | 8479.45 | 7991.8 | 7783.22 | 7787.638 | 8109.28 | 减增 |
3.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 9431.867 | 9068.759 | 8492.333 | 8670.079 | 8626.428 | 8942.089 | 减增 |
2.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 10874.67 | 10603.9 | 9917.007 | 9715.8 | 9760.119 | 10192.09 | 减增 |
1.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 11748.41 | 11655.1 | 10691.97 | 10538.41 | 10392.46 | 11170.86 | 减增 |
9.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 12143.8 | 11778.9 | 11092.84 | 10585.31 | 10290.51 | 10105 | 增 |
8.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 13221.49 | 12421.91 | 12423.99 | 11173.28 | 10615.21 | 11765.07 | 减增 |
7.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 13118.74 | 13267.88 | 12067.15 | 11283.51 | 11328.94 | 11175.66 | 增 |
6.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 14152.05 | 12949.28 | 12552.78 | 12575.63 | 12096.29 | 增 |
5.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 13712.14 | 14297.72 | 12806.92 | 11903.02 | 12119.57 | 减增 |
4.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 15312.7 | 14960.49 | 12806.81 | 12726.17 | 12626.69 | 增 |
3.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 18203.4 | 16270.77 | 15243.97 | 13836.1 | 14477.19 | 减增 |
2.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 19136.19 | 17267.23 | 14914.66 | 14819.74 | 14294.52 | 增 |
1.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 23396.82 | 20689.23 | 18621.47 | 17131.7 | 17840.11 | 减增 |
当δ<0.01随着d的增大ω1有多个拐点
第四组数据m0
m0 | |||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 | |
0.1 | 0.505334 | 0.62826 | 0.73608 | 0.955393 | 1.17095 | 1.610242 | 1.904568 | 2.421481 | 3.007772 | 3.533921 | 减 |
0.01 | 0.737741 | 0.96924 | 1.090497 | 1.172706 | 1.225872 | 1.470611 | 1.851868 | 2.3459 | 3.024788 | 2.815485 | 减 |
0.001 | 1.817987 | 1.881834 | 1.880771 | 1.765998 | 1.671179 | 1.591591 | 1.737443 | 1.684421 | 1.957375 | 1.861023 | 减 |
1.00E-04 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 34.64811 | 7.066283 | 3.911752 | 2.006463 | 1.776902 | 1.494733 | 1.443229 | 1.461345 | 增 |
9.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 183.5996 | 7.930429 | 4.235918 | 2.475097 | 1.916435 | 1.52014 | 1.422273 | 1.427881 | 增 |
8.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 10.53942 | 3.6174 | 2.460676 | 1.724788 | 1.372848 | 1.29334 | 1.449545 | 增 |
7.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 19.67389 | 7.023086 | 2.63957 | 1.96893 | 1.634651 | 1.483292 | 1.526612 | 增 |
6.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 21.05908 | 4.44258 | 2.71271 | 1.618676 | 1.484458 | 1.271116 | 1.368663 | 增 |
5.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 36.54869 | 5.555361 | 2.700215 | 1.723862 | 1.391659 | 1.264312 | 1.326313 | 增 |
4.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 182.501 | 5.1142 | 2.502504 | 1.469764 | 1.202912 | 1.129142 | 1.14833 | 增 |
3.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5.189184 | 2.665425 | 1.473377 | 1.198799 | 1.025559 | 1.089616 | 增 |
2.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 4.308048 | 2.119596 | 1.272601 | 0.971976 | 0.840208 | 0.939283 | 增 |
1.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 32.63614 | 3.561189 | 1.50874 | 0.983697 | 0.821927 | 0.895049 | 增 |
9.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 34.50727 | 4.293304 | 1.666944 | 1.01752 | 0.842583 | 0.782787 | 增 |
8.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 14.37644 | 3.409635 | 1.592611 | 0.885052 | 0.707495 | 0.836023 | 增 |
7.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 32.86958 | 3.943944 | 1.464832 | 0.952661 | 0.777486 | 0.762104 | 增 |
6.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 3.218137 | 1.377416 | 0.87326 | 0.749858 | 0.782384 | 增 |
5.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 3.961576 | 1.528698 | 0.967993 | 0.71802 | 0.671713 | 增 |
4.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 4.860658 | 1.661222 | 0.806434 | 0.64483 | 0.628879 | 增 |
3.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 4.461257 | 1.335311 | 0.850284 | 0.596096 | 0.610854 | 增 |
2.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5.02562 | 1.867248 | 0.790027 | 0.623905 | 0.556138 | 增 |
1.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7.466932 | 1.575092 | 0.720749 | 0.454135 | 0.504466 | 增 |
当δ<0.001随着d的增加m0急剧增加
第五组数据m1
m1 | |||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 | |
0.1 | 0.588446 | 0.616395 | 0.809073 | 1.010402 | 1.002715 | 1.307629 | 1.49206 | 1.368575 | 1.900003 | 2.120443 | 减 |
0.01 | 0.65697 | 0.75939 | 0.935947 | 1.047341 | 1.196221 | 1.229894 | 1.452489 | 1.646385 | 2.020372 | 1.682979 | 减 |
0.001 | 1.140369 | 1.240927 | 1.128779 | 1.065801 | 1.101887 | 0.918593 | 1.057979 | 1.009053 | 1.170221 | 0.862861 | 增 |
1.00E-04 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 17.7641 | 3.984766 | 2.334848 | 1.301857 | 1.190342 | 1.050619 | 0.92598 | 0.937585 | 增 |
9.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 107.5379 | 4.080537 | 2.502425 | 1.485332 | 1.210099 | 1.137352 | 0.833757 | 0.858811 | 增 |
8.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5.279121 | 2.134754 | 1.462137 | 1.153108 | 0.983808 | 0.868943 | 0.843855 | 增 |
7.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 11.02128 | 3.757741 | 1.631517 | 1.261218 | 1.169066 | 1.002674 | 1.00178 | 增 |
6.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 11.72802 | 2.570039 | 1.582754 | 1.187766 | 1.042916 | 0.873924 | 0.961451 | 增 |
5.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 21.23098 | 3.156614 | 1.582298 | 1.085766 | 0.999047 | 0.861446 | 0.883192 | 增 |
4.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 108.7124 | 2.58393 | 1.386599 | 0.985459 | 0.882484 | 0.826737 | 0.733645 | 增 |
3.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.60511 | 1.509307 | 1.033553 | 0.784482 | 0.682455 | 0.645024 | 增 |
2.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.057884 | 1.091841 | 0.809239 | 0.661543 | 0.563204 | 0.546956 | 增 |
1.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 17.88548 | 2.000626 | 1.126295 | 0.772837 | 0.679098 | 0.576027 | 增 |
9.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 17.43058 | 2.380779 | 1.121562 | 0.805022 | 0.739354 | 0.736275 | 增 |
8.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 6.804228 | 1.950875 | 0.910758 | 0.723606 | 0.702869 | 0.570727 | 增 |
7.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 16.76111 | 1.94401 | 0.973069 | 0.800193 | 0.643498 | 0.663353 | 增 |
6.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 1.549521 | 0.873949 | 0.61465 | 0.524536 | 0.62697 | 增 |
5.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.315456 | 0.78499 | 0.70925 | 0.688564 | 0.600932 | 增 |
4.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.451981 | 0.899551 | 0.742505 | 0.60838 | 0.61185 | 增 |
3.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 1.78701 | 0.744542 | 0.585587 | 0.584398 | 0.504193 | 增 |
2.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.081313 | 1.048887 | 0.735424 | 0.59537 | 0.614286 | 增 |
1.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 3.178909 | 0.973091 | 0.64274 | 0.570869 | 0.532656 | 增 |
当δ<0.001随着d的增加m1急剧增加
第六组数据mx0
mx0 | |||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 | |
0.1 | 1.505334 | 1.62826 | 1.73608 | 1.955393 | 2.17095 | 2.610242 | 2.904568 | 3.421481 | 4.007772 | 4.533921 | 减 |
0.01 | 1.737741 | 1.96924 | 2.090497 | 2.172706 | 2.225872 | 2.470611 | 2.851868 | 3.3459 | 4.024788 | 3.815485 | 减 |
0.001 | 2.817987 | 2.881834 | 2.880771 | 2.765998 | 2.671179 | 2.591591 | 2.737443 | 2.684421 | 2.957375 | 2.861023 | 减 |
1.00E-04 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 35.64811 | 8.066283 | 4.911752 | 3.006463 | 2.776902 | 2.494733 | 2.443229 | 2.461345 | 增 |
9.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 184.5996 | 8.930429 | 5.235918 | 3.475097 | 2.916435 | 2.52014 | 2.422273 | 2.427881 | 增 |
8.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 11.53942 | 4.6174 | 3.460676 | 2.724788 | 2.372848 | 2.29334 | 2.449545 | 增 |
7.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 20.67389 | 8.023086 | 3.63957 | 2.96893 | 2.634651 | 2.483292 | 2.526612 | 增 |
6.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 22.05908 | 5.44258 | 3.71271 | 2.618676 | 2.484458 | 2.271116 | 2.368663 | 增 |
5.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 37.54869 | 6.555361 | 3.700215 | 2.723862 | 2.391659 | 2.264312 | 2.326313 | 增 |
4.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 183.501 | 6.1142 | 3.502504 | 2.469764 | 2.202912 | 2.129142 | 2.14833 | 增 |
3.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 6.189184 | 3.665425 | 2.473377 | 2.198799 | 2.025559 | 2.089616 | 增 |
2.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5.308048 | 3.119596 | 2.272601 | 1.971976 | 1.840208 | 1.939283 | 增 |
1.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 33.63614 | 4.561189 | 2.50874 | 1.983697 | 1.821927 | 1.895049 | 增 |
9.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 35.50727 | 5.293304 | 2.666944 | 2.01752 | 1.842583 | 1.782787 | 增 |
8.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 15.37644 | 4.409635 | 2.592611 | 1.885052 | 1.707495 | 1.836023 | 增 |
7.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 33.86958 | 4.943944 | 2.464832 | 1.952661 | 1.777486 | 1.762104 | 增 |
6.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 4.218137 | 2.377416 | 1.87326 | 1.749858 | 1.782384 | 增 |
5.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 4.961576 | 2.528698 | 1.967993 | 1.71802 | 1.671713 | 增 |
4.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5.860658 | 2.661222 | 1.806434 | 1.64483 | 1.628879 | 增 |
3.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5.461257 | 2.335311 | 1.850284 | 1.596096 | 1.610854 | 增 |
2.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 6.02562 | 2.867248 | 1.790027 | 1.623905 | 1.556138 | 增 |
1.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 8.466932 | 2.575092 | 1.720749 | 1.454135 | 1.504466 | 增 |
当δ<0.001随着d的增加mx0急剧增加
第七组数据mx1
mx1 | |||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 | |
0.1 | 1.588446 | 1.616395 | 1.809073 | 2.010402 | 2.002715 | 2.307629 | 2.49206 | 2.368575 | 2.900003 | 3.120443 | 减 |
0.01 | 1.65697 | 1.75939 | 1.935947 | 2.047341 | 2.196221 | 2.229894 | 2.452489 | 2.646385 | 3.020372 | 2.682979 | 减 |
0.001 | 2.140369 | 2.240927 | 2.128779 | 2.065801 | 2.101887 | 1.918593 | 2.057979 | 2.009053 | 2.170221 | 1.862861 | 增 |
1.00E-04 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 18.7641 | 4.984766 | 3.334848 | 2.301857 | 2.190342 | 2.050619 | 1.92598 | 1.937585 | 增 |
9.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 108.5379 | 5.080537 | 3.502425 | 2.485332 | 2.210099 | 2.137352 | 1.833757 | 1.858811 | 增 |
8.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 6.279121 | 3.134754 | 2.462137 | 2.153108 | 1.983808 | 1.868943 | 1.843855 | 增 |
7.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 12.02128 | 4.757741 | 2.631517 | 2.261218 | 2.169066 | 2.002674 | 2.00178 | 增 |
6.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 12.72802 | 3.570039 | 2.582754 | 2.187766 | 2.042916 | 1.873924 | 1.961451 | 增 |
5.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 22.23098 | 4.156614 | 2.582298 | 2.085766 | 1.999047 | 1.861446 | 1.883192 | 增 |
4.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 109.7124 | 3.58393 | 2.386599 | 1.985459 | 1.882484 | 1.826737 | 1.733645 | 增 |
3.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 3.60511 | 2.509307 | 2.033553 | 1.784482 | 1.682455 | 1.645024 | 增 |
2.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 3.057884 | 2.091841 | 1.809239 | 1.661543 | 1.563204 | 1.546956 | 增 |
1.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 18.88548 | 3.000626 | 2.126295 | 1.772837 | 1.679098 | 1.576027 | 增 |
9.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 18.43058 | 3.380779 | 2.121562 | 1.805022 | 1.739354 | 1.736275 | 增 |
8.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7.804228 | 2.950875 | 1.910758 | 1.723606 | 1.702869 | 1.570727 | 增 |
7.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 17.76111 | 2.94401 | 1.973069 | 1.800193 | 1.643498 | 1.663353 | 增 |
6.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.549521 | 1.873949 | 1.61465 | 1.524536 | 1.62697 | 增 |
5.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 3.315456 | 1.78499 | 1.70925 | 1.688564 | 1.600932 | 增 |
4.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 3.451981 | 1.899551 | 1.742505 | 1.60838 | 1.61185 | 增 |
3.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.78701 | 1.744542 | 1.585587 | 1.584398 | 1.504193 | 增 |
2.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 3.081313 | 2.048887 | 1.735424 | 1.59537 | 1.614286 | 增 |
1.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 4.178909 | 1.973091 | 1.64274 | 1.570869 | 1.532656 | 增 |
当δ<0.001随着d的增加mx1急剧增加
第八组数据m01
m01 | |||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 | |
0.1 | 1.09378 | 1.244655 | 1.545153 | 1.965795 | 2.173665 | 2.917871 | 3.396628 | 3.790055 | 4.907775 | 5.654364 | 减 |
0.01 | 1.394711 | 1.72863 | 2.026444 | 2.220046 | 2.422093 | 2.700505 | 3.304357 | 3.992285 | 5.04516 | 4.498464 | 减 |
0.001 | 2.958356 | 3.122761 | 3.00955 | 2.831799 | 2.773067 | 2.510184 | 2.795422 | 2.693475 | 3.127596 | 2.723884 | 增 |
1.00E-04 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 52.41221 | 11.05105 | 6.2466 | 3.308319 | 2.967244 | 2.545352 | 2.369209 | 2.39893 | 增 |
9.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 291.1375 | 12.01097 | 6.738342 | 3.960429 | 3.126534 | 2.657492 | 2.25603 | 2.286692 | 增 |
8.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 15.81854 | 5.752154 | 3.922813 | 2.877896 | 2.356656 | 2.162283 | 2.2934 | 增 |
7.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 30.69517 | 10.78083 | 4.271088 | 3.230148 | 2.803717 | 2.485965 | 2.528391 | 增 |
6.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 32.78711 | 7.012619 | 4.295463 | 2.806442 | 2.527374 | 2.145041 | 2.330114 | 增 |
5.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 57.77967 | 8.711975 | 4.282513 | 2.809628 | 2.390706 | 2.125758 | 2.209505 | 增 |
4.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 291.2134 | 7.69813 | 3.889104 | 2.455223 | 2.085396 | 1.95588 | 1.881975 | 增 |
3.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7.794294 | 4.174732 | 2.50693 | 1.983281 | 1.708014 | 1.73464 | 增 |
2.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 6.365932 | 3.211437 | 2.081841 | 1.633519 | 1.403412 | 1.486239 | 增 |
1.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 50.52162 | 5.561816 | 2.635035 | 1.756534 | 1.501025 | 1.471077 | 增 |
9.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 51.93785 | 6.674083 | 2.788506 | 1.822542 | 1.581936 | 1.519062 | 增 |
8.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 21.18067 | 5.36051 | 2.503369 | 1.608658 | 1.410364 | 1.406749 | 增 |
7.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 49.6307 | 5.887954 | 2.437901 | 1.752853 | 1.420984 | 1.425457 | 增 |
6.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 4.767659 | 2.251365 | 1.48791 | 1.274394 | 1.409355 | 增 |
5.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 6.277032 | 2.313687 | 1.677243 | 1.406584 | 1.272645 | 增 |
4.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7.312639 | 2.560774 | 1.548939 | 1.25321 | 1.240729 | 增 |
3.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 6.248267 | 2.079853 | 1.435871 | 1.180494 | 1.115047 | 增 |
2.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7.106934 | 2.916135 | 1.525451 | 1.219274 | 1.170424 | 增 |
1.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 10.64584 | 2.548183 | 1.363489 | 1.025004 | 1.037122 | 增 |
当δ<0.001随着d的增加m01急剧增加
第九组数据k
k | |||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 | |
0.1 | 2368637 | 2695366 | 3346110 | 4257033 | 4707185 | 6318802 | 7355577 | 8207564 | 10628043 | 12244822 | 减 |
0.01 | 5665208 | 7021562 | 8231262 | 9017658 | 9838357 | 10969246 | 13422046 | 16216355 | 20493052 | 18272415 | 减 |
0.001 | 25192443 | 26592471 | 25628401 | 24114723 | 23614579 | 21375954 | 23804952 | 22936800 | 26633642 | 23195754 | 增 |
1.00E-04 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 9.08E+08 | 1.92E+08 | 1.08E+08 | 57341629 | 51429929 | 44117451 | 41064451 | 41579580 | 增 |
9.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5.23E+09 | 2.16E+08 | 1.21E+08 | 71208447 | 56215038 | 47781673 | 40563381 | 41114685 | 增 |
8.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 3.01E+08 | 1.09E+08 | 74652540 | 54767383 | 44848004 | 41149027 | 43644225 | 增 |
7.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5.87E+08 | 2.06E+08 | 81683219 | 61775572 | 53620223 | 47543314 | 48354698 | 增 |
6.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 6.86E+08 | 1.47E+08 | 89898441 | 58735172 | 52894648 | 44892898 | 48766241 | 增 |
5.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 1.29E+09 | 1.95E+08 | 95736707 | 62809972 | 53444859 | 47521873 | 49394056 | 增 |
4.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7.47E+09 | 1.97E+08 | 99697996 | 62940166 | 53459570 | 50139383 | 48244826 | 增 |
3.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.32E+08 | 1.24E+08 | 74539562 | 58969695 | 50785075 | 51576753 | 增 |
2.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.43E+08 | 1.23E+08 | 79586295 | 62447491 | 53650769 | 56817164 | 增 |
1.00E-05 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.47E+09 | 2.72E+08 | 1.29E+08 | 85829735 | 73344771 | 71881399 | 增 |
9.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.57E+09 | 3.3E+08 | 1.38E+08 | 90201726 | 78293589 | 75181795 | 增 |
8.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 1.19E+09 | 3.01E+08 | 1.41E+08 | 90336596 | 79201117 | 78998135 | 增 |
7.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 2.88E+09 | 3.42E+08 | 1.42E+08 | 1.02E+08 | 82589774 | 82849766 | 增 |
6.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 3.1E+08 | 1.47E+08 | 96851854 | 82953568 | 91738495 | 减增 |
5.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 4.35E+08 | 1.6E+08 | 1.16E+08 | 97557003 | 88267339 | 增 |
4.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5.75E+08 | 2.01E+08 | 1.22E+08 | 98530420 | 97549166 | 增 |
3.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 5.92E+08 | 1.97E+08 | 1.36E+08 | 1.12E+08 | 1.06E+08 | 增 |
2.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 7.62E+08 | 3.13E+08 | 1.64E+08 | 1.31E+08 | 1.26E+08 | 增 |
1.00E-06 | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | #NUM! | 1.74E+09 | 4.17E+08 | 2.23E+08 | 1.68E+08 | 1.7E+08 | 增 |
当δ<0.001随着d的增加k增加
数据综合
计算ωx | 计算ω0 | 计算ω1 | m0 | m1 | mx0 | mx1 | m01 | k | |
δ>0.001 | 减小 | 增加 | 减小 | 减小 | 减小 | 减小 | 减小 | 减小 | 减小 |
δ<=0.001 | 7个拐点 | 9个拐点 | 9个拐点 | 增加 | 增加 | 增加 | 增加 | 增加 | 增加 |
可以明显观察到所有9个量在δ=0.001附近的变化趋势都是相反的,
ω0和ω1的变化规律是相反的,但是波动要比较其他的量要平稳的多,这个现象可以用频率与点的分布有关的假设去解释,
所有9个量只有ω0是先增加再减小的。
实验数据
学习率 0.1 |
权重初始化方式 |
Random rand1 =new Random(); |
int ti1=rand1.nextInt(98)+1; |
int xx=1; |
if(ti1%2==0) |
{ xx=-1;} |
tw[a][b]=xx*((double)ti1/x); |
第一层第二层和卷积核的权重的初始化的x分别为1000,1000,200
|
d2(mnistx,0)81-con(3*3)49-30-2-(2*k) ,k∈{0,1}
最大准确率p-max | ||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 |
0.5 | 0.787707 | 0.926241 | 0.884634 | 0.399817 | 0.967376 | 0.870922 | 0.913948 | 0.828369 | 0.953191 | 0.905437 |
0.4 | 0.611348 | 0.783452 | 0.957447 | 0.921525 | 0.860047 | 0.919622 | 0.979669 | 0.976832 | 0.976832 | 0.982979 |
0.3 | 0.873286 | 0.922459 | 0.987707 | 0.928874 | 0.976832 | 0.987707 | 0.992908 | 0.997636 | 0.998109 | 0.997163 |
0.2 | 0.949409 | 0.988652 | 0.991017 | 0.92746 | 0.990544 | 0.994326 | 0.995745 | 0.997163 | 0.997163 | 0.997636 |
0.1 | 0.989598 | 0.958865 | 0.983924 | 0.925488 | 0.993853 | 0.994799 | 0.998582 | 0.997163 | 0.996217 | 0.998109 |
0.01 | 0.931915 | 0.982033 | 0.987234 | 0.923461 | 0.991962 | 0.993853 | 0.996217 | 0.997636 | 0.997163 | 0.998109 |
0.001 | 0.982033 | 0.978723 | 0.980142 | 0.92071 | 0.982979 | 0.995272 | 0.997636 | 0.997163 | 0.997163 | 0.99669 |
1.00E-04 | 0.865721 | 0.941371 | 0.965957 | 0.921147 | 0.991017 | 0.996217 | 0.994799 | 0.99669 | 0.997163 | 0.998109 |
9.00E-05 | 0.926714 | 0.946572 | 0.976359 | 0.917812 | 0.989598 | 0.990071 | 0.995272 | 0.997636 | 0.997163 | 0.997163 |
8.00E-05 | 0.956028 | 0.983452 | 0.973995 | 0.918451 | 0.982506 | 0.983924 | 0.995745 | 0.998109 | 0.99669 | 0.997163 |
7.00E-05 | 0.968322 | 0.956501 | 0.976359 | 0.918929 | 0.984397 | 0.995745 | 0.995745 | 0.996217 | 0.995272 | 0.997636 |
6.00E-05 | 0.914421 | 0.896927 | 0.979196 | 0.918557 | 0.983924 | 0.995272 | 0.997163 | 0.997163 | 0.997636 | 0.997636 |
5.00E-05 | 0.900236 | 0.963593 | 0.956028 | 0.919095 | 0.995272 | 0.993853 | 0.995272 | 0.997636 | 0.997163 | 0.998109 |
4.00E-05 | 0.904965 | 0.982506 | 0.960757 | 0.91999 | 0.972104 | 0.987707 | 0.995745 | 0.99669 | 0.99669 | 0.997163 |
3.00E-05 | 0.945154 | 0.921513 | 0.970213 | 0.919492 | 0.987707 | 0.995745 | 0.995272 | 0.997163 | 0.997163 | 0.997163 |
2.00E-05 | 0.888416 | 0.972577 | 0.948936 | 0.921213 | 0.983924 | 0.996217 | 0.992908 | 0.998582 | 0.999054 | 0.998109 |
1.00E-05 | 0.952719 | 0.948936 | 0.974941 | 0.920212 | 0.982506 | 0.992435 | 0.995272 | 0.995745 | 0.996217 | 0.998109 |
9.00E-06 | 0.987707 | 0.956974 | 0.979196 | 0.919281 | 0.992908 | 0.990071 | 0.997163 | 0.996217 | 0.997636 | 0.998582 |
8.00E-06 | 0.819385 | 0.972577 | 0.964066 | 0.920896 | 0.976359 | 0.98156 | 0.99669 | 0.996217 | 0.997163 | 0.998109 |
7.00E-06 | 0.869976 | 0.929078 | 0.93617 | 0.922108 | 0.98156 | 0.975414 | 0.992908 | 0.995745 | 0.99669 | 0.997636 |
6.00E-06 | 0.893144 | 0.852482 | 0.926714 | 0.920141 | 0.948936 | 0.984397 | 0.99669 | 0.997163 | 0.997636 | 0.997636 |
5.00E-06 | 0.89409 | 0.889835 | 0.960757 | 0.920539 | 0.966903 | 0.986288 | 0.995745 | 0.994326 | 0.997636 | 0.997163 |
4.00E-06 | 0.914421 | 0.920095 | 0.9513 | 0.920916 | 0.983452 | 0.977305 | 0.992435 | 0.99669 | 0.996217 | 0.99669 |
3.00E-06 | 0.943262 | 0.84539 | 0.919622 | 0.922098 | 0.95792 | 0.983452 | 0.991017 | 0.996217 | 0.996217 | 0.99669 |
2.00E-06 | 0.778251 | 0.910638 | 0.917258 | 0.921464 | 0.992908 | 0.988652 | 0.983452 | 0.99669 | 0.997636 | 0.99669 |
1.00E-06 | 0.910638 | 0.932861 | 0.906856 | 0.92246 | 0.973522 | 0.974941 | 0.995272 | 0.99669 | 0.99669 | 0.998109 |
耗时 min/199 | ||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 |
0.5 | 4.445717 | 3.361217 | 4.853283 | 3.406 | 3.4847 | 3.458233 | 3.58405 | 3.316667 | 5.41685 | 3.722733 |
0.4 | 3.163933 | 4.2936 | 6.098017 | 4.4017 | 4.552417 | 4.593867 | 4.8079 | 4.498533 | 6.949167 | 4.998317 |
0.3 | 5.8274 | 4.495267 | 4.778983 | 4.6172 | 4.767067 | 4.884867 | 4.571567 | 4.706633 | 7.1075 | 5.301083 |
0.2 | 5.9865 | 4.663783 | 6.597683 | 5.83685 | 4.9215 | 5.015717 | 5.144817 | 4.876633 | 7.786967 | 5.439433 |
0.1 | 6.1934 | 4.850433 | 7.2629 | 6.933783 | 5.175167 | 5.184033 | 5.405133 | 5.02295 | 7.796967 | 5.799317 |
0.01 | 6.895617 | 5.63085 | 8.64815 | 7.957717 | 5.96095 | 5.793883 | 6.09255 | 5.772883 | 8.758017 | 6.484483 |
0.001 | 8.632433 | 6.884817 | 9.1431 | 9.311233 | 6.986017 | 4.525033 | 7.05725 | 6.587233 | 10.0382 | 7.310267 |
1.00E-04 | 12.24895 | 9.52915 | 12.1106 | 10.91075 | 6.6905 | 9.654 | 8.636183 | 8.027767 | 11.85452 | 8.90695 |
9.00E-05 | 12.39028 | 9.8186 | 12.5024 | 12.0775 | 9.082133 | 8.743633 | 8.672533 | 8.197933 | 11.82882 | 8.995983 |
8.00E-05 | 11.94238 | 10.12003 | 9.643733 | 12.4507 | 9.248483 | 8.824167 | 7.93385 | 8.202283 | 12.05707 | 9.722083 |
7.00E-05 | 13.26953 | 10.53675 | 12.84552 | 12.79737 | 9.48825 | 9.035233 | 9.023367 | 7.46655 | 12.28057 | 9.805383 |
6.00E-05 | 13.92442 | 10.04992 | 13.33407 | 13.14648 | 9.543667 | 9.471267 | 9.227017 | 8.513233 | 12.4136 | 10.00677 |
5.00E-05 | 14.86603 | 11.6692 | 13.8548 | 10.78533 | 9.878967 | 9.756467 | 9.4494 | 8.646383 | 12.61033 | 10.22158 |
4.00E-05 | 11.97173 | 12.48775 | 13.422 | 14.20235 | 7.94835 | 7.896767 | 10.32367 | 8.83835 | 13.04053 | 10.39577 |
3.00E-05 | 16.50817 | 13.2259 | 14.83683 | 14.55913 | 10.4121 | 10.64587 | 10.20427 | 9.144983 | 13.279 | 9.43595 |
2.00E-05 | 19.00735 | 13.78183 | 17.18997 | 15.72455 | 11.15398 | 11.00283 | 7.299033 | 9.667 | 13.89445 | 10.84797 |
1.00E-05 | 24.54688 | 16.20098 | 20.48065 | 16.59888 | 13.25457 | 12.27335 | 12.2597 | 10.75145 | 11.05777 | 11.62145 |
9.00E-06 | 24.97243 | 17.90365 | 19.66688 | 19.40655 | 13.15702 | 12.50143 | 12.31818 | 10.85813 | 11.25468 | 11.91007 |
8.00E-06 | 25.2692 | 17.9942 | 21.54817 | 20.55805 | 13.49947 | 11.54188 | 12.82097 | 11.089 | 11.63953 | 12.00235 |
7.00E-06 | 27.48128 | 19.79193 | 21.73178 | 20.09165 | 13.99622 | 12.94402 | 12.42 | 11.43927 | 11.66117 | 11.46962 |
6.00E-06 | 28.32122 | 24.37823 | 23.4247 | 19.95688 | 14.77345 | 13.23173 | 10.04913 | 11.41863 | 10.23712 | 14.46183 |
5.00E-06 | 30.18652 | 26.20527 | 18.95425 | 21.78292 | 15.6476 | 14.62495 | 12.6482 | 11.9469 | 13.18252 | 16.55975 |
4.00E-06 | 34.12605 | 29.92287 | 20.53998 | 21.32082 | 14.7863 | 14.35922 | 13.50825 | 11.73323 | 13.47633 | 17.29183 |
3.00E-06 | 40.64245 | 32.4776 | 22.858 | 24.42958 | 17.59202 | 15.59048 | 14.06647 | 12.9705 | 12.55687 | 17.83875 |
2.00E-06 | 36.80765 | 35.65485 | 23.67747 | 27.71418 | 18.94678 | 16.97027 | 15.58413 | 14.46345 | 13.27635 | 19.1907 |
1.00E-06 | 48.57048 | 46.97597 | 31.47465 | 34.03535 | 23.12363 | 19.71553 | 18.36043 | 16.6463 | 15.34665 | 21.71437 |
d2(mnistx,1)81-con(3*3)49-30-2-(2*k) ,k∈{0,1}
最大准确率p-max | ||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 |
0.5 | 0.978723 | 0.982506 | 0.976359 | 0.844917 | 0.942317 | 0.96643 | 0.954137 | 0.980615 | 0.961229 | 0.877541 |
0.4 | 0.984397 | 0.980615 | 0.98487 | 0.986761 | 0.978723 | 0.98487 | 0.982506 | 0.980142 | 0.978723 | 0.970213 |
0.3 | 0.982979 | 0.982979 | 0.982506 | 0.98818 | 0.98487 | 0.979669 | 0.987707 | 0.981087 | 0.976359 | 0.974941 |
0.2 | 0.98487 | 0.986761 | 0.983452 | 0.979669 | 0.98156 | 0.982033 | 0.98156 | 0.980142 | 0.984397 | 0.979669 |
0.1 | 0.979669 | 0.980615 | 0.98487 | 0.984397 | 0.985343 | 0.981087 | 0.985816 | 0.981087 | 0.980615 | 0.978251 |
0.01 | 0.973995 | 0.979669 | 0.985343 | 0.988652 | 0.984397 | 0.990071 | 0.986288 | 0.987707 | 0.986288 | 0.983452 |
0.001 | 0.977778 | 0.980142 | 0.987707 | 0.980142 | 0.987234 | 0.991489 | 0.988652 | 0.990071 | 0.989598 | 0.990071 |
1.00E-04 | 0.986288 | 0.969267 | 0.987707 | 0.98818 | 0.990071 | 0.986761 | 0.991962 | 0.986288 | 0.990071 | 0.989598 |
9.00E-05 | 0.947991 | 0.977778 | 0.979669 | 0.987707 | 0.978723 | 0.991962 | 0.991489 | 0.989125 | 0.990071 | 0.98818 |
8.00E-05 | 0.964539 | 0.983452 | 0.964066 | 0.983452 | 0.977305 | 0.992435 | 0.98487 | 0.990071 | 0.990544 | 0.990071 |
7.00E-05 | 0.980615 | 0.972577 | 0.985816 | 0.991489 | 0.986288 | 0.993381 | 0.988652 | 0.990071 | 0.991962 | 0.990071 |
6.00E-05 | 0.961229 | 0.96643 | 0.962175 | 0.98156 | 0.98818 | 0.994326 | 0.990071 | 0.988652 | 0.992435 | 0.989125 |
5.00E-05 | 0.938534 | 0.949882 | 0.985816 | 0.98487 | 0.982033 | 0.989598 | 0.990071 | 0.993853 | 0.991962 | 0.990544 |
4.00E-05 | 0.977778 | 0.960757 | 0.972577 | 0.980142 | 0.990544 | 0.983452 | 0.990071 | 0.991489 | 0.989598 | 0.991489 |
3.00E-05 | 0.981087 | 0.970213 | 0.984397 | 0.983452 | 0.989125 | 0.982506 | 0.989125 | 0.988652 | 0.990071 | 0.990544 |
2.00E-05 | 0.975414 | 0.942317 | 0.955083 | 0.983452 | 0.98818 | 0.982506 | 0.988652 | 0.991962 | 0.990544 | 0.987234 |
1.00E-05 | 0.987707 | 0.939007 | 0.98818 | 0.991489 | 0.987707 | 0.986288 | 0.992435 | 0.990544 | 0.990071 | 0.989598 |
9.00E-06 | 0.970213 | 0.974941 | 0.965485 | 0.974941 | 0.974941 | 0.986761 | 0.989125 | 0.990544 | 0.991017 | 0.990071 |
8.00E-06 | 0.956974 | 0.953664 | 0.989598 | 0.975887 | 0.992435 | 0.982506 | 0.98818 | 0.987707 | 0.991489 | 0.990544 |
7.00E-06 | 0.955556 | 0.989598 | 0.993381 | 0.977778 | 0.989598 | 0.98487 | 0.990544 | 0.990544 | 0.991489 | 0.991017 |
6.00E-06 | 0.933333 | 0.952719 | 0.977778 | 0.985816 | 0.987234 | 0.978251 | 0.991017 | 0.993381 | 0.989598 | 0.991017 |
5.00E-06 | 0.933806 | 0.965012 | 0.959811 | 0.979196 | 0.98156 | 0.989598 | 0.989125 | 0.994326 | 0.98818 | 0.991962 |
4.00E-06 | 0.964066 | 0.98818 | 0.983452 | 0.980615 | 0.98818 | 0.989598 | 0.98818 | 0.992435 | 0.992435 | 0.991017 |
3.00E-06 | 0.966903 | 0.966903 | 0.979669 | 0.980615 | 0.982506 | 0.991962 | 0.98487 | 0.987707 | 0.989598 | 0.987707 |
2.00E-06 | 0.929078 | 0.95461 | 0.989125 | 0.989598 | 0.985816 | 0.991489 | 0.988652 | 0.992435 | 0.992435 | 0.991489 |
1.00E-06 | 0.919622 | 0.977305 | 0.991962 | 0.983924 | 0.973522 | 0.983924 | 0.992435 | 0.986761 | 0.991962 | 0.990544 |
耗时 min/199 | ||||||||||
δ | 1 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.1 |
0.5 | 1.422333 | 3.894683 | 4.94805 | 3.436117 | 4.308133 | 3.520417 | 3.557617 | 3.3832 | 1.314617 | 3.661117 |
0.4 | 4.9125 | 4.895983 | 6.289583 | 4.534033 | 5.5548 | 6.32855 | 6.516533 | 4.770717 | 5.046167 | 5.3677 |
0.3 | 5.025633 | 5.087283 | 6.566433 | 4.748633 | 5.798317 | 6.636283 | 6.751417 | 4.997483 | 5.375733 | 5.655567 |
0.2 | 5.209883 | 5.251767 | 6.787783 | 4.8946 | 5.962 | 6.840617 | 6.993117 | 5.2482 | 5.600433 | 0.840983 |
0.1 | 5.443217 | 5.470083 | 7.014233 | 5.200683 | 6.22895 | 6.53675 | 7.2 | 5.580383 | 5.7937 | 5.64565 |
0.01 | 6.19535 | 6.41825 | 5.576817 | 5.940117 | 7.637817 | 7.136883 | 8.0642 | 6.294817 | 6.8284 | 6.3787 |
0.001 | 8.228167 | 8.290567 | 10.07687 | 7.4839 | 9.394483 | 8.736217 | 9.565083 | 7.35155 | 7.947683 | 7.489583 |
1.00E-04 | 14.32538 | 11.07957 | 15.31927 | 9.32535 | 12.63123 | 10.96525 | 11.59315 | 8.728033 | 9.3754 | 8.813833 |
9.00E-05 | 14.73663 | 13.9446 | 14.85418 | 11.30035 | 12.74145 | 11.8233 | 11.8336 | 8.936533 | 9.704467 | 8.986367 |
8.00E-05 | 15.501 | 14.81533 | 13.45057 | 11.6163 | 12.79292 | 11.70238 | 12.32752 | 8.99575 | 8.7208 | 9.293967 |
7.00E-05 | 15.87958 | 14.8351 | 15.65873 | 11.7507 | 13.73462 | 11.95635 | 12.08393 | 9.280733 | 9.865183 | 9.2639 |
6.00E-05 | 15.36885 | 15.48042 | 16.55792 | 12.19285 | 13.50033 | 12.81625 | 12.05205 | 9.55095 | 9.9049 | 8.402267 |
5.00E-05 | 16.80617 | 14.42467 | 17.3282 | 11.7784 | 14.10828 | 13.32352 | 10.38122 | 9.691467 | 10.09893 | 9.48175 |
4.00E-05 | 17.2757 | 18.41705 | 18.21748 | 13.35283 | 14.98195 | 9.745533 | 10.48705 | 9.02525 | 10.71492 | 9.5762 |
3.00E-05 | 18.28852 | 19.38785 | 19.89542 | 15.33597 | 15.86695 | 13.89655 | 10.414 | 10.65882 | 6.55155 | 9.962833 |
2.00E-05 | 22.94062 | 22.366 | 22.59092 | 16.22 | 17.06837 | 14.4598 | 11.36835 | 11.13865 | 12.04705 | 10.44915 |
1.00E-05 | 29.61708 | 29.4258 | 29.10293 | 18.65833 | 20.46935 | 16.81587 | 11.91942 | 12.0111 | 12.26727 | 10.42728 |
9.00E-06 | 31.64762 | 30.18498 | 30.4366 | 19.91692 | 21.16757 | 15.83328 | 12.98652 | 12.18153 | 12.30075 | 11.03838 |
8.00E-06 | 33.7263 | 31.05033 | 30.38265 | 25.73568 | 21.83735 | 18.01983 | 13.59408 | 11.48607 | 12.27552 | 11.66977 |
7.00E-06 | 36.5358 | 33.34162 | 31.80323 | 28.13275 | 22.46492 | 18.77172 | 16.54392 | 12.71963 | 7.34375 | 11.59743 |
6.00E-06 | 38.27928 | 35.7317 | 34.83445 | 29.25468 | 24.30003 | 17.63537 | 15.40202 | 13.06252 | 12.94153 | 12.13977 |
5.00E-06 | 41.5101 | 38.83813 | 32.29933 | 29.84257 | 26.60728 | 19.68347 | 18.59375 | 13.63908 | 12.31923 | 10.61688 |
4.00E-06 | 45.5644 | 43.93442 | 33.879 | 32.9055 | 27.73898 | 23.18125 | 19.72765 | 12.87817 | 12.50212 | 13.03635 |
3.00E-06 | 55.64228 | 52.89503 | 40.25887 | 37.23753 | 30.99052 | 21.91538 | 19.30377 | 14.7379 | 13.16163 | 13.23238 |
2.00E-06 | 76.9769 | 54.82058 | 48.90273 | 42.34932 | 29.33985 | 26.40945 | 22.72518 | 15.18567 | 13.90563 | 14.09025 |
1.00E-06 | 120.068 | 88.98115 | 62.04817 | 58.25057 | 36.11708 | 29.29723 | 25.21703 | 19.66868 | 15.39393 | 15.97267 |