VMFL023——fluent计算案例-圆柱绕流。我计算的出现了结果不对，不知道是否因为我采用的三角形网格，胡坤采用的是四边形网格，但是我感觉这个应该不是问题的，为何？

VMFL023——fluent计算案例-圆柱绕流。我计算的出现了结果不对，不知道是否因为我采用的三角形网格，胡坤采用的是四边形网格，但是我感觉这个应该不是问题的，为何？

参考文献：

Fluent验证案例23：圆柱绕流-析模界 (topcfd.cn)

Fluent自带验证案例—023—层流圆柱扰流_哔哩哔哩_bilibili

下面是下图为我计算的速度云图。

下图为我计算258s的速度涡量图。

下面为胡坤老师计算的结果，发现

在fluent中输出的文件不管后缀是“.out”还是“.xy”，都可以输出相同的内容，影响不大。

下面是我计算的升力系数和拖拽系数，发现和参考文献相差较大。

下面是我计算的涡街频率的功率谱图和strouhal number的功率谱图，出现了错误提示，还和胡坤 老师计算相差很大。特别是那个strouhal number的功率谱图。

Error: No keyframes present.

Error Object: #f

Error: CAR: invalid argument [1]: wrong type [not a pair]

Error Object: ()

Video file exported at D:\CFD\CFD-course\VMFL023\VMFL023_files\dp0\FFF\Fluent\\.\\animation-1.mp4

Video file exported at D:\CFD\CFD-course\VMFL023\VMFL023_files\dp0\FFF\Fluent\\.\\animation-1.mp4

Reading "D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/lift.xy"...

Warning: Read_Signal: FFT can handle a constant sampling interval only!

Jump in sampling interval at sample number 13 is more than 1 percent!

Reading "D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/lift.xy"...

Warning: Read_Signal: FFT can handle a constant sampling interval only!

Jump in sampling interval at sample number 13 is more than 1 percent!

Reading "D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/lift.xy"...

Warning: Read_Signal: FFT can handle a constant sampling interval only!

Jump in sampling interval at sample number 13 is more than 1 percent!

full signal length of 25863 samples is used.

Reading "D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/lift.xy"...

Warning: Read_Signal: FFT can handle a constant sampling interval only!

Jump in sampling interval at sample number 13 is more than 1 percent!

full signal length of 25863 samples is used.

Reading "D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/lift.xy"...

Warning: Read_Signal: FFT can handle a constant sampling interval only!

Jump in sampling interval at sample number 13 is more than 1 percent!

full signal length of 25863 samples is used.

Reading "D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/lift.xy"...

Warning: Read_Signal: FFT can handle a constant sampling interval only!

Jump in sampling interval at sample number 13 is more than 1 percent!

full signal length of 25863 samples is used.

Reading "D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/lift.xy"...

Warning: Read_Signal: FFT can handle a constant sampling interval only!

Jump in sampling interval at sample number 13 is more than 1 percent!

full signal length of 25863 samples is used.

Reading from DESKTOP-6NL2RP5:"D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/FFF.1-4-10000.dat.h5" in NODE0 mode ...

Reading results.

Parallel variables...

Done.

Reading "D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/lift.xy"...

Warning: Read_Signal: FFT can handle a constant sampling interval only!

Jump in sampling interval at sample number 13 is more than 1 percent!

Reading "D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/lift.xy"...

Warning: Read_Signal: FFT can handle a constant sampling interval only!

Jump in sampling interval at sample number 13 is more than 1 percent!

Reading "D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/lift.xy"...

Warning: Read_Signal: FFT can handle a constant sampling interval only!

Jump in sampling interval at sample number 13 is more than 1 percent!

full signal length of 25863 samples is used.

Reading "D:/CFD/CFD-course/VMFL023/VMFL023_files/dp0/FFF/Fluent/lift.xy"...

Warning: Read_Signal: FFT can handle a constant sampling interval only!

Jump in sampling interval at sample number 13 is more than 1 percent!

full signal length of 25863 samples is used.

下面是胡坤的计算结果。

• 重新显示图形如下图所示，可以看出最大功率谱密度（power spectral density）对应的频率约0.08左右（公众号上面数据有误）

• 可以设置X轴为Strouhal Number，如下图所示

可看出Strouhal数约为0.2，要获取精确的St数，可通过勾选选项Write FFT to File输出计算结果，找出Power Spectral Density最大值对应的St数，如下图所示，其值为0.178。

后面发现那个reference values下面的length自己设置为1，应该设置为2，后面修改为2了，还是要查看帮助文件关于那个strouhal number定义。strouhal number稍微接近了些0.178，但是还是相差较大。还是出现了那个报错。