Intel Atom vs TI OMAP3

source: http://bec-systems.com/site/326/intel-atom-vs-ti-omap3

 

As we look at new projects, both the Intel Atom and the TI OMAP3 processors generate considerable interest.  As we have already shown, the OMAP3 does offer a considerable performance improvement over earlier generations of ARM CPUs.  The following video I found on YouTube shows a similar comparison of a OMAP3 and Atom systems rendering web pages:

As one would expect, the Atom does perform better (about 14%), but considering the power differences, the OMAP does surprisingly well.  It is also unknown in this demo if the screen size would make a significant difference in the results.  Like most things, the choice depends on the application, and no two applications are the same, and each solution has advantages.  Some things to think about:

1. Power: OMAP3 platform consumes on the order of <1-2W while the Atom is more in the range of 2-5W.
2. High Speed I/O Interfaces: Atom supports PCI and PCI expansion interfaces where OMAP3 is limited to more special purpose user interfaces such as SD, Camera, Asynchronous bus, etc.
3. Packaging: OMAP3 packaging is very aggressive with the stacked Package-on-Package.  To get an idea how much space an OMAP3 solution takes, check out the module from Gumstix.  There are basically only two chips in the system: the OMAP3+stacked RAM/Flash and a power management+I/O chip.  This is very high integration!
4. Module availability: for many embedded systems with volumes in the 1000’s of units per year, a module solution is very attractive compared to a full custom design.  This drastically reduces the engineering effort and time to market.  A sampling of the modules available include:
   • OMAP3:
     • Gumstix Overo ($117 for 3000 units)
     • LogicPD OMAP35x SOM-LV (Cost unknown)
   • Atom:
     • Eurotech Catalyst (Cost unknown)
5. Software support:  TI and the open source community have done a remarkable job of supporting the OMAP3 with the BeagleBoard effort.  Intel also has invested significantly in software with their Moblin project.  Other factors to consider is the boot software open (bootloader vs BIOS), are there 3D graphics libraries available, etc.
6. Multimedia processing:  The OMAP3 is available with an on-chip DSP.  Intel has traditionally offered extensions for multimedia processing such as SIMD.