【国产化信创实践】TongWeb集成SpringBoot

     1.修改pom.xml

               移除springboot自带的tomcat

<dependency>

    <groupId>org.springframework.boot</groupId>

    <artifactId>spring-boot-starter-web</artifactId>

    <exclusions>

        <exclusion>

            <groupId>org.springframework.boot</groupId>

            <artifactId>spring-boot-starter-tomcat</artifactId>

        </exclusion>

    </exclusions>

</dependency>

           添加tongweb相关依赖，tongweb-spring-boot-starter和tongweb-embed为tongweb核心依赖，必须添加，其他根据需求选择添加。

<!--TongWeb 嵌入式版提供的与 springboot 集成的 starter。 -->

<dependency>

    <groupId>com.tongweb.springboot</groupId>

    <artifactId>tongweb-spring-boot-starter</artifactId>

    <version>2.x.0.RELEASE</version>

</dependency>

<!-- TongWeb 嵌入式版提供的 web 应用的核心功能支持 -->

<dependency>

    <groupId>com.tongweb</groupId>

    <artifactId>tongweb-embed</artifactId>

    <version>7.0.E.1</version>

</dependency>

<!-- 集成websocket支持-->

<dependency>

    <groupId>com.tongweb.springboot</groupId>

    <artifactId>tongweb-spring-boot-websocket</artifactId>

    <version>2.x.0.RELEASE</version>

</dependency>

<!-- jsp支持-->

<dependency>

    <groupId>com.tongweb</groupId>

    <artifactId>tongweb-jsp</artifactId>

    <version>7.0.E.1</version>

</dependency>

<!-- 国密的jar包-->

<dependency>

    <groupId>com.tongweb</groupId>

    <artifactId>tongweb-gmssl</artifactId>

    <version>1.0.0</version>

</dependency>

     2.编写yml文件,license必须添加

server:

  port: 8087

  tongweb:

    max-threads: 2000 #最大工作线程

    max-connections: 10000 #最大连接数

    accept-count: 2000 #最大等待队列

  license:

    type: file

    path: classpath:tongweb/license.dat

 

         使用 TongWeb 嵌入式版时，首先需要经过 license 认证。TongWeb 嵌入式版采取读取 license.dat 文件认证的方式。

         通过配置项 server.tongweb.license.type 指定 license 认证的方式。

         当配置项 server.tongweb.license.type = file 时，表示 license 认证方式为文件认证。

         如果 server.tongweb.license.type = file，需要在配置项 server.tongweb.license.path 指 定 License 文件的存放目录。

  3.启动，出现如下图所示表示配置成功

    

4.TongWeb、BES、Tomcat、UnderTow、Jetty性能对比

    说明：本次测试项目为简单springboot工程，分别引入以上5个中间件，采用jmeter对同步和异步接口进行压测，并发量分别为100、300、500、1000、3000、5000、10000、20000。

    1. 测试项目：https://download.csdn.net/download/zhb15810357012/87793327

    2.各中间件关键配置

           1.tongweb、bes、tomcat：最大工作线程2000，最大连接数10000，最大等待队列2000

           2.jetty：最大工作线程2000

          3.UnderTow：工作线程2000

    3.服务器

           硬件型号：KunTai R722

          CPU：HUAWEI Kunpeng 920

         操作系统：Kylin Linux Advanced Server release V10 (Tercel)

         Kernel：4.19.90-23.8.v2101.ky10.aarch64

  4.测试结果

      

 6、详细测试结果

1)bes测试结果

Label	# Samples	Average	Median	90% Line	95% Line	99% Line	Min	Max	Error %	Throughput	Received KB/sec	Sent KB/sec
BES	100	3	3	5	7	14	2	18	0	147.275405	44.29768041	18.98472018
BES	100	2	2	3	3	32	1	71	0	233.1002331	70.11217949	30.04807692
BES	100	3	2	5	6	11	1	12	0	401.6064257	120.7956827	51.76957831
BES	100	2	2	4	4	5	1	8	0	279.3296089	84.01710894	36.0073324
BES	100	2	2	4	5	5	1	6	0	270.2702703	81.29222973	34.83952703
		2.333333333
BES	300	2	2	2	3	6	1	239	0	226.4150943	68.10141509	29.18632075
BES	300	1	2	2	3	3	1	5	0	483.0917874	145.3049517	62.27355072
BES	300	4	2	3	4	124	1	125	0	494.2339374	148.6563015	63.70984349
BES	300	2	2	3	4	14	1	86	0	444.4444444	133.6805556	57.29166667
BES	300	2	2	2	3	8	1	162	0	668.1514477	200.9674276	86.12889755
		2
BES	500	4	2	3	3	29	1	511	0	791.1392405	237.9598497	101.9827927
BES	500	2	2	3	3	18	1	205	0	680.2721088	204.6130952	87.69132653
BES	500	3	2	2	3	8	1	252	0	651.0416667	195.8211263	83.92333984
BES	500	3	2	5	7	59	1	226	0	261.7801047	78.73854712	33.74509162
BES	500	1	2	2	2	4	1	119	0	766.8711656	230.6604678	98.8544862
		2.666666667
BES	1000	2	2	2	3	20	1	257	0	538.2131324	161.8844187	69.3790366
BES	1000	1	1	2	2	5	0	178	0	1081.081081	325.1689189	139.3581081
BES	1000	1	2	2	3	4	1	106	0	204.0399918	61.3714038	26.3020302
BES	1000	3	1	2	4	58	1	142	0	1623.376623	488.28125	209.2633929
BES	1000	1	1	2	2	2	1	269	0	1009.081736	303.5128658	130.0769425
		1.333333333
BES	3000	3	1	2	2	48	0	351	0	1162.790698	349.7456395	149.8909884
BES	3000	2	1	2	2	6	0	620	0	1143.728555	344.0121045	147.4337591
BES	3000	7	1	2	3	143	1	3009	0	489.7959184	147.3214286	63.1377551
BES	3000	2	1	2	3	9	1	343	0	852.7572484	256.4933911	109.9257391
BES	3000	7	1	2	3	211	1	833	0	709.89115	213.5219475	91.50940606
		4
BES	5000	3	1	2	3	11	0	3087	0	832.362244	250.3589562	107.2966955
BES	5000	2	1	2	3	6	0	615	0	830.2889406	249.7353454	107.0294337
BES	5000	5	1	2	3	39	0	3050	0	748.1669909	225.0346027	96.44340117
BES	5000	3	1	2	3	85	0	3184	0	537.9236148	161.7973373	69.34171598
BES	5000	4	1	2	3	151	0	433	0	979.8157946	294.7102195	126.3043798
		3.333333333
BES	10000	5	1	2	3	65	0	3646	0	817.1269815	245.7764749	105.332775
BES	10000	4	1	2	3	96	0	1059	0	1240.387001	373.0851526	159.8936368
BES	10000	3	1	2	3	58	0	566	0	1329.080276	399.7624269	171.3267544
BES	10000	8	1	3	3	114	0	3287	0	928.1603861	279.1732411	119.6456748
BES	10000	6	1	4	23	68	0	3130	0	1251.721117	376.4942421	161.3546752
		5
BES	20000	3	1	2	2	7	0	1338	0	1581.277672	475.6186749	203.836575
BES	20000	3	1	2	2	5	0	2627	0	1100.594321	331.0381356	141.8734867
BES	20000	5	1	2	3	90	0	1433	0	1286.587327	386.9813445	165.8491476
BES	20000	4	1	2	3	52	0	3041	0	1213.224143	364.9150743	156.3921747
BES	20000	3	1	2	3	60	0	3173	0	1325.820351	398.7819026	170.9065297
		3.333333333

 2)UnderTow测试结果

Label	# Samples	Average	Median	90% Line	95% Line	99% Line	Min	Max	Error %	Throughput	Received KB/sec	Sent KB/sec
undertow	100	3	3	4	5	6	1	7	0	350.877193	97.99890351	45.23026316
undertow	100	4	3	6	9	42	2	43	0	240.3846154	67.13867188	30.98707933
undertow	100	5	3	21	24	27	2	28	0	310.5590062	86.73815994	40.03299689
undertow	100	1	2	3	4	6	1	21	0	363.6363636	101.5625	46.875
undertow	100	3	3	5	6	10	1	12	0	406.504065	113.535315	52.40091463
		3.333333333
undertow	300	2	1	2	2	3	1	187	0	259.5155709	72.48188798	33.45317907
undertow	300	2	2	3	4	8	1	31	0	508.4745763	142.0153602	65.54555085
undertow	300	2	2	3	3	4	1	12	0	337.4578178	94.25091395	43.50042182
undertow	300	2	2	3	4	6	1	41	0	729.9270073	203.8663321	94.09215328
undertow	300	4	2	3	3	40	1	370	0	205.9025395	57.50793583	26.54212423
		2
undertow	500	4	2	2	3	179	1	329	0	578.0346821	161.4432803	74.51228324
undertow	500	2	2	3	3	5	1	96	0	369.8224852	103.2902644	47.67242973
undertow	500	1	2	3	4	7	1	40	0	819.6721311	228.9318648	105.6608607
undertow	500	3	1	2	2	6	1	283	0	451.2635379	126.0364959	58.17069043
undertow	500	1	2	2	3	3	1	56	0	1256.281407	350.8754711	161.9425251
		2
undertow	1000	3	2	3	7	54	1	239	0	618.8118812	172.8322246	79.76871906
undertow	1000	2	1	2	3	7	1	443	0	1090.512541	304.5767448	140.5738822
undertow	1000	3	1	2	2	66	1	249	0	696.8641115	194.6319686	89.83013937
undertow	1000	2	1	2	3	6	0	212	0	747.9431563	208.8981862	96.41454749
undertow	1000	2	1	2	3	5	0	357	0	781.25	218.2006836	100.7080078
		2.333333333
undertow	3000	1	1	2	2	5	0	502	0	1302.648719	363.8257165	167.9195614
undertow	3000	2	1	2	4	7	0	611	0	1321.003963	368.9522787	170.2856671
undertow	3000	4	1	2	3	96	0	3066	0	643.2246998	179.6506486	82.91568396
undertow	3000	2	1	2	3	11	1	597	0	1607.717042	449.0303457	207.2447749
undertow	3000	6	1	2	3	186	0	730	0	1140.250855	318.4685006	146.9854618
		2.666666667
undertow	5000	5	1	2	4	23	0	3633	0	889.5214375	248.4405577	114.6648728
undertow	5000	3	1	2	3	63	0	3004	0	824.1305423	230.1770851	106.2355777
undertow	5000	8	1	2	3	313	0	3035	0	793.398921	221.5938393	102.2740797
undertow	5000	3	1	2	3	29	0	1154	0	1320.655045	368.854827	170.2406894
undertow	5000	5	1	2	3	8	0	3154	0	652.1455589	182.1422166	84.06563845
		4.333333333
undertow	10000	6	1	2	3	11	0	3129	0	1339.943722	374.2420943	172.7271205
undertow	10000	7	1	2	3	171	0	3032	0	1275.998469	356.3823848	164.4841776
undertow	10000	4	1	2	3	22	0	2998	0	1059.209829	295.8339953	136.5387671
undertow	10000	3	1	2	3	69	0	654	0	1426.12664	398.3127139	183.8366372
undertow	10000	5	1	2	3	22	0	3014	0	1223.840411	341.8148023	157.760678
		5
undertow	20000	7	1	2	3	81	0	3075	0	1356.760057	378.938844	174.8948511
undertow	20000	3	1	2	3	13	0	3798	0	1153.535587	322.1788845	148.6979467
undertow	20000	4	1	2	3	72	0	3125	0	1503.420281	419.9005863	193.8002706
undertow	20000	4	1	2	3	24	0	3666	0	1201.995312	335.7135345	154.9447082
undertow	20000	3	1	2	3	5	0	3311	0	1646.090535	459.7479424	212.191358
		3.666666667

3)Tomcat测试结果

Label	# Samples	Average	Median	90% Line	95% Line	99% Line	Min	Max	Error %	Throughput	Received KB/sec	Sent KB/sec
tomcat	100	1	2	3	3	3	1	7	0	236.4066194	60.0251182	30.47429078
tomcat	100	4	3	6	7	12	2	15	0	793.6507937	201.5128968	102.3065476
tomcat	100	2	2	3	4	4	1	49	0	1204.819277	305.9111446	155.3087349
tomcat	100	2	2	3	3	9	1	19	0	259.0673575	65.77882124	33.39540155
tomcat	100	4	2	7	27	38	1	38	0	316.4556962	80.35007911	40.79311709
		2.666666667
tomcat	300	4	2	3	3	20	1	254	0	1115.241636	283.1668216	143.7616171
tomcat	300	1	2	2	3	5	1	11	0	158.2278481	40.17503956	20.39655854
tomcat	300	2	2	3	5	19	1	22	0	480	121.875	61.875
tomcat	300	2	2	3	4	18	1	162	0	917.4311927	232.9415138	118.2626147
tomcat	300	2	2	2	2	3	1	115	0	2127.659574	540.2260638	274.268617
		2
tomcat	500	6	2	2	3	230	1	479	0	400.3202562	101.6438151	51.60378303
tomcat	500	4	2	3	3	159	1	159	0	369.54915	93.83083888	47.63719512
tomcat	500	2	2	2	3	38	1	65	0	548.8474204	139.3557903	70.74986279
tomcat	500	3	1	2	2	91	1	102	0	1234.567901	313.4645062	159.1435185
tomcat	500	5	2	2	3	238	1	239	0	729.9270073	185.3330292	94.09215328
		4
tomcat	1000	2	2	3	3	14	1	189	0	897.6660682	227.9230251	115.7147666
tomcat	1000	2	1	2	3	7	1	387	0	343.8789546	87.31301582	44.32814649
tomcat	1000	5	1	3	4	154	1	318	0	924.2144177	234.663817	119.1370148
tomcat	1000	2	1	2	3	4	1	267	0	1763.66843	447.8064374	227.3478836
tomcat	1000	2	1	2	2	61	1	357	0	999.000999	253.6525974	128.7774725
		2
tomcat	3000	3	1	2	3	9	1	457	0	1072.194425	272.2368656	138.2125625
tomcat	3000	1	1	2	3	5	0	140	0	942.5070688	239.3084354	121.4950518
tomcat	3000	8	1	2	2	197	0	894	0	1482.94612	376.5292882	191.1610232
tomcat	3000	2	1	2	3	4	1	596	0	1102.535832	279.9407387	142.1237596
tomcat	3000	1	2	2	3	5	1	181	0	1217.532468	309.1391031	156.9475446
		2
tomcat	5000	7	1	3	3	9	0	3144	0	684.5564074	173.8131503	88.2435994
tomcat	5000	2	1	2	3	8	0	319	0	1443.418014	366.4928551	186.0656033
tomcat	5000	4	1	2	3	48	1	3011	0	940.7337723	238.8581844	121.2664628
tomcat	5000	1	1	2	3	4	0	560	0	1655.629139	420.3745861	213.4209437
tomcat	5000	3	1	2	3	83	0	519	0	1091.464746	277.1297206	140.6966274
		3
tomcat	10000	7	1	3	3	134	0	1319	0	1617.599482	410.7186186	208.5186833
tomcat	10000	2	1	2	3	18	0	2013	0	1490.090896	378.3433914	192.0820295
tomcat	10000	3	1	2	3	91	0	566	0	1223.990208	310.7787638	157.7799878
tomcat	10000	3	1	2	2	29	0	3047	0	1002.506266	254.5426065	129.2293233
tomcat	10000	4	1	2	3	5	0	3015	0	939.4081729	238.5216064	121.0955848
		3.333333333
tomcat	20000	6	1	2	3	249	0	1355	0	1637.733377	415.8307403	211.1140681
tomcat	20000	9	1	3	6	232	0	1444	0	1267.427123	321.8076679	163.3792776
tomcat	20000	5	1	2	2	4	0	4576	0	944.1979039	239.737749	121.713011
tomcat	20000	4	1	2	2	7	0	3358	0	1345.804455	341.7081623	173.4826055
tomcat	20000	6	1	2	2	7	0	4255	0	1059.602649	269.0397351	136.589404
		5.666666667

4）Jetty测试结果

Label	# Samples	Average	Median	90% Line	95% Line	99% Line	Min	Max	Error %	Throughput	Received KB/sec	Sent KB/sec
Jetty	100	2	2	3	3	11	1	14	0	217.3913043	55.62160326	28.02309783
Jetty	100	3	2	3	5	23	1	24	0	1063.829787	272.1908245	137.1343085
Jetty	100	3	2	4	6	9	1	47	0	1388.888889	355.3602431	179.0364583
Jetty	100	1	2	2	3	3	1	5	0	1149.425287	294.0912356	148.1681034
Jetty	100	3	2	4	24	28	1	29	0	1351.351351	345.7559122	174.1976351
		2.666666667
Jetty	300	2	2	3	3	4	1	23	0	1060.070671	271.2290194	136.649735
Jetty	300	2	2	3	3	10	1	25	0	958.4664537	245.2326278	123.5523163
Jetty	300	2	2	2	3	35	1	37	0	1339.285714	342.6688058	172.6422991
Jetty	300	2	2	3	3	5	1	49	0	1209.677419	309.5073085	155.9349798
Jetty	300	1	2	2	2	15	1	32	0	1408.450704	360.3653169	181.5580986
		2
Jetty	500	1	2	2	2	4	1	28	0	1388.888889	355.3602431	179.0364583
Jetty	500	2	2	3	3	17	1	85	0	1344.086022	343.8970094	173.2610887
Jetty	500	1	2	2	2	3	1	31	0	1207.729469	309.008907	155.6838768
Jetty	500	1	2	2	3	4	1	42	0	1204.819277	308.2643072	155.3087349
Jetty	500	1	1	2	2	3	1	7	0	1048.218029	268.1964099	135.1218553
		1
Jetty	1000	1	2	2	2	5	1	42	0	1248.439451	319.4249376	160.9316479
Jetty	1000	1	2	2	3	9	1	59	0	1298.701299	332.2849026	167.4107143
Jetty	1000	1	1	2	2	3	0	19	0	1310.61599	335.3333879	168.9465924
Jetty	1000	1	1	2	3	7	1	39	0	1333.333333	341.1458333	171.875
Jetty	1000	1	1	2	2	4	1	49	0	1277.139208	326.7680396	164.6312261
		1
Jetty	3000	1	1	2	2	3	1	325	0	1449.275362	370.8106884	186.8206522
Jetty	3000	1	1	2	2	4	1	37	0	1217.532468	311.5170962	156.9475446
Jetty	3000	1	1	2	2	3	0	146	0	1312.335958	335.773458	169.1683071
Jetty	3000	2	1	2	2	3	1	276	0	1560.062402	399.1565913	201.1017941
Jetty	3000	5	1	2	3	184	1	424	0	1547.987616	396.067144	199.5452786
		1.333333333
Jetty	5000	2	1	2	2	5	0	329	0	1054.407423	269.7800243	135.9197069
Jetty	5000	3	1	2	3	37	1	701	0	1412.828483	361.4854125	182.1224216
Jetty	5000	1	1	2	2	4	1	362	0	1122.334456	287.1597924	144.6759259
Jetty	5000	1	1	2	2	5	0	194	0	1342.64232	343.5276249	173.0749866
Jetty	5000	5	1	2	3	232	0	373	0	1364.25648	349.0578104	175.8611869
		2
Jetty	10000	4	1	2	3	90	0	3586	0	787.6496534	201.527548	101.5329631
Jetty	10000	5	1	2	3	106	0	3005	0	1093.852549	279.8724294	141.0044301
Jetty	10000	4	1	2	3	41	0	3803	0	1118.31805	286.1321572	144.1581861
Jetty	10000	4	1	2	3	112	0	3006	0	1552.795031	397.2971661	200.1649845
Jetty	10000	3	1	2	4	94	0	280	0	990.0990099	253.3261139	127.6299505
		4
Jetty	20000	6	1	2	3	66	0	4994	0	1237.700353	316.6772387	159.5473111
Jetty	20000	10	1	2	3	318	0	3107	0	1707.796089	436.95564	220.1455896
Jetty	20000	8	1	2	3	9	0	9270	0	1109.508488	283.8781482	143.0225785
Jetty	20000	8	1	2	3	6	0	5967	0	798.084597	204.1974262	102.8780926
Jetty	20000	6	1	2	3	61	0	3228	0	1253.132832	320.6257832	161.5366541
		7.333333333

 

5）TongWeb 异步测试结果

Label	# Samples	Average	Median	90% Line	95% Line	99% Line	Min	Max	Error %	Throughput	Received KB/sec	Sent KB/sec
tongweb	100	3	2	9	11	13	1	18	0	602.4096386	184.1349774	80.59582078
tongweb	100	2	2	3	3	27	1	28	0	292.3976608	89.37545687	39.11960892
tongweb	100	2	1	2	2	33	1	36	0	564.9717514	172.6915607	75.58704096
tongweb	100	3	2	3	4	69	1	69	0	310.5590062	94.92672748	41.54939829
tongweb	100	1	1	3	5	9	1	14	0	295.8579882	90.43315459	39.58256287
		2.333333333
tongweb	300	2	2	2	2	7	1	85	0	327.1537623	99.99914804	43.76959515
tongweb	300	2	2	3	4	18	1	75	0	1145.038168	349.9970181	153.193583
tongweb	300	3	2	2	3	36	1	145	0	530.9734513	162.2995022	71.03844027
tongweb	300	2	1	2	2	33	1	200	0	700.9345794	214.2505111	93.77738026
tongweb	300	1	1	2	3	3	1	17	0	592.8853755	181.2237525	79.32157856
		2
tongweb	500	1	1	2	2	3	1	58	0	781.25	238.8000488	104.5227051
tongweb	500	2	1	2	7	13	1	45	0	1315.789474	402.1895559	176.0382401
tongweb	500	1	2	2	3	3	1	54	0	683.0601093	208.7869279	91.38597165
tongweb	500	1	2	2	3	3	1	26	0	1231.527094	376.4335745	164.7648553
tongweb	500	2	1	2	3	8	1	314	0	390.625	119.4000244	52.26135254
		1.333333333
tongweb	1000	2	1	2	3	48	1	399	0	1024.590164	313.1803919	137.0789575
tongweb	1000	2	1	2	2	11	1	163	0	1138.952164	348.1367454	152.3793423
tongweb	1000	2	1	2	2	4	1	141	0	1945.525292	594.6771644	260.2900049
tongweb	1000	3	1	2	2	32	1	379	0	676.5899865	206.8092439	90.52033999
tongweb	1000	1	1	2	2	3	1	5	0	1329.787234	406.4681682	177.9109874
		2
tongweb	3000	3	1	2	3	12	1	564	0	1694.915254	518.0746822	226.7611229
tongweb	3000	1	2	2	2	4	1	120	0	1364.877161	417.1938979	182.6056358
tongweb	3000	4	1	2	2	3	1	3055	0	669.3440428	204.5944193	89.55091198
tongweb	3000	1	1	2	2	4	1	115	0	1379.944802	421.7995343	184.6215214
tongweb	3000	2	2	2	3	6	1	349	0	1263.689975	386.2646114	169.067897
		2
tongweb	5000	1	1	2	3	3	1	194	0	1254.390366	383.4220553	167.8237111
tongweb	5000	2	1	2	3	28	1	369	0	1209.189843	369.6058797	161.7763755
tongweb	5000	1	1	2	2	4	1	79	0	1404.494382	429.3034586	187.9059867
tongweb	5000	1	1	2	3	4	1	318	0	1297.690112	396.6572314	173.6167434
tongweb	5000	4	2	2	3	4	1	3089	0	1208.313195	369.3379199	161.6590895
		1.333333333
tongweb	10000	3	2	4	7	35	1	627	0	1519.525908	464.4644621	203.2959467
tongweb	10000	2	2	3	3	5	1	3025	0	1070.663812	327.2634502	143.2431076
tongweb	10000	3	2	2	3	19	1	818	0	1396.843135	426.9647472	186.8823334
tongweb	10000	2	2	2	3	28	1	499	0	1511.258879	461.9375283	202.1899086
tongweb	10000	4	2	3	4	22	1	1033	0	1575.795777	481.6641388	210.8242397
		2.666666667
tongweb	20000	264	2	1242	1423	2110	1	4401	0	1144.950767	349.9703028	153.1818897
tongweb	20000	426	2	838	3607	7741	1	11876	0.0033	699.8880179	218.9333105	93.32835848
tongweb	20000	452	3	1346	1825	6328	1	7868	1.00E-04	991.9158855	303.4078898	132.6942257
tongweb	20000	525	2	1910	2356	2636	1	8248	0	1024.38025	313.1162287	137.0508733
tongweb	20000	331	2	830	2807	3064	1	3223	0	908.8843445	277.8132811	121.5987844
		403

 

6）Bes异步测试结果

Label	# Samples	Average	Median	90% Line	95% Line	99% Line	Min	Max	Error %	Throughput	Received KB/sec	Sent KB/sec
BES	100	3	2	7	9	51	1	92	0	558.6592179	170.7620461	74.74249302
BES	100	3	2	2	3	47	1	47	0	334.4481605	102.2287834	44.74550585
BES	100	2	1	2	3	9	1	41	0	826.446281	252.6149277	110.5694731
BES	100	1	2	2	3	7	1	8	0	520.8333333	159.2000326	69.68180339
BES	100	3	1	4	7	45	1	47	0	367.6470588	112.3764936	49.18715533
		2.666666667
BES	300	2	2	2	3	23	1	150	0	456.6210046	139.5726313	61.09089612
BES	300	2	2	2	3	21	1	85	0	974.025974	297.7247362	130.3140219
BES	300	1	2	2	2	3	1	104	0	980.3921569	299.6706495	131.1657475
BES	300	1	1	2	3	6	1	61	0	2142.857143	654.9944196	286.6908482
BES	300	1	2	2	2	3	1	4	0	815.2173913	249.1826596	109.0671705
		1.333333333
BES	500	1	2	3	6	8	1	9	0	941.6195857	287.8192679	125.9784016
BES	500	3	1	2	2	30	1	223	0	514.9330587	157.3965306	68.89241117
BES	500	1	2	2	3	4	1	68	0	860.5851979	263.0499677	115.1368868
BES	500	2	1	2	3	5	1	162	0	1079.913607	330.0907802	144.480629
BES	500	2	2	2	3	26	1	47	0	1592.356688	486.7262142	213.0399084
		1.666666667
BES	1000	1	1	2	3	6	1	12	0	1233.045623	376.8977343	164.9680179
BES	1000	2	1	2	2	36	1	50	0	946.969697	289.4546046	126.694188
BES	1000	3	2	2	3	5	1	587	0	470.8097928	143.9096339	62.9892008
BES	1000	1	1	2	2	3	1	44	0	1140.250855	348.5337087	152.5530929
BES	1000	3	1	2	2	16	1	422	0	1094.091904	334.424576	146.3775301
		2
BES	3000	2	2	2	3	5	1	499	0	869.0614137	265.6408423	116.2709118
BES	3000	3	2	2	3	92	1	500	0	847.9366874	259.1837726	113.4446545
BES	3000	1	1	2	2	4	1	249	0	1577.287066	482.1199724	211.0237579
BES	3000	5	2	2	3	188	1	432	0	858.8605783	262.5228135	114.9061516
BES	3000	2	2	2	3	8	1	648	0	795.5449483	243.1695008	106.4352128
		2.333333333
BES	5000	2	2	2	3	4	1	375	0	1654.533422	505.7314072	221.3584753
BES	5000	3	1	2	3	51	1	567	0	1269.680041	388.0955593	169.8693023
BES	5000	1	2	2	3	4	1	374	0	1184.834123	362.1612115	158.5178466
BES	5000	1	2	2	3	4	1	373	0	1144.426642	349.8100967	153.1117676
BES	5000	2	1	2	3	21	1	492	0	1348.072257	412.0572425	180.3573234
		1.666666667
BES	10000	4	2	3	3	98	1	901	0	1356.668023	414.6846595	181.507343
BES	10000	3	2	3	4	8	1	1203	0	1293.493727	395.3745473	173.055313
BES	10000	4	2	3	5	26	1	808	0	1646.903821	503.3993124	220.3377182
BES	10000	4	2	3	4	95	1	3169	0	1490.979574	455.7388736	199.4767594
BES	10000	5	2	5	11	69	1	3159	0	1019.679821	311.6794764	136.4220072
		4
BES	20000	642	2	3477	5078	6765	1	9823	4.00E-04	716.4863509	219.624897	95.81969397
BES	20000	469	2	2030	2200	2431	1	5071	4.00E-04	813.3387556	249.31311	108.7723033
BES	20000	228	2	1249	1775	2332	1	5693	0	959.3706529	293.2451312	128.3533002
BES	20000	463	2	1668	2196	4461	1	5381	0	1229.2563	375.7394745	164.4610479
BES	20000	517	7	2144	2368	2844	1	4754	0	1242.390359	379.7540844	166.2182414
		483

7）测试结果undertow异步

Label	# Samples	Average	Median	90% Line	95% Line	99% Line	Min	Max	Error %	Throughput	Received KB/sec	Sent KB/sec
undertow	100	1	1	2	2	3	1	9	0	1639.344262	465.8683402	219.326332
undertow	100	1	1	2	2	5	1	6	0	1315.789474	373.9206414	176.0382401
undertow	100	2	1	2	5	10	1	58	0	1298.701299	369.0645292	173.7520292
undertow	100	2	2	3	3	34	1	39	0	735.2941176	208.9556526	98.37431066
undertow	100	1	2	2	3	4	1	5	0	606.0606061	172.2301136	81.0842803
		1.333333333
undertow	300	1	1	2	2	7	1	17	0	1276.595745	362.7825798	170.7945479
undertow	300	1	1	2	2	4	1	20	0	1304.347826	370.6691576	174.5074728
undertow	300	1	2	2	3	4	1	79	0	1244.813278	353.7506483	166.5424015
undertow	300	1	1	2	3	3	1	92	0	650.7592191	184.9325515	87.06446584
undertow	300	1	1	2	2	3	1	20	0	785.3403141	223.1777651	105.0699444
		1
undertow	500	1	1	2	2	3	1	4	0	1133.786848	322.1991922	151.6882795
undertow	500	1	1	2	2	3	1	117	0	810.3727715	230.291481	108.4190134
undertow	500	1	1	2	2	3	1	4	0	1278.772379	363.4011349	171.0857577
undertow	500	1	1	2	2	3	1	42	0	1199.040767	340.7430306	160.4185402
undertow	500	1	1	2	2	3	1	3	0	1305.483029	370.9917591	174.6593505
		1
undertow	1000	1	1	2	2	3	1	43	0	1023.541453	290.8696904	136.9386515
undertow	1000	1	1	2	2	5	1	118	0	1470.588235	417.9113051	196.7486213
undertow	1000	1	1	2	2	4	1	6	0	945.1795841	268.6008388	126.4546905
undertow	1000	1	1	2	2	2	1	4	0	1270.64803	361.0923602	169.9988088
undertow	1000	1	1	2	2	3	1	97	0	1706.484642	484.9482722	228.3089804
		1
undertow	3000	2	2	2	2	4	1	582	0	1076.426265	305.8984795	144.0140608
undertow	3000	3	2	2	3	8	1	3042	0	698.8120196	198.5881813	93.49340496
undertow	3000	1	1	2	2	8	1	64	0	1194.267516	339.3865695	159.7799313
undertow	3000	2	1	2	2	4	1	287	0	1292.546316	367.3154082	172.9285599
undertow	3000	1	1	2	2	3	1	245	0	1581.444386	449.4143714	211.5799618
		1.666666667
undertow	5000	2	1	2	2	17	1	478	0	1288.327751	366.1165776	172.3641619
undertow	5000	3	2	2	3	40	1	680	0	1472.75405	418.5267857	197.0383837
undertow	5000	3	1	2	2	19	1	496	0	1645.278052	467.5546027	220.1202081
undertow	5000	1	1	2	2	4	1	256	0	1359.434475	386.3236644	181.877464
undertow	5000	3	1	2	3	5	1	597	0	1422.879909	404.3535679	190.3657691
		2.666666667
undertow	10000	8	2	11	56	114	1	1130	0	1469.075951	417.4815447	196.5462943
undertow	10000	9	2	5	37	156	1	1064	0	1135.589371	322.7114325	151.9294373
undertow	10000	10	2	9	30	296	1	2997	0	1276.65007	362.798018	170.801816
undertow	10000	7	2	4	13	151	1	3117	0	1481.262035	420.9445823	198.176659
undertow	10000	6	2	3	10	112	0	3088	0	1555.209953	441.9590785	208.0700816
		8
undertow	20000	316	2	1222	2069	3873	1	7083	1.00E-04	894.7745168	254.4724745	119.6990727
undertow	20000	142	2	634	851	1058	1	4836	0	1093.01563	310.6128402	146.2335365
undertow	20000	289	12	917	1272	2607	1	3519	0	1362.490633	387.1921623	182.2863444
undertow	20000	261	3	986	1418	2887	1	5226	0	993.8382031	282.42863	132.9646815
undertow	20000	510	25	1962	2357	3826	1	6262	0	1325.468885	376.6713334	177.3332394
		288.6666667

 8）Tomcat异步测试结果

Label	# Samples	Average	Median	90% Line	95% Line	99% Line	Min	Max	Error %	Throughput	Received KB/sec	Sent KB/sec
tomcat	100	2	2	2	3	3	1	46	0	1449.275362	375.0566123	193.897192
tomcat	100	1	2	3	4	7	1	11	0	1369.863014	354.5055651	183.2726884
tomcat	100	2	1	2	2	22	1	43	0	1219.512195	315.5964177	163.1573933
tomcat	100	2	2	2	3	13	1	16	0	420.1680672	108.7349002	56.21389181
tomcat	100	1	1	2	3	5	1	6	0	653.5947712	169.1431781	87.4438317
		1.666666667
tomcat	300	2	2	2	3	39	1	43	0	887.5739645	229.6944342	118.7476886
tomcat	300	1	1	2	2	3	1	10	0	1063.829787	275.3075133	142.3287899
tomcat	300	2	2	2	3	3	1	122	0	502.5125628	130.044755	67.23068467
tomcat	300	1	1	2	2	3	1	39	0	1045.296167	270.5112152	139.8491943
tomcat	300	1	1	2	2	3	1	4	0	681.8181818	176.4470881	91.21981534
		1.333333333
tomcat	500	2	2	2	2	3	1	198	0	914.0767824	236.5530736	122.2934758
tomcat	500	1	2	2	3	5	1	22	0	1557.632399	403.0982282	208.3941783
tomcat	500	2	2	2	3	5	1	106	0	1818.181818	470.5255682	243.2528409
tomcat	500	2	2	2	2	3	1	336	0	788.6435331	204.0923206	105.5118789
tomcat	500	2	1	2	2	15	1	173	0	451.6711834	116.8875621	60.42866418
		2
tomcat	1000	1	1	2	2	3	1	4	0	1336.898396	345.9746825	178.862383
tomcat	1000	1	1	2	2	3	1	110	0	1470.588235	380.5721507	196.7486213
tomcat	1000	1	1	2	2	3	1	35	0	1150.747986	297.8009925	153.9574942
tomcat	1000	2	1	2	2	5	1	247	0	1453.488372	376.1468932	194.4608467
tomcat	1000	2	2	2	3	4	1	280	0	639.7952655	165.572017	85.59760877
		1.333333333
tomcat	3000	2	2	2	3	4	1	512	0	1031.282228	266.8845608	137.9742824
tomcat	3000	2	2	2	3	20	1	165	0	1270.64803	328.8298126	169.9988088
tomcat	3000	1	1	2	3	4	1	39	0	1191.421763	308.3269212	159.3992008
tomcat	3000	1	1	2	2	4	1	82	0	1306.051371	337.99181	174.7353886
tomcat	3000	2	2	2	3	9	1	484	0	1345.29148	348.1467209	179.9852859
		1.666666667
tomcat	5000	2	2	2	4	27	1	380	0	1348.435814	348.9604403	180.4059635
tomcat	5000	2	1	2	2	4	1	548	0	1404.889014	363.5699108	187.9587841
tomcat	5000	1	1	2	2	3	1	523	0	1373.626374	355.4794815	183.7761848
tomcat	5000	2	2	2	3	16	1	209	0	1170.411985	302.8898203	156.5883222
tomcat	5000	1	2	2	3	4	1	244	0	1149.161112	297.3903269	153.7451879
		1.666666667
tomcat	10000	3	2	3	3	5	1	2749	0	981.932443	254.1133764	131.371821
tomcat	10000	3	2	3	5	51	1	816	0	1325.908247	343.1305522	177.3920213
tomcat	10000	2	2	3	4	8	1	673	0	1194.74313	309.1864546	159.8435633
tomcat	10000	7	2	16	39	121	1	766	0	1199.184555	310.3358466	160.4377773
tomcat	10000	4	2	3	4	7	1	3608	0	1226.692836	317.454689	164.1180845
		3.333333333
tomcat	20000	611	2	3114	3471	3904	1	6319	0	1369.394043	354.3842006	183.2099452
tomcat	20000	464	2	2414	2676	3077	1	4169	0	1127.649977	291.8234805	150.8672333
tomcat	20000	271	2	1117	1561	2225	1	3576	0	1339.49501	346.646658	179.2097817
tomcat	20000	520	2	2875	3215	3512	1	3736	0	1085.540599	280.926034	145.2334591
tomcat	20000	584	2	1767	2313	3764	1	3946	0	1176.263012	304.4040022	157.3711257
		522.6666667

9）Jetty异步测试结果

Label	# Samples	Average	Median	90% Line	95% Line	99% Line	Min	Max	Error %	Throughput	Received KB/sec	Sent KB/sec
Jetty	100	1	1	2	3	4	1	12	0	1538.461538	393.6298077	198.3173077
Jetty	100	1	2	2	3	11	1	12	0	746.2686567	194.583722	99.84258396
Jetty	100	1	2	3	3	4	1	16	0	1086.956522	278.1080163	140.1154891
Jetty	100	1	1	2	2	7	1	37	0	1492.537313	381.8796642	192.3973881
Jetty	100	1	1	3	6	7	1	7	0	337.8378378	88.08857686	45.1990076
		1
Jetty	300	1	1	2	2	4	1	25	0	1250	319.8242188	161.1328125
Jetty	300	1	1	2	3	4	1	37	0	710.9004739	185.3617447	95.11070794
Jetty	300	1	1	2	2	3	0	28	0	1363.636364	348.8991477	175.78125
Jetty	300	1	1	2	2	4	1	35	0	1327.433628	339.6363385	171.1144912
Jetty	300	1	1	2	2	12	1	23	0	1260.504202	322.5118172	162.4868697
		1
Jetty	500	1	1	2	3	12	1	15	0	1144.16476	292.7452803	147.4899886
Jetty	500	1	1	2	2	4	1	5	0	1082.251082	276.9040855	139.5089286
Jetty	500	1	1	2	2	3	1	47	0	1278.772379	327.1859015	164.8417519
Jetty	500	1	1	2	2	3	1	4	0	1291.989664	330.567668	166.5455426
Jetty	500	1	1	2	3	6	1	20	0	1091.703057	279.3224618	140.7273472
		1
Jetty	1000	1	1	2	6	16	1	19	0	1186.23962	303.5105279	152.9137011
Jetty	1000	1	1	2	2	3	1	23	0	1314.060447	336.2146846	169.3906045
Jetty	1000	1	1	2	2	6	1	13	0	1090.512541	279.0178571	140.5738822
Jetty	1000	1	1	2	2	4	1	31	0	1148.105626	293.7535878	147.9979908
Jetty	1000	1	1	2	2	3	1	7	0	1261.034048	322.6473834	162.5551702
		1
Jetty	3000	2	2	2	3	10	1	235	0	1311.762134	342.0317282	175.4994261
Jetty	3000	1	1	2	2	5	0	41	0	1130.369254	289.2155708	145.7116616
Jetty	3000	1	1	2	2	3	1	96	0	1340.482574	342.9750335	172.7965818
Jetty	3000	1	1	2	2	4	1	9	0	1251.564456	320.2244994	161.3344806
Jetty	3000	1	1	2	2	5	1	166	0	1374.255612	351.6161819	177.1501374
		1
Jetty	5000	2	1	2	3	10	1	371	0	1283.697047	328.4459243	165.4765725
Jetty	5000	1	2	2	3	4	1	351	0	1330.140995	346.8238727	177.9583167
Jetty	5000	1	1	2	3	6	1	206	0	1132.246377	289.6958503	145.9536345
Jetty	5000	1	1	2	3	7	0	296	0	1274.534795	326.101676	164.2955009
Jetty	5000	1	1	2	3	6	1	206	0	1317.523057	343.5338439	176.2701746
		1
Jetty	10000	5	1	2	3	141	0	2996	0	1019.471914	260.8414466	131.4163014
Jetty	10000	4	1	2	3	8	1	3041	0	1056.189269	270.2359263	136.149398
Jetty	10000	7	1	2	3	14	0	3084	0	1109.139308	283.7836901	142.9749889
Jetty	10000	4	1	2	3	74	1	3151	0	985.901607	252.252169	127.088879
Jetty	10000	6	1	2	3	36	0	3237	0	1191.611058	304.8848606	153.606113
		5
Jetty	20000	5	1	3	4	41	0	5521	0	1261.272624	322.7084253	162.5859242
Jetty	20000	9	1	2	3	30	0	9041	0	493.3034063	126.2163012	63.58989221
Jetty	20000	12	1	2	4	136	0	3096	0	1213.224143	310.414771	156.3921747
Jetty	20000	4	1	2	3	44	0	3122	0	1511.258879	386.6697522	194.8107148
Jetty	20000	6	1	2	3	158	0	3162	0	1135.524896	290.5346903	146.3762562
		6.666666667