学术会议 Rebuttal 模板

学术会议 Rebuttal 模板

Note that the author rebuttal is optional, and serves to provide you with an opportunity to rebut factual errors in the reviews, or to supply additional information requested by the reviewers.

The rebuttal is limited to 4000 characters. Please be concise and polite. Comments that are not to the point or offensive will make rejection of your paper more likely. Make sure to preserve anonymity in your rebuttal. Links to websites that reveal the authors’identities are not allowed and will be considered a violation of the double-blind policy. Links to websites with new figures, tables, videos or other materials are not allowed.

撰写原则

• 言简意赅（少说废话，抓住重点，用最少的话让反面意见或中立意见的审稿人改变态度）
• 结构清晰，语法没毛病 （排版组织）
• 客观陈述事实
• 千万不要犯“思想政治错误”
• 不礼貌
• 抓审稿人文字毛病
• 破坏双盲评审规定，添加链接等可能暴露身份的信息

阅读之前，你需要清楚以下几点：

• 内容来自于 NIPS会议 公开的 Rebuttal，适用于计算机领域的学术会议 【 NIPS会议会把往年已接收的论文的 Rebuttal 贴出来，参见 http://papers.nips.cc/ （只给出了持正面意见的reviewer的意见）NIPS2013 NIPS2014 NIPS2015 】

• rebuttal 只会在你论文处于接收边缘的时候起作用，如果reviewers意见普遍很严厉，那么rebuttal的作用几乎可以忽略。当然如果 reviewers 意见普遍很好且没有提问，也可以不写 rebuttal。

• Rebuttal 是给审稿人和 area chair 看的。Confidential comment to Area Chair 一般用于举报审稿人（仅area chair可见），不用填。

内容组织

说明： 带有星号*的部分为重点内容，其余为可选内容。

首句表达感谢*

即使是反对你的审稿人，也拿出了很多宝贵的时间审阅你的论文，因此作为作者要学会感恩。

• We thank the reviewers for acknowledging the strong performance of this work and the quality of the presentation. We address the comments as follows.
• 感谢好评 We thank the reviewers for their positive and constructive feedbacks.
• We thank all the reviewers for helpful comments.
• Thanks for all your feedback and suggestions. We will carefully incorporate them into our paper.
• Thanks for the helpful comments!
• Thank you for the feedback and suggestions, we will add clarification where needed and includ