第21关
Premise:
Conclusion: ~(A/\B)<->(~A\/~B)
1. ~A,~(A/\B) |- ~(A/\B) prem
2. ~A,A/\B |- A/\B prem
3. ~A,A/\B |- A ande 2
4. ~A,A/\B |- ~A prem
5. ~A,A/\B |- ~(A/\B) ne 3,4
6. ~A |- ~(A/\B) preme 1,5
7. ~B,~(A/\B) |- ~(A/\B) prem
8. ~B,A/\B |- A/\B prem
9. ~B,A/\B |- B ande 8
10. ~B,A/\B |- ~B prem
11. ~B,A/\B |- ~(A/\B) ne 9,10
12. ~B |- ~(A/\B) preme 7,11
13. ~A\/~B |- ~(A/\B) ore 6,12
14. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B),~A |- ~(~A\/~B) prem
15. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B),~A |- ~A prem
16. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B),~A |- ~A\/~B ori 15
17. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B) |- ~~A ni 14,16
18. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B) |- A nne 17
19. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B),~B |- ~(~A\/~B) prem
20. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B),~B |- ~B prem
21. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B),~B |- ~A\/~B ori 20
22. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B) |- ~~B ni 19,21
23. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B) |- B nne 22
24. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B) |- A/\B andi 18,23
25. ~(A/\B),~(~A\/~B) |- ~(A/\B) prem
26. ~(A/\B) |- ~~(~A\/~B) ni 24,25
27. ~(A/\B) |- (~A\/~B) nne 26
28. |- ~(A/\B)<->(~A\/~B) equivi 13,27
第22关
Premise:
Conclusion: A/\(B\/C)<->(A/\B)\/(A/\C)
1. A/\B |- A/\B prem
2. A/\B |- A ande 1
3. A/\B |- B ande 1
4. A/\B |- B\/C ori 3
5. A/\B |- A/\(B\/C) andi 2,4
6. A/\C |- A/\C prem
7. A/\C |- A ande 6
8. A/\C |- C ande 6
9. A/\C |- B\/C ori 8
10. A/\C |- A/\(B\/C) andi 7,9
11. (A/\B)\/(A/\C) |- A/\(B\/C) ore 5,10
12. A/\(B\/C),B |- B prem
13. A/\(B\/C),B |- A/\(B\/C) prem
14. A/\(B\/C),B |- A ande 13
15. A/\(B\/C),B |- A/\B andi 12,14
16. A/\(B\/C),B |- (A/\B)\/(A/\C) ori 15
17. A/\(B\/C),~B |- A/\(B\/C) prem
18. A/\(B\/C),~B |- A ande 17
19. A/\(B\/C),~B |- B\/C ande 17
20. B,~(~B/\~C) |- ~(~B/\~C) prem
21. B,~B/\~C |- ~B/\~C prem
22. B,~B/\~C |- ~B ande 21
23. B,~B/\~C |- B prem
24. B,~B/\~C |- ~(~B/\~C) ne 22,23
25. B |- ~(~B/\~C) preme 20,24
26. C,~(~B/\~C) |- ~(~B/\~C) prem
27. C,~B/\~C |- ~B/\~C prem
28. C,~B/\~C |- ~C ande 27
29. C,~B/\~C |- C prem
30. C,~B/\~C |- ~(~B/\~C) ne 28,29
31. C |- ~(~B/\~C) preme 26,30
32. B\/C |- ~(~B/\~C) ore 25,31
33. |- (B\/C)->~(~B/\~C) impli 32
34. A/\(B\/C),~B,~C |- ~B prem
35. A/\(B\/C),~B,~C |- ~C prem
36. A/\(B\/C),~B,~C |- ~B/\~C andi 34,35
37. A/\(B\/C),~B,~C |- B\/C premi 19
38. A/\(B\/C) |- (B\/C)->~(~B/\~C) premi 33
39. A/\(B\/C),~B |- (B\/C)->~(~B/\~C) premi 38
40. A/\(B\/C),~B,~C |- (B\/C)->~(~B/\~C) premi 39
41. A/\(B\/C),~B,~C |- ~(~B/\~C) imple 37,40
42. A/\(B\/C),~B |- ~~C ni 36,41
43. A/\(B\/C),~B |- C nne 42
44. A/\(B\/C),~B |- A/\C andi 43,18
45. A/\(B\/C),~B |- (A/\B)\/(A/\C) ori 44
46. A/\(B\/C) |- (A/\B)\/(A/\C) preme 45,16
47. |- A/\(B\/C)<->(A/\B)\/(A/\C) equivi 46,11
第23关
Premise:
Conclusion: A\/(B/\C)<->(A\/B)/\(A\/C)
1. A |- A prem
2. A |- A\/B ori 1
3. A |- A\/C ori 1
4. A |- (A\/B)/\(A\/C) andi 2,3
5. B/\C |- B/\C prem
6. B/\C |- B ande 5
7. B/\C |- A\/B ori 6
8. B/\C |- C ande 5
9. B/\C |- A\/C ori 8
10. B/\C |- (A\/B)/\(A\/C) andi 7,9
11. A\/(B/\C) |- (A\/B)/\(A\/C) ore 4,10
12. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),A |- A prem
13. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),A |- A\/(B/\C) ori 12
14. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A,~B |- (A\/B)/\(A\/C) prem
15. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A,~B |- A\/B ande 14
16. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A,~B |- ~(A\/B) dr
17. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A |- ~~B ni 15,16
18. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A |- B nne 17
19. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A,~C |- (A\/B)/\(A\/C) prem
20. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A,~C |- A\/C ande 19
21. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A,~C |- ~(A\/C) dr
22. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A |- ~~C ni 20,21
23. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A |- C nne 22
24. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A |- B/\C andi 23,18
25. (A\/B)/\(A\/C),~A |- A\/(B/\C) ori 24
26. (A\/B)/\(A\/C) |- A\/(B/\C) preme 13,25
27. |- A\/(B/\C)<->(A\/B)/\(A\/C) equivi 26,11
第24关
Premise:
Conclusion: A\/F<->A
1. A\/F |- A dr
2. A |- A\/F dr
3. |- A\/F<->A equivi 1,2
第25关
Premise:
Conclusion: A/\T<->A
1. A/\T |- A dr
2. A |- A/\T dr
3. |- A/\T<->A equivi 1,2
第26关
Premise:
Conclusion: (A->B)<->~A\/B
1. (A->B) |- ~A\/B dr
2. ~A\/B |- (A->B) dr
3. |- (A->B)<->~A\/B equivi 1,2
第27关
Premise: ~(A->B)
Conclusion: A
1. ~(A->B) |- A/\A dr
2. ~(A->B) |- A ande 1
第28关
Premise: ~(A->B)
Conclusion: ~B
1. ~(A->B) |- ~(~A\/B) dr
2. ~(A->B) |- A/\~B dr
3. ~(A->B) |- ~B ande 2
第29关
Premise:
Conclusion: ((Exist x)(C->P(x)))<->(C->(Exist x)P(x))
1. C->P(x),C |- C->P(x) prem
2. C->P(x),C |- C prem
3. C->P(x),C |- P(x) imple 1,2
4. C->P(x),C |- (Exist x)P(x) ei 3 (x/x)
5. C->P(x) |- C->(Exist x)P(x) impli 4
6. (Exist x)(C->P(x)) |- C->(Exist x)P(x) lei 5
7. C->(Exist x)P(x),C |- C->(Exist x)P(x) prem
8. C->(Exist x)P(x),C |- C prem
9. C->(Exist x)P(x),C |- (Exist x)P(x) imple 7,8
10. C->(Exist x)P(x),C,P(t) |- (Exist x)(C->P(x)) dr
11. C->(Exist x)P(x),C |- (Exist x)(C->P(x)) ee 9,10
12. C->(Exist x)P(x),~C |- (Exist x)(C->P(x)) dr
13. C->(Exist x)P(x) |- (Exist x)(C->P(x)) preme 11,12
14. |- ((Exist x)(C->P(x)))<->(C->(Exist x)P(x)) equivi 6,13
第30关
Premise: (Exist x)(P(x)->C)
Conclusion: (All x)P(x)->C
1. P(t)->C |- P(t)->C prem
2. P(t)->C,P(t) |- C dr
3. (All x)P(x) |- P(t)->C->C dr
5. P(t)->C |- (All x)P(x)->C dr
6. (Exist x)(P(x)->C) |- (Exist x)(P(x)->C) prem
7. (Exist x)(P(x)->C),P(t)->C |- P(t)->C prem
8. (Exist x)(P(x)->C),(P(t)->C) |- (All x)P(x)->C dr
9. (P(x)->C) |- (All x)P(x)->C dr
10. (Exist x)(P(x)->C) |- (All x)P(x)->C lei 9