附录1 标准Job-shop Benchmark问题数据集最优解（续2）

JOB SHOP

Best lower and upper bounds known, from OR-Lib (27.10.97).
Update 27.1.99 including Brinkkoetter’s optimal solutions.
Update 30. 6. 99 including Schilham’s new upper bounds
Update 4.5.0 including Henning’s new upper bounds
Update 11.7.0 including Schilham’s new lower bounds
Update 27.9.01 including Nowicki and Smutnicki new upper bounds
Update 30.8.02 including Henning new upper bounds
Update 20.10.02 including Nowicki and Smutnicki new upper bounds
Update 10.3.03 including Caldeira new upper bound
Update 23.11.05 including Zhang new upper bounds
Update 29.10.09/23.11.09 including Nasiri and Kianfar new upper bounds
Update 10.09.2011 including Beck, Feng and Watson new upper bounds
Update 31.10.2011 including Gon鏰lves & Resende new upper bounds and Gharbi & Labidi new lower bounds
Update 17.06.2013 including Yuichi Nagata and Isao Ono new upper bounds

ta01-05 1231 | 1244 | 1218 | 1175 | 1224
15 x 15 Ta1 Ta1 | VA NS | B BV | B We | B B
ta06-10 1238 | 1227 | 1217 | 1274 | 1241

15 x 15 B B	B B	B BV	B BV	VA BV
ta11-15 1323-1357	1351-1367	1282-1342	1345	1304-1339
20 x 15 S BFW	S BV	S H2	VA NS	S ZLGR
ta16-20 1304-1360	1462	1369-1396	1304-1332	1318-1348
20 x 15 GL H	S NSc	VA BV	GL BFW	S ZLGR
----------------------	-----------	-----------	-----------	----------
ta21-25 1573-1642	1542-1600	1474-1557	1606-1644	1518-1595
20 x 20 GL BFW	GL NSb	GL NSb	GL BFW	GL NSd
ta26-30 1558-1643	1617-1680	1591-1603	1525-1625	1485-1584
20 x 20 GL BFW	GL NSb	VA ZLGR	GL Aa	GL NSb
----------------------	-----------	-----------	-----------	----------
ta31-35 1764	1774-1785	1778-1791	1828-1829	2007
30 x 15 Ta1 AHLS	Ta1 GR	VA ZLGR	Ta1 NSb	VA Ta1
ta36-40 1819	1771	1673	1795	1631-1669
30 x 15 VA AHLS	Ta1 ZLGR	Ta1 H	VA AHLS	VA GR
----------------------	-----------	-----------	-----------	----------
ta41-45 1876-2005	1867-1937	1809-1848	1927-1979	1997-2000
30 x 20 GL NO	VA GR	VA NK	VA NO	VA NSb
ta46-50 1940-2004	1789-1894	1912-1943	1915-1961	1807-1924
30 x 20 Ta1 GR	VA GR	VA GR	VA NO	VA BFW
----------------------	-----------	-----------	-----------	----------
ta51-55 2760	2756	2717	2839	2679
50 x 15 Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 NS
ta56-60 2781	2943	2885	2655	2723
50 x 15 Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1
----------------------	-----------	-----------	-----------	----------
ta61-65 2868	2869	2755	2702	2725
50 x 20 Ta1 NS	VA JPC	Ta1 NS	BV NS	Ta1 NS
ta66-70 2845	2825	2784	3071	2995
50 x 20 Ta1 NS	VA AHLS	BV NS	Ta1 NS	Ta1 NS
----------------------	-----------	-----------	-----------	----------
ta71-75 5464	5181	5568	5339	5392
100 x 20 Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1
ta76-80 5342	5436	5394	5358	5183
100 x 20 Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 Ta1	Ta1 NS

Aa:
E. Aarts (1996),
Personal communication.
(a parallel taboo search algorithm)

AHLS:
E. Aarts, Huub ten Eikelder, J.K. Lenstra, R. Schilham (23.6.1999)
Personnal communication.
(An adaptive memory programme embedding a taboo search algorithm with
NS neighbourhood and constant time Ta )

B:
Wolfgang Brinkkoetter (27.1.1999),
Personal communication.
(The method combines ideas of Carlier and Pinson with an
efficient way of propagating release/queue-time adjustments
in a simulation of parallel preemptive machines.
The method is described in:
Wolfgang Brinkkoetter (1997),
Erzeugung hochwertiger Loesungen fuer das Job Shop Scheduling Problem
mit Schwerpunkt auf dem Qualitaetsnachweis,
University of Paderborn, Paderborn, Germany).
c.f. also:
W. Brinkkoetter, P. Brucker
Solving open benchmarks problems for the job shop problem,
(1999)

BFW:
J. Christopher Beck, T. K. Feng, Jean-Paul Watson
Combining Constraint Programming and Local Search for Job-Shop Scheduling
INFORMS Journal on Computing 23(1): 1-14 (2011)

BV:
E. Balas, A. Vazacopoulos (1995),
Guided local search with shifting bottleneck for job shop scheduling,
Management Science Research Report #MSRR-609® [revised version],
Graduate School of Industrial Administration, Carnegie-Mellon University,
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.

BV’:
E. Balas, A. Vazacopoulos (1996),
Personal communication.

GL:
A. Gharbi, L. Labidi (6.6.2011)
Personal communication. Results obtained with method desribed in:
Anis Gharbi, Mohamed Labidi (2010),
“Extending the single machine-based relaxation scheme for the job shop scheduling problem”,
Electronic Notes in Discrete Mathematics, Volume 36, pp. 1057?064.

GR:
JOS?FERNANDO GON茿LVES AND MAURICIO G. C. RESENDE (2011)
A BIASED RANDOM-KEY GENETIC ALGORITHM FOR JOB-SHOP SCHEDULING
AT&T Labs Research Techhnical Report.

H:
Andre Henning (2000)
Private communication (5.4.0)
(Interactive method including various local searches and parameters)

H2:
Andr?Henning (2002)
Practical job shop scheduling problems (in german)(to be submitted)
Department of Mathematics and Computer Science
Friedrich-Schiller-University Jena
07740 Jena, Germany

JPC: Jo鉶 Paulo Caldeira (2003)
Private communication, 30.1.2003
Private communication, 10.3.2003
(hybrid evolutionary-tabu algorithm)

NK:
Nasiri and Kianfar (2009)
A pseudo杙ath relinking algorithm for the job shop problem
Private communications, 28.20.2009/23.11.2009

NO:
Yuichi Nagata and Isao Ono (2013)
Guided Constructive Local Search for the Job Shop Scheduling Problem
Technical report submitted for publication
27.02.2013

NS:
E. Nowicki, C. Smutnicki (1993),
A fast taboo search algorithm for the job shop problem,
Preprinty nr 8/93,
Institute of Engineering Cybernetics, Technical University of Wroclaw,
Wroclaw, Poland.

NSb:
E.Nowicki, C.Smutnicki, (2001)
New Ideas in TS for Job Shop Scheduling
Preprinty nr 50/2001
Institute of Engineering Cybernetics, Technical University of Wroclaw,
Wroclaw, Poland.
(A method that combines path relinking with NS’s fast taboo search)

NSc: Same method as NSb, Personal communication (7.5.2002)

NSd:
E.Nowicki, C.Smutnicki, (2002)
“Some New Tools to Solve the Job Shop Problem”
Technical Report 60/2002, Institute of Engineering Cybernetics, Technical University of Wroclaw,
Wroclaw, Poland.

S: R. Schilham (11.7.2000)
Personnal communication. (see below)

Ta1:
E. D. Taillard, (1994)
Parallel taboo search techniques for the job shop scheduling problem,
ORSA Journal on Computing 6, 108 ?117.
Results also reported in:
E. D. Taillard (1993),
Benchmarks for basic scheduling problems,
EJOR 64, 278-285.

VA:
R.J.M. Vaessens (1995),
Personal communication.
(lower bounds found using Applegate & Cook’s algorithm `edge-finder’)

VAAa:
R.J.M. Vaessens (1996),
Personal communication.
(upper bounds found using Applegate & Cook’s algorithm `shuffle’ with
initial solutions of B. Aarts (1996))

VABV:
R.J.M. Vaessens (1996),
Personal communication.
(upper bounds found using Applegate & Cook’s algorithm `shuffle’ with
initial solutions of E. Balas and A. Vazacopoulos (1995))

VAWe:
R.J.M. Vaessens (1995),
Personal communication.
(upper bounds found using Applegate & Cook’s algorithm `shuffle’ with
initial solutions of M. Wennink (1995))

We:
M. Wennink (1995),
Personal communication.
(upper bounds found by a taboo search algorithm)

WHW
Jean-Paul Watson, Adele E. Howeb and L. Darrell Whitley
Deconstructing Nowicki and Smutnicki’s i-TSAB tabu search algorithm for the job-shop scheduling problem
Volume 33, Issue 9, September 2006, Pages 2623-2644

ZLGR:
ChaoYong Zhang, PeiGen Li, ZaiLin Guan, YunQing Rao (2005)
A Tabu Search Algorithm with a New Neighborhood Structure for the Job Shop Scheduling Problem
and
A Very Fast TS/SA Algorithm for the Job Shop Scheduling Problem
School of Mechanical Science & Engineering, Huazhong University of Science & Technology,
Wuhan, 430074, P.R. China

NK - Nasiri and Kianfar, private communication, 28.20.2009
Tai_20_15_1
1358
13 8 2 11 7 6 12 14 3 17 5 10 15 1 9 4 20 19 16 18
8 10 7 4 11 5 6 14 12 13 2 9 1 19 15 17 20 16 3 18
12 7 8 18 3 5 19 9 16 4 13 6 11 1 14 2 15 17 20 10
11 15 6 12 4 14 17 1 2 19 13 10 8 3 18 7 9 5 16 20
9 8 10 4 14 12 2 13 16 11 5 7 1 3 19 17 20 15 18 6
16 9 20 2 12 15 6 8 5 4 14 3 7 19 17 11 10 1 18 13
12 20 16 15 9 6 13 7 18 11 5 8 14 2 19 10 17 1 4 3
12 13 8 9 17 7 6 11 4 2 1 3 15 18 14 10 16 5 19 20
4 5 18 12 13 7 16 2 11 6 17 8 19 10 3 9 20 14 15 1
9 20 14 11 13 5 4 12 16 15 3 18 8 7 6 2 19 17 1 10
18 7 11 4 20 9 6 13 5 17 10 12 14 1 2 3 8 15 19 16
20 18 1 8 6 16 13 4 12 17 10 7 5 11 3 19 2 9 14 15
14 7 13 16 19 5 8 2 9 3 11 6 15 1 17 12 10 20 18 4
4 8 20 18 15 19 7 6 12 13 5 10 9 17 16 14 2 11 3 1
5 20 16 13 15 12 4 1 7 11 18 3 17 2 10 8 19 6 14 9

Tai30_20_1
2010
10 22 28 6 9 24 11 12 4 17 2 20 14 25 19 18 16 29 3 26 23 30 7 21 1 27 15 5 13 8
6 11 23 26 19 15 27 2 10 13 18 30 14 16 17 5 9 12 22 3 25 7 21 8 20 24 4 28 1 29
7 10 2 21 5 27 13 6 12 3 9 22 17 30 14 18 16 8 23 19 25 1 26 24 28 20 4 29 15 11
7 9 10 18 14 22 16 2 30 19 12 13 1 4 8 29 5 3 21 24 6 28 15 20 26 27 17 25 11 23
16 15 23 11 2 14 20 13 8 6 10 5 29 27 17 3 4 19 30 1 9 12 22 25 24 21 26 28 7 18
1 12 23 13 24 3 2 18 6 16 17 27 19 15 10 5 22 20 30 26 4 25 14 21 28 9 7 8 29 11
12 5 25 18 23 21 22 2 20 30 13 10 6 19 1 15 9 4 29 16 3 26 8 11 17 14 24 28 27 7
22 21 9 20 18 2 27 12 23 6 19 17 4 26 5 25 30 3 1 8 15 29 10 13 24 28 14 7 11 16
5 3 20 15 4 10 28 2 14 16 23 6 12 22 17 29 8 7 27 1 25 11 21 26 30 18 19 13 9 24
19 16 18 12 10 23 2 14 27 15 28 29 30 5 20 22 26 1 7 24 25 21 8 11 4 13 6 17 9 3
9 23 6 14 17 12 26 27 8 11 15 19 7 10 22 13 2 25 1 24 20 5 16 28 4 3 29 18 21 30
25 19 13 29 15 27 23 5 4 24 12 16 17 9 14 30 8 20 3 11 22 28 6 7 1 18 26 21 2 10
8 22 2 23 26 10 6 17 5 12 28 21 7 14 18 1 16 20 13 15 30 3 24 25 9 29 11 27 19 4
2 6 26 18 13 4 20 5 17 19 1 23 10 12 7 27 22 15 8 11 29 28 24 9 16 25 14 30 3 21
9 15 24 27 25 13 2 17 18 29 16 3 4 21 12 23 6 1 8 11 7 19 20 26 30 14 5 22 10 28
2 15 13 16 5 27 18 7 6 1 10 11 14 28 24 22 17 19 29 8 20 30 3 23 4 25 12 9 21 26
30 22 7 21 5 25 18 27 10 16 6 19 15 17 20 29 28 9 12 11 3 26 1 14 8 13 2 23 24 4
21 20 17 19 18 9 7 16 14 8 6 15 3 25 28 5 23 12 2 10 22 24 26 1 11 13 4 29 27 30
26 23 16 29 25 28 17 3 6 18 30 22 2 20 15 14 4 19 9 7 21 13 8 24 27 5 12 11 1 10
18 13 16 27 17 9 22 6 2 14 10 5 1 12 7 28 8 24 15 11 4 25 20 23 19 21 3 30 29 26

Tai30_20_2
1945
13 9 25 15 22 5 19 8 16 27 12 1 14 21 20 11 29 26 18 17 3 23 28 10 6 30 24 4 2 7
15 5 10 2 21 24 4 22 8 7 27 29 3 19 28 17 1 25 12 14 6 18 20 30 26 13 16 9 23 11
13 16 2 18 7 4 15 5 14 26 25 9 21 22 24 6 29 8 12 27 28 1 11 19 17 3 10 20 23 30
25 5 26 7 1 2 29 16 10 15 12 17 28 11 14 6 30 21 27 22 19 18 23 9 4 20 3 24 8 13
1 7 29 26 14 25 24 23 17 16 19 9 6 20 22 12 8 4 11 13 10 27 21 18 15 3 28 2 30 5
12 13 1 29 25 21 11 26 30 27 9 17 14 6 24 28 22 2 3 10 19 23 8 16 15 18 7 4 5 20
2 12 26 18 23 15 10 25 1 17 8 24 29 19 5 14 6 22 11 7 3 30 21 27 4 16 13 20 28 9
23 4 5 26 17 9 7 8 21 19 15 2 11 13 22 18 20 29 27 1 16 25 30 14 12 6 10 24 3 28
21 26 29 17 14 1 3 30 22 25 20 6 11 19 7 27 28 4 18 23 10 16 15 12 13 8 9 24 5 2
24 10 12 16 9 15 25 13 26 29 17 6 19 21 20 22 4 30 7 3 28 27 1 11 23 5 2 14 8 18
5 14 1 25 11 8 22 27 2 15 19 10 3 20 7 29 26 17 13 12 23 18 24 21 28 9 30 16 6 4
29 10 19 30 2 21 25 24 17 11 27 1 26 20 9 5 8 22 7 13 6 14 16 12 28 15 18 4 3 23
25 14 1 10 2 12 17 16 24 27 5 29 21 30 6 20 22 8 7 28 9 3 19 15 23 18 11 26 13 4
26 7 18 2 22 29 11 14 17 28 27 10 16 25 3 1 15 5 30 19 9 21 20 6 4 12 24 23 13 8
25 11 16 30 18 2 12 22 24 29 23 15 10 3 28 19 9 1 17 4 7 14 8 13 26 6 27 20 5 21
19 7 3 15 25 22 1 12 14 28 23 21 8 24 30 16 17 2 4 13 29 27 10 5 11 18 9 6 20 26
30 15 22 10 28 16 21 24 3 8 14 5 7 11 4 26 1 2 20 18 25 12 23 6 27 19 17 29 13 9
7 9 17 3 5 15 12 20 14 24 8 21 29 22 23 4 30 16 25 1 2 28 6 27 13 10 26 19 18 11
12 11 13 29 17 5 8 15 22 18 26 25 2 9 19 6 1 30 20 16 10 14 4 3 7 28 24 23 27 21
11 19 7 15 13 17 21 28 26 1 14 30 2 22 16 12 29 27 23 6 10 20 9 18 3 4 5 8 25 24

Tai30_20_6
2014
30 7 15 19 14 12 18 20 13 29 9 24 23 22 28 6 16 2 25 17 5 8 21 10 1 26 11 4 27 3
11 15 23 16 26 28 5 19 4 12 1 27 13 8 24 7 18 14 25 2 22 6 3 29 10 20 21 30 17 9
14 12 18 5 22 27 20 17 11 15 25 4 28 16 13 30 7 29 19 24 10 23 9 26 21 8 1 2 3 6
5 20 16 18 8 13 30 19 27 10 4 12 24 14 15 28 21 6 9 3 2 17 23 1 11 25 7 29 26 22
19 23 18 14 16 30 8 12 26 22 5 7 27 15 4 24 9 10 25 17 21 11 28 29 13 2 3 1 6 20
18 15 7 16 19 8 13 9 29 12 20 24 10 2 23 5 25 30 22 17 11 14 21 3 1 26 27 4 6 28
13 14 29 24 19 26 20 6 11 28 7 8 15 27 25 2 9 23 17 12 3 10 30 18 5 16 4 22 1 21
30 15 12 19 1 18 6 26 16 22 14 11 8 7 20 29 17 5 10 24 3 21 28 2 9 13 27 25 23 4
30 19 7 5 26 15 27 9 13 12 18 23 2 28 10 25 20 6 29 14 1 24 16 22 8 21 3 4 11 17
15 19 7 26 25 10 22 4 6 13 30 20 8 18 29 24 28 9 12 14 27 3 16 5 17 11 23 1 2 21
7 2 16 1 18 5 20 11 9 14 26 15 24 4 12 23 8 19 3 29 28 6 17 21 10 30 22 27 13 25
12 16 6 15 24 13 1 25 18 4 9 2 11 8 30 27 5 19 17 28 22 21 23 26 3 14 7 10 20 29
23 1 14 9 8 7 19 15 10 26 13 17 20 18 28 30 5 11 12 25 27 6 4 21 3 22 29 24 16 2
24 19 21 4 25 16 13 7 29 8 28 20 6 26 10 15 11 30 17 12 9 5 22 2 27 18 23 3 1 14
16 29 25 20 1 12 8 18 4 13 27 11 23 7 6 15 17 24 19 30 9 3 21 10 2 26 5 14 22 28
7 3 18 1 12 10 27 8 11 16 21 19 15 5 6 23 2 25 30 28 24 17 22 14 9 13 26 29 20 4
20 14 21 26 29 24 19 18 2 8 10 15 12 6 11 9 17 5 27 3 23 22 28 7 16 4 25 30 13 1
29 21 12 14 19 22 28 1 24 18 11 7 9 25 16 26 27 17 8 10 23 30 2 5 3 4 6 20 13 15
23 26 11 7 29 4 6 30 8 15 13 22 24 10 14 19 25 16 12 20 1 2 27 3 28 17 21 18 5 9
30 12 1 6 8 7 11 28 27 9 18 23 15 4 24 13 29 19 10 3 2 22 17 16 20 25 14 26 5 21

Tai30_20_7
1899
16 12 20 9 24 27 26 2 29 25 5 15 3 8 19 17 21 13 14 30 4 1 22 11 10 28 7 18 6 23
17 18 8 29 9 19 15 24 16 27 2 4 3 26 1 7 5 28 11 30 13 14 23 12 20 21 10 25 22 6
4 21 7 29 28 9 24 19 5 3 23 10 17 27 22 2 13 15 1 12 20 25 6 26 30 11 18 8 14 16
13 18 29 16 14 12 25 3 30 19 5 10 9 8 27 11 17 2 26 6 15 21 23 22 1 7 4 28 24 20
28 15 13 16 24 7 2 19 27 9 5 8 22 12 26 4 29 21 6 3 17 14 25 18 23 11 10 1 30 20
14 6 29 25 8 23 13 20 17 19 12 2 24 7 4 27 26 30 16 9 10 3 21 22 18 5 1 15 28 11
29 25 4 8 10 14 13 6 22 9 7 5 19 21 2 11 30 18 24 20 1 26 23 17 28 16 3 12 15 27
15 8 13 19 1 18 28 21 11 16 25 17 7 14 12 24 22 30 5 27 6 20 10 3 4 2 23 26 9 29
5 22 7 15 19 2 13 16 24 27 8 14 6 25 10 18 1 12 29 9 4 17 28 21 23 3 26 20 30 11
22 26 20 21 19 7 29 16 6 13 5 3 4 11 8 18 25 28 30 10 15 9 23 17 14 27 12 2 24 1
30 19 15 3 5 25 24 14 16 6 12 11 8 17 10 29 2 13 1 28 26 23 4 18 20 22 7 21 9 27
19 1 17 15 12 16 11 25 30 3 26 10 4 2 7 5 8 20 29 9 6 13 27 28 23 21 22 24 14 18
11 14 9 18 19 15 8 4 29 1 13 3 17 2 5 6 26 30 21 27 20 22 16 10 25 24 28 7 23 12
21 20 15 28 10 16 6 14 4 13 3 24 19 2 29 12 7 8 18 5 17 1 23 26 22 30 27 25 9 11
21 14 16 3 4 29 9 26 8 20 10 24 22 5 11 6 13 30 7 12 27 1 15 2 18 23 17 28 19 25
4 19 16 18 28 13 15 12 20 29 8 21 27 14 6 25 5 24 2 22 10 30 11 1 23 26 3 17 9 7
22 8 21 15 1 5 27 10 6 9 16 23 4 19 29 18 24 3 28 2 20 17 25 14 12 30 7 13 26 11
5 22 16 27 28 10 29 4 17 30 2 11 13 19 14 20 15 9 21 8 26 24 25 12 6 3 7 1 18 23
26 11 29 12 15 27 17 10 24 21 8 22 3 14 13 4 19 16 1 2 30 6 7 5 28 18 23 25 20 9
17 3 1 7 4 19 5 21 29 2 10 15 6 22 23 9 24 26 11 27 12 18 8 13 25 30 20 16 14 28

NK - Nasiri and Kianfar, private communication, 23.11.2009
tai30_15_2
1790
1 19 13 11 23 4 12 17 7 28 5 14 2 25 29 20 27 6 18 30 9 8 10 24 21 15 26 3 16 22
16 24 5 4 11 26 18 7 19 8 3 1 21 27 15 12 28 2 17 30 10 25 23 29 13 22 20 14 6 9
27 16 25 1 7 15 17 5 28 12 29 13 8 4 14 22 18 23 19 11 24 3 20 2 30 10 9 6 21 26
19 15 7 27 5 8 28 12 21 2 10 29 4 3 18 30 25 6 26 9 13 11 22 20 24 14 1 23 16 17
28 10 20 6 7 4 19 29 1 8 15 5 12 16 17 13 14 2 27 3 26 23 25 11 22 9 30 21 18 24
19 20 7 14 5 10 16 11 6 8 15 17 29 1 27 25 12 4 3 30 22 13 9 23 24 26 28 18 21 2
10 23 16 30 20 19 15 1 17 11 22 28 9 5 4 14 8 18 21 29 3 26 2 25 6 24 12 27 13 7
8 5 16 23 20 19 2 4 14 7 15 30 27 26 13 28 24 11 17 10 29 12 22 6 18 9 3 25 21 1
23 7 14 18 1 5 22 26 16 28 17 30 27 13 2 4 29 20 25 24 19 10 9 15 21 8 3 6 11 12
15 18 7 29 19 8 16 24 13 28 14 23 22 17 20 1 25 21 10 5 6 11 12 4 2 9 30 27 3 26
20 21 1 19 15 14 27 16 3 9 8 12 18 17 23 5 26 6 30 2 4 29 22 25 28 11 24 10 13 7
23 6 20 13 30 17 11 15 7 16 12 1 21 28 3 5 4 27 18 10 14 2 8 19 29 25 26 22 9 24
19 12 3 7 4 1 29 22 5 27 13 24 11 8 2 14 10 23 15 21 20 9 30 25 28 6 26 17 18 16
1 4 19 17 12 14 27 11 7 22 5 25 23 3 2 13 21 30 29 9 8 10 24 28 15 26 6 18 20 16
28 4 8 27 22 7 6 14 19 3 21 1 9 16 26 30 2 10 5 23 12 25 15 13 24 29 17 18 11 20

tai30_15_10
1673
26 23 19 20 22 7 28 12 30 13 18 9 11 3 29 17 27 4 24 25 6 21 10 15 16 5 14 1 2 8
10 24 18 22 16 20 21 1 4 12 28 14 6 29 25 2 11 19 23 15 8 9 30 7 27 5 3 26 13 17
7 17 18 28 9 12 6 29 13 27 30 3 19 23 11 5 10 2 20 22 16 8 24 1 14 15 25 26 4 21
14 25 7 19 29 26 28 21 30 18 11 13 12 16 17 3 1 27 15 22 23 4 9 20 24 10 6 8 5 2
11 27 6 25 18 14 22 21 30 2 24 16 23 17 1 28 19 13 7 9 10 29 20 5 8 4 3 12 15 26
25 12 30 24 5 8 1 17 23 28 6 11 14 16 4 7 27 15 20 21 2 9 13 19 29 3 18 22 10 26
10 11 17 13 8 7 23 29 1 26 9 16 15 3 6 12 14 27 28 24 30 20 21 19 18 2 5 4 25 22
19 11 24 27 10 14 12 21 5 22 7 17 16 28 9 18 25 23 30 1 4 29 13 8 3 26 2 15 6 20
27 25 2 8 21 23 19 11 29 14 5 24 6 18 28 9 17 16 30 4 3 12 20 7 22 10 26 15 1 13
3 12 18 21 23 25 1 29 11 9 30 2 28 22 8 20 6 5 27 24 14 10 7 13 26 15 17 4 16 19
16 22 30 21 29 5 10 14 9 11 13 6 17 12 15 3 25 23 19 24 8 2 1 20 26 27 18 28 4 7
2 21 6 23 30 11 1 18 29 20 16 7 27 28 13 24 15 3 12 4 10 22 14 5 25 9 8 17 19 26
21 28 24 14 13 4 5 12 6 26 25 18 27 11 30 23 2 7 3 15 22 1 20 19 17 16 29 9 8 10
9 18 16 12 21 11 24 29 25 22 28 17 27 4 3 23 30 1 15 20 7 19 5 10 2 14 6 13 26 8
18 8 27 26 21 10 6 22 12 23 7 28 17 20 11 16 4 5 9 3 13 24 30 14 1 15 29 19 2 25

tai30_20_1
2006
10 22 28 6 9 24 11 12 4 17 2 20 25 14 18 19 16 29 3 26 23 30 7 21 1 27 15 5 13 8
6 11 23 26 19 15 27 2 18 13 10 30 16 14 17 5 22 12 9 3 25 21 7 8 1 24 4 28 20 29
7 10 2 21 5 27 13 6 12 9 3 17 22 30 18 14 16 8 25 23 1 26 28 24 20 4 19 29 15 11
7 9 10 18 14 22 16 2 30 19 12 13 8 1 4 29 5 3 21 6 24 28 15 20 26 27 25 17 11 23
16 15 23 11 2 14 20 13 8 6 5 10 29 27 17 3 30 4 1 9 22 12 25 21 24 19 26 28 7 18
12 23 13 1 24 3 2 18 6 16 17 27 19 15 5 22 20 30 26 10 4 25 14 21 28 7 9 8 29 11
12 5 25 18 23 21 22 2 20 30 13 10 6 19 1 15 9 29 4 16 3 26 8 11 14 24 17 28 27 7
22 21 9 20 18 2 27 12 23 6 19 17 4 26 5 25 30 3 1 8 15 29 10 13 24 28 7 14 11 16
5 3 20 15 4 10 28 2 14 16 23 6 12 22 17 29 7 8 1 27 25 11 21 26 30 18 13 19 9 24
19 16 18