websocket传输速率_使用MySQL数据库更改发送WebSocket更新的效率更高

I'm currently experimenting with WebSockets in a bid to reduce / remove the need for constant AJAX requests in a potentially low bandwidth environment. All devices are WebSocket compliant so there's no issue there, and I'm trying to keep it to native PHP WebSockets, no node.js or other frameworks / libraries (Which so far has been fine).

What I'm looking to do is to decide how to go about notifying connected clients about an update to a database by another Client. The use case in question is a person pressing a button on their device, which then alerts that persons manager(s) to that press. So the two options I have though of are as follows:

1. Looping a Database Query (PHP)

My first thought was to insert a query into the WebSocket server that is effectively saying "Has the alert field changed? If so, notify the manager(s)". Whilst this is the most straightforward and sensible approach (That I can think of), it seems wasteful to have a PHP script designed to reduce strain on the server, that is now running a query every second, however, at least this would ensure that when a Database update is detected, the update is sent.

2. Sending a notification from the Client

Another thought I had, was that when the client updates the Database, they could in fact send a WebSocket notification themself. This has the advantage of reducing any intensive and looped queries, but also means that I'd need to have a WebSocket message being sent every time I want to change any data, such as:

$.post("AttemptDatabaseUpdate.php", {Data}).function(Result) // Don't worry about the semantics of this, it's not actual code

{

if(Result == "Successful")

{

SendWebSocketNotification(OtherData);

}

}

Maybe this is the best option, as it is the most efficient, but I worry that there is a chance the connection may drop between updating the Database, and sending the WebSocket notification, which may create a need for a fallback check in the PHP file, much like the one in the first solution, albeit at a longer interval (Say every 30 seconds).

3. MySQL Trigger?

This is purely a guess, but perhaps another option is to create a MySQL trigger, which can somehow notify the server.php file directly? I've no idea how this would work, and would hazard a guess that this may end up with the same or similar Query requirements as solution #1, but it's just a though...

Thank you in advance for your help :)

EDIT: Solution possibility 4

Another thought has just popped into my head in fact, whereby the PHP file used to update the database could in fact have a WebSocket message built into it. So that when the PHP file updates the database, the WebSocket server is notified via PHP, is this possible?

解决方案

If you use websockets, you should use notifications from client. That's one of their main use cases.

If you're worried about inconsistencies due to connection dropping or something changing in-between, you could implement a system similar to HTTP ETags, where client would send a hash code that you can respond on server side if there is a conflict in updating.

Update: I guess I understood your initial issue a bit wrong. If I understand your use case correctly: you are sending database updates from a client and after that all connected clients need to be updated. In that case, I think server should send the update messages after DB updates have been done, so I agree with solution 4. I am assuming here that your websocket server is the same server running PHP and doing the DB updates.

However, depending on your use case, client should still send a hash value on the next request identifying its "view of the world", so you would not be doing identical updates multiple times if a connection gets broken.

Update 2: so it was now understood that you indeed use a separate, standalone websocket server. Basically you have two different web servers on the server side and are having an issue on how to communicate between the two. This is a real issue, and I'd recommend only using one server at a time - either take a look at using Apache websocket support (experimental and not really recommended) or migrating your php scripts to the websocket instance.

Neither PHP or Apache was really build with websockets in mind. It is quite easy to set up a standalone websocket server using only PHP, but it might not be so easy then to migrate the rest of the PHP stack to it if the code is relying on Apache/web server on. Apache websocket support also is hardly optimal. For a real websocket solution, unfortunately, best practice would be using a technology that is built for it from the ground up.