十万种考研考证电子书、
题库视频学习平台
圣才电子书
www.100xuexi.com
◆非此即彼逻辑错误
Argument
72
增加长期通勤乘客使用公家车频率的方法
The
following
appeared
in
the
editorial
section
of
a
local
newspaper.
“Commuter
use
of
the
new
subway
train
is
exceeding
the
transit
company’s
projections.
However,
commuter
use
of
the
shuttle
buses
that
transport
people
to
the
subway
stations
is
below
the
projected
volume.
If
the
transit
company
expects
commuters
to
ride
the
shuttle
buses
to
the
subway
rather
than
drive
there,
it
must
either
reduce
the
shuttle
bus
fares
or
increase
the
price
of
parking
at
the
subway
stations.”
Discuss
how
well
reasoned
you
find
this
argument.
In
your
discussion
be
sure
to
analyze
the
line
of
reasoning
and
the
use
of
evidence
in
the
argument.
For
example,
you
may
need
to
consider
what
questionable
assumptions
underlie
the
thinking
and
what
alternative
explanations
or
counterexamples
might
weaken
the
conclusion.
You
can
also
discuss
what
sort
of
evidence
would
strengthen
or
refute
the
argument,
what
changes
in
the
argument
would
make
it
more
logically
sound,
and
what,
if
anything,
would
help
you
better
evaluate
its
conclusion.
【参考范文】
The
author
concludes
that
the
local
transit
company
must
either
reduce
fares
for
the
shuttle
buses
that
transport
people
to
their
subway
stations
or
increase
parking
fees
at
the
stations.
The
reasons
offered
to
support
this
conclusion
are
that