本文制作了一个生成对抗网络GAN网络,并通过调节权重的初始化方法来观察权重对网络性能的影响。
生成网络的结构是784*300*784,对抗网络的结构是784*300*1.生成网络的输入是一个28*28的二维数组,
double []z=new double[28*28];
for(int n=0 ;n<28;n++){
for(int m=0 ;m<28;m++){
z[n*28+m]=((double)(n+1)*(m+1)/100);
}}
样本是mnist数据集的9的前5000张图片,也就是说
logD(x)=logD(mnist9)
log(1-D(G(z)))=log(1-D(G(z)))
比如将这个网络简写成呢个
gan( z, mnist 9(784*300*784) )-784*300*1-p
具体进样顺序 | |
n=4999 | m=1 |
for n do | |
for m do | |
z |
|
mnist 9-n | |
计算 (logD(x)+log(1-D(G(z))) )/m ,和(log(1-D(G(z))) )/m | |
end for | |
每隔100张记录下网络的输出值,每隔500张生成一张图片 | |
梯度下降 | |
end for |
权重的初始化方法
Random rand1 =new Random();
int ti1=rand1.nextInt(98)+1;
ti1=1;
int xx=1;
if(ti1%2==0){
xx=-1;}
w[a][b]=xx*((double)ti1/wx);
本文就是通过调整wx的值观察网路的性能,本文一共尝试了包括270,280,300,400,500,600,700,800,900,1000,2000,3000,4000,5000,10000,20000,50000,10w,50w,100w,共20个值。
分别统计了当n=4999时的网络的D(x)和D(G(z))值
D(x)表格
D(x) | ||||||||||||||||||||
100w | 50w | 10w | 5w | 20000 | 10000 | 5000 | 4000 | 3000 | 2000 | 1000 | 900 | 800 | 700 | 600 | 500 | 400 | 300 | 280 | 270 | |
red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | red[0] | |
100 | 0.42332 | 0.423304 | 0.423172 | 0.423008 | 0.422517 | 0.421705 | 0.420103 | 0.419314 | 0.418016 | 0.415502 | 0.409576 | 0.409081 | 0.40948 | 0.413039 | 0.429066 | 0.472792 | 0.301123 | 0.273265 | 0.263532 | 0.283752 |
200 | 0.41651 | 0.416487 | 0.41631 | 0.416089 | 0.415423 | 0.414311 | 0.412074 | 0.410948 | 0.40906 | 0.405247 | 0.394108 | 0.391871 | 0.389247 | 0.385864 | 0.37756 | 0.405426 | 0.302072 | 0.538325 | 0.535189 | 0.544812 |
300 | 0.416064 | 0.416048 | 0.41592 | 0.41576 | 0.415282 | 0.414491 | 0.412933 | 0.412164 | 0.410899 | 0.408445 | 0.402723 | 0.402146 | 0.401846 | 0.400838 | 0.382686 | 0.473559 | 0.314931 | 0.305442 | 0.511287 | 0.496561 |
400 | 0.407169 | 0.407146 | 0.406962 | 0.406732 | 0.40604 | 0.404883 | 0.402554 | 0.401382 | 0.39942 | 0.395499 | 0.385833 | 0.385135 | 0.386305 | 0.39389 | 0.415384 | 0.435926 | 0.312878 | 0.289498 | 0.290688 | 0.292386 |
500 | 0.403415 | 0.403403 | 0.403311 | 0.403196 | 0.402853 | 0.402292 | 0.401204 | 0.400676 | 0.399824 | 0.39825 | 0.395397 | 0.395657 | 0.397711 | 0.406133 | 0.426644 | 0.446426 | 0.460958 | 0.497144 | 0.509821 | 0.515502 |
600 | 0.402458 | 0.402441 | 0.402306 | 0.402138 | 0.401631 | 0.400787 | 0.399092 | 0.398239 | 0.396807 | 0.393883 | 0.382105 | 0.377689 | 0.37053 | 0.358989 | 0.344414 | 0.333786 | 0.3257 | 0.469694 | 0.489312 | 0.493531 |
700 | 0.399725 | 0.399712 | 0.399609 | 0.399479 | 0.399085 | 0.39841 | 0.396972 | 0.3962 | 0.394815 | 0.391567 | 0.374569 | 0.368697 | 0.360487 | 0.34991 | 0.338939 | 0.332785 | 0.328749 | 0.395198 | 0.4207 | 0.432533 |
800 | 0.383543 | 0.383514 | 0.383281 | 0.38299 | 0.382112 | 0.380629 | 0.377611 | 0.376088 | 0.373565 | 0.368784 | 0.361099 | 0.361747 | 0.363926 | 0.367491 | 0.368457 | 0.369652 | 0.374919 | 0.389076 | 0.39488 | 0.395938 |
900 | 0.380004 | 0.37998 | 0.379786 | 0.379543 | 0.378812 | 0.377592 | 0.375187 | 0.374038 | 0.372274 | 0.369693 | 0.373111 | 0.375681 | 0.379161 | 0.383424 | 0.387678 | 0.386902 | 0.381842 | 0.380088 | 0.380335 | 0.381278 |
1000 | 0.370074 | 0.370039 | 0.369756 | 0.369399 | 0.368311 | 0.366444 | 0.362541 | 0.360533 | 0.357153 | 0.350459 | 0.331843 | 0.327815 | 0.322749 | 0.316556 | 0.309889 | 0.305734 | 0.303392 | 0.298054 | 0.296555 | 0.295893 |
1100 | 0.379493 | 0.379471 | 0.379293 | 0.37907 | 0.3784 | 0.377285 | 0.375124 | 0.37411 | 0.372559 | 0.370062 | 0.365579 | 0.364484 | 0.362848 | 0.360534 | 0.357891 | 0.357083 | 0.357157 | 0.356423 | 0.356133 | 0.355772 |
1200 | 0.361382 | 0.361342 | 0.361023 | 0.36062 | 0.359393 | 0.357296 | 0.353007 | 0.350863 | 0.347352 | 0.340713 | 0.324346 | 0.321463 | 0.318333 | 0.315186 | 0.312427 | 0.312108 | 0.313253 | 0.311726 | 0.311668 | 0.311501 |
1300 | 0.356825 | 0.356791 | 0.356523 | 0.356188 | 0.355184 | 0.353526 | 0.350351 | 0.348861 | 0.346539 | 0.342467 | 0.333439 | 0.331899 | 0.330216 | 0.328506 | 0.327046 | 0.326882 | 0.326959 | 0.32666 | 0.32698 | 0.326661 |
1400 | 0.355961 | 0.355938 | 0.355753 | 0.355523 | 0.354848 | 0.353777 | 0.351876 | 0.351049 | 0.349845 | 0.347983 | 0.344716 | 0.344134 | 0.343353 | 0.34217 | 0.340232 | 0.336311 | 0.331284 | 0.327824 | 0.327747 | 0.32779 |
1500 | 0.348964 | 0.348938 | 0.348733 | 0.348481 | 0.347756 | 0.346654 | 0.34482 | 0.344069 | 0.343019 | 0.341507 | 0.339407 | 0.339162 | 0.338881 | 0.33849 | 0.337767 | 0.336259 | 0.334005 | 0.333555 | 0.334358 | 0.333849 |
1600 | 0.338164 | 0.338131 | 0.337869 | 0.337548 | 0.336622 | 0.335205 | 0.332803 | 0.331791 | 0.330337 | 0.328115 | 0.324467 | 0.323963 | 0.323398 | 0.322721 | 0.321825 | 0.320396 | 0.319002 | 0.317424 | 0.317137 | 0.317288 |
1700 | 0.350118 | 0.350101 | 0.349963 | 0.349795 | 0.349313 | 0.348584 | 0.347366 | 0.346858 | 0.346136 | 0.345043 | 0.343263 | 0.343009 | 0.342717 | 0.342351 | 0.341811 | 0.340583 | 0.339225 | 0.337401 | 0.336932 | 0.337118 |
1800 | 0.376305 | 0.376297 | 0.376232 | 0.376152 | 0.375924 | 0.375578 | 0.375013 | 0.374791 | 0.374498 | 0.374152 | 0.37395 | 0.37389 | 0.373719 | 0.373273 | 0.37229 | 0.36925 | 0.364011 | 0.362036 | 0.361916 | 0.361729 |
1900 | 0.329043 | 0.329026 | 0.32889 | 0.328724 | 0.32826 | 0.327579 | 0.326486 | 0.326041 | 0.325407 | 0.324422 | 0.322662 | 0.322452 | 0.322303 | 0.322337 | 0.322804 | 0.324652 | 0.328424 | 0.330203 | 0.330144 | 0.33051 |
2000 | 0.376939 | 0.376941 | 0.376956 | 0.376976 | 0.377046 | 0.377185 | 0.377511 | 0.377682 | 0.377965 | 0.378478 | 0.379539 | 0.379723 | 0.379964 | 0.380343 | 0.381094 | 0.383014 | 0.385746 | 0.388051 | 0.388498 | 0.388578 |
2100 | 0.262365 | 0.262341 | 0.262149 | 0.261913 | 0.26124 | 0.260217 | 0.258487 | 0.257753 | 0.256685 | 0.255005 | 0.252069 | 0.251662 | 0.251226 | 0.250746 | 0.250101 | 0.24917 | 0.248024 | 0.24643 | 0.246148 | 0.246005 |
2200 | 0.337182 | 0.337174 | 0.337113 | 0.337039 | 0.336827 | 0.336506 | 0.33597 | 0.335747 | 0.335432 | 0.334963 | 0.334258 | 0.334167 | 0.334058 | 0.3339 | 0.333597 | 0.332793 | 0.33168 | 0.331245 | 0.330888 | 0.33103 |
2300 | 0.34082 | 0.340819 | 0.340814 | 0.340807 | 0.340794 | 0.340786 | 0.340804 | 0.340823 | 0.340859 | 0.34093 | 0.341105 | 0.341152 | 0.341226 | 0.341359 | 0.341606 | 0.342154 | 0.342847 | 0.343484 | 0.343597 | 0.343709 |
2400 | 0.327921 | 0.327919 | 0.327901 | 0.327879 | 0.327821 | 0.327745 | 0.327648 | 0.327619 | 0.327588 | 0.327559 | 0.327516 | 0.327505 | 0.327492 | 0.327478 | 0.327502 | 0.327839 | 0.328473 | 0.329035 | 0.328589 | 0.328576 |
2500 | 0.351282 | 0.351286 | 0.351322 | 0.351366 | 0.351494 | 0.351697 | 0.352058 | 0.352215 | 0.352446 | 0.352801 | 0.353343 | 0.353417 | 0.353513 | 0.353669 | 0.353976 | 0.354775 | 0.35603 | 0.356595 | 0.356548 | 0.356553 |
2600 | 0.316087 | 0.316085 | 0.316068 | 0.316048 | 0.31599 | 0.315908 | 0.315781 | 0.315733 | 0.31567 | 0.315586 | 0.315493 | 0.315484 | 0.315469 | 0.315436 | 0.31531 | 0.315128 | 0.314597 | 0.315128 | 0.315595 | 0.315643 |
2700 | 0.344381 | 0.344391 | 0.344472 | 0.344572 | 0.344861 | 0.345306 | 0.346068 | 0.34639 | 0.346849 | 0.347524 | 0.348435 | 0.348544 | 0.348687 | 0.348935 | 0.34943 | 0.350849 | 0.352879 | 0.353684 | 0.353955 | 0.354045 |
2800 | 0.386672 | 0.386674 | 0.386693 | 0.386716 | 0.386785 | 0.386902 | 0.387126 | 0.387231 | 0.387394 | 0.387668 | 0.388144 | 0.388206 | 0.388277 | 0.388383 | 0.388647 | 0.389233 | 0.39036 | 0.390766 | 0.390494 | 0.390398 |
2900 | 0.308498 | 0.308496 | 0.308473 | 0.308446 | 0.308374 | 0.308274 | 0.308138 | 0.308094 | 0.308044 | 0.308001 | 0.308024 | 0.308029 | 0.308025 | 0.30799 | 0.307917 | 0.307785 | 0.307894 | 0.308429 | 0.308526 | 0.308828 |
3000 | 0.365196 | 0.365201 | 0.365243 | 0.365294 | 0.365444 | 0.36568 | 0.366101 | 0.366288 | 0.366566 | 0.367011 | 0.367759 | 0.367857 | 0.367968 | 0.368119 | 0.368428 | 0.369074 | 0.370497 | 0.371093 | 0.370995 | 0.370993 |
3100 | 0.354485 | 0.35449 | 0.354535 | 0.35459 | 0.354749 | 0.354992 | 0.355405 | 0.355578 | 0.355822 | 0.356172 | 0.356594 | 0.356635 | 0.356691 | 0.356801 | 0.357093 | 0.357912 | 0.359231 | 0.359516 | 0.359481 | 0.359323 |
3200 | 0.345722 | 0.345729 | 0.345787 | 0.345858 | 0.346063 | 0.346376 | 0.346905 | 0.347126 | 0.347437 | 0.347886 | 0.348443 | 0.348496 | 0.348561 | 0.348676 | 0.348959 | 0.349816 | 0.35115 | 0.352034 | 0.352159 | 0.351925 |
3300 | 0.364998 | 0.365004 | 0.36505 | 0.365107 | 0.36527 | 0.365524 | 0.365963 | 0.366152 | 0.366425 | 0.366839 | 0.367453 | 0.367529 | 0.367618 | 0.367749 | 0.368014 | 0.368716 | 0.369728 | 0.370699 | 0.370688 | 0.370611 |
3400 | 0.349388 | 0.349395 | 0.349458 | 0.349534 | 0.349752 | 0.350079 | 0.35061 | 0.350821 | 0.351103 | 0.351459 | 0.351664 | 0.351653 | 0.351654 | 0.351706 | 0.351873 | 0.352801 | 0.354504 | 0.355102 | 0.354933 | 0.354983 |
3500 | 0.286883 | 0.286886 | 0.28691 | 0.28694 | 0.287023 | 0.287145 | 0.28733 | 0.287396 | 0.287473 | 0.28753 | 0.287303 | 0.287229 | 0.28715 | 0.287096 | 0.287169 | 0.287568 | 0.288588 | 0.287802 | 0.287295 | 0.286977 |
3600 | 0.371487 | 0.371492 | 0.371539 | 0.371595 | 0.371759 | 0.372011 | 0.37244 | 0.372622 | 0.372882 | 0.373271 | 0.373839 | 0.373914 | 0.374011 | 0.374163 | 0.374465 | 0.375242 | 0.376348 | 0.376944 | 0.376745 | 0.376907 |
3700 | 0.416953 | 0.41696 | 0.417013 | 0.417077 | 0.417263 | 0.417543 | 0.418005 | 0.418193 | 0.418452 | 0.418803 | 0.419147 | 0.419169 | 0.419203 | 0.419291 | 0.419539 | 0.420369 | 0.421489 | 0.42199 | 0.422043 | 0.421845 |
3800 | 0.368211 | 0.368216 | 0.368262 | 0.368318 | 0.368478 | 0.368724 | 0.369139 | 0.369313 | 0.369557 | 0.369912 | 0.370364 | 0.370411 | 0.370469 | 0.37057 | 0.370822 | 0.371518 | 0.372765 | 0.373351 | 0.373034 | 0.373005 |
3900 | 0.376307 | 0.376313 | 0.376362 | 0.376421 | 0.376593 | 0.376855 | 0.377298 | 0.377483 | 0.377746 | 0.378132 | 0.378667 | 0.378733 | 0.378818 | 0.378956 | 0.379232 | 0.379982 | 0.381095 | 0.382025 | 0.382168 | 0.38232 |
4000 | 0.330135 | 0.330139 | 0.330164 | 0.330196 | 0.330287 | 0.330429 | 0.330677 | 0.330784 | 0.330941 | 0.331188 | 0.331589 | 0.33164 | 0.3317 | 0.331783 | 0.331932 | 0.33223 | 0.333081 | 0.33357 | 0.333658 | 0.333813 |
4100 | 0.368477 | 0.368483 | 0.36853 | 0.368587 | 0.36875 | 0.368992 | 0.369381 | 0.369532 | 0.369732 | 0.369973 | 0.370086 | 0.370079 | 0.37009 | 0.370161 | 0.370349 | 0.371111 | 0.371984 | 0.372172 | 0.372139 | 0.37221 |
4200 | 0.371553 | 0.371555 | 0.371569 | 0.371587 | 0.371638 | 0.371718 | 0.371859 | 0.37192 | 0.372011 | 0.372153 | 0.372363 | 0.372383 | 0.372401 | 0.37243 | 0.372508 | 0.372728 | 0.373166 | 0.373224 | 0.373553 | 0.373538 |
4300 | 0.345383 | 0.345387 | 0.345423 | 0.345467 | 0.345591 | 0.345771 | 0.346045 | 0.346144 | 0.346262 | 0.346364 | 0.346187 | 0.346132 | 0.346085 | 0.346082 | 0.346162 | 0.346748 | 0.347434 | 0.347535 | 0.347381 | 0.347446 |
4400 | 0.419458 | 0.419462 | 0.419497 | 0.41954 | 0.419662 | 0.419847 | 0.420151 | 0.420273 | 0.42044 | 0.420663 | 0.420867 | 0.42088 | 0.420903 | 0.420964 | 0.42113 | 0.421629 | 0.422226 | 0.423008 | 0.422994 | 0.422981 |
4500 | 0.36795 | 0.367952 | 0.367974 | 0.368002 | 0.368082 | 0.368208 | 0.368436 | 0.368538 | 0.368692 | 0.368949 | 0.369444 | 0.369522 | 0.369614 | 0.369729 | 0.369911 | 0.370363 | 0.370693 | 0.371614 | 0.371816 | 0.37191 |
4600 | 0.382483 | 0.382486 | 0.382512 | 0.382543 | 0.382635 | 0.382774 | 0.383008 | 0.383105 | 0.383242 | 0.383437 | 0.383672 | 0.383694 | 0.383724 | 0.383785 | 0.383952 | 0.38431 | 0.385253 | 0.385451 | 0.385205 | 0.385258 |
4700 | 0.411907 | 0.411911 | 0.411943 | 0.411982 | 0.412093 | 0.412262 | 0.412539 | 0.412651 | 0.412804 | 0.413012 | 0.413208 | 0.413219 | 0.413238 | 0.413289 | 0.413423 | 0.413941 | 0.414728 | 0.415101 | 0.415039 | 0.415103 |
4800 | 0.381367 | 0.381372 | 0.381407 | 0.38145 | 0.381572 | 0.381757 | 0.382061 | 0.382183 | 0.38235 | 0.382569 | 0.382736 | 0.382736 | 0.382742 | 0.382784 | 0.382947 | 0.383571 | 0.384237 | 0.384658 | 0.384778 | 0.384492 |
4900 | 0.349585 | 0.349588 | 0.349605 | 0.349627 | 0.349688 | 0.349782 | 0.349937 | 0.350001 | 0.350089 | 0.350212 | 0.350336 | 0.350343 | 0.350353 | 0.350381 | 0.350489 | 0.350669 | 0.351284 | 0.351477 | 0.351289 | 0.351204 |
将D(x)对n的曲线画成图
可以明显的观察到无论权重如何初始化,只是在第20点,2000张图片以前有比较明显的影响。超过2000以后的曲线几乎是完全重合的。
Wx有一个极小值,当wx小于270的时候无法收敛。
D(G(z)) | ||||||||||||||||||||
| 100w | 50w | 10w | 5w | 20000 | 10000 | 5000 | 4000 | 3000 | 2000 | 1000 | 900 | 800 | 700 | 600 | 500 | 400 | 300 | 280 | 270 |
reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | reg[0] | |
100 | 0.42113 | 0.421104 | 0.420898 | 0.420641 | 0.419867 | 0.418574 | 0.415973 | 0.414664 | 0.41247 | 0.408049 | 0.3957 | 0.393779 | 0.392566 | 0.394725 | 0.411862 | 0.465034 | 0.245413 | 0.204475 | 0.19225583 | 0.214899 |
200 | 0.410986 | 0.41095 | 0.410663 | 0.410305 | 0.409223 | 0.4074 | 0.403677 | 0.401774 | 0.398537 | 0.391824 | 0.370606 | 0.365975 | 0.360355 | 0.353105 | 0.338673 | 0.370705 | 0.23073 | 0.55751 | 0.55320705 | 0.567952 |
300 | 0.408129 | 0.408098 | 0.407854 | 0.407549 | 0.406632 | 0.405097 | 0.401994 | 0.400425 | 0.397782 | 0.392419 | 0.377354 | 0.374816 | 0.372235 | 0.36825 | 0.341034 | 0.462564 | 0.24232 | 0.221219 | 0.51742799 | 0.494667 |
400 | 0.395194 | 0.395153 | 0.394824 | 0.394411 | 0.393165 | 0.391063 | 0.386759 | 0.384554 | 0.380802 | 0.373059 | 0.351171 | 0.348124 | 0.347086 | 0.354174 | 0.380398 | 0.406715 | 0.23292 | 0.195334 | 0.19512288 | 0.196323 |
500 | 0.38719 | 0.38716 | 0.386915 | 0.386609 | 0.38569 | 0.384152 | 0.381046 | 0.379478 | 0.376844 | 0.371566 | 0.357823 | 0.356132 | 0.356556 | 0.36556 | 0.392083 | 0.418857 | 0.438937 | 0.495337 | 0.51616347 | 0.525594 |
600 | 0.384044 | 0.384007 | 0.383705 | 0.383327 | 0.382186 | 0.380259 | 0.376299 | 0.374263 | 0.370788 | 0.363541 | 0.337421 | 0.329342 | 0.317151 | 0.298584 | 0.275526 | 0.257226 | 0.241324 | 0.450638 | 0.48241873 | 0.489312 |
700 | 0.376893 | 0.376861 | 0.376602 | 0.376276 | 0.375286 | 0.373588 | 0.369983 | 0.368064 | 0.364673 | 0.35709 | 0.324674 | 0.314842 | 0.301528 | 0.284661 | 0.266817 | 0.254366 | 0.243389 | 0.332159 | 0.37086777 | 0.389316 |
800 | 0.352891 | 0.352835 | 0.35239 | 0.35183 | 0.350131 | 0.347234 | 0.341211 | 0.338107 | 0.33286 | 0.322507 | 0.301214 | 0.30013 | 0.300923 | 0.303427 | 0.301984 | 0.299875 | 0.302664 | 0.318455 | 0.32682748 | 0.327834 |
900 | 0.341847 | 0.341791 | 0.341338 | 0.34077 | 0.339045 | 0.336115 | 0.33012 | 0.327115 | 0.322239 | 0.313727 | 0.306367 | 0.30809 | 0.311015 | 0.31499 | 0.318783 | 0.314258 | 0.302052 | 0.293507 | 0.29268343 | 0.293424 |
1000 | 0.320677 | 0.320602 | 0.319999 | 0.319239 | 0.316913 | 0.312896 | 0.30442 | 0.300027 | 0.292612 | 0.277972 | 0.239539 | 0.231934 | 0.222708 | 0.211672 | 0.199416 | 0.188674 | 0.178261 | 0.163611 | 0.16061738 | 0.159038 |
1100 | 0.333097 | 0.333041 | 0.332588 | 0.332017 | 0.330285 | 0.327342 | 0.321398 | 0.318484 | 0.313844 | 0.305724 | 0.289319 | 0.286142 | 0.281969 | 0.276479 | 0.269914 | 0.264365 | 0.258018 | 0.250806 | 0.24941754 | 0.248104 |
1200 | 0.302274 | 0.302184 | 0.301456 | 0.300539 | 0.297738 | 0.292943 | 0.283129 | 0.278238 | 0.270278 | 0.255503 | 0.221436 | 0.215748 | 0.209556 | 0.203088 | 0.196682 | 0.192151 | 0.18812 | 0.180141 | 0.17882735 | 0.17784 |
1300 | 0.287685 | 0.287598 | 0.286894 | 0.286011 | 0.283352 | 0.27892 | 0.270313 | 0.266237 | 0.259864 | 0.248751 | 0.225429 | 0.22164 | 0.217431 | 0.212812 | 0.207771 | 0.202267 | 0.194881 | 0.18776 | 0.1874086 | 0.186267 |
1400 | 0.282668 | 0.28259 | 0.281963 | 0.281182 | 0.278862 | 0.275109 | 0.268191 | 0.26507 | 0.260381 | 0.252739 | 0.23864 | 0.23639 | 0.233674 | 0.230081 | 0.224875 | 0.215086 | 0.20217 | 0.191629 | 0.1904838 | 0.189764 |
1500 | 0.25895 | 0.25886 | 0.258137 | 0.257243 | 0.254632 | 0.250524 | 0.243273 | 0.240113 | 0.235472 | 0.228152 | 0.215645 | 0.213878 | 0.211868 | 0.209365 | 0.205737 | 0.198879 | 0.189088 | 0.181937 | 0.18195364 | 0.180211 |
1600 | 0.242323 | 0.242223 | 0.241428 | 0.240447 | 0.237601 | 0.233173 | 0.225456 | 0.222119 | 0.217232 | 0.20953 | 0.196228 | 0.194318 | 0.19215 | 0.189508 | 0.185942 | 0.179651 | 0.17185 | 0.164573 | 0.16363021 | 0.163124 |
1700 | 0.236133 | 0.236049 | 0.235382 | 0.234563 | 0.232189 | 0.228511 | 0.222117 | 0.21935 | 0.215291 | 0.208863 | 0.197586 | 0.19593 | 0.194026 | 0.191655 | 0.188268 | 0.181592 | 0.172572 | 0.163915 | 0.16317948 | 0.162587 |
1800 | 0.266634 | 0.266568 | 0.266051 | 0.265415 | 0.263572 | 0.260714 | 0.255755 | 0.253624 | 0.25053 | 0.245766 | 0.237965 | 0.236761 | 0.235195 | 0.232825 | 0.228821 | 0.219006 | 0.203598 | 0.194268 | 0.19364865 | 0.192586 |
1900 | 0.174993 | 0.174909 | 0.174244 | 0.173431 | 0.1711 | 0.16755 | 0.161529 | 0.158971 | 0.155259 | 0.149452 | 0.139498 | 0.138136 | 0.136677 | 0.13508 | 0.133178 | 0.130334 | 0.127338 | 0.124134 | 0.12356952 | 0.123451 |
2000 | 0.212475 | 0.21241 | 0.211894 | 0.211263 | 0.209452 | 0.206698 | 0.202053 | 0.200099 | 0.197295 | 0.193028 | 0.186173 | 0.185221 | 0.184116 | 0.1827 | 0.180709 | 0.17668 | 0.171026 | 0.166857 | 0.16684048 | 0.166344 |
2100 | 0.138915 | 0.138859 | 0.138419 | 0.13788 | 0.13634 | 0.134008 | 0.13009 | 0.128441 | 0.126068 | 0.122413 | 0.116386 | 0.115583 | 0.11471 | 0.113705 | 0.112347 | 0.109928 | 0.106592 | 0.104075 | 0.10389201 | 0.103719 |
2200 | 0.173539 | 0.173486 | 0.173065 | 0.172548 | 0.171061 | 0.168782 | 0.164885 | 0.163226 | 0.160826 | 0.157132 | 0.151149 | 0.150328 | 0.149368 | 0.148082 | 0.14599 | 0.141292 | 0.134577 | 0.130088 | 0.12958323 | 0.12936 |
2300 | 0.162564 | 0.162519 | 0.162166 | 0.161734 | 0.160495 | 0.158607 | 0.155412 | 0.154063 | 0.152125 | 0.149172 | 0.144573 | 0.143985 | 0.143315 | 0.14243 | 0.140955 | 0.137516 | 0.132186 | 0.129545 | 0.13026103 | 0.130011 |
2400 | 0.124357 | 0.124306 | 0.123909 | 0.123422 | 0.122029 | 0.119914 | 0.116372 | 0.114898 | 0.112807 | 0.109709 | 0.105128 | 0.104526 | 0.10379 | 0.102711 | 0.100854 | 0.096396 | 0.090419 | 0.087057 | 0.08703736 | 0.086734 |
2500 | 0.120204 | 0.120161 | 0.119821 | 0.119404 | 0.118205 | 0.116375 | 0.113275 | 0.111972 | 0.110109 | 0.107312 | 0.10309 | 0.102534 | 0.10186 | 0.100881 | 0.099138 | 0.094937 | 0.0889 | 0.08572 | 0.08626267 | 0.085888 |
2600 | 0.09377 | 0.093733 | 0.09344 | 0.093081 | 0.092052 | 0.09049 | 0.087873 | 0.086784 | 0.085243 | 0.082975 | 0.079723 | 0.07931 | 0.078799 | 0.078023 | 0.076585 | 0.072998 | 0.068021 | 0.065475 | 0.06599977 | 0.065851 |
2700 | 0.076423 | 0.076396 | 0.076179 | 0.075914 | 0.075154 | 0.073999 | 0.072064 | 0.071257 | 0.070114 | 0.068423 | 0.065973 | 0.065663 | 0.065286 | 0.064729 | 0.063712 | 0.061165 | 0.057524 | 0.055559 | 0.0559506 | 0.055761 |
2800 | 0.123226 | 0.123184 | 0.122849 | 0.122439 | 0.121266 | 0.11949 | 0.116534 | 0.115313 | 0.1136 | 0.111123 | 0.107746 | 0.107329 | 0.1068 | 0.105969 | 0.104478 | 0.100393 | 0.094941 | 0.091688 | 0.09186927 | 0.091608 |
2900 | 0.07484 | 0.074813 | 0.074601 | 0.074341 | 0.073604 | 0.072497 | 0.070682 | 0.069945 | 0.068922 | 0.067476 | 0.065637 | 0.065428 | 0.065157 | 0.064699 | 0.063805 | 0.061366 | 0.05803 | 0.056632 | 0.05680478 | 0.056719 |
3000 | 0.064951 | 0.064926 | 0.064727 | 0.064484 | 0.063789 | 0.062741 | 0.061009 | 0.060301 | 0.059315 | 0.057918 | 0.056159 | 0.055963 | 0.055706 | 0.055265 | 0.054376 | 0.051854 | 0.048421 | 0.046716 | 0.04674847 | 0.046632 |
3100 | 0.075192 | 0.075172 | 0.075014 | 0.074822 | 0.07427 | 0.073435 | 0.072042 | 0.071467 | 0.070659 | 0.069494 | 0.067963 | 0.067793 | 0.067581 | 0.067238 | 0.066562 | 0.064593 | 0.061808 | 0.060288 | 0.0603472 | 0.060144 |
3200 | 0.046168 | 0.046154 | 0.046043 | 0.045906 | 0.045516 | 0.044924 | 0.043937 | 0.04353 | 0.042959 | 0.042135 | 0.041056 | 0.040933 | 0.040779 | 0.040523 | 0.040009 | 0.038564 | 0.036642 | 0.035601 | 0.03572211 | 0.035653 |
3300 | 0.052227 | 0.052212 | 0.052091 | 0.051943 | 0.051519 | 0.050879 | 0.049816 | 0.049379 | 0.048768 | 0.047894 | 0.046779 | 0.046657 | 0.046499 | 0.046226 | 0.045649 | 0.044016 | 0.041661 | 0.040694 | 0.04104587 | 0.040877 |
3400 | 0.046177 | 0.046164 | 0.046063 | 0.045939 | 0.045587 | 0.045055 | 0.044176 | 0.043817 | 0.043317 | 0.042608 | 0.041732 | 0.04164 | 0.04152 | 0.041307 | 0.040846 | 0.039561 | 0.037806 | 0.036995 | 0.03707548 | 0.037041 |
3500 | 0.051891 | 0.051882 | 0.051806 | 0.051714 | 0.051449 | 0.051048 | 0.050379 | 0.050102 | 0.049714 | 0.049155 | 0.048432 | 0.048355 | 0.048258 | 0.048095 | 0.047755 | 0.046784 | 0.045395 | 0.044686 | 0.04474092 | 0.044694 |
3600 | 0.043633 | 0.043622 | 0.043541 | 0.043442 | 0.043158 | 0.042728 | 0.042011 | 0.041716 | 0.041304 | 0.040715 | 0.039978 | 0.0399 | 0.039798 | 0.039619 | 0.039243 | 0.038137 | 0.036621 | 0.035846 | 0.03596746 | 0.035864 |
3700 | 0.049849 | 0.049839 | 0.049756 | 0.049655 | 0.049365 | 0.048927 | 0.048201 | 0.047903 | 0.047489 | 0.046905 | 0.046198 | 0.046128 | 0.046037 | 0.045873 | 0.045508 | 0.044384 | 0.04266 | 0.041849 | 0.04198492 | 0.041854 |
3800 | 0.034224 | 0.034216 | 0.034161 | 0.034092 | 0.033897 | 0.033602 | 0.033112 | 0.032912 | 0.032634 | 0.032243 | 0.031795 | 0.031754 | 0.0317 | 0.031595 | 0.031354 | 0.030575 | 0.029478 | 0.028952 | 0.02904693 | 0.029035 |
3900 | 0.034694 | 0.034687 | 0.034636 | 0.034573 | 0.034395 | 0.034128 | 0.033695 | 0.033522 | 0.033288 | 0.032982 | 0.032731 | 0.032725 | 0.032709 | 0.032645 | 0.03246 | 0.031756 | 0.030724 | 0.030369 | 0.03054064 | 0.030514 |
4000 | 0.030107 | 0.030102 | 0.030056 | 0.03 | 0.02984 | 0.029598 | 0.029196 | 0.029032 | 0.028805 | 0.028487 | 0.028127 | 0.028096 | 0.028053 | 0.02797 | 0.027766 | 0.027118 | 0.026193 | 0.025753 | 0.02584268 | 0.025829 |
4100 | 0.019325 | 0.019321 | 0.019289 | 0.01925 | 0.019138 | 0.01897 | 0.018694 | 0.018582 | 0.018428 | 0.018216 | 0.01799 | 0.017972 | 0.017947 | 0.017893 | 0.01776 | 0.017317 | 0.016715 | 0.016398 | 0.01640883 | 0.016386 |
4200 | 0.0363 | 0.036292 | 0.036231 | 0.036157 | 0.035946 | 0.035628 | 0.035108 | 0.034898 | 0.034611 | 0.034221 | 0.033827 | 0.033798 | 0.033752 | 0.033646 | 0.033385 | 0.032508 | 0.031292 | 0.030703 | 0.03088538 | 0.030754 |
4300 | 0.021836 | 0.021832 | 0.021804 | 0.021769 | 0.021669 | 0.02152 | 0.021274 | 0.021175 | 0.021038 | 0.020853 | 0.020666 | 0.020652 | 0.020632 | 0.020583 | 0.020455 | 0.020046 | 0.019458 | 0.019261 | 0.01929284 | 0.019287 |
4400 | 0.026677 | 0.026672 | 0.026639 | 0.026598 | 0.026481 | 0.026306 | 0.026023 | 0.025909 | 0.025756 | 0.025555 | 0.025389 | 0.025383 | 0.025369 | 0.025322 | 0.02519 | 0.02469 | 0.024005 | 0.023792 | 0.02386009 | 0.023844 |
4500 | 0.029618 | 0.029614 | 0.029578 | 0.029534 | 0.029411 | 0.029229 | 0.028941 | 0.02883 | 0.028687 | 0.028519 | 0.028494 | 0.028519 | 0.02854 | 0.028529 | 0.028426 | 0.027916 | 0.027158 | 0.027063 | 0.02716909 | 0.027162 |
4600 | 0.013632 | 0.013629 | 0.013607 | 0.013581 | 0.013505 | 0.01339 | 0.013202 | 0.013125 | 0.01302 | 0.012875 | 0.012726 | 0.012715 | 0.012699 | 0.012661 | 0.012564 | 0.012248 | 0.011791 | 0.011604 | 0.01163984 | 0.011611 |
4700 | 0.016068 | 0.016065 | 0.016045 | 0.016021 | 0.015951 | 0.015846 | 0.015677 | 0.01561 | 0.01552 | 0.015404 | 0.015327 | 0.015329 | 0.015328 | 0.01531 | 0.01524 | 0.014942 | 0.014552 | 0.014344 | 0.01437805 | 0.014362 |
4800 | 0.015081 | 0.015079 | 0.015067 | 0.015051 | 0.015006 | 0.01494 | 0.01483 | 0.014786 | 0.014727 | 0.014648 | 0.014585 | 0.014584 | 0.014581 | 0.014566 | 0.014517 | 0.014325 | 0.014056 | 0.01397 | 0.01398192 | 0.014001 |
4900 | 0.029043 | 0.02904 | 0.029017 | 0.028988 | 0.028905 | 0.028781 | 0.028575 | 0.028492 | 0.028378 | 0.028224 | 0.028084 | 0.028078 | 0.028069 | 0.02804 | 0.027957 | 0.027586 | 0.027063 | 0.026742 | 0.02681954 | 0.026791 |
将D(G(z))对n的曲线画成图
画成图
这个结果也是非常明显权重的变化仅反应在收敛过程的初始阶段,随着迭代次数的增加,曲线的形态变得高度统一。
生成的图片
对比生的图片,wx变大对网络性能有正面影响,对比1500列图片,当wx=100w时要比当wx=270时的图片清晰的多。
实验数据
学习率0.1
red[0]=D(x)
reg[0]=D(G(z))
double d1=(-1)*log(D(x),10)+(-1)*log(1- D(G(z)),10);
double d2=(-1)*log(1- D(G(z)),10);
270
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.283752 0.214899 0.652136 0.105074
0.544812 0.567952 0.628221 0.364468
0.496561 0.494667 0.60045 0.296422
0.292386 0.196323 0.628962 0.094918
0.515502 0.525594 0.61162 0.32385
0.493531 0.489312 0.59853 0.291845
0.432533 0.389316 0.578164 0.214183
0.395938 0.327834 0.574896 0.172523
0.381278 0.293424 0.569599 0.150841
0.295893 0.159038 0.604089 0.075224
0.355772 0.248104 0.57267 0.123842
0.311501 0.17784 0.591584 0.085043
0.326661 0.186267 0.575421 0.089518
0.32779 0.189764 0.575793 0.091388
0.333849 0.180211 0.562747 0.086298
0.317288 0.163124 0.575885 0.077339
0.337118 0.162587 0.549279 0.077061
0.361729 0.192586 0.53452 0.092904
0.33051 0.123451 0.538039 0.057224
0.388578 0.166344 0.489536 0.079013
0.246005 0.103719 0.656612 0.047556
0.33103 0.12936 0.540294 0.060162
0.343709 0.130011 0.524295 0.060486
0.328576 0.086734 0.522767 0.039403
0.356553 0.085888 0.486877 0.039001
0.315643 0.065851 0.530388 0.029584
0.354045 0.055761 0.47586 0.024918
0.390398 0.091608 0.450219 0.041727
0.308828 0.056719 0.535643 0.025359
0.370993 0.046632 0.451373 0.02074
0.359323 0.060144 0.471453 0.026939
0.351925 0.035653 0.469316 0.015767
0.370611 0.040877 0.449207 0.018126
0.354983 0.037041 0.466185 0.016392
0.286977 0.044694 0.56201 0.019857
0.376907 0.035864 0.439627 0.015862
0.421845 0.041854 0.393415 0.018568
0.373005 0.029035 0.441081 0.012796
0.38232 0.030514 0.431032 0.013459
0.333813 0.025829 0.487861 0.011365
0.37221 0.016386 0.436388 0.007175
0.373538 0.030754 0.441231 0.013566
0.347446 0.019287 0.46757 0.008458
0.422981 0.023844 0.38416 0.010481
0.37191 0.027162 0.441522 0.01196
0.385258 0.011611 0.41932 0.005072
0.415103 0.014362 0.388126 0.006282
0.384492 0.014001 0.421236 0.006124
0.351204 0.026791 0.466235 0.011794
280
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.263532 0.192256 0.671892 0.092726
0.535189 0.553207 0.621387 0.349894
0.511287 0.517428 0.607773 0.316438
0.290688 0.195123 0.630843 0.09427
0.509821 0.516163 0.607883 0.315301
0.489312 0.482419 0.596435 0.286021
0.4207 0.370868 0.577286 0.201258
0.39488 0.326827 0.575409 0.171874
0.380335 0.292683 0.57022 0.150386
0.296555 0.160617 0.603935 0.07604
0.356133 0.249418 0.572989 0.124602
0.311668 0.178827 0.591873 0.085566
0.32698 0.187409 0.575606 0.090128
0.327747 0.190484 0.576235 0.091774
0.334358 0.181954 0.563011 0.087222
0.317137 0.16363 0.576355 0.077602
0.336932 0.163179 0.549825 0.077368
0.361916 0.193649 0.534868 0.093476
0.330144 0.12357 0.538578 0.057283
0.388498 0.16684 0.489883 0.079272
0.246148 0.103892 0.656444 0.04764
0.330888 0.129583 0.540591 0.060273
0.343597 0.130261 0.524562 0.060611
0.328589 0.087037 0.522894 0.039547
0.356548 0.086263 0.48706 0.039179
0.315595 0.066 0.530523 0.029653
0.353955 0.055951 0.476057 0.025005
0.390494 0.091869 0.450237 0.041852
0.308526 0.056805 0.536106 0.025398
0.370995 0.046748 0.451425 0.020792
0.359481 0.060347 0.471356 0.027033
0.352159 0.035722 0.469059 0.015798
0.370688 0.041046 0.449193 0.018202
0.354933 0.037075 0.466261 0.016408
0.287295 0.044741 0.561551 0.019879
0.376745 0.035967 0.439861 0.015908
0.422043 0.041985 0.393271 0.018628
0.373034 0.029047 0.441054 0.012802
0.382168 0.030541 0.431216 0.01347
0.333658 0.025843 0.48807 0.011371
0.372139 0.016409 0.436481 0.007185
0.373553 0.030885 0.441273 0.013625
0.347381 0.019293 0.467655 0.008461
0.422994 0.02386 0.384154 0.010488
0.371816 0.027169 0.441634 0.011963
0.385205 0.01164 0.419393 0.005085
0.415039 0.014378 0.388201 0.00629
0.384778 0.013982 0.420905 0.006115
0.351289 0.02682 0.466142 0.011807
300
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.273265 0.204475 0.662763 0.099346
0.538325 0.55751 0.623052 0.354096
0.305442 0.221219 0.623656 0.108585
0.289498 0.195334 0.632738 0.094385
0.497144 0.495337 0.600516 0.296998
0.469694 0.450638 0.588326 0.260142
0.395198 0.332159 0.578512 0.175327
0.389076 0.318455 0.576471 0.166505
0.380088 0.293507 0.571008 0.150892
0.298054 0.163611 0.603296 0.077592
0.356423 0.250806 0.57344 0.125406
0.311726 0.180141 0.592487 0.086261
0.32666 0.18776 0.57622 0.090315
0.327824 0.191629 0.576748 0.092389
0.333555 0.181937 0.564046 0.087213
0.317424 0.164573 0.576451 0.078091
0.337401 0.163915 0.549603 0.07775
0.362036 0.194268 0.535057 0.093809
0.330203 0.124134 0.538781 0.057562
0.388051 0.166857 0.490391 0.07928
0.24643 0.104075 0.656034 0.047728
0.331245 0.130088 0.540375 0.060525
0.343484 0.129545 0.524346 0.060254
0.329035 0.087057 0.522315 0.039556
0.356595 0.08572 0.486745 0.038921
0.315128 0.065475 0.530922 0.029409
0.353684 0.055559 0.47621 0.024825
0.390766 0.091688 0.449849 0.041765
0.308429 0.056632 0.536164 0.025319
0.371093 0.046716 0.451295 0.020778
0.359516 0.060288 0.471288 0.027005
0.352034 0.035601 0.469159 0.015743
0.370699 0.040694 0.449022 0.018043
0.355102 0.036995 0.466018 0.016371
0.287802 0.044686 0.56076 0.019854
0.376944 0.035846 0.439577 0.015853
0.42199 0.041849 0.393264 0.018566
0.373351 0.028952 0.440642 0.012759
0.382025 0.030369 0.431302 0.013393
0.33357 0.025753 0.488144 0.011331
0.372172 0.016398 0.436437 0.007181
0.373224 0.030703 0.441574 0.013543
0.347535 0.019261 0.467448 0.008447
0.423008 0.023792 0.384109 0.010458
0.371614 0.027063 0.441823 0.011915
0.385451 0.011604 0.4191 0.005069
0.415101 0.014344 0.388121 0.006275
0.384658 0.01397 0.421035 0.00611
0.351477 0.026742 0.465874 0.011772
400
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.301123 0.245413 0.643547 0.122291
0.302072 0.23073 0.63381 0.113921
0.314931 0.24232 0.622299 0.120514
0.312878 0.23292 0.619785 0.11516
0.460958 0.438937 0.587326 0.250988
0.3257 0.241324 0.607126 0.119943
0.328749 0.243389 0.604263 0.121127
0.374919 0.302664 0.582621 0.156558
0.381842 0.302052 0.574293 0.156177
0.303392 0.178261 0.603262 0.085266
0.357157 0.258018 0.576748 0.129607
0.313253 0.18812 0.594613 0.090508
0.326959 0.194881 0.579647 0.09414
0.331284 0.20217 0.577889 0.09809
0.334005 0.189088 0.567273 0.091026
0.319002 0.17185 0.578098 0.081891
0.339225 0.172572 0.551783 0.08227
0.364011 0.203598 0.537753 0.098867
0.328424 0.127338 0.54272 0.059154
0.385746 0.171026 0.495158 0.081459
0.248024 0.106592 0.654457 0.04895
0.33168 0.134577 0.542053 0.062771
0.342847 0.132186 0.526473 0.061573
0.328473 0.090419 0.524659 0.041158
0.35603 0.0889 0.488947 0.040434
0.314597 0.068021 0.53284 0.030594
0.352879 0.057524 0.478104 0.02573
0.39036 0.094941 0.451857 0.043323
0.307894 0.05803 0.537561 0.025963
0.370497 0.048421 0.45277 0.021555
0.359231 0.061808 0.472335 0.027708
0.35115 0.036642 0.47072 0.016212
0.369728 0.041661 0.450598 0.018481
0.354504 0.037806 0.467117 0.016737
0.288588 0.045395 0.559898 0.020176
0.376348 0.036621 0.440613 0.016203
0.421489 0.04266 0.394148 0.018934
0.372765 0.029478 0.441559 0.012995
0.381095 0.030724 0.43252 0.013553
0.333081 0.026193 0.488977 0.011527
0.371984 0.016715 0.436796 0.007321
0.373166 0.031292 0.441905 0.013807
0.347434 0.019458 0.467661 0.008534
0.422226 0.024005 0.385007 0.010552
0.370693 0.027158 0.442943 0.011958
0.385253 0.011791 0.419406 0.005151
0.414728 0.014552 0.388603 0.006366
0.384237 0.014056 0.421548 0.006148
0.351284 0.027063 0.466257 0.011915
500
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.472792 0.465034 0.597004 0.271674
0.405426 0.370705 0.593234 0.201146
0.473559 0.462564 0.594299 0.269673
0.435926 0.406715 0.587324 0.226736
0.446426 0.418857 0.585967 0.235717
0.333786 0.257226 0.605675 0.129143
0.332785 0.254366 0.60531 0.127474
0.369652 0.299875 0.587031 0.154824
0.386902 0.314258 0.576239 0.163839
0.305734 0.188674 0.605461 0.090805
0.357083 0.264365 0.580569 0.133338
0.312108 0.192151 0.598366 0.09267
0.326882 0.202267 0.583752 0.098143
0.336311 0.215086 0.578437 0.105178
0.336259 0.198879 0.569628 0.096302
0.320396 0.179651 0.580314 0.086001
0.340583 0.181592 0.554807 0.08703
0.36925 0.219006 0.540033 0.107352
0.324652 0.130334 0.549229 0.060647
0.383014 0.17668 0.501217 0.084432
0.24917 0.109928 0.65408 0.050575
0.332793 0.141292 0.54398 0.066155
0.342154 0.137516 0.530027 0.064249
0.327839 0.096396 0.528362 0.044022
0.354775 0.094937 0.493368 0.043321
0.315128 0.072998 0.534432 0.032919
0.350849 0.061165 0.482291 0.027411
0.389233 0.100393 0.455738 0.045947
0.307785 0.061366 0.539257 0.027504
0.369074 0.051854 0.456011 0.023125
0.357912 0.064593 0.475223 0.028999
0.349816 0.038564 0.47324 0.01708
0.368716 0.044016 0.452857 0.019549
0.352801 0.039561 0.470001 0.01753
0.287568 0.046784 0.562069 0.020809
0.375242 0.038137 0.442575 0.016887
0.420369 0.044384 0.396086 0.019717
0.371518 0.030575 0.443506 0.013486
0.379982 0.031756 0.434252 0.014015
0.33223 0.027118 0.490501 0.01194
0.371111 0.017317 0.438083 0.007587
0.372728 0.032508 0.44296 0.014353
0.346748 0.020046 0.46878 0.008794
0.421629 0.02469 0.385927 0.010857
0.370363 0.027916 0.443668 0.012296
0.38431 0.012248 0.420671 0.005352
0.413941 0.014942 0.3896 0.006538
0.383571 0.014325 0.422421 0.006266
0.350669 0.027586 0.467252 0.012149
600
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.429066 0.411862 0.597996 0.23052
0.37756 0.338673 0.602598 0.179584
0.382686 0.341034 0.598294 0.181137
0.415384 0.380398 0.589438 0.207887
0.426644 0.392083 0.58609 0.216156
0.344414 0.275526 0.602896 0.139977
0.338939 0.266817 0.604665 0.134787
0.368457 0.301984 0.589748 0.156134
0.387678 0.318783 0.578243 0.166714
0.309889 0.199416 0.605387 0.096593
0.357891 0.269914 0.582875 0.136626
0.312427 0.196682 0.600364 0.095112
0.327046 0.207771 0.58654 0.101149
0.340232 0.224875 0.578853 0.110628
0.337767 0.205737 0.571419 0.100036
0.321825 0.185942 0.581725 0.089345
0.341811 0.188268 0.556801 0.090588
0.37229 0.228821 0.541964 0.112845
0.322804 0.133178 0.553131 0.06207
0.381094 0.180709 0.50553 0.086562
0.250101 0.112347 0.653641 0.051757
0.333597 0.14599 0.545315 0.068537
0.341606 0.140955 0.532459 0.065984
0.327502 0.100854 0.530956 0.04617
0.353976 0.099138 0.496368 0.045342
0.31531 0.076585 0.535865 0.034603
0.34943 0.063712 0.48523 0.02859
0.388647 0.104478 0.458368 0.047924
0.307917 0.063805 0.5402 0.028634
0.368428 0.054376 0.457929 0.024281
0.357093 0.066562 0.477133 0.029915
0.348959 0.040009 0.474959 0.017733
0.368014 0.045649 0.454428 0.020292
0.351873 0.040846 0.471725 0.018112
0.287169 0.047755 0.563114 0.021251
0.374465 0.039243 0.443975 0.017386
0.419539 0.045508 0.397455 0.020228
0.370822 0.031354 0.44467 0.013835
0.379232 0.03246 0.435426 0.014331
0.331932 0.027766 0.49118 0.012229
0.370349 0.01776 0.439171 0.007782
0.372508 0.033385 0.44361 0.014746
0.346162 0.020455 0.469696 0.008976
0.42113 0.02519 0.386664 0.01108
0.369911 0.028426 0.444426 0.012524
0.383952 0.012564 0.421214 0.005491
0.413423 0.01524 0.390275 0.00667
0.382947 0.014517 0.423211 0.006351
0.350489 0.027957 0.46764 0.012314
700
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.413039 0.394725 0.602056 0.218047
0.385864 0.353105 0.602732 0.189166
0.400838 0.36825 0.596486 0.199455
0.39389 0.354174 0.59451 0.189885
0.406133 0.36556 0.588941 0.197609
0.358989 0.298584 0.598943 0.154024
0.34991 0.284661 0.601531 0.145488
0.367491 0.303427 0.591786 0.157033
0.383424 0.31499 0.580623 0.164303
0.316556 0.211672 0.602842 0.103293
0.360534 0.276479 0.583602 0.140549
0.315186 0.203088 0.600023 0.098589
0.328506 0.212812 0.587378 0.103922
0.34217 0.230081 0.579313 0.113555
0.33849 0.209365 0.572478 0.102024
0.322721 0.189508 0.582424 0.091251
0.342351 0.191655 0.557932 0.092403
0.373273 0.232825 0.543079 0.115106
0.322337 0.13508 0.554713 0.063024
0.380343 0.1827 0.507443 0.087619
0.250746 0.113705 0.653188 0.052422
0.3339 0.148082 0.545985 0.069602
0.341359 0.14243 0.53352 0.066731
0.327478 0.102711 0.531886 0.047068
0.353669 0.100881 0.497586 0.046183
0.315436 0.078023 0.53637 0.03528
0.348935 0.064729 0.486318 0.029063
0.388383 0.105969 0.459388 0.048648
0.30799 0.064699 0.540512 0.029049
0.368119 0.055265 0.458702 0.02469
0.356801 0.067238 0.477803 0.030229
0.348676 0.040523 0.475543 0.017966
0.367749 0.046226 0.455003 0.020554
0.351706 0.041307 0.472141 0.018321
0.287096 0.048095 0.563379 0.021406
0.374163 0.039619 0.444496 0.017557
0.419291 0.045873 0.397878 0.020394
0.37057 0.031595 0.445073 0.013943
0.378956 0.032645 0.435825 0.014414
0.331783 0.02797 0.491466 0.01232
0.370161 0.017893 0.43945 0.007841
0.37243 0.033646 0.443819 0.014864
0.346082 0.020583 0.469854 0.009032
0.420964 0.025322 0.386894 0.011139
0.369729 0.028529 0.444687 0.01257
0.383785 0.012661 0.421445 0.005534
0.413289 0.01531 0.390446 0.0067
0.382784 0.014566 0.423418 0.006372
0.350381 0.02804 0.467811 0.012352
800
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.40948 0.392566 0.604269 0.216501
0.389247 0.360355 0.603836 0.194061
0.401846 0.372235 0.598143 0.202203
0.386305 0.347086 0.598213 0.185144
0.397711 0.356556 0.591922 0.19149
0.37053 0.317151 0.596852 0.165676
0.360487 0.301528 0.598962 0.155851
0.363926 0.300923 0.594462 0.155475
0.379161 0.311015 0.582967 0.16179
0.322749 0.222708 0.600551 0.109416
0.362848 0.281969 0.584132 0.143857
0.318333 0.209556 0.599247 0.102129
0.330216 0.217431 0.58768 0.106477
0.343353 0.233674 0.579845 0.115586
0.338881 0.211868 0.573354 0.103401
0.323398 0.19215 0.582932 0.092669
0.342717 0.194026 0.558743 0.093679
0.373719 0.235195 0.543904 0.116449
0.322303 0.136677 0.555563 0.063827
0.379964 0.184116 0.508629 0.088372
0.251226 0.11471 0.652849 0.052915
0.334058 0.149368 0.546436 0.070258
0.341226 0.143315 0.534137 0.067179
0.327492 0.10379 0.532389 0.04759
0.353513 0.10186 0.49825 0.046656
0.315469 0.078799 0.536688 0.035646
0.348687 0.065286 0.486885 0.029321
0.388277 0.1068 0.45991 0.049051
0.308025 0.065157 0.540676 0.029261
0.367968 0.055706 0.459083 0.024893
0.356691 0.067581 0.478097 0.030389
0.348561 0.040779 0.475802 0.018081
0.367618 0.046499 0.455282 0.020679
0.351654 0.04152 0.472302 0.018417
0.28715 0.048258 0.563372 0.021481
0.374011 0.039798 0.444753 0.017637
0.419203 0.046037 0.398044 0.020469
0.370469 0.0317 0.445239 0.01399
0.378818 0.032709 0.436012 0.014443
0.3317 0.028053 0.491612 0.012358
0.37009 0.017947 0.439558 0.007865
0.372401 0.033752 0.4439 0.014911
0.346085 0.020632 0.469871 0.009054
0.420903 0.025369 0.386978 0.01116
0.369614 0.02854 0.444827 0.012575
0.383724 0.012699 0.421531 0.00555
0.413238 0.015328 0.390509 0.006708
0.382742 0.014581 0.423472 0.006379
0.350353 0.028069 0.467858 0.012364
900
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.409081 0.393779 0.605559 0.217369
0.391871 0.365975 0.60475 0.197894
0.402146 0.374816 0.599609 0.203992
0.385135 0.348124 0.600221 0.185835
0.395657 0.356132 0.593884 0.191203
0.377689 0.329342 0.596364 0.173499
0.368697 0.314842 0.59754 0.164209
0.361747 0.30013 0.596577 0.154982
0.375681 0.30809 0.585131 0.15995
0.327815 0.231934 0.598973 0.114601
0.364484 0.286142 0.584709 0.146388
0.321463 0.215748 0.598413 0.105544
0.331899 0.22164 0.587813 0.108819
0.344134 0.23639 0.580401 0.117128
0.339162 0.213878 0.574103 0.10451
0.323963 0.194318 0.583341 0.093836
0.343009 0.19593 0.5594 0.094706
0.37389 0.236761 0.544595 0.117339
0.322452 0.138136 0.556096 0.064561
0.379723 0.185221 0.509493 0.08896
0.251662 0.115583 0.652525 0.053343
0.334167 0.150328 0.546785 0.070749
0.341152 0.143985 0.534571 0.067518
0.327505 0.104526 0.532729 0.047947
0.353417 0.102534 0.498694 0.046982
0.315484 0.07931 0.53691 0.035886
0.348544 0.065663 0.487239 0.029496
0.388206 0.107329 0.460247 0.049309
0.308029 0.065428 0.540795 0.029387
0.367857 0.055963 0.459332 0.025011
0.356635 0.067793 0.478263 0.030487
0.348496 0.040933 0.475953 0.018151
0.367529 0.046657 0.455459 0.020751
0.351653 0.04164 0.472357 0.018471
0.287229 0.048355 0.563297 0.021525
0.373914 0.0399 0.444911 0.017683
0.419169 0.046128 0.398121 0.02051
0.370411 0.031754 0.445331 0.014014
0.378733 0.032725 0.436117 0.01445
0.33164 0.028096 0.491709 0.012376
0.370079 0.017972 0.439581 0.007876
0.372383 0.033798 0.443942 0.014932
0.346132 0.020652 0.469822 0.009063
0.42088 0.025383 0.387007 0.011166
0.369522 0.028519 0.444925 0.012566
0.383694 0.012715 0.421572 0.005558
0.413219 0.015329 0.390529 0.006709
0.382736 0.014584 0.423481 0.00638
0.350343 0.028078 0.467875 0.012369
1000
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.409576 0.3957 0.606412 0.218747
0.394108 0.370606 0.605462 0.201077
0.402723 0.377354 0.600752 0.205759
0.385833 0.351171 0.601471 0.18787
0.395397 0.357823 0.595312 0.192345
0.382105 0.337421 0.59658 0.178763
0.374569 0.324674 0.596954 0.170486
0.361099 0.301214 0.59803 0.155656
0.373111 0.306367 0.587032 0.15887
0.331843 0.239539 0.59799 0.118923
0.365579 0.289319 0.585343 0.148325
0.324346 0.221436 0.597698 0.108706
0.333439 0.225429 0.587923 0.110939
0.344716 0.23864 0.580948 0.11841
0.339407 0.215645 0.574767 0.105487
0.324467 0.196228 0.583697 0.094867
0.343263 0.197586 0.559975 0.095602
0.37395 0.237965 0.545212 0.118025
0.322662 0.139498 0.5565 0.065248
0.379539 0.186173 0.510211 0.089468
0.252069 0.116386 0.652218 0.053738
0.334258 0.151149 0.547087 0.071168
0.341105 0.144573 0.534929 0.067817
0.327516 0.105128 0.533006 0.048239
0.353343 0.10309 0.499054 0.047251
0.315493 0.079723 0.537092 0.036081
0.348435 0.065973 0.487519 0.02964
0.388144 0.107746 0.460519 0.049511
0.308024 0.065637 0.5409 0.029484
0.367759 0.056159 0.459537 0.025101
0.356594 0.067963 0.478392 0.030567
0.348443 0.041056 0.476075 0.018207
0.367453 0.046779 0.455605 0.020807
0.351664 0.041732 0.472385 0.018513
0.287303 0.048432 0.563221 0.02156
0.373839 0.039978 0.445034 0.017719
0.419147 0.046198 0.398176 0.020542
0.370364 0.031795 0.445404 0.014033
0.378667 0.032731 0.436196 0.014453
0.331589 0.028127 0.491791 0.01239
0.370086 0.01799 0.439581 0.007884
0.372363 0.033827 0.443978 0.014945
0.346187 0.020666 0.469759 0.009069
0.420867 0.025389 0.387023 0.011169
0.369444 0.028494 0.445006 0.012555
0.383672 0.012726 0.421602 0.005562
0.413208 0.015327 0.39054 0.006708
0.382736 0.014585 0.423482 0.006381
0.350336 0.028084 0.467886 0.012371
2000
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.415502 0.408049 0.609141 0.227714
0.405247 0.391824 0.608251 0.215971
0.408445 0.392419 0.605262 0.216396
0.395499 0.373059 0.605627 0.202773
0.39825 0.371566 0.601585 0.201741
0.393883 0.363541 0.600863 0.19623
0.391567 0.35709 0.599043 0.19185
0.368784 0.322507 0.602323 0.169095
0.369693 0.313727 0.595661 0.163503
0.350459 0.277972 0.596808 0.141446
0.370062 0.305724 0.590194 0.158468
0.340713 0.255503 0.595748 0.128137
0.342467 0.248751 0.589597 0.124216
0.347983 0.252739 0.584969 0.126528
0.341507 0.228152 0.579068 0.112468
0.328115 0.20953 0.586089 0.102114
0.345043 0.208863 0.563875 0.101748
0.374152 0.245766 0.549446 0.122494
0.324422 0.149452 0.55919 0.070301
0.378478 0.193028 0.515102 0.093142
0.255005 0.122413 0.650162 0.05671
0.334963 0.157132 0.549243 0.074241
0.34093 0.149172 0.537493 0.070158
0.327559 0.109709 0.535178 0.050468
0.352801 0.107312 0.501771 0.0493
0.315586 0.082975 0.5385 0.037619
0.347524 0.068423 0.489797 0.030781
0.387668 0.111123 0.462699 0.051158
0.308001 0.067476 0.541789 0.03034
0.367011 0.057918 0.461232 0.025911
0.356172 0.069494 0.479621 0.031281
0.347886 0.042135 0.477259 0.018696
0.366839 0.047894 0.45684 0.021315
0.351459 0.042608 0.473035 0.01891
0.28753 0.049155 0.563207 0.02189
0.373271 0.040715 0.446028 0.018052
0.418803 0.046905 0.398853 0.020864
0.369912 0.032243 0.446136 0.014234
0.378132 0.032982 0.436922 0.014565
0.331188 0.028487 0.492477 0.012551
0.369973 0.018216 0.439814 0.007984
0.372153 0.034221 0.444401 0.015122
0.346364 0.020853 0.469619 0.009152
0.420663 0.025555 0.387308 0.011243
0.368949 0.028519 0.4456 0.012566
0.383437 0.012875 0.421934 0.005628
0.413012 0.015404 0.390779 0.006742
0.382569 0.014648 0.423699 0.006409
0.350212 0.028224 0.468103 0.012434
3000
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.418016 0.41247 0.609777 0.23097
0.40906 0.398537 0.609004 0.220791
0.410899 0.397782 0.606511 0.220247
0.39942 0.380802 0.606741 0.208171
0.399824 0.376844 0.603534 0.205403
0.396807 0.370788 0.602624 0.201203
0.394815 0.364673 0.600609 0.197003
0.373565 0.33286 0.603417 0.175783
0.372274 0.322239 0.598061 0.168924
0.357153 0.292612 0.597488 0.150342
0.372559 0.313844 0.592382 0.163577
0.347352 0.270278 0.596073 0.136843
0.346539 0.259864 0.590936 0.130688
0.349845 0.260381 0.587116 0.130992
0.343019 0.235472 0.581288 0.116606
0.330337 0.217232 0.587409 0.106367
0.346136 0.215291 0.566045 0.105291
0.374498 0.25053 0.551796 0.125245
0.325407 0.155259 0.560849 0.073276
0.377965 0.197295 0.517993 0.095444
0.256685 0.126068 0.649122 0.058522
0.335432 0.160826 0.550544 0.076148
0.340859 0.152125 0.539094 0.071668
0.327588 0.112807 0.536654 0.051982
0.352446 0.110109 0.50357 0.050663
0.31567 0.085243 0.539461 0.038694
0.346849 0.070114 0.49143 0.03157
0.387394 0.1136 0.464217 0.05237
0.308044 0.068922 0.542402 0.031014
0.366566 0.059315 0.462404 0.026556
0.355822 0.070659 0.480592 0.031825
0.347437 0.042959 0.478193 0.019069
0.366425 0.048768 0.457729 0.021713
0.351103 0.043317 0.473797 0.019232
0.287473 0.049714 0.563548 0.022146
0.372882 0.041304 0.446748 0.018319
0.418452 0.047489 0.399485 0.02113
0.369557 0.032634 0.446727 0.014409
0.377746 0.033288 0.437503 0.014703
0.330941 0.028805 0.492943 0.012694
0.369732 0.018428 0.440191 0.008078
0.372011 0.034611 0.444742 0.015298
0.346262 0.021038 0.46983 0.009234
0.42044 0.025756 0.387628 0.011332
0.368692 0.028687 0.445977 0.012641
0.383242 0.01302 0.422219 0.005692
0.412804 0.01552 0.391049 0.006793
0.38235 0.014727 0.423983 0.006443
0.350089 0.028378 0.468324 0.012503
4000
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.419314 0.414664 0.610056 0.232595
0.410948 0.401774 0.609347 0.223134
0.412164 0.400425 0.607086 0.222156
0.401382 0.384554 0.607252 0.21081
0.400676 0.379478 0.604449 0.207243
0.398239 0.374263 0.603465 0.203608
0.3962 0.368064 0.601412 0.199327
0.376088 0.338107 0.603923 0.179212
0.374038 0.327115 0.599144 0.172059
0.360533 0.300027 0.597974 0.154919
0.37411 0.318484 0.593525 0.166524
0.350863 0.278238 0.596468 0.141606
0.348861 0.266237 0.591791 0.134444
0.351049 0.26507 0.588386 0.133754
0.344069 0.240113 0.582606 0.119251
0.331791 0.222119 0.588222 0.109087
0.346858 0.21935 0.567392 0.107544
0.374791 0.253624 0.553254 0.127042
0.326041 0.158971 0.561917 0.075189
0.377682 0.200099 0.519837 0.096964
0.257753 0.128441 0.6485 0.059703
0.335747 0.163226 0.551379 0.077392
0.340823 0.154063 0.540133 0.072662
0.327619 0.114898 0.537637 0.053007
0.352215 0.111972 0.504765 0.051573
0.315733 0.086784 0.540106 0.039426
0.34639 0.071257 0.492539 0.032105
0.387231 0.115313 0.46524 0.053211
0.308094 0.069945 0.542809 0.031491
0.366288 0.060301 0.463188 0.027011
0.355578 0.071467 0.481267 0.032203
0.347126 0.04353 0.478842 0.019329
0.366152 0.049379 0.458331 0.021993
0.350821 0.043817 0.474373 0.019459
0.287396 0.050102 0.563843 0.022323
0.372622 0.041716 0.447237 0.018506
0.418193 0.047903 0.399942 0.021319
0.369313 0.032912 0.44714 0.014534
0.377483 0.033522 0.43791 0.014808
0.330784 0.029032 0.493251 0.012795
0.369532 0.018582 0.440494 0.008146
0.37192 0.034898 0.444977 0.015427
0.346144 0.021175 0.470038 0.009295
0.420273 0.025909 0.387869 0.011401
0.368538 0.02883 0.446222 0.012705
0.383105 0.013125 0.42242 0.005738
0.412651 0.01561 0.39125 0.006833
0.382183 0.014786 0.424198 0.00647
0.350001 0.028492 0.468484 0.012554
5000
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.420103 0.415973 0.610211 0.233567
0.412074 0.403677 0.609543 0.224518
0.412933 0.401994 0.607415 0.223294
0.402554 0.386759 0.607545 0.212369
0.401204 0.381046 0.604977 0.208342
0.399092 0.376299 0.60395 0.205024
0.396972 0.369983 0.601887 0.200648
0.377611 0.341211 0.604209 0.181254
0.375187 0.33012 0.599755 0.174003
0.362541 0.30442 0.598295 0.157653
0.375124 0.321398 0.59421 0.168385
0.353007 0.283129 0.596776 0.144559
0.350351 0.270313 0.59236 0.136864
0.351876 0.268191 0.589213 0.135602
0.34482 0.243273 0.583468 0.121061
0.332803 0.225456 0.588767 0.110954
0.347366 0.222117 0.568299 0.109086
0.375013 0.255755 0.554237 0.128284
0.326486 0.161529 0.562647 0.076512
0.377511 0.202053 0.521097 0.098026
0.258487 0.13009 0.648086 0.060526
0.33597 0.164885 0.551953 0.078254
0.340804 0.155412 0.54085 0.073355
0.327648 0.116372 0.538323 0.053731
0.352058 0.113275 0.505597 0.052211
0.315781 0.087873 0.540558 0.039944
0.346068 0.072064 0.49332 0.032482
0.387126 0.116534 0.465958 0.05381
0.308138 0.070682 0.54309 0.031836
0.366101 0.061009 0.463737 0.027339
0.355405 0.072042 0.481748 0.032472
0.346905 0.043937 0.479303 0.019514
0.365963 0.049816 0.458755 0.022192
0.35061 0.044176 0.474798 0.019622
0.28733 0.050379 0.564069 0.02245
0.37244 0.042011 0.447583 0.01864
0.418005 0.048201 0.400273 0.021455
0.369139 0.033112 0.447434 0.014624
0.377298 0.033695 0.438201 0.014886
0.330677 0.029196 0.493465 0.012869
0.369381 0.018694 0.440721 0.008196
0.371859 0.035108 0.445143 0.015521
0.346045 0.021274 0.470206 0.009339
0.420151 0.026023 0.388046 0.011451
0.368436 0.028941 0.446392 0.012754
0.383008 0.013202 0.422564 0.005772
0.412539 0.015677 0.391398 0.006862
0.382061 0.01483 0.424356 0.006489
0.349937 0.028575 0.4686 0.012591
10000
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.421705 0.418574 0.610497 0.235505
0.414311 0.4074 0.609912 0.227238
0.414491 0.405097 0.608038 0.225554
0.404883 0.391063 0.608099 0.215428
0.402292 0.384152 0.605985 0.210527
0.400787 0.380259 0.604875 0.20779
0.39841 0.373588 0.60281 0.20314
0.380629 0.347234 0.60474 0.185242
0.377592 0.336115 0.600885 0.177907
0.366444 0.312896 0.59897 0.162978
0.377285 0.327342 0.595536 0.172206
0.357296 0.292943 0.597517 0.150546
0.353526 0.27892 0.593595 0.142017
0.353777 0.275109 0.590997 0.139727
0.346654 0.250524 0.585347 0.125243
0.335205 0.233173 0.589993 0.115303
0.348584 0.228511 0.570363 0.11267
0.375578 0.260714 0.556487 0.131187
0.327579 0.16755 0.564326 0.079642
0.377185 0.206698 0.524008 0.100562
0.260217 0.134008 0.64715 0.062486
0.336506 0.168782 0.553293 0.080285
0.340786 0.158607 0.542519 0.075001
0.327745 0.119914 0.539939 0.055475
0.351697 0.116375 0.507563 0.053732
0.315908 0.09049 0.541632 0.041193
0.345306 0.073999 0.495185 0.033389
0.386902 0.11949 0.467665 0.055266
0.308274 0.072497 0.543748 0.032684
0.36568 0.062741 0.465039 0.028141
0.354992 0.073435 0.482905 0.033124
0.346376 0.044924 0.480414 0.019962
0.365524 0.050879 0.459763 0.022678
0.350079 0.045055 0.475856 0.020022
0.287145 0.051048 0.564655 0.022756
0.372011 0.042728 0.448409 0.018964
0.417543 0.048927 0.401085 0.021786
0.368724 0.033602 0.448142 0.014844
0.376855 0.034128 0.438906 0.01508
0.330429 0.029598 0.49397 0.013048
0.368992 0.01897 0.4413 0.008318
0.371718 0.035628 0.445542 0.015755
0.345771 0.02152 0.470659 0.009448
0.419847 0.026306 0.388486 0.011578
0.368208 0.029229 0.44679 0.012883
0.382774 0.01339 0.422913 0.005855
0.412262 0.015846 0.391764 0.006937
0.381757 0.01494 0.42475 0.006537
0.349782 0.028781 0.468885 0.012683
20000
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.422517 0.419867 0.610628 0.236472
0.415423 0.409223 0.610085 0.228576
0.415282 0.406632 0.608333 0.226676
0.40604 0.393165 0.608361 0.216929
0.402853 0.38569 0.606466 0.211613
0.401631 0.382186 0.605314 0.209142
0.399085 0.375286 0.603253 0.204319
0.382112 0.350131 0.604984 0.187174
0.378812 0.339045 0.601404 0.179828
0.368311 0.316913 0.599309 0.165524
0.3784 0.330285 0.596159 0.17411
0.359393 0.297738 0.597931 0.153501
0.355184 0.283352 0.594241 0.144694
0.354848 0.278862 0.591939 0.141982
0.347756 0.254632 0.586354 0.127629
0.336622 0.237601 0.590676 0.117817
0.349313 0.232189 0.571531 0.114746
0.375924 0.263572 0.55777 0.13287
0.32826 0.1711 0.565279 0.081498
0.377046 0.209452 0.525678 0.102072
0.26124 0.13634 0.646618 0.063657
0.336827 0.171061 0.554071 0.081478
0.340794 0.160495 0.543485 0.075977
0.327821 0.122029 0.540882 0.05652
0.351494 0.118205 0.508714 0.054632
0.31599 0.092052 0.542265 0.041939
0.344861 0.075154 0.496287 0.03393
0.386785 0.121266 0.468672 0.056142
0.308374 0.073604 0.544126 0.033203
0.365444 0.063789 0.465806 0.028626
0.354749 0.07427 0.483595 0.033516
0.346063 0.045516 0.481076 0.020231
0.36527 0.051519 0.460357 0.022972
0.349752 0.045587 0.476504 0.020264
0.287023 0.051449 0.565022 0.02294
0.371759 0.043158 0.448898 0.01916
0.417263 0.049365 0.401577 0.021986
0.368478 0.033897 0.448565 0.014977
0.376593 0.034395 0.439328 0.0152
0.330287 0.02984 0.494265 0.013156
0.36875 0.019138 0.44166 0.008392
0.371638 0.035946 0.445779 0.015899
0.345591 0.021669 0.470952 0.009514
0.419662 0.026481 0.388756 0.011656
0.368082 0.029411 0.447021 0.012965
0.382635 0.013505 0.423121 0.005905
0.412093 0.015951 0.391988 0.006983
0.381572 0.015006 0.42499 0.006567
0.349688 0.028905 0.469057 0.012738
50000
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.423008 0.420641 0.610704 0.237052
0.416089 0.410305 0.610186 0.229372
0.41576 0.407549 0.608506 0.227348
0.406732 0.394411 0.608514 0.217822
0.403196 0.386609 0.606747 0.212263
0.402138 0.383327 0.60557 0.209945
0.399479 0.376276 0.603514 0.205008
0.38299 0.35183 0.605123 0.188311
0.379543 0.34077 0.601702 0.180963
0.369399 0.319239 0.59951 0.167005
0.37907 0.332017 0.596516 0.175235
0.36062 0.300539 0.598186 0.155236
0.356188 0.286011 0.594629 0.146309
0.355523 0.281182 0.592513 0.143381
0.348481 0.257243 0.586974 0.129154
0.337548 0.240447 0.591107 0.119442
0.349795 0.234563 0.572277 0.11609
0.376152 0.265415 0.558594 0.133958
0.328724 0.173431 0.565889 0.082721
0.376976 0.211263 0.526754 0.103068
0.261913 0.13788 0.646275 0.064432
0.337039 0.172548 0.554577 0.082257
0.340807 0.161734 0.544109 0.076618
0.327879 0.123422 0.541496 0.05721
0.351366 0.119404 0.509464 0.055223
0.316048 0.093081 0.542679 0.042431
0.344572 0.075914 0.497007 0.034287
0.386716 0.122439 0.469331 0.056723
0.308446 0.074341 0.544369 0.033549
0.365294 0.064484 0.466306 0.028949
0.35459 0.074822 0.484048 0.033775
0.345858 0.045906 0.481511 0.020409
0.365107 0.051943 0.460746 0.023165
0.349534 0.045939 0.476934 0.020424
0.28694 0.051714 0.56527 0.023061
0.371595 0.043442 0.449218 0.019289
0.417077 0.049655 0.401902 0.022119
0.368318 0.034092 0.448842 0.015064
0.376421 0.034573 0.439606 0.015281
0.330196 0.03 0.494457 0.013228
0.368587 0.01925 0.441902 0.008442
0.371587 0.036157 0.445934 0.015994
0.345467 0.021769 0.471152 0.009559
0.41954 0.026598 0.388934 0.011708
0.368002 0.029534 0.44717 0.01302
0.382543 0.013581 0.423258 0.005938
0.411982 0.016021 0.392136 0.007014
0.38145 0.015051 0.425149 0.006586
0.349627 0.028988 0.469171 0.012775
10w
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.423172 0.420898 0.610728 0.237245
0.41631 0.410663 0.61022 0.229637
0.41592 0.407854 0.608562 0.227571
0.406962 0.394824 0.608564 0.218118
0.403311 0.386915 0.60684 0.212479
0.402306 0.383705 0.605655 0.210211
0.399609 0.376602 0.603599 0.205235
0.383281 0.35239 0.605168 0.188686
0.379786 0.341338 0.601799 0.181338
0.369756 0.319999 0.599576 0.167491
0.379293 0.332588 0.596631 0.175606
0.361023 0.301456 0.598272 0.155806
0.356523 0.286894 0.594758 0.146846
0.355753 0.281963 0.592705 0.143853
0.348733 0.258137 0.587183 0.129676
0.337869 0.241428 0.591254 0.120003
0.349963 0.235382 0.572533 0.116556
0.376232 0.266051 0.558879 0.134334
0.32889 0.174244 0.566098 0.083148
0.376956 0.211894 0.527125 0.103416
0.262149 0.138419 0.646156 0.064704
0.337113 0.173065 0.554752 0.082528
0.340814 0.162166 0.544325 0.076842
0.327901 0.123909 0.541708 0.057451
0.351322 0.119821 0.509724 0.055429
0.316068 0.09344 0.542823 0.042603
0.344472 0.076179 0.497258 0.034412
0.386693 0.122849 0.46956 0.056925
0.308473 0.074601 0.544453 0.033671
0.365243 0.064727 0.46648 0.029062
0.354535 0.075014 0.484206 0.033865
0.345787 0.046043 0.481662 0.020471
0.36505 0.052091 0.460881 0.023233
0.349458 0.046063 0.477085 0.02048
0.28691 0.051806 0.565357 0.023103
0.371539 0.043541 0.44933 0.019334
0.417013 0.049756 0.402016 0.022165
0.368262 0.034161 0.448938 0.015095
0.376362 0.034636 0.439703 0.015309
0.330164 0.030056 0.494523 0.013253
0.36853 0.019289 0.441987 0.008459
0.371569 0.036231 0.445988 0.016027
0.345423 0.021804 0.471222 0.009574
0.419497 0.026639 0.388997 0.011726
0.367974 0.029578 0.447222 0.013039
0.382512 0.013607 0.423305 0.00595
0.411943 0.016045 0.392188 0.007025
0.381407 0.015067 0.425205 0.006593
0.349605 0.029017 0.46921 0.012788
50w
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.423304 0.421104 0.610748 0.2374
0.416487 0.41095 0.610246 0.229848
0.416048 0.408098 0.608607 0.22775
0.407146 0.395153 0.608604 0.218355
0.403403 0.38716 0.606913 0.212653
0.402441 0.384007 0.605721 0.210424
0.399712 0.376861 0.603668 0.205415
0.383514 0.352835 0.605204 0.188985
0.37998 0.341791 0.601876 0.181636
0.370039 0.320602 0.599629 0.167876
0.379471 0.333041 0.596722 0.175901
0.361342 0.302184 0.59834 0.156259
0.356791 0.287598 0.59486 0.147275
0.355938 0.28259 0.592858 0.144233
0.348938 0.25886 0.587351 0.1301
0.338131 0.242223 0.591373 0.120459
0.350101 0.236049 0.572741 0.116934
0.376297 0.266568 0.55911 0.13464
0.329026 0.174909 0.566268 0.083498
0.376941 0.21241 0.527427 0.1037
0.262341 0.138859 0.64606 0.064926
0.337174 0.173486 0.554895 0.08275
0.340819 0.162519 0.544501 0.077025
0.327919 0.124306 0.541881 0.057648
0.351286 0.120161 0.509936 0.055597
0.316085 0.093733 0.54294 0.042744
0.344391 0.076396 0.497462 0.034514
0.386674 0.123184 0.469746 0.057091
0.308496 0.074813 0.544521 0.03377
0.365201 0.064926 0.466622 0.029154
0.35449 0.075172 0.484335 0.033939
0.345729 0.046154 0.481786 0.020522
0.365004 0.052212 0.460991 0.023289
0.349395 0.046164 0.477209 0.020526
0.286886 0.051882 0.565428 0.023137
0.371492 0.043622 0.449421 0.019371
0.41696 0.049839 0.402109 0.022203
0.368216 0.034216 0.449017 0.01512
0.376313 0.034687 0.439782 0.015332
0.330139 0.030102 0.494577 0.013274
0.368483 0.019321 0.442056 0.008473
0.371555 0.036292 0.446032 0.016055
0.345387 0.021832 0.471281 0.009587
0.419462 0.026672 0.389048 0.011741
0.367952 0.029614 0.447264 0.013055
0.382486 0.013629 0.423344 0.00596
0.411911 0.016065 0.39223 0.007034
0.381372 0.015079 0.42525 0.006599
0.349588 0.02904 0.469243 0.012799
100w
red[0] reg[0] d1 d2
0.42332 0.42113 0.61075 0.237419
0.41651 0.410986 0.610249 0.229874
0.416064 0.408129 0.608613 0.227773
0.407169 0.395194 0.608609 0.218384
0.403415 0.38719 0.606922 0.212674
0.402458 0.384044 0.60573 0.21045
0.399725 0.376893 0.603676 0.205437
0.383543 0.352891 0.605209 0.189022
0.380004 0.341847 0.601885 0.181673
0.370074 0.320677 0.599635 0.167924
0.379493 0.333097 0.596734 0.175938
0.361382 0.302274 0.598349 0.156315
0.356825 0.287685 0.594873 0.147328
0.355961 0.282668 0.592878 0.14428
0.348964 0.25895 0.587372 0.130153
0.338164 0.242323 0.591388 0.120516
0.350118 0.236133 0.572768 0.116982
0.376305 0.266634 0.559139 0.134679
0.329043 0.174993 0.56629 0.083542
0.376939 0.212475 0.527465 0.103736
0.262365 0.138915 0.646048 0.064954
0.337182 0.173539 0.554913 0.082778
0.34082 0.162564 0.544523 0.077048
0.327921 0.124357 0.541903 0.057673
0.351282 0.120204 0.509963 0.055618
0.316087 0.09377 0.542955 0.042762
0.344381 0.076423 0.497488 0.034527
0.386672 0.123226 0.46977 0.057112
0.308498 0.07484 0.54453 0.033783
0.365196 0.064951 0.46664 0.029166
0.354485 0.075192 0.484351 0.033948
0.345722 0.046168 0.481801 0.020528
0.364998 0.052227 0.461005 0.023296
0.349388 0.046177 0.477225 0.020532
0.286883 0.051891 0.565437 0.023142
0.371487 0.043633 0.449432 0.019375
0.416953 0.049849 0.402121 0.022208
0.368211 0.034224 0.449027 0.015123
0.376307 0.034694 0.439792 0.015335
0.330135 0.030107 0.494584 0.013276
0.368477 0.019325 0.442065 0.008475
0.371553 0.0363 0.446037 0.016058
0.345383 0.021836 0.471288 0.009588
0.419458 0.026677 0.389055 0.011743
0.36795 0.029618 0.447269 0.013057
0.382483 0.013632 0.423349 0.005961
0.411907 0.016068 0.392236 0.007035
0.381367 0.015081 0.425256 0.006599
0.349585 0.029043 0.469247 0.0128