会议 rebuttal怎么写 汇总

格式

如何写学术论文的rebuttal？

顶会rebuttal技术浅谈：站着，还把论文中了

花式引战，勾起内部讨论

由于审稿人的领域和偏好各不相同，我们可能收到完全相反的评论：审稿人A说写作好，novelty一般；审稿人B却说写作不行，novelty不错。在这种情况下，我们可以“断章取义”（当然，也是在实事求是的前提下），用一个审稿人的观点去反驳另一个审稿人的负面判断，以谋求他们对自己观点的重新审视。

例如，我们可以在rebuttal的开始时说：We are glad that the Reviewers appreciate the novelty (Reviewer X), writing (Reviewer Y), impressive experimental results (Reviewer Z) …

分别回应每个审稿人时，要注意语言的技巧，不要说得太直接（“人家Reviewer Y都能看出来我的创新所在，你怎么就不懂？”），不然会给人一种“你在教我做事”的感觉。要把别人的正面评价作为暗示融入到你的回应中。例如：

We would like to note that XXX distinguishes our method from YYY and ZZZ, which is appreciated by Reviewer Y and Z.

除了让审稿人更容易重新审视自己的判断以外，这样做还可能起到的一个正面效果是激发rebuttal后AC带领审稿人进行的讨论（“各位审稿人，我看了rebuttal，注意到了你们的评价各不相同，你们说说这是怎么回事？”）。如果AC觉得讨论是热烈而有益的，自己没白忙活，也收获了一些知识，那么作为引发讨论的素材，你的文章可能会得到一些印象分。

---

要改就改，不画虚空大饼

如果审稿人说得对，你也想改，那就要在rebuttal中让他们知道你真的会改。由于会议论文只有一次审稿，审稿人和AC会担忧你的修改是不可控的（超出篇幅限制、删除了他们没想让你删的东西、引入了新的错误等）。所以要尽量避免虚空画饼：

• 我们会做你说的实验

• 我们会改Figure 2

• 我们会重写第二章

要非常具体：

• 我们做了XX和YY的实验，我们会将以下结果加入Table 1

• 我们会把XX的图例加到Figure 2里并修改字号和颜色

在我曾经的一篇文章中，审稿人指出整个第三章（讲方法的部分）逻辑混乱，他“got completely lost”，要求重写。我用了相当的篇幅向他描述我会如何重组这个部分：

• 原来第三章第一节是讲述背景的，所以我们会放进Related Work中；

• 我们会在第三章开头加一个总括性的段落以概括整个方法，简述其主要组成部分并清晰地指向后续各个详述细节的小节。这个段落如下……

• 后续各个小节分别描述的是……

开源的review和rebuttal例子

LipNet: End-to-End Sentence-level Lipreading | OpenReview

【常用句式】

以下列举一些rebuttal中的常用句式，供大家选择使用：

• 开头

  • Thank you for your suggestion.

  • Thank you for the positive/detailed/constructive comments.

  • We sincerely thank all reviewers and ACs for their time and efforts. Below please find the responses to some specific comments.

  • We thank the reviewers for their useful comments. The common questions are first answered, then we clarify questions from every individual review.

  • We thank the useful suggestions from the reviewers. Some important or common questions are first addressed, followed by answers to individual reviews.

• 表达同意

  • We thank the reviewer for pointing out this issue.

  • We agree with you and have incorporated this suggestion throughout our paper.

  • We have reflected this comment by …

  • We can/will add/compare/revise/correct ... in our revised manuscript/our final version.

  • Due to the rebuttal policy, “authors should not include new experimental results in the rebuttal”, additional results may not be included. However, we will add these mentioned experiments and discussions in our final version. Thank you for the constructive comment.（对于CVPR/ICCV/ECCV rebuttal不能提供新结果的政策）

• 表达不同意

  • We respectfully disagree with Reviewer #id that ...

  • The reviewer might have overlooked Table #id ...

  • We can compare ... but it is not quite related to our work ...

  • We have to emphasize that ...

  • The reviewer raises an interesting concern. However, our work ...

  • Thank you for the comment, but we cannot fully agree with the comment. As stated/emphasized ...

  • You have raised an important point; however, we believe that ... would be outside the scope of our paper because …

  • This is a valid assessment of …; however, we believe that ... would be more appropriate because ...

• 解释澄清

  • We have indeed stated/included/discussed/compared/reported/clarified/elaborated ... in our original paper ... (cf. Line #id).

  • As we stated in Line #id, ...

  • We have rewritten ... to be more in line with your comments. We hope that the edited section clarifies …

• 额外信息与解释

  • We have included a new figure/table (cf. Figure/Table #id) to further illustrate…

  • We have supplemented the xxx section with explanations of ...

  • Thank you for the comment. We will explore this in future work.

• 魏秀参：浅谈学术论文rebuttal

Rebuttal常见问题和常用表达

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/i91B-al6qawj4Rkylrgvew