如果你收到了审稿人意见的返修,无论是大修还是小修,这都是一件值得高兴的事情。
在目前这个学术投稿量巨大的时代,能进入under review,这本身不仅仅需要论文实力,还需要很大的好运
一. 前言
本次给大家分享的是关于返修内容的书写要点,我以我自身不久前写的返修意见为例,仅供参考
如果期刊没有给返修回复意见的模板,你可以写在word里,然后转成pdf上传
二. 正文开始
假设你的论文题目ABC 投稿编号EFG
标题居中:ABC [EFG] Response to Reviewers
开头先感谢,感情基调:每位审稿人都很厉害,我都改了,你们都对我提供了很多帮助等等
Firstly, we are very grateful to the Editor and Reviewers for giving us such a valuable opportunity
to revise our manuscript! We appreciate the time and effort that the Editor and the Reviewers for the insightful and constructive feedback. We are convinced that the Reviewers' comments have greatly improved our manuscript and brought us a lot of inspiration.
(开头第一段 第一点,要感谢编辑处理你稿件付出的时间和给予你返修的机会,其实你的论文最终是否被接受,主要还是编辑在考虑了每位审稿人的意见之后给出的。第二点,要感谢每位审稿人给您i提出的具有有建设性的意见和建议)
Based on the Reviewers' comments, we have corrected the errors in the content of the manuscript, and have made extensive alterations to the structure, format, and experimental analyses of our manuscript. In response, we have addressed all of the Reviewers technical concerns with a substantial amount of new data, supported by additional detailed explanations in our revised manuscript.
(第二段要说明 你已经根据每位审稿人的意见进行了广泛的修正,态度要真诚,要有自己的思考,这次的返修手稿已经做了全面的修正)
Below are our point-to-point responses to the Reviewers' valuable comments, including the exact
location where the change can be found in the revised manuscript. We use
black bold font
for the Reviewers' comments, normal black font for our responses, black italics
for the content in the original manuscript, and
red italics
for the changes in the revised manuscript.
(第三段要说明你这次写的返修意见中,采用什么形式来和点对点的回复审稿人,例如,你可以用黑色的加粗字体来标注审稿人的问题,用黑色正常字体来写你的回应,红色的斜体来表示你在原文上修改的内容)
开头这些套话,感谢话等等建议自己改一改,不要在网上找到了直接复制粘贴,语序,内容根据实际修改
三. 点对点回复注意事项
接下来就是点对点回复,我建议大家针对每个审稿人的每条意见都进行点对点回复(可能你觉得有些意见是审稿人没有好好读文章提出来的“无理取闹问题”,但是最好认真解释,因为你尊重别人,别人才会尊重你,不排除有些过分的审稿人,碰到了确实有点受挫)
To Reviewer #1
1. XXXXX审稿人的原问题
?
Authors' Response: Thanks for the kind and insightful comments and suggestions! (先感谢审稿人提出的问题,然后认真解释). We have taken this comment positively and added this part of the description with the following changes in the original manuscript:(说明自己修改后的内容)
"Line 74-80 in original manuscript: xxxxxxxx
." (原文的内容)
"
Line 71-81 in the revised manuscript: xxxxx
" (修改后的内容)
注意:一定要突出你的修改内容,审稿人大概率不会一边对照你的初稿和你的返修论文一段一段的去对比你改了哪些内容,最好明确的告诉他你都改了哪
2.XXXXX审稿人的问题(这时候假如他说你需要补充实验图或者模块原理图等)
Authors' Response:
Thank you very much for the insightful and constructive comments, which
have inspired us to further refine our research work! We have fully considered your comments and added Fig. 6: Visual results of the features in our proposed method to the manuscript, as well as a more detailed description of the principle in the figure caption.(承认自己工作中的不足,和不全面之处)
这里放上你增加的图片
接下来说明一下你增加的这幅图想要说明哪些问题
To Reviewer #2
形式同上类似
在回复完所有审稿人之后,结尾可以再加上感谢语,表示自己已经全力修改了文章内容
四. 一些自己的投稿审稿心得
我也审过很多稿子,各种水平的也都有接触,实话说,作为一个审稿人,我会根据期刊本身的水平去严肃的审论文,一个端正的学术态度,你的论文是会为你说话的,返修意见回来之后,审稿人也能感受到你的回复态度,这些都是有温度的,尊重是相互的,认真对待每件事,你的反馈都不会太差。
希望能帮助到你。祝你论文高中!前程似锦!