Apollo9.0 PNC源码学习之Control模块（一）—— 控制模块概览

0 前言

从planning的角度看control，首先需要了解的就是相关的数据接口，规划出的轨迹（路径+速度）发给Control模块去执行
modules/planning/planning_component/planning_component.cc
planning模块发布轨迹信息

planning_writer_ = node_->CreateWriter<ADCTrajectory>(
      config_.topic_config().planning_trajectory_topic());

modules/control/control_component/control_component.cc
Control模块接受轨迹信息

trajectory_reader_ =
      node_->CreateReader<ADCTrajectory>(planning_reader_config, nullptr);
ACHECK(trajectory_reader_ != nullptr);

ADCTrajectory在modules/common_msgs/planning_msgs/planning.proto定义

message ADCTrajectory {
  optional apollo.common.Header header = 1;

  optional double total_path_length = 2;  // in meters

  optional double total_path_time = 3;    // in seconds

  optional EStop estop = 6;

  optional apollo.planning_internal.Debug debug = 8;

  // is_replan == true mean replan triggered 重规划 
  optional bool is_replan = 9 [default = false];

  // Specify trajectory gear 档位
  optional apollo.canbus.Chassis.GearPosition gear = 10;

  // path data + speed data 路径数据 + 速度数据
  repeated apollo.common.TrajectoryPoint trajectory_point = 12;

  // path point without speed info 路径点
  repeated apollo.common.PathPoint path_point = 13;

  optional apollo.planning.DecisionResult decision = 14;

  optional LatencyStats latency_stats = 15;

  // the routing used for current planning result
  optional apollo.common.Header routing_header = 16;
  enum RightOfWayStatus {
    UNPROTECTED = 0;
    PROTECTED = 1;
  }
  optional RightOfWayStatus right_of_way_status = 17;

  // lane id along current reference line
  repeated apollo.hdmap.Id lane_id = 18;

  // set the engage advice for based on current planning result.
  optional apollo.common.EngageAdvice engage_advice = 19;

  // the region where planning cares most
  message CriticalRegion {
    repeated apollo.common.Polygon region = 1;
  }
  // critical region will be empty when planning is NOT sure which region is
  // critical
  // critical regions may or may not overlap
  optional CriticalRegion critical_region = 20;
  // 轨迹类型（未知、正常、）
  enum TrajectoryType {
    UNKNOWN = 0;       // 未知的轨迹类型，通常用于表示无法确定或识别的情况
    NORMAL = 1;        // 正常的轨迹类型，可能是由标准路径规划算法生成的轨迹
    PATH_FALLBACK = 2; // 路径回退类型，当标准路径规划失败时，可能会使用备用路径规划算法生成轨迹
    SPEED_FALLBACK = 3;// 速度回退类型，当无法满足速度约束条件时，可能会使用备用速度规划算法生成轨迹
    PATH_REUSED = 4;   // 重用路径类型，可能是之前生成的路径的重用或修改版本
    OPEN_SPACE = 5;    // 开放空间类型，通常用于表示在开放环境中的轨迹规划，比如停车或避障等情况
  }
  optional TrajectoryType trajectory_type = 21 [default = UNKNOWN];

  optional string replan_reason = 22;

  // lane id along target reference line
  repeated apollo.hdmap.Id target_lane_id = 23;

  // complete dead end flag
  optional bool car_in_dead_end = 24;

  // output related to RSS
  optional RSSInfo rss_info = 100;
}

1 纵览控制模块

Control模块由control组件包和controller控制器组成，control组件包包含control的整体架构和流程。control根据上游模块输入planning模块的期望轨迹信息，定位模块的当前定位信息，车辆底盘及车身状态信息，通过不同的控制算法计算控制车辆的指令（包含转向、油门、刹车等）输出给canbus模块

1.1 control_component

control_component是继承于apollo::cyber::TimerComponent的子类，是一个定时触发的组件，通过dag配置可以修改定时器周期。Init和Proc是入口函数，在初始化函数中，主要实现了ControlTaskAgent的初始化，以及control上游的相关消息的订阅。在Proc执行函数中，分别执行了几步操作：获取订阅消息的当前最新数据–>检查订阅消息输入数据（代码里主要检查了对轨迹线数据是否为空的检查，其它消息数据的检查也可以自行添加）是否完整–>检查订阅消息输入数据时间戳是否在容差范围内（上游消息的数据周期是否超时，如果超时control会有紧急处理）–>更新车身姿态信息–>进行control控制计算（这部分调用ControlTaskAgent的ComputeControlCommand方法，ControlTaskAgent通过配置文件，管理控制器ControlTask的加载和执行顺序，进而完成控制指令的计算）–>输出底盘控制指令

1.2 control_task_base

control_component/controller_task_base/主要包含ControlTaskAgent和ControlTask定义。ControlTaskAgent用来管理ControlTask插件的加载和执行顺序，ControlTask是controller控制器插件的父类，Control/controller控制器插件都继承于ControlTask，目前Apollo已经支持的控制器插件有横向控制器（LatController），纵向控制器（LonController），MPC控制器（MPCController），以及DemoControlTask任务器（DemoControlTask）

1.3 controller

Apollo对车辆的控制是将车辆在车体坐标系转换到Frenet坐标系下进行位置跟踪，将车辆跟踪轨迹的运动分解为横向运动和纵向运动，通过对车体的动力学建模，选取合适的状态变量对车辆的跟踪情况进行观测，再通过横向和纵向的控制算法，计算合理的控制指令，达到对轨迹线的跟踪目标

1.4 文件组织结构及说明

control/
├── control_component/                  // control基础组件
    ├── common                          // 模块全局gflag定义
    ├── conf                            // 模块配置文件，参数文件目录，包含gflags变量的配置，插件启用的配置文件，车辆标定表等通用的配置文件
    ├── controller_task_base/           // control控制器父类组件
    │   ├── common/                     // 数学公式，算法公式，滤波函数，轨迹分析
    │   ├── integration_tests/          // 单元测试文件夹
    │   ├── control_task_agent.cc       // 控制器加载管理器实现文件
    │   ├── control_task_agent.h        // 控制器加载管理器实现文件
    │   └── control_task.h              // 控制器父类实现文件
    ├── dag/                            // 模块启动文件(mainboard)
    ├── docs/                           // 相关模块说明文档
    ├── launch/                         // 模块启动文件(cyber_launch)
    ├── proto/                          // 组件定义的配置文件
    ├── submodules/                     // control子模块
    ├── testdata/                       // 单元测试数据
    ├── tools/                          // 调试工具
    ├── BUILD                           // 构建规则文件
    ├── control_component.cc            // 组件实现的代码文件
    ├── control_component.h             // 组件实现的代码文件
    ├── control_component_test.cc       // 组件单元测试文件
    ├── control.json                    // 打包描述文件
    ├── cyberfile.xml                   // 包管理配置文件
    └── README_cn.md                    // 说明文档
└── controllers/                        // 控制器算法或逻辑任务组件
    ├── demo_control_task               // demo控制器插件包
    │   ├── proto/                      // 控制器的配置定义文件夹
    │   ├── conf/                       // 控制器配置文件夹
    │   ├── BUILD                       // 构建规则文件
    │   ├── cyberfile.xml               // 包管理配置文件
    │   ├── demo_control_task.cc        // demo控制器实现文件
    │   ├── demo_control_task.h         // demo控制器实现文件
    │   └── plugins.xml                 // 插件规则文件
    ├── lat_based_lqr_controller        // LQR横向控制器插件包
    │   ├── proto/                      // 控制器的配置定义文件夹
    │   ├── conf/                       // 控制器配置文件夹
    │   ├── BUILD                       // 构建规则文件
    │   ├── cyberfile.xml               // 包管理配置文件
    │   ├── lat_controller.cc           // LQR横向控制器实现文件
    │   ├── lat_controller.h            // LQR横向控制器实现文件
    │   ├── lat_controller_test.cc      // LQR横向控制器单元测试文件
    │   ├── lateral_controller_test     // 控制器测试数据
    │   └── plugins.xml                 // 插件规则文件
    ├── lon_based_pid_controller        // PID纵向控制器插件包
    │   ├── proto/                      // 控制器的配置定义文件夹
    │   ├── conf/                       // 控制器配置文件夹
    │   ├── BUILD                       // 构建规则文件
    │   ├── cyberfile.xml               // 包管理配置文件
    │   ├── lon_controller.cc           // PID纵向控制器实现文件
    │   ├── lon_controller.h            // PID纵向控制器实现文件
    │   ├── lon_controller_test.cc      // PID纵向控制器单元测试文件
    │   ├── longitudinal_controller_test// 控制器测试数据
    │   └── plugins.xml                 // 插件规则文件
    └── mpc_controller                  // MPC横纵向控制器插件包
        ├── proto/                      // 控制器的配置定义文件夹
        ├── conf/                       // 控制器配置文件夹
        ├── BUILD                       // 构建规则文件
        ├── cyberfile.xml               // 包管理配置文件
        ├── mpc_controller.cc           // MPC控制器实现文件
        ├── mpc_controller.h            // MPC控制器实现文件
        ├── mpc_controller_test.cc      // MPC控制器单元测试文件
        ├── mpc_controller_test_data    // 控制器测试数据
        └── plugins.xml                 // 插件规则文件

1.5 模块输入输出与配置

输入：

Channel名称	类型	描述
/apollo/planning	apollo::planning::ADCTrajectory	车辆规划轨迹线信息
/apollo/localization/pose	apollo::localization::LocalizationEstimate	车辆定位信息
/apollo/canbus/chassis	apollo::canbus::Chassis	车辆底盘信息
-	apollo::common::VehicleState	车身姿态信息
/apollo/control/pad	apollo::control::ControlCommand::PadMessage	自动驾驶使能（请求进入自动驾驶）指令

输出：

Channel名称	类型	描述
/apollo/control	apollo::control::ControlCommand	车辆的控制指令，如方向盘、油门、刹车等信息

配置文件：

文件路径	类型/结构	说明
modules/control/control_component/conf/pipeline.pb.txt	apollo::control::ControlPipeline	ControlComponent的配置文件
modules/control/control_component/conf/control.conf	command line flags	命令行参数配置
modules/control/control_component/conf/calibration_table.pb.txt	apollo::control::calibration_table	车辆纵向标定表配置

Flags：

flagfile	类型	描述
modules/control/control_component/common/control_gflags.cc	flags	Control组件flags变量定义文件
modules/control/control_component/common/control_gflags.h	declare	Control组件flags声明文件

2 控制器组件代码解析

control_component.h

#pragma once

#include <memory>
#include <string>

#include "modules/common_msgs/chassis_msgs/chassis.pb.h"
#include "modules/common_msgs/control_msgs/control_cmd.pb.h"
#include "modules/common_msgs/control_msgs/pad_msg.pb.h"
#include "modules/common_msgs/external_command_msgs/command_status.pb.h"
#include "modules/common_msgs/localization_msgs/localization.pb.h"
#include "modules/common_msgs/planning_msgs/planning.pb.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/proto/preprocessor.pb.h"

#include "cyber/class_loader/class_loader.h"
#include "cyber/component/timer_component.h"
#include "cyber/time/time.h"
#include "modules/common/monitor_log/monitor_log_buffer.h"
#include "modules/common/util/util.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/controller_task_base/common/dependency_injector.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/controller_task_base/control_task_agent.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/submodules/preprocessor_submodule.h"

/**
 * @namespace apollo::control
 * @brief apollo::control
 */
namespace apollo {
namespace control {

/**
 * @class Control
 *
 * @brief control module main class, it processes localization, chassis, and
 * pad data to compute throttle, brake and steer values.
 */
// 控制模块主类，处理定位、底盘、pad数据为了计算油门、刹车和转向，继承apollo::cyber::TimerComponent，定时触发
class ControlComponent final : public apollo::cyber::TimerComponent {
  friend class ControlTestBase;

 public:
  ControlComponent();
  bool Init() override;

  bool Proc() override;

 private:
  // Upon receiving pad message
  // 接收pad消息
  void OnPad(const std::shared_ptr<PadMessage> &pad);
  // 接收底盘消息
  void OnChassis(const std::shared_ptr<apollo::canbus::Chassis> &chassis);
  // 接受轨迹消息
  void OnPlanning(
      const std::shared_ptr<apollo::planning::ADCTrajectory> &trajectory);
  // 规划命令状态信息
  void OnPlanningCommandStatus(
      const std::shared_ptr<external_command::CommandStatus>
          &planning_command_status);
  // 接收定位消息
  void OnLocalization(
      const std::shared_ptr<apollo::localization::LocalizationEstimate>
          &localization);

  // Upon receiving monitor message
  // 接收检测信息
  void OnMonitor(
      const apollo::common::monitor::MonitorMessage &monitor_message);

  common::Status ProduceControlCommand(ControlCommand *control_command);
  common::Status CheckInput(LocalView *local_view);
  common::Status CheckTimestamp(const LocalView &local_view);
  common::Status CheckPad();
  void ResetAndProduceZeroControlCommand(ControlCommand *control_command);
  void GetVehiclePitchAngle(ControlCommand *control_command);

 private:
  apollo::cyber::Time init_time_;

  localization::LocalizationEstimate latest_localization_;
  canbus::Chassis latest_chassis_;
  planning::ADCTrajectory latest_trajectory_;
  external_command::CommandStatus planning_command_status_;
  PadMessage pad_msg_;
  common::Header latest_replan_trajectory_header_;

  ControlTaskAgent control_task_agent_;

  bool estop_ = false;
  std::string estop_reason_;
  bool pad_received_ = false;

  unsigned int status_lost_ = 0;
  unsigned int status_sanity_check_failed_ = 0;
  unsigned int total_status_lost_ = 0;
  unsigned int total_status_sanity_check_failed_ = 0;

  ControlPipeline control_pipeline_;

  std::mutex mutex_;
  // 订阅者 底盘、pad、定位、轨迹、命令状态
  std::shared_ptr<cyber::Reader<apollo::canbus::Chassis>> chassis_reader_;
  std::shared_ptr<cyber::Reader<PadMessage>> pad_msg_reader_;
  std::shared_ptr<cyber::Reader<apollo::localization::LocalizationEstimate>>
      localization_reader_;
  std::shared_ptr<cyber::Reader<apollo::planning::ADCTrajectory>>
      trajectory_reader_;
  std::shared_ptr<cyber::Reader<apollo::external_command::CommandStatus>>
      planning_command_status_reader_;
  // 发布者 控制命令、使用控制子模块LocalView
  std::shared_ptr<cyber::Writer<ControlCommand>> control_cmd_writer_;
  // when using control submodules
  std::shared_ptr<cyber::Writer<LocalView>> local_view_writer_;
  
  common::monitor::MonitorLogBuffer monitor_logger_buffer_;

  LocalView local_view_;

  std::shared_ptr<DependencyInjector> injector_;

  double previous_steering_command_ = 0.0;
};

CYBER_REGISTER_COMPONENT(ControlComponent)
}  // namespace control
}  // namespace apollo

control_component.cc

#include "modules/control/control_component/control_component.h"

#include "absl/strings/str_cat.h"

#include "cyber/common/file.h"
#include "cyber/common/log.h"
#include "cyber/time/clock.h"
#include "modules/common/adapters/adapter_gflags.h"
#include "modules/common/latency_recorder/latency_recorder.h"
#include "modules/common/vehicle_state/vehicle_state_provider.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/common/control_gflags.h"

namespace apollo {
namespace control {

using apollo::canbus::Chassis;
using apollo::common::ErrorCode;
using apollo::common::Status;
using apollo::common::VehicleStateProvider;
using apollo::cyber::Clock;
using apollo::localization::LocalizationEstimate;
using apollo::planning::ADCTrajectory;

const double kDoubleEpsilon = 1e-6;

ControlComponent::ControlComponent()
    : monitor_logger_buffer_(common::monitor::MonitorMessageItem::CONTROL) {}

bool ControlComponent::Init() {
  injector_ = std::make_shared<DependencyInjector>();
  init_time_ = Clock::Now();

  AINFO << "Control init, starting ...";

  ACHECK(
      cyber::common::GetProtoFromFile(FLAGS_pipeline_file, &control_pipeline_))
      << "Unable to load control pipeline file: " + FLAGS_pipeline_file;

  AINFO << "ControlTask pipeline config file: " << FLAGS_pipeline_file
        << " is loaded.";

  // initial controller agent when not using control submodules
  ADEBUG << "FLAGS_use_control_submodules: " << FLAGS_use_control_submodules;
  if (!FLAGS_is_control_ut_test_mode) {
    if (!FLAGS_use_control_submodules &&
        !control_task_agent_.Init(injector_, control_pipeline_).ok()) {
      // set controller
      ADEBUG << "original control";
      monitor_logger_buffer_.ERROR(
          "Control init controller failed! Stopping...");
      return false;
    }
  }

  cyber::ReaderConfig chassis_reader_config;
  chassis_reader_config.channel_name = FLAGS_chassis_topic;
  chassis_reader_config.pending_queue_size = FLAGS_chassis_pending_queue_size;
  // 订阅底盘信息
  chassis_reader_ =
      node_->CreateReader<Chassis>(chassis_reader_config, nullptr);
  ACHECK(chassis_reader_ != nullptr);
  
  cyber::ReaderConfig planning_reader_config;
  planning_reader_config.channel_name = FLAGS_planning_trajectory_topic;
  planning_reader_config.pending_queue_size = FLAGS_planning_pending_queue_size;
  // 订阅轨迹信息
  trajectory_reader_ =
      node_->CreateReader<ADCTrajectory>(planning_reader_config, nullptr);
  ACHECK(trajectory_reader_ != nullptr);

  cyber::ReaderConfig planning_command_status_reader_config;
  planning_command_status_reader_config.channel_name =
      FLAGS_planning_command_status;
  planning_command_status_reader_config.pending_queue_size =
      FLAGS_planning_status_msg_pending_queue_size;
  // 订阅规划命令状态
  planning_command_status_reader_ =
      node_->CreateReader<external_command::CommandStatus>(
          planning_command_status_reader_config, nullptr);
  ACHECK(planning_command_status_reader_ != nullptr);

  cyber::ReaderConfig localization_reader_config;
  localization_reader_config.channel_name = FLAGS_localization_topic;
  localization_reader_config.pending_queue_size =
      FLAGS_localization_pending_queue_size;
  // 订阅定位信息
  localization_reader_ = node_->CreateReader<LocalizationEstimate>(
      localization_reader_config, nullptr);
  ACHECK(localization_reader_ != nullptr);

  cyber::ReaderConfig pad_msg_reader_config;
  pad_msg_reader_config.channel_name = FLAGS_pad_topic;
  pad_msg_reader_config.pending_queue_size = FLAGS_pad_msg_pending_queue_size;
  // 订阅pad消息
  pad_msg_reader_ =
      node_->CreateReader<PadMessage>(pad_msg_reader_config, nullptr);
  ACHECK(pad_msg_reader_ != nullptr);
  // 如果使用控制子模块，发布控制话题，否则，发布控制local_view
  if (!FLAGS_use_control_submodules) {
    control_cmd_writer_ =
        node_->CreateWriter<ControlCommand>(FLAGS_control_command_topic);
    ACHECK(control_cmd_writer_ != nullptr);
  } else {
    local_view_writer_ =
        node_->CreateWriter<LocalView>(FLAGS_control_local_view_topic);
    ACHECK(local_view_writer_ != nullptr);
  }

  // set initial vehicle state by cmd
  // need to sleep, because advertised channel is not ready immediately
  // simple test shows a short delay of 80 ms or so
  // 休眠1000ms
  AINFO << "Control resetting vehicle state, sleeping for 1000 ms ...";
  std::this_thread::sleep_for(std::chrono::milliseconds(1000));

  // should init_vehicle first, let car enter work status, then use status msg
  // trigger control
  // 首先初始化vehicle，让车到工作状态，然后使用状态消息
  AINFO << "Control default driving action is "
        << DrivingAction_Name((enum DrivingAction)FLAGS_action);
  pad_msg_.set_action((enum DrivingAction)FLAGS_action);

  return true;
}

void ControlComponent::OnPad(const std::shared_ptr<PadMessage> &pad) {
  // 创建锁，确保在访问 pad_msg_ 期间不会发生数据竞争
  std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(mutex_);
  // 将 pad 中的数据复制到 pad_msg_
  pad_msg_.CopyFrom(*pad);
  ADEBUG << "Received Pad Msg:" << pad_msg_.DebugString();
  AERROR_IF(!pad_msg_.has_action()) << "pad message check failed!";
}

void ControlComponent::OnChassis(const std::shared_ptr<Chassis> &chassis) {
  ADEBUG << "Received chassis data: run chassis callback.";
  // 创建锁，确保在访问 latest_chassis_ 期间不会发生数据竞争
  std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(mutex_);
  latest_chassis_.CopyFrom(*chassis);
}

void ControlComponent::OnPlanning(
    const std::shared_ptr<ADCTrajectory> &trajectory) {
  ADEBUG << "Received chassis data: run trajectory callback.";
  // 创建锁，确保在访问 latest_trajectory_ 期间不会发生数据竞争
  std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(mutex_);
  latest_trajectory_.CopyFrom(*trajectory);
}

void ControlComponent::OnPlanningCommandStatus(
    const std::shared_ptr<external_command::CommandStatus>
        &planning_command_status) {
  ADEBUG << "Received plannning command status data: run planning command "
            "status callback.";
  // 创建锁，确保在访问 planning_command_status_ 期间不会发生数据竞争
  std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(mutex_);
  planning_command_status_.CopyFrom(*planning_command_status);
}

void ControlComponent::OnLocalization(
    const std::shared_ptr<LocalizationEstimate> &localization) {
  ADEBUG << "Received control data: run localization message callback.";
  // 创建锁，确保在访问 latest_localization_ 期间不会发生数据竞争
  std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(mutex_);
  latest_localization_.CopyFrom(*localization);
}

void ControlComponent::OnMonitor(
    const common::monitor::MonitorMessage &monitor_message) {
  for (const auto &item : monitor_message.item()) {
    if (item.log_level() == common::monitor::MonitorMessageItem::FATAL) {
      // 检测到严重问题，需要立即停止
      estop_ = true;
      return;
    }
  }
}

Status ControlComponent::ProduceControlCommand(
    ControlCommand *control_command) {
  // 检查输入数据
  Status status = CheckInput(&local_view_);
  // check data
  if (!status.ok()) {
    AERROR_EVERY(100) << "Control input data failed: "
                      << status.error_message();
    control_command->mutable_engage_advice()->set_advice(
        apollo::common::EngageAdvice::DISALLOW_ENGAGE);
    control_command->mutable_engage_advice()->set_reason(
        status.error_message());
    estop_ = true;
    estop_reason_ = status.error_message();
  } else {
    estop_ = false;
    // 检查时间戳
    Status status_ts = CheckTimestamp(local_view_);
    if (!status_ts.ok()) {
      AERROR << "Input messages timeout";
      // Clear trajectory data to make control stop if no data received again
      // next cycle.
      // keep the history trajectory for control compute.
      // latest_trajectory_.Clear();
      estop_ = true;
      status = status_ts;
      if (local_view_.chassis().driving_mode() !=
          apollo::canbus::Chassis::COMPLETE_AUTO_DRIVE) {
        control_command->mutable_engage_advice()->set_advice(
            apollo::common::EngageAdvice::DISALLOW_ENGAGE);
        control_command->mutable_engage_advice()->set_reason(
            status.error_message());
      }
    } else {
      control_command->mutable_engage_advice()->set_advice(
          apollo::common::EngageAdvice::READY_TO_ENGAGE);
      estop_ = false;
    }
  }

  // 检查 estop
  estop_ = FLAGS_enable_persistent_estop
               ? estop_ || local_view_.trajectory().estop().is_estop()
               : local_view_.trajectory().estop().is_estop();
  // 如果规划中的 estop 标志为真，则设置 estop_ 为真
  if (local_view_.trajectory().estop().is_estop()) {
    estop_ = true;
    estop_reason_ = "estop from planning : ";
    estop_reason_ += local_view_.trajectory().estop().reason();
  }
  // 如果规划中的轨迹点为空，则设置 estop_ 为真
  if (local_view_.trajectory().trajectory_point().empty()) {
    AWARN_EVERY(100) << "planning has no trajectory point. ";
    estop_ = true;
    estop_reason_ = "estop for empty planning trajectory, planning headers: " +
                    local_view_.trajectory().header().ShortDebugString();
  }
  // 如果启用了 gear_drive 负速度保护功能，并且当前驾驶模式为 gear_drive，并且第一个轨迹点的速度小于 -kEpsilon，则设置 estop_ 为真
  if (FLAGS_enable_gear_drive_negative_speed_protection) {
    const double kEpsilon = 0.001;
    auto first_trajectory_point = local_view_.trajectory().trajectory_point(0);
    if (local_view_.chassis().gear_location() == Chassis::GEAR_DRIVE &&
        first_trajectory_point.v() < -1 * kEpsilon) {
      estop_ = true;
      estop_reason_ = "estop for negative speed when gear_drive";
    }
  }

  if (!estop_) {
    // 如果当前驾驶模式为完全手动驾驶，则重置控制器
    if (local_view_.chassis().driving_mode() == Chassis::COMPLETE_MANUAL) {
      control_task_agent_.Reset();
      AINFO_EVERY(100) << "Reset Controllers in Manual Mode";
    }
    // 设置控制命令的调试信息
    auto debug = control_command->mutable_debug()->mutable_input_debug();
    debug->mutable_localization_header()->CopyFrom(
        local_view_.localization().header());
    debug->mutable_canbus_header()->CopyFrom(local_view_.chassis().header());
    debug->mutable_trajectory_header()->CopyFrom(
        local_view_.trajectory().header());
    // 如果当前规划的轨迹点不为空，则将最新的重新规划轨迹头信息记录下来
    if (local_view_.trajectory().is_replan()) {
      latest_replan_trajectory_header_ = local_view_.trajectory().header();
    }
    // 如果最新的重新规划轨迹头具有序列号，则将其记录在控制命令的调试信息中
    if (latest_replan_trajectory_header_.has_sequence_num()) {
      debug->mutable_latest_replan_trajectory_header()->CopyFrom(
          latest_replan_trajectory_header_);
    }
  }
  // 如果当前规划的轨迹点不为空，则调用控制任务代理计算控制命令
  if (!local_view_.trajectory().trajectory_point().empty()) {
    // controller agent
    Status status_compute = control_task_agent_.ComputeControlCommand(
        &local_view_.localization(), &local_view_.chassis(),
        &local_view_.trajectory(), control_command);
    ADEBUG << "status_compute is " << status_compute;
    // 如果计算控制命令失败，记录错误信息并设置 estop_ 为 true
    if (!status_compute.ok()) {
      AERROR << "Control main function failed"
             << " with localization: "
             << local_view_.localization().ShortDebugString()
             << " with chassis: " << local_view_.chassis().ShortDebugString()
             << " with trajectory: "
             << local_view_.trajectory().ShortDebugString()
             << " with cmd: " << control_command->ShortDebugString()
             << " status:" << status_compute.error_message();
      estop_ = true;
      estop_reason_ = status_compute.error_message();
      status = status_compute;
    }
  }

  // if planning set estop, then no control process triggered
  // 如果规划停止，控制就触发不了
  if (estop_) {
    AWARN_EVERY(100) << "Estop triggered! No control core method executed!";
    // set Estop command
    control_command->set_speed(0);
    control_command->set_throttle(0);
    control_command->set_brake(FLAGS_soft_estop_brake);
    control_command->set_gear_location(Chassis::GEAR_DRIVE);
    previous_steering_command_ =
        injector_->previous_control_command_mutable()->steering_target();
    control_command->set_steering_target(previous_steering_command_);
  }
  // check signal
  if (local_view_.trajectory().decision().has_vehicle_signal()) {
    control_command->mutable_signal()->CopyFrom(
        local_view_.trajectory().decision().vehicle_signal());
  }
  return status;
}
// 核心函数Proc
bool ControlComponent::Proc() {
  const auto start_time = Clock::Now();

  chassis_reader_->Observe();
  const auto &chassis_msg = chassis_reader_->GetLatestObserved();
  // 接收不到底盘信息
  if (chassis_msg == nullptr) {
    AERROR << "Chassis msg is not ready!";
    injector_->set_control_process(false);
    return false;
  }
  OnChassis(chassis_msg);

  trajectory_reader_->Observe();
  const auto &trajectory_msg = trajectory_reader_->GetLatestObserved();
  // 接收不到轨迹信息
  if (trajectory_msg == nullptr) {
    AERROR << "planning msg is not ready!";
  } else {
    // Check if new planning data received.
    if (latest_trajectory_.header().sequence_num() !=
        trajectory_msg->header().sequence_num()) {
      OnPlanning(trajectory_msg);
    }
  }

  planning_command_status_reader_->Observe();
  const auto &planning_status_msg =
      planning_command_status_reader_->GetLatestObserved();
  if (planning_status_msg != nullptr) {
    OnPlanningCommandStatus(planning_status_msg);
    ADEBUG << "Planning command status msg is \n"
           << planning_command_status_.ShortDebugString();
  }
  injector_->set_planning_command_status(planning_command_status_);

  localization_reader_->Observe();
  const auto &localization_msg = localization_reader_->GetLatestObserved();
  // 接收不到定位消息
  if (localization_msg == nullptr) {
    AERROR << "localization msg is not ready!";
    injector_->set_control_process(false);
    return false;
  }
  OnLocalization(localization_msg);

  pad_msg_reader_->Observe();
  const auto &pad_msg = pad_msg_reader_->GetLatestObserved();
  if (pad_msg != nullptr) {
    OnPad(pad_msg);
  }

  {
    // TODO(SHU): to avoid redundent copy
    std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(mutex_);
    local_view_.mutable_chassis()->CopyFrom(latest_chassis_);
    local_view_.mutable_trajectory()->CopyFrom(latest_trajectory_);
    local_view_.mutable_localization()->CopyFrom(latest_localization_);
    if (pad_msg != nullptr) {
      local_view_.mutable_pad_msg()->CopyFrom(pad_msg_);
    }
  }

  // use control submodules
  if (FLAGS_use_control_submodules) {
    local_view_.mutable_header()->set_lidar_timestamp(
        local_view_.trajectory().header().lidar_timestamp());
    local_view_.mutable_header()->set_camera_timestamp(
        local_view_.trajectory().header().camera_timestamp());
    local_view_.mutable_header()->set_radar_timestamp(
        local_view_.trajectory().header().radar_timestamp());
    common::util::FillHeader(FLAGS_control_local_view_topic, &local_view_);

    const auto end_time = Clock::Now();

    // measure latency
    static apollo::common::LatencyRecorder latency_recorder(
        FLAGS_control_local_view_topic);
    latency_recorder.AppendLatencyRecord(
        local_view_.trajectory().header().lidar_timestamp(), start_time,
        end_time);

    local_view_writer_->Write(local_view_);
    return true;
  }

  if (pad_msg != nullptr) {
    ADEBUG << "pad_msg: " << pad_msg_.ShortDebugString();
    if (pad_msg_.action() == DrivingAction::RESET) {
      AINFO << "Control received RESET action!";
      estop_ = false;
      estop_reason_.clear();
    }
    pad_received_ = true;
  }

  if (FLAGS_is_control_test_mode && FLAGS_control_test_duration > 0 &&
      (start_time - init_time_).ToSecond() > FLAGS_control_test_duration) {
    AERROR << "Control finished testing. exit";
    injector_->set_control_process(false);
    return false;
  }

  injector_->set_control_process(true);

  ControlCommand control_command;

  Status status;
  // 自动驾驶模式
  if (local_view_.chassis().driving_mode() ==
      apollo::canbus::Chassis::COMPLETE_AUTO_DRIVE) {
    status = ProduceControlCommand(&control_command);
    ADEBUG << "Produce control command normal.";
  } else {
    ADEBUG << "Into reset control command.";
    ResetAndProduceZeroControlCommand(&control_command);
  }

  AERROR_IF(!status.ok()) << "Failed to produce control command:"
                          << status.error_message();

  if (pad_received_) {
    control_command.mutable_pad_msg()->CopyFrom(pad_msg_);
    pad_received_ = false;
  }

  // forward estop reason among following control frames.
  if (estop_) {
    control_command.mutable_header()->mutable_status()->set_msg(estop_reason_);
  }

  // set header
  control_command.mutable_header()->set_lidar_timestamp(
      local_view_.trajectory().header().lidar_timestamp());
  control_command.mutable_header()->set_camera_timestamp(
      local_view_.trajectory().header().camera_timestamp());
  control_command.mutable_header()->set_radar_timestamp(
      local_view_.trajectory().header().radar_timestamp());

  common::util::FillHeader(node_->Name(), &control_command);

  ADEBUG << control_command.ShortDebugString();
  if (FLAGS_is_control_test_mode) {
    ADEBUG << "Skip publish control command in test mode";
    return true;
  }

  if (fabs(control_command.debug().simple_lon_debug().vehicle_pitch()) <
      kDoubleEpsilon) {
    injector_->vehicle_state()->Update(local_view_.localization(),
                                       local_view_.chassis());
    GetVehiclePitchAngle(&control_command);
  }

  const auto end_time = Clock::Now();
  const double time_diff_ms = (end_time - start_time).ToSecond() * 1e3;
  ADEBUG << "total control time spend: " << time_diff_ms << " ms.";

  control_command.mutable_latency_stats()->set_total_time_ms(time_diff_ms);
  control_command.mutable_latency_stats()->set_total_time_exceeded(
      time_diff_ms > FLAGS_control_period * 1e3);
  ADEBUG << "control cycle time is: " << time_diff_ms << " ms.";
  status.Save(control_command.mutable_header()->mutable_status());

  // measure latency
  if (local_view_.trajectory().header().has_lidar_timestamp()) {
    static apollo::common::LatencyRecorder latency_recorder(
        FLAGS_control_command_topic);
    latency_recorder.AppendLatencyRecord(
        local_view_.trajectory().header().lidar_timestamp(), start_time,
        end_time);
  }

  // save current control command 保存当前控制命令
  injector_->Set_pervious_control_command(&control_command);
  injector_->previous_control_command_mutable()->CopyFrom(control_command);
  injector_->previous_control_debug_mutable()->CopyFrom(
      injector_->control_debug_info());
  // 发布控制命令
  control_cmd_writer_->Write(control_command);
  return true;
}
// 检查输入
Status ControlComponent::CheckInput(LocalView *local_view) {
  ADEBUG << "Received localization:"
         << local_view->localization().ShortDebugString();
  ADEBUG << "Received chassis:" << local_view->chassis().ShortDebugString();

  if (!local_view->trajectory().estop().is_estop() &&
      local_view->trajectory().trajectory_point().empty()) {
    AWARN_EVERY(100) << "planning has no trajectory point. ";
    const std::string msg =
        absl::StrCat("planning has no trajectory point. planning_seq_num:",
                     local_view->trajectory().header().sequence_num());
    return Status(ErrorCode::CONTROL_COMPUTE_ERROR, msg);
  }

  for (auto &trajectory_point :
       *local_view->mutable_trajectory()->mutable_trajectory_point()) {
    if (std::abs(trajectory_point.v()) < FLAGS_minimum_speed_resolution &&
        std::abs(trajectory_point.a()) < FLAGS_max_acceleration_when_stopped) {
      trajectory_point.set_v(0.0);
      trajectory_point.set_a(0.0);
    }
  }

  injector_->vehicle_state()->Update(local_view->localization(),
                                     local_view->chassis());

  return Status::OK();
}
// 检查时间戳
Status ControlComponent::CheckTimestamp(const LocalView &local_view) {
  if (!FLAGS_enable_input_timestamp_check || FLAGS_is_control_test_mode) {
    ADEBUG << "Skip input timestamp check by gflags.";
    return Status::OK();
  }
  double current_timestamp = Clock::NowInSeconds();
  double localization_diff =
      current_timestamp - local_view.localization().header().timestamp_sec();
  if (localization_diff >
      (FLAGS_max_localization_miss_num * FLAGS_localization_period)) {
    AERROR << "Localization msg lost for " << std::setprecision(6)
           << localization_diff << "s";
    monitor_logger_buffer_.ERROR("Localization msg lost");
    return Status(ErrorCode::CONTROL_COMPUTE_ERROR, "Localization msg timeout");
  }

  double chassis_diff =
      current_timestamp - local_view.chassis().header().timestamp_sec();
  if (chassis_diff > (FLAGS_max_chassis_miss_num * FLAGS_chassis_period)) {
    AERROR << "Chassis msg lost for " << std::setprecision(6) << chassis_diff
           << "s";
    monitor_logger_buffer_.ERROR("Chassis msg lost");
    return Status(ErrorCode::CONTROL_COMPUTE_ERROR, "Chassis msg timeout");
  }

  double trajectory_diff =
      current_timestamp - local_view.trajectory().header().timestamp_sec();
  if (trajectory_diff >
      (FLAGS_max_planning_miss_num * FLAGS_trajectory_period)) {
    AERROR << "Trajectory msg lost for " << std::setprecision(6)
           << trajectory_diff << "s";
    monitor_logger_buffer_.ERROR("Trajectory msg lost");
    return Status(ErrorCode::CONTROL_COMPUTE_ERROR, "Trajectory msg timeout");
  }
  return Status::OK();
}
// 重置控制命令
void ControlComponent::ResetAndProduceZeroControlCommand(
    ControlCommand *control_command) {
  control_command->set_throttle(0.0);
  control_command->set_steering_target(0.0);
  control_command->set_steering_rate(0.0);
  control_command->set_speed(0.0);
  control_command->set_brake(0.0);
  control_command->set_gear_location(Chassis::GEAR_DRIVE);
  control_task_agent_.Reset();
  latest_trajectory_.mutable_trajectory_point()->Clear();
  latest_trajectory_.mutable_path_point()->Clear();
  trajectory_reader_->ClearData();
}
// 获得汽车的俯仰角
void ControlComponent::GetVehiclePitchAngle(ControlCommand *control_command) {
  double vehicle_pitch = injector_->vehicle_state()->pitch() * 180 / M_PI;
  control_command->mutable_debug()
      ->mutable_simple_lon_debug()
      ->set_vehicle_pitch(vehicle_pitch + FLAGS_pitch_offset_deg);
}

}  // namespace control
}  // namespace apollo

控制全局变量配置文件见control_gflags.cc

配置加载的控制器，Apollo中modules/control/control_component/conf/pipeline.pb.txt

controller {
  name: "LAT_CONTROLLER"
  type: "LatController"
}
controller {
  name: "LON_CONTROLLER"
  type: "LonController"
}

name是用户自定义，表达清楚是什么控制器就行，type是控制器的子类名称，如果和子类名称不一致，会导致加载控制器失败。上面是先加载横向控制器，再加载纵向控制器

3 Control组件包逻辑梳理

主要是梳理Init函数和Proc函数
Init函数：
主要实现ControlTaskAgent的初始化，以及control上游的相关消息的订阅

摘取Init函数里面的主要部分

bool ControlComponent::Init() {
  // 初始化控制器agent
  if (!FLAGS_is_control_ut_test_mode) {
    if (!FLAGS_use_control_submodules &&
        !control_task_agent_.Init(injector_, control_pipeline_).ok()) {
      // set controller
      ADEBUG << "original control";
      monitor_logger_buffer_.ERROR(
          "Control init controller failed! Stopping...");
      return false;
    }
  }
  // 订阅底盘信息
  chassis_reader_ =
      node_->CreateReader<Chassis>(chassis_reader_config, nullptr);
  // 订阅轨迹信息
  trajectory_reader_ =
      node_->CreateReader<ADCTrajectory>(planning_reader_config, nullptr);
  // 订阅规划命令状态
  planning_command_status_reader_ =
      node_->CreateReader<external_command::CommandStatus>(
          planning_command_status_reader_config, nullptr);
  // 订阅定位信息
  localization_reader_ = node_->CreateReader<LocalizationEstimate>(
      localization_reader_config, nullptr);
  // 订阅pad消息
  pad_msg_reader_ =
      node_->CreateReader<PadMessage>(pad_msg_reader_config, nullptr);
}

Proc函数：
(1) 获取订阅消息的当前最新数据
(2) 检查订阅消息输入数据
(3) 检查订阅消息输入数据时间戳是否在容差范围内
(4) 更新车身姿态信息
(5) 进行control控制计算(调用ControlTaskAgent的ComputeControlCommand方法)
(6) 输出底盘控制指令

摘取Proc函数里面的主要部分

bool ControlComponent::Proc() {
    // 获取订阅消息的当前最新数据
	const auto &chassis_msg = chassis_reader_->GetLatestObserved();
	const auto &trajectory_msg = trajectory_reader_->GetLatestObserved();
	const auto &planning_status_msg =
      planning_command_status_reader_->GetLatestObserved();
    const auto &localization_msg = localization_reader_->GetLatestObserved();
    const auto &pad_msg = pad_msg_reader_->GetLatestObserved();
    // 检查订阅消息输入数据
    // 检查订阅消息输入数据时间戳是否在容差范围内
    // 自动驾驶模式
    if (local_view_.chassis().driving_mode() ==
        apollo::canbus::Chassis::COMPLETE_AUTO_DRIVE) {
    // 计算控制命令
      status = ProduceControlCommand(&control_command);
      ADEBUG << "Produce control command normal.";
    } else {
      ADEBUG << "Into reset control command.";
      ResetAndProduceZeroControlCommand(&control_command);
    }
    // 更新车身姿态信息
    injector_->vehicle_state()->Update(local_view_.localization(),
                                       local_view_.chassis());
    // 发布控制命令
    control_cmd_writer_->Write(control_command);
}

3 controller_task_base

之前的控制组件包讲解告一段落，如有疑惑可在评论区留言讨论

controller_task_base主要包含ControlTaskAgent和ControlTask定义，ControlTaskAgent用来管理ControlTask插件的加载和执行顺序，ControlTask是controller控制器插件的父类，Control/controller控制器插件都继承于ControlTask

control_task_agent.h：

#pragma once

#include <memory>
#include <vector>

#include "modules/common_msgs/control_msgs/control_cmd.pb.h"
#include "modules/common_msgs/planning_msgs/planning.pb.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/proto/pipeline.pb.h"

#include "cyber/plugin_manager/plugin_manager.h"
#include "modules/common/util/factory.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/controller_task_base/common/dependency_injector.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/controller_task_base/control_task.h"

/**
 * @namespace apollo::control
 * @brief apollo::control
 */
namespace apollo {
namespace control {

/**
 * @class ControlTaskAgent
 *
 * @brief manage all controllers declared in control config file.
 */
class ControlTaskAgent {
 public:
  /**
   * @brief 初始化 ControlTaskAgent
   * @param control_conf control configurations
   * @return Status initialization status
   */
  common::Status Init(std::shared_ptr<DependencyInjector> injector,
                      const ControlPipeline &control_pipeline);

  /**
   * @brief compute control command based on current vehicle status
   *        and target trajectory
   * @param localization vehicle location
   * @param chassis vehicle status e.g., speed, acceleration
   * @param trajectory trajectory generated by planning
   * @param cmd control command
   * @return Status computation status
   */
  // 基于当前车辆状态和目标轨迹计算控制命令
  common::Status ComputeControlCommand(
      const localization::LocalizationEstimate *localization,
      const canbus::Chassis *chassis, const planning::ADCTrajectory *trajectory,
      control::ControlCommand *cmd);

  /**
   * @brief reset ControlTaskAgent
   * @return Status reset status
   */
  // 重置ControlTaskAgent
  common::Status Reset();

 private:
  std::vector<std::shared_ptr<ControlTask>> controller_list_;
  std::shared_ptr<DependencyInjector> injector_ = nullptr;
};

}  // namespace control
}  // namespace apollo

control_task_agent.cc

#include "modules/control/control_component/controller_task_base/control_task_agent.h"

#include <utility>

#include "cyber/common/log.h"
#include "cyber/time/clock.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/common/control_gflags.h"

namespace apollo {
namespace control {

using apollo::common::ErrorCode;
using apollo::common::Status;
using apollo::cyber::Clock;
using apollo::cyber::plugin_manager::PluginManager;
// 初始化控制器
Status ControlTaskAgent::Init(std::shared_ptr<DependencyInjector> injector,
                              const ControlPipeline &control_pipeline) {
  if (control_pipeline.controller_size() == 0) {
    AERROR << "control_pipeline is empty";
    return Status(ErrorCode::CONTROL_INIT_ERROR, "Empty control_pipeline");
  }

  injector_ = injector;
  for (int i = 0; i < control_pipeline.controller_size(); i++) {
    auto controller = PluginManager::Instance()->CreateInstance<ControlTask>(
        "apollo::control::" + control_pipeline.controller(i).type());
    if (!controller->Init(injector_).ok()) {
      AERROR << "Can not init controller " << controller->Name();
      return Status(
          ErrorCode::CONTROL_INIT_ERROR,
          "Failed to init Controller:" + control_pipeline.controller(i).name());
    }
    controller_list_.push_back(controller);
    AINFO << "Controller <" << controller->Name() << "> init done!";
  }
  return Status::OK();
}
// 计算控制命令
Status ControlTaskAgent::ComputeControlCommand(
    const localization::LocalizationEstimate *localization,
    const canbus::Chassis *chassis, const planning::ADCTrajectory *trajectory,
    control::ControlCommand *cmd) {
  for (auto &controller : controller_list_) {
    ADEBUG << "controller:" << controller->Name() << " processing ...";
    double start_timestamp = Clock::NowInSeconds();
    // 计算控制命令 （核心）
    controller->ComputeControlCommand(localization, chassis, trajectory, cmd);
    double end_timestamp = Clock::NowInSeconds();
    const double time_diff_ms = (end_timestamp - start_timestamp) * 1000;

    ADEBUG << "controller: " << controller->Name()
           << " calculation time is: " << time_diff_ms << " ms.";
    cmd->mutable_latency_stats()->add_controller_time_ms(time_diff_ms);
  }
  return Status::OK();
}

Status ControlTaskAgent::Reset() {
  for (auto &controller : controller_list_) {
    ADEBUG << "controller:" << controller->Name() << " reset...";
    controller->Reset();
  }
  return Status::OK();
}

}  // namespace control
}  // namespace apollo

ControlTask是controller控制器插件的父类，Control/controller控制器插件都继承于ControlTask

control_task.h

/**
 * @file
 * @brief Defines the Controller base class.
 */

#pragma once

#include <memory>
#include <string>

#include <cxxabi.h>

#include "modules/common_msgs/control_msgs/control_cmd.pb.h"
#include "modules/common_msgs/localization_msgs/localization.pb.h"
#include "modules/common_msgs/planning_msgs/planning.pb.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/proto/calibration_table.pb.h"

#include "cyber/common/file.h"
#include "cyber/plugin_manager/plugin_manager.h"
#include "modules/common/status/status.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/common/control_gflags.h"
#include "modules/control/control_component/controller_task_base/common/dependency_injector.h"

namespace apollo {
namespace control {

class ControlTask {
 public:
  ControlTask() = default;
  virtual ~ControlTask() = default;

  /**
   * @brief initialize Controller
   * @param control_conf control configurations
   * @return Status initialization status
   */
  virtual common::Status Init(std::shared_ptr<DependencyInjector> injector) = 0;

  /**
   * @brief compute control command based on current vehicle status
   *        and target trajectory
   * @param localization vehicle location
   * @param chassis vehicle status e.g., speed, acceleration
   * @param trajectory trajectory generated by planning
   * @param cmd control command
   * @return Status computation status
   */
  virtual common::Status ComputeControlCommand(
      const localization::LocalizationEstimate *localization,
      const canbus::Chassis *chassis, const planning::ADCTrajectory *trajectory,
      control::ControlCommand *cmd) = 0;

  /**
   * @brief reset Controller
   * @return Status reset status
   */
  virtual common::Status Reset() = 0;

  /**
   * @brief controller name
   * @return string controller name in string
   */
  virtual std::string Name() const = 0;

  /**
   * @brief stop controller
   */
  virtual void Stop() = 0;

 protected:
  template <typename T>
  bool LoadConfig(T *config);
  // 加载油门制动标定表
  bool LoadCalibrationTable(calibration_table *calibration_table_conf) {
    std::string calibration_table_path = FLAGS_calibration_table_file;

    if (!apollo::cyber::common::GetProtoFromFile(calibration_table_path,
                                                 calibration_table_conf)) {
      AERROR << "Load calibration table failed!";
      return false;
    }
    AINFO << "Load the calibraiton table file successfully, file path: "
          << calibration_table_path;
    return true;
  }
};

template <typename T>
bool ControlTask::LoadConfig(T *config) {
  int status;
  std::string class_name =
      abi::__cxa_demangle(typeid(*this).name(), 0, 0, &status);
  // Generate the default task config path from PluginManager.
  std::string config_path_ =
      apollo::cyber::plugin_manager::PluginManager::Instance()
          ->GetPluginConfPath<ControlTask>(class_name,
                                           "conf/controller_conf.pb.txt");

  if (!apollo::cyber::common::GetProtoFromFile(config_path_, config)) {
    AERROR << "Load config of " << class_name << " failed!";
    return false;
  }
  AINFO << "Load the [" << class_name
        << "] config file successfully, file path: " << config_path_;
  return true;
}

}  // namespace control
}  // namespace apollo

4 controller

接下来看一下具体控制器的实现

---

具体控制器讲解见下一章节